Comparative Economic Analysis of Floating Photovoltaic Systems Using a Synthesis Approach

Authors: Ching-Feng Chen, Shih-Kai Chen

Abstract:

The Floating Photovoltaic (FPV) system highlights economic benefits and energy performance to carbon dioxide (CO2) discharges. Due to land resource scarcity and many negligent water territories, such as reservoirs, dams, and lakes in Japan and Taiwan, both countries are actively developing FPV and responding to the pricing of the emissions trading systems (ETS). This paper performs a case study through a synthesis approach to compare the economic indicators between the FPVs of Taiwan’s Agongdian Reservoir and Japan’s Yamakura Dam. The research results show that the metrics of the system capacity, installation costs, bank interest rates, and ETS and Electricity Bills affect FPV operating gains. In the post-Feed-In-Tariff (FIT) phase, investing in FPV in Japan is more profitable than in Taiwan. The former’s positive net present value (NPV), eminent internal rate of return (IRR) (11.6%), and benefit-cost ratio (BCR) above 1 (2.0) at the discount rate of 10% indicate that investing the FPV in Japan is more favorable than in Taiwan. In addition, the breakeven point is modest (about 61.3%). The presented methodology in the study helps investors evaluate schemes’ pros and cons and determine whether a decision is beneficial while funding PV or FPV projects.

Keywords: Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, Floating Photovoltaic, Emissions Trading Systems, Net Present Value, NPV, Internal Rate of Return, IRR, Benefit-Cost Ratio.

References:

[1] Worldbank. Pricing Carbon. https://www.worldbank.org/en/programs/pricing-carbon (retrieved on May 14, 2022).
[2] Tsai, K.L. Taiwan Commodity Testing, and Verification Center Quarterly, January 2021, 37. Available online (In Chinese): https://www.etc.org.tw/_library/P00/ETC (retrieved on February 1, 2022).
[3] Ni, M. World Bank (WB): 2020 Global Carbon Pricing Status and Trends Development Report. Risk Society and Policy Research Center 2020. Available online (In Chinese). https://rsprc.ntu.edu.tw/zh-tw/m01-3/en-trans/en-news/1455- 0710-carbonprice.html (retrieved on May 18, 2022).
[4] Trapani, K.; Redón Santafé, M. A review of floating photovoltaic installations: 2007–2013. Prog Photovoltaics Res Appl, 23(4), pp. 524–32 (2014)
[5] Billinton R.; Allan, R.N. Reliability Evaluation of Power Systems, 2nd edition, NY: Plenum Press (1996)
[6] Silvérioa, N.M.; Barros, R.M.; Filhob, G.L.T.; Redón-Santaféc, M.; Santosa, I. F. S.; Mello Valério, V.E. Use of floating PV plants for coordinated operation with hydropower plants: A case study of the hydroelectric plants of the São Francisco River basin. Energy Conversion and Management, 171, pp. 339-349 (2018)
[7] Goswami, A.; Sadhu, P.; Goswami, U.; Sadhu, P. Floating solar power plant for sustainable development: A techno-economic analysis. Environmental Progress & Sustainable Energy, 38, e13268 (2019)
[8] Sahu, A.; Yadav, N.; Sudhakar, K., Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 66, 815-824 (2016)
[9] Singh, C.; Kim, Y. An efficient technique for reliability analysis of power systems including time-dependent sources, IEEE Trans. Power Syst. Aug., 3 (3), pp. 1090–1096 (1988)
[10] Gray, J.L. The Physics of the Solar Cell, in Handbook of Photovoltaic Science and Engineering, John Wiley and Sons (2011)
[11] Rhouma, M.B.; Gastli A.; Brahim, LB; Touati F.; Benammar M. A simple method for extracting the PV cell single-diode model parameters, Renew. Energy, 113, pp. 885-894 (2017)
[12] Di Piazza M.C.; Luna M.; Petrone G.; Spagnuolo G. Translation of the single-diode PV model parameters identified using explicit formulas IEEE J. Photovolt, 7 (4), pp. 1009-1016 (2017)
[13] Choi Y. A study on power generation analysis of floating PV system considering environmental impact. Int J Software Eng Appl. 8(1), pp. 75–84 (2014)
[14] Gangshan Household Registration Office. Available online (In Chinese) https://gangshan-house.kcgg.( retrieved on September 18, 2021).
[15] Water Resources Agency. Available online (In Chinese): https://www.wrasb.gov.tw(retrieved on September 18, 2021).
[16] Kyocera TCL Solar. https://global.kyocera.com/newws-archive/2018/ (retrieved on May 13, 2022).
[17] Chiba Prefecture Water Works Bureau. https://www.pref.chiba.lg.jp (retrieved on May 13, 2022).
[18] Khan, M.Y. Theory & Problems in Financial Management. Boston: McGraw Hill Higher Education (1999)
[19] Hartman, J.C.; Schafrick, I.C. The Relevant Internal Rate of Return. The Engineering Economist, 49(2) (2004)
[20] Zangeneh, A.; Jadid, S.; Rahimi-Kian, A. Normal boundary intersection and benefit-cost ratio for distributed generation planning. European Transactions on Electrical Power, 20(2), pp.97-113 (2010)
[21] Kiran, D.R. Chapter Twenty-two - Machinery replacement analysis, Principles of Economics and Management for Manufacturing Engineering, Butterworth-Heinemann, pp. 259-267 (2022)
[22] Bureau of Energy, Ministry of Economic Affairs. https://ghgregistry.epa.gov.tw/Upload/News3/00001339_001.pdf (retrieved on May 18, 2022).
[23] Council for Economic Planning and Development, Executive Yuan, Available online (In Chinese): https://ws.ndc.gov.tw/ (retrieved on January 29, 2022).
[24] Electricity MaP. 2020. https://app.electricitymap.org/map (retrieved on May 18, 2022).
[25] Sultan, S.; Kim, J. H., Kim, S.H., Kwon, Y. Lee, J.S. Innovative strategies toward PV-powered electrochemical CO2 reduction challenges, Journal of Energy Chemistry, 60, pp. 410-416 (2021)
[26] Bureau of Energy, Ministry of Economic Affairs. Energy Technology Research and Development White Paper 2007, Available online (In Chinese): https://www.moeaboe.gov.tw (retrieved on November 24, 2022).
[27] Staebler, D. L.; Wronski, C. R. Reversible conductivity changes in discharge-produced amorphous Si. Applied physics letters, 31(4), pp. 292-294 (1977)
[28] Geoffrey Rothwell, Encyclopedia of Energy, Nuclear Power Economics (2004)
[29] Corporate Finance Institute. “WACC.” https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/knowledge/finance (retrieved on May 13, 2022).
[30] Carl, S.; Lawrence, B. Mathematics for Economists. W. W. Norton & Company (1994)
[31] Saaty, T. L. Decision making with dependence and feedback: The analytic network process. RWS Publication, 4922 (1996)
[32] Saaty, T.L. The Analytic Hierarchy Process McGraw-Hill, New York (1980)
[33] Saaty, T.L. The Analytic Network Process, RWS Publications, Expert Choice, Inc. (1996)
[34] Bureau of Energy, Ministry of Economic Affairs. Available online (In Chinese): https://www.moeaboe.gov.tw (retrieved on September 18, 2021)
[35] Human Resource Bank 1111 (In Chinese). Available online (In Chinese): https://www.jobsalary.com.tw/salarycompare.aspx?codeNo=150212 (retrieved on May 18, 2022).
[36] Salary Explorer. http://www.salaryexplorer.com/salary-loc=107&loctype=1&job=12678&jobtype=3 (retrieved on May 18, 2022).
[37] Central Bank, Taiwan. Available online (In Chinese): https://www.cbc.gov.tw (retrieved on April 2, 2021).
[38] CEIC Data. https://www.ceicdata.com/zh-hans/indicator/japan/bank-lending-rate (retrieved on May 14, 2022).
[39] Ijiri, Y. Convergence of cash recovery rate. In Quantitative planning and control. Academic Press, pp. 259-267 (1979)
[40] Tradingview. https://tw.tradingview.com (retrieved on May 18, 2022).
[41] Anue. https://invest.cnyes.com/forex/detail/USDTWD/technical#fixed (retrieved on May 18, 2022).
[42] Taiwan Power Company. Available online (In Chinese): https://www.taipower.com.tw/tc/page.aspx?mid=126.(retrieved on May 14, 2022).
[43] Tokyo Electric Power Company (TEPCO). https://www.tepco.co.jp/en/hd/index- e.html (retrieved on May 14, 2022).
[44] New Energy and Industrial Technology Development Organization (NEDO). NEDO Available online (In Japanese): https://www.nedo.go.jp/content/100930737.pdf. (retrieved on May 14, 2022)
[45] Creative Commons Global Network. https://app.electricitymap.org/map (retrieved on May 14, 2022).
[46] Climate Investment Funds (CIF). Meeting documents/notes on financial and economic analysis (2017). https://www.climateinvestmentfunds.org/sites/cif_enc/files/meeting- documents/note_on_financial_and_economic_analysis_for_storage_ and_floating_solar_applications_07202017.pdf (retrieved on May 18, 2022).
[47] Ramasamy, Vignesh, and Robert Margolis. 2021. Floating Photovoltaic System Cost Benchmark: Q1 2021 Installations on Artificial Water Bodies. Golden, CO: National Renewable Energy Laboratory. NREL/TP-7A40-80695 https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy22osti/80695.pdf.
[48] Corporate Finance Institute. “WACC.” https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/knowledge/finance (retrieved on May 13, 2022).
[49] Japan National Tax Agency. https://www.nta.go.jp/taxes/nozei/nofu/01.htm (retrieved on May 18, 2022).
[50] Chiba Prefecture. https://www.pref.chiba.lg.jp/index.html (retrieved on May 18, 2022).
[51] National Taxation Bureau of Taipei, Ministry of Finance https://www.ntbt.gov.tw/singlehtml/ (retrieved on May 14, 2022).
[52] Zheng, D.; Wang, Y.; Zhang X. Management Accounting Third Edition. Guide Bookstore (In Chinese) (2015).
[53] Ministry of Economic Affairs. Available online (In Chinese):https://www.moeaboe.gov.tw/ECW/populace/web_book/wHandWebReports_File.ashx?type=office&book_code=M_CH&chapter_code=C&report_code=01 (retrieved on May 18, 2022).
[54] Japan’s Ministry of Economy, Trade, and Industry (METI). https://www.meti.go.jp/shingikai/sankoshin/hoan_shohi/denryoku_anzen/newenergy_hatsuden_wg/pdf/022_04_00.pdf (retrieved on May 18, 2022)
[55] Gore, T. “The Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism proposal fails the ambition and equity tests” (2021)
[56] Japan External Trade Organization (JETRO). https://www.jetro.go.jp/mypage/ (retrieved May 14, 2022)
[57] “Ministry urges firms to step up decarbonization - Taipei Times.” www.taipeitimes.com. (October 2, 2021) (retrieved May 14, 2021).
[58] Yasuo, T. Research Institute of Economy, Trade, and Industry (RIETI)
[59] Japan should lead the global effort to decarbonize in view of the EU’s CBAM proposal. (October 21, 2021). https://www.rieti.go.jp/en/columns/a01_0665.html. (retrieved May 14, 2021).
[60] Web site: Martín. José Rojo. BayWa r.e. adds to European floating solar momentum with double project completion. PV Tech. En. 2019-10-27.
[61] Fu, R.; Feldman, D.J.; Margolis, R. M. US solar photovoltaic system cost benchmark: Q1 2018 (No. NREL/TP-6A20-72399). National Renewable Energy Lab. (NREL), Golden, CO (United States) (2018)
[62] Gorjian, S.; Sharon, H.; Ebadi, H.; Kant, K.; Scavo, F. B.; Tina, G. M. Recent technical advancements, economics and environmental impacts of floating photovoltaic solar energy conversion systems. Journal of Cleaner Production, p. 278 (2021)
[63] Taiwan Power Company. Available online (In Chinese): https://www.taiwanstat.com/realtime/power/ (retrieved on 14. January 2022).
[64] Sultan, S.; Kim, J. H.; Kim, S.H.; Kwon, Y.; Lee, J.S. Innovative strategies toward PV-powered electrochemical CO2 reduction challenges, Journal of Energy Chemistry, 60, pp. 410-416 (2021)
[65] Redón, S. M.; Soler J. B. T.; Romero F. J. S. et al., Theoretical and experimental analysis of a floating photovoltaic cover for water irrigation reservoirs. Energy, 67, pp. 246–255 (2014)
[66] Chen, Z.; Wang, B. Lakes and Reservoirs in Taiwan. Science Monthly, Issue 0339, March 1998.
[67] Supervised by the River Bureau of the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism, Dam Engineering Center. “Japan’s Multipurpose Dam Appendix 1990 Edition” Sankaido (Japanese: Sankaido). (In Japanese) (1990)
[68] Japan Dam Foundation「Dam Handbook」. (In Japanese) http://damnet.or.jp