Piping Fragility Composed of Different Materials by Using OpenSees Software

Authors: Woo Young Jung, Min Ho Kwon, Bu Seog Ju

Abstract:

A failure of the non-structural component can cause  significant damages in critical facilities such as nuclear power plants  and hospitals. Historically, it was reported that the damage from the  leakage of sprinkler systems, resulted in the shutdown of hospitals for  several weeks by the 1971 San Fernando and 1994 North Ridge  earthquakes. In most cases, water leakages were observed at the cross  joints, sprinkler heads, and T-joint connections in piping systems  during and after the seismic events. Hence, the primary objective of  this study was to understand the seismic performance of T-joint  connections and to develop an analytical Finite Element (FE) model  for the T-joint systems of 2-inch fire protection piping system in  hospitals subjected to seismic ground motions. In order to evaluate the  FE models of the piping systems using OpenSees, two types of  materials were used: 1) Steel02 materials and 2) Pinching4 materials.  Results of the current study revealed that the nonlinear  moment-rotation FE models for the threaded T-joint reconciled well  with the experimental results in both FE material models. However,  the system-level fragility determined from multiple nonlinear time  history analyses at the threaded T-joint was slightly different. The  system-level fragility at the T-joint, determined by Pinching4 material  was more conservative than that of using Steel02 material in the piping  system.

Keywords: Fragility, T-joint, Piping, Leakage, Sprinkler.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1090480

References:

[1] R. Reitherman, "Nonstructural Earthquake Damage,” Construction of University for Research in Earthquake Engineering (CUREE), 2009, http://www.curee.org/image_gallery/calendar/essays/2010-CUREE_exce rpt.pdf
[2] C. A. Kircher, "It Makes Dollars and Sense to Improve Nonstructural System Performance,” Proceedings of Seminar on Seismic Design, Performance, and Retrofit of Nonstructural Components in Critical Facilities, ATC-29-2, 2003
[3] J. M. Ayres and R. J. Phillips, "Water Damage in Hospital Resulting from the Northridge Earthquake,” ASHRAE Transactions Part 1B, SF-98-14-2, 1286-1296, 1998
[4] R. J. Wasilewski, "Seismic Restraints for piping System,” ASHRAE Transactions Part 1B, SF-98-14-1, 1273-1285, 1998
[5] NFPA-13, Standard for the installation of Sprinkler System, National Fire Protection Association, MA, 2007 Edition
[6] G. Antaki and D. Guzy, ""Seismic Testing of Grooved and Threaded Fire Protection Joints and Correlation with NFPA Seismic Design Provisions,” ASME 1998, PVP-Vol. 364, Seismic Engineering-1998, 69-75
[7] B.S. Ju, S.T. Taninada and A. Gupta, "Fragility Analysis of Threaded T-joint Connections in Hospital Piping Systems,” Proceeding of the ASME 2011 Pressure Vessel and Piping Division Conference, Baltimore, Maryland, 2011
[8] OpenSees, Open System for Earthquake Engineering Simulation, Available at http://opensees.berkeley.edu, 2011
[9] B.S. Ju and W.Y. Jung, "Seismic Fragility Evaluation of Multi-Branch Piping Systems Installed in Critical Low-Rise Buildings,” Disaster Advances, Vol. 6(4), 59-65, 2013
[10] B.S. Ju, W.Y. Jung and Y.H., Ryu, " Seismic Fragility Evaluation of Piping System Installed in Critical Structures,” Structural Engineering and Mechanics, An International Journal, Vol. 46, No. 3, 337-352, 2013
[11] J. Dow, "Testing and Analysis of Iron and Plastic T-joint in Sprinkler Systems, NEESR-GC: Simulation of the Seismic Performance of Nonstructural Systems,” Available at http://nees,org/site/oldnees/ filedir_2/REU2009_DOW_Paper.pdf, 2010
[12] Y. Tian et al., "NEESR Nonstructural : Progress Report on Tests of Tee Joint Component of Sprinkler Piping System ,” Progress Report, NEESR-GC: Simulation of the Seismic Performance of Nonstructural Systems, October, 2010
[13] S. Mazzoni et al., OpenSees Command Language Manual, Available at http://opensees,berkeley.edu, 2006
[14] R. Bachman et al., " Engineering Demand Parameters for Nonstructural Components,” ATC-58 Project Task Report, ATC, Redwood City, California, 2004
[15] ASME, Rule for Construction of Nuclear Facility Components, ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section III, American Society of Mechanical Engineers (2004)
[16] A. Gupta and B. Choi, "Consideration of Uncertainties in Seismic Analysis of Coupled Building Piping System,” Nuclear Engineering and Design, 235, 2071-2086, 2005.