Failure Analysis of Methanol Evaporator

Authors: D. Sufi Ahmadi, B. Bagheri

Abstract:

Thermal water hammer is a special type of water hammer which rarely occurs in heat exchangers. In biphasic fluids, if steam bubbles are surrounded by condensate, regarding lower condensate temperature than steam, they will suddenly collapse. As a result, the vacuum caused by an extreme change in volume lead to movement of the condensates in all directions and their collision the force produced by this collision leads to a severe stress in the pipe wall. This phenomenon is a special type of water hammer. According to fluid mechanics, this phenomenon is a particular type of transient flows during which abrupt change of fluid leads to sudden pressure change inside the tube. In this paper, the mechanism of abrupt failure of 80 tubes of 481 tubes of a methanol heat exchanger is discussed. Initially, due to excessive temperature differences between heat transfer fluids and simultaneous failure of 80 tubes, thermal shock was presupposed as the reason of failure. Deeper investigation on cross-section of failed tubes showed that failure was, ductile type of failure, so the first hypothesis was rejected. Further analysis and more accurate experiments revealed that failure of tubes caused by thermal water hammer. Finally, the causes of thermal water hammer and various solutions to avoid such mechanism are discussed.

Keywords: Thermal water hammer, Brittle Failure, Condensate thermal shock

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1055289

References:

[1] TEMA Standard, TEMA_9TH EDITION_2007
[2] ASTM A334A334M, Standard Specification for Seamless and Welded Carbon and Alloy-Steel Tubes for Low-Temperature Service
[3] ASTM E415, Standard Test Method for optical Emission Vacuum Spectrometric Analysis of Carbon and Low-Alloy Steel, 2005
[4] ASTM E10 , Standard Test Method for Brinell Hardness of Metallic Materials, 2004
[5] ASTM E23, Standard Test Methods for Notched Bar Impact Testing of Metallic Materials 2006
[6] ASTM A1016 , Standard Specification for General Requirements for Ferritic Alloy Steel, Austenitic Alloy Steel, and Stainless Steel Tubes ,2004
[7] William F.Hosford, Robert M.Caddell," Metal Forming Mechanics and Metallurgy", Third Edition
[8] Fred Truman, "Operation and Maintenance of heat exchangers" S.A.Armstrong Limited 1963 Toronto, Canada