Application of Western and Islamic Philosophy to Business Ethics

Authors: Elmamy Ahmedsalem

Abstract:

The world has witnessed the collapse of many corporate giants as a result of unethical behavior in recent decades. This has induced a series of questions by the global community on why such occurrences could happen, even with corporate governance in place. This paper attempts to propose a philosophical approach from an Islamic perspective to be consolidated with current corporate governance in order to confront contemporary dilemmas. In this paper, ethical theories are presented as a discussion followed by their applications to modern cases of financial collapses. Virtue ethics by Aristotle, justice and fairness by John Rawls, deontology by Immanuel Kant, and utilitarianism by John Stuart Mill, are the four theories which can then be contrasted with the paradigm of Muslim scholars. Despite the differences between the fundamental principles of Islamic and Western worldviews, their ethical theories are aimed at making right decisions and solving ethical dilemmas based on what is good for society. Therefore, Islamic principles should be synthesized with Western philosophy to form a more coherent framework. The integration of Islamic and western ethical theories into business is important for sound corporate governance.

Keywords: Business ethics, Islamic philosophy, western philosophy, Western and Islamic Worldview of Ethics.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1316634

References:

[1] S. Arjoon, Corporate governance. http://list25.com/25-biggest-corporate-scandals-ever/, accessed on 15 / 12 /2015.
[2] T. Kara, Financial Crises 2008, Perpetrators, and Justice. [3] Seven Pillars Institute for Global Finance and Ethics http://sevenpillarsinstitute.org/mission, accessed on 10 / 07 /2016.
[4] H. Edward, http://futurepositive.synearth.net/, accessed on 15 / 07 /2016.
[5] A regional Islamic Summit on Environmental Governance for Islamic Leaders, the Academe and Community Advocates. EL Manuel Convention Center, (July 9, 2007), Al Khalifa (The Steward), pp. 15–17.
[6] R. I. Beekun, (1997). Islamic Business Ethics. The International Institute of Islamic Thought. Human Development, Vol. 2, pp 20–60.
[7] Ryan, Huldah A., Bottiglieri, W., Kroleski Steven L. (2008). Fraud vs. Ethics Ethics: The Case of the Backdating of Stock Options, Journal of Business and Economics Research, vol. 6, pp. 13-23.
[8] C. Raiborn, M. Massoud, R. Morris, and C. Pier (2007), Ethics of Options Repricing and Backdating: Banishing Greed from Corporate Governance and Management. The CPA Journal Online, http://www.nysscpa.org/cpajournal.
[9] G. Curtis, (2012). Investopedia, “The dangers of options backdating” http://www.investopedia.com/articles/optioninvestor/07/options_backdating.asp, accessed on 20 / 12 /2015.
[10] Leonard J. Brooks; Paul Dunn (2019). Business and Professional Ethics for Directors, Executives and Accountants, vol. 5, pp. 60-80.
[11] S. M. Al-Attas, (1992). “Islam: The Concept of Religion and the Foundation of Ethics and Morality, pp. 17–54.
[12] R. Machan, J. E. Chesher, (1996), What is Morally Right with Insider Trading, Vol. 10, pp.135-142.
[13] N. P. Barry, (1991), the Ethic of Insider Trading, pp. 57–60.
[14] J. Rachels, (2007), The Elements of Moral Philosophy, pp, 125–200.
[15] R. M. Kolb, (1971), Risk Management and Risk Transfer: Distributive Justice in Finance, Vol.13, No 4, 90–98.
[16] J. Rawls, (1971), Justice as Fairness, The Main Idea of The Theory of Justice), pp, 5–10.
[17] H. Shefrin (2008), A Behavioral Approach to Asset Pricing, pp.20-86
[18] H. J. Hejase, B. Hamdar, M. Raslan, (2013), Business Ethics and Religion in The Financial Business Sector: Case of Syria, Journal of Business & Management, Coes&Rj-Jbm, Vol.1 No 2, pp.73-87.
[19] B.Debacle, (2013), Unauthorized Trading, https://www.glynholton.com/notes/barings_debacle/, accessed on 08 / 06 /2016.
[20] B. N. Waller, (2005), Consider Ethics: Theory, Readings, and Contemporary Issues, pp. 45–70.
[21] M. A. Quasem, (1997). The Ethics of Al Ghazali: A composite ethics in Islam, pp.150-200.
[22] L. J. Brooks, P. Dunn, (2010). Business and Professional Ethics for Directors, Executives, & Accountants. Mason, OH: South Western Cengage Learning, pp. 300–378.
[23] Center for Responsibility Lending (CLR), (2008), report on IndyMac, titled, what went wrong? pp. 6–18.