The Effect of Pilates Method in Scholar’s Trunk Strength and Hamstring Flexibility: Gender Differences

Authors: Noelia González-Gálvez, María Carrasco Poyatos, Pablo Jorge Marcos Pardo, Yuri Feito

Abstract:

Musculoskeletal injuries in school children could be reduced improving trunk strength and hamstring flexibility. Low levels of trunk muscle strength and hamstring flexibility may result in acute and musculoskeletal chronic diseases. The Pilates Method can be appropriate to improve these physical condition attributes and has been rarely employed by this social group. On the other hand, it has been shown that trunk strength and flexibility are different between genders, but there is no evidence about the effect of exercise programs designed to improve both items in school children. Therefore the objective of this study was to measure the effect of a six-week Pilates-based exercise program in 14 year old school children trunk strength and hamstring flexibility, establishing differences in gender. The sample was composed of 57 students divided into experimental group (EG; n=30) and control group (CG; n=27). Bench Trunk Curl test (BTC), Sörensen test and Toe-touch test (TT) were used to measure dynamic muscular resistance in trunk flexion, isometric strength in trunk extension and hamstring flexibility, respectively. EG utilized the Pilates exercise program during six-weeks (2 days/week, 55minutes/session). After this period of training, EG improved trunk strength and hamstring flexibility significantly but there were no significant differences within CG. Although boys were better in BTC test and girls were better in TT test, there were no significant differences between them.

Keywords: Teens, school, trunk muscular resistance, intervention, physical performance, abdominal, back.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1097357

References:

[1] V. Akuthota, and S. Nadler. “Core strengthening” Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 85, 2004, 86-92.
[2] B. Bixler, and R.L. Jones, R. L. “High-school foorball injuries: effects of a post-halftime warm-up and stretching routine” American Journal of Sports Medicine, 12, 1992, 131-139.
[3] P.A. Lopez-Miñarro. “Ejercicios desaconsejados en la actividad Física. Detección y alternativas” 2000. Barcelona: INDE
[4] F.M. Kovacs, M. Gestoso, MT.G. Del Real, J.Lopez, N. Mufraggi, and J.I. Mendez. “Risk factors for non-specific low back pain in schoolchildren and their parents: a population based study” Pain, 103, 2003, 259-268.
[5] C. Bouchard, F.T. Dionne, J.A. Simoneau, and M.R. Boulay. “Genetics of aerobic and anaerobic performances” Exercise and Sports Sciences Reviews, 1992, 20, 27-58.
[6] K.. Tiainen, S. Sipila, M. Alen, E. Heikkinen, J. Kaprio, M. Koskenvuo, A. Tolvanen, S. Pajala, S. and T. Rantanen. “Heritability of maximal isometric muscle strength in older female twins” Journal of Applied Physiology, 2004, 96, 173-180.
[7] J. Ftitz, and M. George. “The use of a classification approach to identify subgroups of patients with acute low pain. Interrater realiabity andshotyerm treatament otcomes” Spine, 2000, 25, 106-114.
[8] S.L. Edmon, and D.T. Felson, D.T. “Prevalence of back pain syntoms” Journal Rheumatology, 2000, 27(1), 220-225.
[9] R.F.C. Moreira, F.H. Akagi, P.Y.L. Wun, C.S. Moriguchi and T.O. Sato “Effects of a school based exercise program on children's resistance and flexibility” Work, 41, 2012, 922-928.
[10] D. Mayorga, J. Viciana, A. Cocca, and M.T. Miranda. “Efecto del entrenamiento de la fuerza sobre la resistencia muscular abdominal en escolares pre-púberes” EF Deportes, 15(148), 2010, 1. En línea: http://www.efdeportes.com/efd148/resistencia-muscular-abdominal-enpre- puberes.htm (12/05/2012).
[11] A. Lavandera, O. Abadia, and J. Azael, (2006). Influencia de un trabajo de flexibilidad en las clases de educación física en primaria. Revista digital Ef deportes, 11(100), 2006, 1-8.
[12] P. Sainz de Baranda, P.L. Rodríguez, F. Santonja, and P. Andujar “La columna vertebral del escolar Sevilla: Wanceulen.
[13] R. Valdivia, F. Calero and L. Orlando “ Programas de ejercicios físicos de estiramientos para la mejora del acortamiento isquiosural”. Revista digital Ef deportes, 15(154), 2011, 1-16.
[14] R.C.T. Nelson, and W.D. Bandy, W.D. “Eccentric Training and Static Stretching Improve Hamstring Flexibility of High School Males” Journal of Athletic Training, 39(3), 2014, 254-258.
[15] D.A. Reid, and P.J. McNair. “Passive Force, Angle, and Stiffness Changes after Stretching of Hamstring Muscles” Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 36(11), 2004, 1944-1948.
[16] P.L. Rodríguez, F. Santonja, M. Canteras, M. Delgado, J. Fernández, and J. Balsalobre. “Mejora de la extensibilidad isquiosural tras un programa escolar de estiramientos” Selección, 8(4), 1999, 15-22. 16
[17] P. Sainz de Baranda. “ El trabajo de la flexibilidad en Educación Física: Programa de intervención” Ciencia Cultura y Deporte, 4(10), 2009, 33- 38.
[18] A.C. Sollerhed and G. Ejlertsson.“Physical benefits of expanded physical education in primary school: findings from a 3-year intervention study in Sweden” Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Sciences in sports, 18, 2008,102-107.
[19] K. Adamany. Pilates: Guía para la mejora del rendimiento. 2006. Badalona: Paidotribo.
[20] A. Menendes. “The complete guide to Joseph H. Pilates´ techniques of physical conditioning: with special help for back pain and sport training” (2nd ed). 2004. United states of America.libraryof congress cataloguingin- publication data. Hunter House. Inc publishers.
[21] I.E. García, S.M. De Barros, and M. Saldanha. Avaliação isocinética da musculatura envolvida na flexão e extensão do tronco: efeito do método Pilates” Revista Brasileira de Medicina do Esporte, 2004, 10(6), 487- 490.
[22] J. Kloubec. “Pilates for improvement of muscle endurance, flexibility, balance and posture” Journal of stretch and conditioning research, 2010, 24(3), 661-667.
[23] N. Segal, J. Hein, and J. Basford. “The effects of Pilates training on flexibility and body composition: an observational study” Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 2004, 85, 1977-1981.
[24] B. Sekendiz, O. Altun, F. Korkusuz, and S. Akın. “Effects of Pilates exercise on trunk strength, endurance and flexibility in sedentary adult females. Exercise Physiology” Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies, 2007, 11,318-326.
[25] C. Bouchard, F.T. Dionne, J.A. Simoneau, and M.R. Boulay. “Genetics of aerobic and anaerobic performances” Exercise and Sports Sciences Reviews, 20, 1992, 27-58.
[26] K. Tiainen, S. Sipila, M. Alen, E. Heikkinen, J. Kaprio, M.Koskenvuo, A. Tolvanen, S.Pajala, and T. Rantanen. “Heritability of maximal isometric muscle strength in older female twins” Journal of Applied Physiology, 96, 2004, 173-180.
[27] D. Knudson “The validity of recent curl-up test in Young adults” Journal of strength and conditioning research, 15(1), 2001, 81-85.
[28] C. Demoulin, M.Vanderthommen, C. Duysens and J.M. Crielaard “Spinal muscle evaluation using the Sorensen test: a critical appraisal of the literature” Joint Bone Spine, 73, 2006, 43-50.
[29] F. Santonja, V. Ferrer and I. Martínez “Exploraciónclínica del síndrome de isquiosuralescortos”. Selección, 4(2), 1991, 81-91.
[30] N. González-Gálvez, M. Carrasco, and P.J. Marcos. “El Método Pilates: una propuesta didáctica para 3º de Educación Secundaria Obligatoria”EmásF: Revista digital de Educación Física, 4(24), 2013, 1- 14.
[31] J.C. Eisenmann andR.M. Malina. “Age- and sex-associated variation in neuromuscular capacities of adolescent distance runners”Journal of Sports Sciences. Jul;21(7), 2003, 551-557.
[32] H. Krombholz. “Physical performance in relation to age, sex, birth order, social class, and sports activities of preschool children” Perceptual and Motor Skills.Apr;102(2), 2006, 477-84.
[33] F.B. Ortega, J.R. Ruiz, M.J. Castillo, L.A. Moreno, A. Urzanqui, M. Gonzalez-Gross et al. “Health-related physical fitness according to chronological and biological age in adolescents. The AVENA study. Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness. Sep;48(3), 2008, 371- 379.
[34] M. Saar and T.Jurimae. “Relationships between anthropometry, physical activity and motor abilities in 10-17 year old Estonians” Journal of Human Movement Studies.47(1), 2004, 1-12.
[35] A. Starker, T. Lampert, A. Worth, J. Oberger, H. Kahl and K. Bos. “Motor fitness. Results of the German Health Interview and Examination Survey for Children and Adolescents (KiGGS)”Bundesgesundheitsblatt- GesundheitsforschungGesundheitsschutz. May-Jun;50(5-6), 2007, 775- 783.
[36] C. León “Influencia del sexo en la práctica deportiva. Biología de la mujer deportista” Arbor CLXV, 650 (feb, 2000), 249-263.