Comparative Analysis of Ranunculus muricatus and Typha latifolia as Wetland Plants Applied for Domestic Wastewater Treatment in a Mesocosm Scale Study

Authors: S. Aziz, M. Ali, S. Asghar, S. Ahmed

Abstract:

Comparing other methods of waste water treatment, constructed wetlands are one of the most fascinating practices because being a natural process they are eco-friendly have low construction and maintenance cost and have considerable capability of wastewater treatment. The current research was focused mainly on comparison of Ranunculus muricatus and Typha latifolia as wetland plants for domestic wastewater treatment by designing and constructing efficient pilot scale horizontal subsurface flow mesocosms. Parameters like chemical oxygen demand, biological oxygen demand, phosphates, sulphates, nitrites, nitrates, and pathogenic indicator microbes were studied continuously with successive treatments. Treatment efficiency of the system increases with passage of time and with increase in temperature. Efficiency of T. latifolia planted setups in open environment was fairly good for parameters like COD and BOD5 which was showing reduction up to 82.5% for COD and 82.6% for BOD5 while DO was increased up to 125%. Efficiency of R. muricatus vegetated setup was also good but lowers than that of T. latifolia planted showing 80.95% removal of COD and BOD5. Ranunculus muricatus was found effective in reducing bacterial count in wastewater. Both macrophytes were found promising in wastewater treatment.

Keywords: Biological oxygen demand, chemical oxygen demand, horizontal subsurface flow, Total suspended solids, Wetland.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1100180

References:

[1] Y. Zhang, “Design of a Constructed Wetland for Wastewater Treatment and Reuse in Mount Pleasant, Utah,” 2012. All Graduate Plan B and report, paper 216.
[2] M. Hazra, K.Avishek, G. Pathak, “Developing an Artificial Wetland System for Wastewater Treatment: A Designing Perspective,” IJEP.2011.
[3] A. Simi, C. Mitchell, “Design and Hydraulics Performance of a Constructed Wetland Treating Oil Refinery Wastewater,” WST.Vol.40, pp.301-307, 1999.
[4] C. C. Tanner, “Plants as ecosystem engineers in subsurface-flow treatment wetlands,” WST. Vol.44 (11–12), pp.9–17, 2001.
[5] H. E. Muga, J. R. Mihelcic, “Sustainability of wastewater treatment technologies”. JEM. Vol.88(3), pp.437-447, 2008.
[6] R. I. Smith, “Ecology and Field Biology”(3rd .Edn) Harper and Row. New York. 1980.
[7] RH. Kadlec, RL. Knight, “Treatment Wetlands”. Boca Raton Lewis Publishers., FL.pp. 893, 1996.
[8] G. Merlin, C. Sedilot, N. Herbert, D. Grasselly,“Treatment of tomato greenhouses drainage solutions by experimental constructed wetlands” in Proc.8th International Conf. Wetland Systems for Water Pollution Control, University of Dar-es-Salaam, Tanzania and IWA, 2002,pp. 526–533.
[9] AA. Chaudhry, “Wetlands In Pakistan: What Is Happening To Them?” World Environment Day. 2010.
[10] RH. Kadlec, “Hydrological factors in wetland water treatment. In Constructed Wetlands for Wastewater Treatment” DA. Hammer, ed., Lewis Publishers, USA, 1989, pp. 21-40
[11] U.S. EPA, “Subsurface Flow Constructed Wetlands for Wastewater Treatment: A Technology Assessment” Office of Water, Washington, USA, 1993, EPA 832-R-93-001.
[12] H. Brix, H. Schierup “The use of macrophytes in water pollution control,” AMBIO. vol.18, pp. 100-107, 1989.
[13] J. Vymazal, L. Kröpfelová “Wastewater Treatment in Constructed Wetlands with Horizontal Sub-Surface Flow,” Springer. Dordrecht, Netherlands 2008.
[14] B. Collins, JV. McArthur, RR. Sharitz “Plant effects on microbial assemblages and remediation of acidic coal pile runoff in mesocosm treatment wetlands,” Ecological Enginering, vol.23, pp. 107-115, 2004.
[15] C. Munch, P. Kuschk, I. Roske, “Root stimulated nitrogen removal: only a local effect or important for water treatment,” WST, vol.51, pp.185- 192, 2005.
[16] V. Gagnon, F. Chazarenc, Y. Comeau, J. Brisson, “Influence of macrophyte species on microbial density and activity in constructed wetlands,” WST.vol.56(3), pp.249–254, 2007.
[17] H. Brix, “Do macrophytes play a role in constructed treatment wetlands?” WST. Vol. 35(5), pp.11–17, 1997.
[18] U. Stottmeister, A. Wießner, P. Kuschk, U. Kappelmeyer, M. Kastner, O. Bederski, RA. Muller, H.Moormann, “Effects of plants and microorganisms in constructed wetlands for wastewater treatment,” Biotechnology Advances. Vol. 22(1), pp. 93– 117, 2003.
[19] K.Seidel, “Wirkung höherer Pflanzen auf pathogene Keime in Gewassern” Naturwissenschaften vol.58, pp.150– 1, 1971.
[20] F. Rivera, A. Warren, E. Ramirez, O. Decamp, P. Bonilla, E. Gallegos, A. Calderón, JT. Sánchez, “Removal of pathogens from wastewaters by the root zone method (RZM),” WST. Vol.32, pp.211 –8, 1995.
[21] S. Rasool, S. Ali, TA. Mughal, “Antimicrobial and synergistic studies of Ranunculus murricatus against some indigenous bacteria,” PJB. Vol.46 (1), pp.345-352, 2014.
[22] S. Nazir, K. Tahir, R. Naz, ZH. Khan, A. Khan, R. Islam, A. Rehman, “In vitro screening of Ranunculus muricatusfor potential cytotoxic and antimicrobial activities,” GJP. Vol.8 (3), pp.427-431, 2014.
[23] American Public Health Association (APHA) “Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater,” (20th edn.). Washington D.C. 1998.
[24] National Standards for Drinking water Quality (NSDWG) Government of Pakistan, Pakistan Environmental Protection Agency. http://www.freshwateraction.net/sites/. 2008.
[25] S. Kouki, F. M’hiri, N. Saidi, Belaid, A. Hassen “Performances of a constructed wetland treating domestic wastewaters during a macrophyte life cycle,” Desalination. Vol.246, pp.452-467, 2009.
[26] J. Dickopp, M. Kazda, and H. Clžková, “Differences in rhizome aeration of Phragmites australis in a constructed wetland,” Ecological Enginering. Vol. 37, pp. 1647-1653, 2011.
[27] S. Vacca, “Bioretention Facilities and Constructed Wetlands Efficiency and Use: A Review,” http://soils.ifas.ufl.edu/docs/pdf/academic/papers/ Vacca_Samuel.pdf 2011.
[28] JL. Faulwetter, V. Gagnon, C. Sundberg, F. Chazarenc, MD. Burr, J. Brisson, AK. Camper, OR. Stein, “Microbial processes influencing performance of treatment wetlands: a review,” Ecological Engineering. Vol.35 (6), pp.987-1004, 2009.
[29] Suhendrayatna, Marwan, R. Andriani, Y. Fajriana, Elvitriana, “Removal of municipal wastewater BOD, COD, and TSS by Phyto-Reduction: A laboratory–scale comparison of aquatic plants at different species Typha latifolia and Saccharum spontaneum,” IJEIT. Vol.2 (6), 2012.
[30] International Water Association (IWA) “Constructed Wetlands for Pollution Control. IWA Special Group on Use of Macrophytes in Water Pollution Control,” Science and Technology. Rep. 8. IWA Publication, London, 2000.
[31] J. Vymazal, “Removal of BOD5 in constructed wetlands with horizontal sub-surface flow: Czech experience,” Water Science and Technology. Vol.40 (3), pp.133-138, 1999.
[32] SL. Whitmire, and SK. Hamilton,“Rapid removal of nitrate and sulfate in freshwater wetland sediments,” JEQ. Vol.34, pp. 2062-2071, 2005.
[33] D. Fortin, R. Goulet, M. Roy “Seasonal cycling of Fe and S in a constructed wetland: The role of sulfate-reducing bacteria,” Geomicrobiology Journal. Vol.17, pp. 221-235, 2000.
[34] S. Hsu, J. Maynard “The use of sulfur isotopes to monitor the effectiveness of constructed wetlands in controlling acid mine drainage,” EEP. Vol.1, pp.223-233, 1999.
[35] D. Borden, O. Stein, P. Hook, “Seasonal effects of supplemental organic carbon on sulfate reduction and zinc sulfide precipitation in constructed wetland microcosms,” In International Ecological Engineering Society Meeting. Lincoln University, New Zealand. pp. 296-300, 2001.
[36] OR. Stein, PB. Hook, “Temperature, plants and oxygen: how does season affect constructed wetland performance,” JESH. Part A: vol.40 (6–7), pp.1331–1342, 2005.
[37] WC. Allen, PB. Hook, OR. Stein, JR. Beiderman,“Temperature and wetland plant species effects on wastewater treatment and root zone oxidation,” JEQ. Vol.31, pp.1010-1016, 2002.
[38] FJ. Szogi, JM. Humenik, PG. Rice, Hunt, “Swine wastewater treatment by Media Filtration” JESH. Vol. 832(5), pp.831-843, 1997.
[39] L. Bonomo, G. Pastorelli, N. Zambon, “Advantages and limitations of duckweed-based wastewater treatment systems,” WST. Vol.35(5), pp.236, 1997.
[40] K. Sakadevan, H. Bavor, “Phosphate adsorption characteristics of soils, Slags and zeolite to be used as substrates in constructed wetland systems,” Water Research. Vol.32(2), pp. 393-399, 1998.
[41] AS. Brooks, MN. Rozenwald, LD. Geohring, LW. Lion, TS. Steenhuis, “Phosphorus removal by wollastonite: a constructed wetland substrate,” Ecological Enginering. Vol.15, pp. 121-132,2000.
[42] B. Bostrom, M. Jansson, C. Forsberg, “Phosphorus release from lake sediments”. Archiv für Hydrobiologie–Beiheft Ergebnisse der Limnologie. vol. 18, pp. 5–59, 1982.
[43] A. Valipour, VK. Raman, VS. Ghole, “A new approach in wetland systems for domestic wastewater treatment using Phragmites sp,” Ecological Enginering. Vol.35, pp.1797–1803, 2009.
[44] E. Paul, F.Clark “Soil Microbiology and Biochemistry”. Elsevier. New York. 1989.
[45] R. Hauck, “Atmospheric nitrogen chemistry, nitrification, denitrification, and their relationships” Handbook of Environmental Chemistry. Hutzinger, O. (ed). Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag. pp. 105-127, 1984.
[46] J.Vymazal, “Algae and element cycling in wetlands” Chelsea, Michigan, USA: Lewis Publishers, 1995.
[47] M. Garcia, E. Becares “Bacterial removal in three pilot-scale wastewater treatment systems for rural areas,” WST. Vol.35, pp. 197-200, 1997.