High Specific Speed in Circulating Water Pump Can Cause Cavitation, Noise and Vibration

Authors: Chandra Gupt Porwal

Abstract:

Excessive vibration means increased wear, increased repair efforts, bad product selection & quality and high energy consumption. This may be sometimes experienced by cavitation or suction/discharge recirculation which could occur only when net positive suction head available NPSHA drops below the net positive suction head required NPSHR. Cavitation can cause axial surging, if it is excessive, will damage mechanical seals, bearings, possibly other pump components frequently, and shorten the life of the impeller. Efforts have been made to explain Suction Energy (SE), Specific Speed (Ns), Suction Specific Speed (Nss), NPSHA, NPSHR & their significance, possible reasons of cavitation /internal recirculation, its diagnostics and remedial measures to arrest and prevent cavitation in this paper. A case study is presented by the author highlighting that the root cause of unwanted noise and vibration is due to cavitation, caused by high specific speeds or inadequate net- positive suction head available which results in damages to material surfaces of impeller & suction bells and degradation of machine performance, its capacity and efficiency too. Author strongly recommends revisiting the technical specifications of CW pumps to provide sufficient NPSH margin ratios >1.5, for future projects and Nss be limited to 8500 - 9000 for cavitation free operation.

Keywords: Best efficiency point (BEP), Net positive suction head NPSHA, NPSHR, Specific Speed NS, Suction Specific Speed Nss.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1110884

References:

[1] “Investigation of Recirculation Effects on the Formation of Vapour Bubbles in Centrifugal Pump Blades” by Mohammad Taghi Shervani Tabar, Seyyed Hojjat Majidi, Zahra Poursharifi, -World Academy of Science, Engineering & Technology- 49 2011.
[2] “Pump Cavitation-Various NPSHR Criteria, NPSHA Margins And Impeller Life Expectancy” by Bruno Schiavello, Director Fluid Dynamics, Applied Technology Department Philipsburg, New Jersey and Frank C. Visser, Principal Design & Fluid Dynamics Engineer, Flowserve Pump Division, Technical Services, Central Engineering Etten-Leur,The, The Netherlands. Proceeding of the Twenty-Fifth International Pump Users Symposium-2009.
[3] “Detecting Cavitation in Centrifugal Pumps” by Jeremy Jensen, Project Engineer and Kenwood Dayton, Sr. Research Engineer, Bently Rotor Dynamics & Research Corporation, Orbit journal 2nd Quarter 2000, page no 26-27.
[4] “Hydraulic Institute standards”: Pump Operations, Efficiency, Testing & Systems and NPSH margin; www.pump.org/
[5] “Pump Cavitation and High Pressure Liquid Health Essay” by UKEssays.com..
[6] “A review of Nss Limitations-New Opportunities” by Michael Hirschberger, Head of Hydrodynamic Department and Ian James Engineering Manager, Ruhrpumpen Inc. of Ruhrpumpen Group, Tulsa, Oklahoma. Proceeding of The Twenty-Fifth International Pump Users Symposium-2009.
[7] “How to Avoid Expensive Pump Failures and Repairs from Cavitation by Determining the ‘Suction Energy’ of a pump”, WaterWorldCE.com.
[8] “Specific Speed v Suction Specific Speed” Newsletter on pumps and reliability, Nov 2007 by Dale B. Andrews- Lawrence pumps http:/www.lawrencepumps.com
[9] “Specific Speed” by Steve Wilson by Grundfos (White Paper) https://www.grundfos.com/
[10] “All About Specific Speed 7-3” http://www.mcnallyinstitute.com
[11] “Does Impeller Affect NPSHR?” by Daisude Konno, Senior Engineer and Project Team Leader and Yoshiyuki Yamada, Design Engineer, Hydraulic Machinery Department Ebara Corporation Tokyo, Japan, Proceedings of The First International Pump Symposium.
[12] “Understanding Pump and Suction Specific Speed” by PDH online Course M136 (2PDH) Randall W. Whitesides, PE 2012, PDHonline.com.
[13] “Sufficient NPSH Margin Important to Pump Reliability” by Allan R. Budris, www.waterworld.com/
[14] “What is Best Efficiency Point?” Frequently asked questions http://epumpdoctor.com/
[15] “Avoid Repeat Pump Failure” By Heinz P. Bloch, P.E., Process Machinery Consulting, www.plantservices.com/
[16] “Article #3: Suction Specific Speed” http://www.pump-magazine.com/
[17] “Centrifugal Pump: Which Suction Specific Speeds are Acceptable?” by J. L Hallam, Amoco Oil Co. Texas City, Texas. Hydrocarbon Processing, April 1982, page 195.
[18] “Pump Vibrations” by W.E(Ed) Nelson, Consultant Dickinson, Texas & J. W. Dufour, Chief Engineer, Mechanical Equipment Services, Amoco, Oil Company, Chicago, Illinois -Proceedings of The Ninth International Pump Users Symposium,
[19] “Can Pump Design Upgrades Allow Lower Flow Operation without NPSHR Recirculation Damage?” by Lev Nelik, Ph.D., June 2014 in Pumps & Systems. www.pumpsandsystems.com/
[20] “Cavitation Prediction” www.pumpfundamentals.com/
[21] “Why NPSHR Changes With Impeller Diameter?” by Petroskills by John M Campbell, www.jmcampbell.com/
[22] “Which is Which Cavitation or Recirculation?” by John C. Robertson PE/CPE, AMSCO Inc. 105 Goldenrain Way, Simpsonville, S.C. 29680, www.maintenanceresources.com/
[23] “What is Pump Cavitation?” Crane Engineering, Optimizing Fluid System Performance. Posted by Brad Parkhurst. (July 10. 2014).
[24] “Influence of Impeller Suction Specific Speed on Vibration Performance” by David Cowan, Hydraulic Engineer, ITT Goulds Pumps Basingstoke, Hampshire, UK, Simon Bradshaw, Director of API Product Development & Technology And Thomas Liebner, Hydraulics Engineer, ITT Goulds Pumps, Seneca Falls, NY, USA. Proceedings of Twenty- Ninth Turbomachinery International Pump Users Symposium, October 1-3, 2013, Houston, Texas.
[25] “Understanding Pump Curves #6 Minimum Flow” Part Two: Suction Specific Speed by Ron Astall, United Pumps Australia. Courtesy PIA Australian Pump Technical Handbook.
[26] “Pump Guy Mailbag: Minimum Acceptable Flow for Effective Pump Operation” by Larry Bachus http://www.flowcontrolnetwork.com/pumpguy- mailbag-minimum-acceptable-flow-for-effective-pump-operation/
[27] WPIL Limited India, Data sheet of CW Pumps (3x500 MW )