Gender Differences in Negotiation: Considering the Usual Driving Forces?

Authors: Claude Alavoine, Ferkan Kaplanseren

Abstract:

Negotiation is a specific form of interaction based on communication in which the parties enter into deliberately, each with clear but different interests or goals and a mutual dependency towards a decision due to be taken at the end of the confrontation. Consequently, negotiation is a complex activity involving many different disciplines from the strategic aspects and the decision making process to the evaluation of alternatives or outcomes and the exchange of information. While gender differences can be considered as one of the most researched topic within negotiation studies, empirical works and theory present many conflicting evidences and results about the role of gender in the process or the outcome. Furthermore, little interest has been shown over gender differences in the definition of what is negotiation, its essence or fundamental elements. Or, as differences exist in practices, it might be essential to study if the starting point of these discrepancies does not come from different considerations about what is negotiation and what will encourage the participants in their strategic decisions. Some recent and promising experiments made with diverse groups show that male and female participants in a common and shared situation barely consider the same way the concepts of power, trust or stakes which are largely considered as the usual driving forces of any negotiation. Furthermore, results from Human Resource self-assessment tests display and confirm considerable differences between individuals regarding essential behavioral dimensions like capacity to improvise and to achieve, aptitude to conciliate or to compete and orientation towards power and group domination which are also part of negotiation skills. Our intention in this paper is to confront these dimensions with negotiation’s usual driving forces in order to build up new paths for further research.

Keywords: Gender, negotiation, personality, power, stakes, trust.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1093848

References:

[1] G-O. Faure, G. Sjöstedt, "Culture and negotiation: An introduction" in G-O. Faure, J. Z. Rubin (ed.), Culture and Negotiation, Sage Publications, 1993, pp.1-13.
[2] L. L. Putnam, , "Reframing integrative and distributive bargaining: A process perspective", in R. J. Lewicki, B. H. Sheppard, M.H. Bazerman (eds.), Research on negotiation in organizations, JAI series annual, Greenwich CT: JAI, 1990.
[3] L. L. Putnam, M. E. Roloff, Communication and Negotiation, Sage Publications, Newbury Park. CA. 1992.
[4] D. A. Lax, J. K. Sebenius, The manager as negotiator, New York: Free Press. 1986.
[5] W. I. Zartman, "Resolving the toughness dilemma", in G-O. Faure, La négociation : Regards sur sa diversité, Première biennale internationale de la négociation, Paris: Editions Publibook, 2005, pp. 45-59
[6] D. Nelson, M. Wheeler, "Rocks and hard places: managing two tensions in negotiation", Negotiation Journal, vol. 20, n°. 1, pp.113-128, 2004.
[7] J. K. Sebenius, "Six habits of merely effective negotiators", Harvard Business Review, vol. 79, n°. 4, April, pp. 87-95, 2001.
[8] Rousseau Denise M., Sitkin Sim B., Burt Ronald S., Camerer Colin, (1998), "Not so different after all: A cross-discipline view of trust”, The Academy of Management Review, Vol. 23, n°3, pp. 393−404.
[9] Lewicki Roy J., McAllister Daniel J., (1998), "Trust and distrust: New relationships and realities”, Academy of Management. The Academy of Management Review, Vol.23, n°3, pp. 438-458.
[10] Turel Ofir, Yuan Yufei, (2008), "You can't shake hands with clenched fists: potential effects of trust assessments on the adoption of e-negotiation services”, Group Decision and Negotiation, Vol. 17, n°2, pp.141−155.
[11] I. W. Zartman, "The structure of negotiation", in V. A. Kremenyuk (ed.), International Negotiation: Analysis, Approaches, Issues, Jossey Bass Publishers, San Francisco, 1991, pp. 65-77.
[12] K. Boulding, "The nature of power", in Lewicki Roy J., Saunders David M., Minton John W., Negotiation: readings, exercises and cases, Mc Graw Hill, 3rd edition, 1999, pp. 180-192.
[13] Lewicki Roy J., Saunders David M., Minton John W., (2001), Essentials of negotiation, Mc Graw Hill, 2nd edition.
[14] M. Deutsch, The Resolution of Conflict, New Haven, Yale University Press, 1973.
[15] Bacharach Samuel B., Lawler Edward J., (1981), Bargaining: Power, Tactics and Outcomes, San Francisco, Jossey-Bass.
[16] C. Dupont, "A model of the negotiation process with different strategies", in P. Ghauri, J. C. Usunier (eds), International Business Negotiations, Pergamon / Elsevier Science, 1996, pp. 39-67.
[17] Kim Peter H., Pinkley Robin L., Fragale Alison R., (2005), "Power dynamics in negotiation”, Academy of Management Review, Vol.30, n°4, pp. 779-822.R. E. Walton, R. B. McKersie, A behavioral theory of labor negotiations: An analysis of a social interaction system. New York: Mc Graw Hill, 1965.
[18] M. Leroux, Les dimensions cachées de la négociation, Paris, Insep Editions, 1992.
[19] Rubin J. Z., Brown B. R., (1975), The social psychology of bargaining and negotiation, New York: Academic Press.
[20] Stuhlmacher Alice F., Walters Amy E., (1999), "Gender differences in negotiation outcome: A meta-analysis”, Personnel Psychology, Vol.52, n°3, pp. 653-677.
[21] Barkacs Linda L., Standifird Stephen, (2008), "Gender distinctions and empathy in negotiation”, Journal of Organizational Culture, Communications and Conflicts, Vol.12, n°1, pp. 83-92.
[22] Walters Amy E., Stuhlmacher Alice F., Meyer L. L., (1998), "Gender and negotiator competitiveness: A meta-analysis”, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, Vol.76, n°1, pp. 1-29.
[23] Calhoun Patrick S., Smith William P., (1999), "Integrative bargaining: Does gender make a difference?”, The International Journal of Conflict Management, Vol.10, n°3, pp. 203-224.
[24] Thompson Leigh, (1990), "Negotiation behavior and outcomes: Empirical evidence and theoretical issues”, Psychological Bulletin, Vol.108, n°3, pp. 515-532.
[25] Menkel-Meadow Carrie, (2000), "Teaching about gender and negotiation: Sex, truths and videotape”, Negotiation Journal, Vol.16, n°4, pp. 357-375.
[26] Kolb Deborah M., (2000), "More than just a footnote: constructing a theoretical framework for teaching about gender in negotiation”, Negotiation Journal, Vol.16, n°4, pp. 347-356.
[27] Kolb Deborah M., (2009), "Too bad for the women or does it have to be? Gender and negotiation research over the past twenty five years”, Negotiation Journal, Vol.25, n°4, pp. 515-531.
[28] Kray Laura J., Thompson Leigh, (2005), "Gender stereotypes and negotiation performance: An examination of theory and research”, Research in Organizational Behavior, Vol.26, pp. 105-184.
[29] Costa P.T. Jr., McCrae R.R. (1985). The NEO Personality Inventory manual. Odessa, FL: Psychological Assessment Resources.
[30] Goldberg, L. R. (1990). "An alternative description of personality: The Big Five factor structure”. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Vol.59, pp. 1216-1229.
[31] Costa P.T. Jr., Terracciano, A., McCrae, R.R., (2001), "Gender Differences in Personality Traits Across Cultures: Robust and Surprising Findings". Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Vol. 81, n°2, pp. 322–331.