A Longitudinal Study of the Readability of the Chairman’s Narratives in Corporate Reports: Malaysian Evidence

Authors: Azhar Abdul Rahman

Abstract:

This paper examines the readability of the chairman’s narratives, as determined by the Flesch score, of a Malaysian public listed company’s corporate reports from 1962 to 2009. It partially supports earlier studies which demonstrated that corporate reports were difficult to read, and had shown very negligible decrease in difficulty over time. Net profit to sales and readability was significantly positively correlated but number of financial statements was significantly negatively correlated with readability.

Keywords: Chairman’s narratives, corporate communications, readability, longitudinal.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1093510

References:

[1] American Accounting Association (1966), A Statement of Basic Accountancy Theory, American Accounting Association, p. 1.
[2] Accounting Standards Steering Committee (1975), The Corporate Report, Accounting Standards Steering Committee, London, p.28.
[3] Steele, C. G. (1983), ‘Better Financial Reporting by Disclosing less’, Directors and Boards, Autumn, pp. 19-23.
[4] Smith, M. and Taffler, R. (1984), Improving the Communication Function of Published Accounting Statements’, Accounting and Business Research, Spring, pp. 139-146.
[5] Moriarty, S. (1979), ‘Communicating Financial Information through Multi-dimensional Graphics’, Journal of Accounting Research, Vol. 17, No, I Spring, pp. 205-224.
[6] Gambling, T. and Beattie, V. (1986), Effects of the Medium of Communication on the Comprehension and Retention of Messages in Corporate Reports’. Paper presented at the British Accounting Association Conference, Aberystwyth, April.
[7] Maunders, K. T. (1981), ‘Simplified and Employee Reports’ in the ICAEW Survey of Published Accounts 198142 1982-83, pp. 211-216 and 173-177.
[8] Hussey, R. (1983), Disclosure of Information and Employee Reporting, Gower, Alders hot.
[9] Hilton, A. (1978), Employee Reports, Woodhead Faulkner, Cambridge. 1978.
[10] Pashalian, S. and Crissy, W. E. (1952), ‘Corporate Annual Reports are Difficult, Dull Reading, Human Interest Value Low, Survey Shows’, Journal of Accountancy, Vol. 94, August, pp. 215-219.
[11] Lewis, N. R., Parker, L. D., Pound, 0. D. and Sutcliffe, P. (1986), Accounting Report Readability Techniques’, Accounting and Business Research, Summer, pp. 199-209.
[12] Jones, M. J. (1988). A Longitudinal Study of the Readability of the Chairman’s Narratives in the Corporate Reports of a UK Company. Accounting and Business Research. Vol. 18, Iss. 72; p. 297-306.
[13] Clatworthy, M. and Jones, M.J. (2001), ‘The effect of thematic structure on the variability of annual report readability’, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, Vol. 14 No. 3, pp. 311-26.
[14] Merkl-Davies, D. and Brennan, N. (2007), ‘Discretionary disclosure strategies in corporate narratives: Incremental information or impression management?’, Journal of Accounting Literature, Vol. 26, pp. 116-96.
[15] Li, F. (2008), "Annual report readability, current earnings, and earnings persistence", Journal of Accounting and Economics, Vol. 45, Nos 2/3, pp. 221-47.
[16] Carsberg, B., Hope, A. and Scapens, R, W. (1974), ‘The Objectives of Published Accounting Reports’, Accounting and Business Research, Summer, pp. 162-173.
[17] American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (1973), Objectives of Financial Statements, Report of the Study Group on Objectives of Financial Statements, New York.
[18] Regazzi, 3. H. (1974), ‘Why aren’t Financial Statements Understood?’, Journal of Accountancy, April, pp. 48-55.
[19] Estes, R. (1982), The Auditor’s Report and Investor Behavior, Lexington Books.
[20] Chall, J. S. (1958), Readability—an Appraisal of Research and Application, Ohio State University Press, Ohio.
[21] Smith, I. E. and Smith, N. p. (1971), ‘Readability: A Measure of Performance of the Communication Function of Financial Reporting’, Accounting Review, July, pp. 552-561.
[22] Haried, A. A. (1972), ‘The Semantic Dimensions of Financial Statements’, Journal of Accounting Research, Autumn, pp. 376-391.
[23] Haried, A. A. (1973), Measurement of Meaning in Financial Reports’, Journal of Accounting Research, pp. 117-145.
[24] Lee, T. A. and Tweedie, D. P. (1975), ‘Accounting Information: An Investigation of Private Shareholder Understanding’, Accounting and Business Research, Winter, pp. 3-17.
[25] Lee, T. A. and Tweedie, D. P. (1976), ‘The Private Shareholder: his Source of Financial Information and his Understanding of Reporting Practices’, Accounting and Business Research, Autumn, pp. 304-314.
[26] Lee, T. A. and Tweedie, D. P. (1977), The Private Shareholder and the Corporate Report, institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales.
[27] Lee, T. A. and Tweedie, I). P. (1981), The Institutional Investor and Financial Information, Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales.
[28] Flesch, R. (1949), The Art of Readable Writing, Harper and Urns, New York.
[29] Adelberg, A. II, (1983), ‘The Accounting Syntactic Complexity Formula: A New Instrument for Predicting the Readability of Selected Accounting Communications’, Accounting and Business Research, Summer, pp. 162-175.
[30] Brennan, N., Pierce, A. and Guillamon-Saorin, E. (2009), Impression management; Developing and illustrating a scheme of analysis for narrative disclosures - a methodological note. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal. Vol. 22, Iss. 5; pp. 789-832.
[31] Jones, M.J. and Shoemaker, P.A. (1994), "Accounting narratives: a review of empirical studies of content and readability", Journal of Accounting Literature, Vol. 13, pp. 142-84.
[32] Soper, F. I. and Dolphin, R. (1964), ‘Readability and Corporate Annual Reports’, Accounting Review, April, pp. 358-362.
[33] Still, M. D. (1972), The Readability of Chairmen’s Statements’, Accounting and Business Research, Winter, pp. 36-39.
[34] Dolphin, R. and Wagley, R. A. (1977), ‘Reading the Annual Report’, Financial Executive, June, pp. 20-22.
[35] Healey, p. (1977), ‘Can You Understand the Footnotes to Financial Statements?’, Accountant’s Journal, July, pp. 219-222.
[36] Stead, B. A. (1977), ‘Contents Analysis and Readability Formulas as Applied to the Accounting Principles Board’, Options Journal of Business Communication, Vol. 14, pp. 23-34.
[37] Sattari, S; Pitt, L. F. and Caruana, A (2011), ‘How readable are mission statements? An exploratory study’, Corporate Communications, Vol. 16, No. 4, pp. 282-292.
[38] Adelberg, A. H. (1979), ‘Narrative Disclosures Contained in Financial Reports: Means of Communication or Manipulation?’, Accounting and Business Research, Summer, pp. 179-189.
[39] Pound, G. D. (1980), ‘Employee Reports: Readability’, Australian Accountant, December, pp. 775-779.
[40] Pound, 0. D. (1981), ‘A Note on Audit Report Readability’, Accounting and Finance, May, pp. 45-55.
[41] Parker, L. D. (1982), ‘Corporate Annual Reporting: A Mass Communication Perspective’, Accounting and Business Research, Autumn, pp. 279-286.
[42] Courtis, J. K. (1986), ‘An Investigation into Annual Report Readability and Corporate Risk Return Relationships’, Accounting and Business Research, Autumn, pp. 285-294.
[43] Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (1995), Educational Statistics Yearbook Volume I, OECD Publications, Paris.
[44] Philpot, J. and Johnson, D. T. (2007). ‘Mutual fund performance and fund prospectus clarity’. Journal of Financial Services Marketing. Vol. 11, Iss. 3: p. 211-216.
[45] Singhvi, S. S. and Desai, H. B. (1971), ‘An Empirical Analysis of the Quality of Corporate Financial Disclosure’, Accounting Review, January, pp. 129-138.
[46] Morton, J. K. (1974), ‘Qualitative Objectives of Financial Accounting: A Comment on Relevance and Understandability Techniques, Journal of Accounting Research, Autumn, pp. 288-298.
[47] Klare, 0 R. (1974), ‘Assessing Readability’, Reading Research Quarterly, Vol. 10. pp. 62-102.
[48] Duffy, T. M. and Kabance, P. (1982), Testing a Readable Writing Approach to Text Revision’, Journal of Educational Psychology, Vol. 4, No. 5, pp. 733-748.
[49] Griesinger, W. S. and Klene, R. R. (1984), ‘Readability of Introductory Psychology Textbooks: Flesch versus Student Ratings’, Teaching of Psychology, Vol. II, No. 2, April.
[50] Swanson, C, a and Fox, H. G. (1953), Validity of Readability Formulas’, Journal of Applied Psychology. Vol. 37, No. 2, pp. 114-118.
[51] Pichert, J.W. and Elam, P. (1985), ‘Readability Formulas May Mislead You’, Patient Education and Counselling, 7, pp. 181-191.
[52] Freund, J. E. and Williams, F. J. (1977), Elementary Business Statistics -the Modern Approach, Prentice-Hall, New Jersey.
[53] Moroney, M. J. (1965), Facts and Figures, 3rd. ed., Penguin, Harmondsworth.
[54] Taylor, P. and Dunning, D. (1977), Statistics for Business, Polytechnic Publishers, Stockport.
[55] Wonnacott, T. H. and Wonnacolt, R. J. (1981), Regression: A Second Course in Statistics, J. Wiley & Sons: New York.
[56] Cohen, J. and Cohen P. (1975), Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Analysis for the Behavioural Sciences, 3. Wiley & Sons, New York.
[57] Hebden, J. (1981), Statistics for Economists, Philip Allan, Oxford.
[58] Chatterjee, S. and Price, 8. (1977), Regression Analysis by Example, 3. Wiley & Sons, New York.
[59] Render, B., Stair, R. M., Steans, G. K. and Villere, M. (1976), ‘The Readability of Operations Research and Operations Management Textbooks’, Interfaces, November, pp. 95-105.
[60] Haggle, 0. (1984), The Annual Report as an Aid to Communication&, Accountancy, August, pp. 66—69.
[61] Hopwood A. (1983), ‘On Trying to Study Accounting in the Context in which it Operates’, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 8, No. 2/3, pp. 287-305.
[62] Kaplan, R. S. (1986), ‘The Role for Empirical Research in Management Accounting’, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. II, No. 4/5, pp. 429-452.
[63] Tricker, R. 1. (1978), Research in Accounting: Purpose, Process and Potential, University of Glasgow.
[64] Kaplan, R. S. (1983), Measuring Manufacturing Performance: a New Challenge for Managerial Accounting Research, Accounting Review, October.
[65] Babbie, E. R. (1973), Survey Research Methods, Wadsworth.
[66] Wall, W. D. and Williams, H. L. (1970), Longitudinal Studies and the Social Sciences, Heinemann, London.
[67] Yin, R. K (1985), Case Study Research, Sage Publications, Beverley Hills.
[68] Rickwood, C., Coates, J. and Stacey, R. (1987), ‘Managed Costs and the Capture of Information’, Accounting and Business Research, Spring, pp. 319-326.
[69] Adams, G. R. and Schvaneveldt, I D. (1985), Understanding Research Methods, Longman.
[70] Tomkins, C. and Groves, R. (1983), ‘The Everyday Accountant and Researching his Reality’ Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 18, No. 4, pp. 361-374.
[71] Black, J. A. and Champion, D. J. (1976), Methods and Issues in Social Research, 3. Wiley and Sons, New York.
[72] Bird, P. (1984), The Development of Standard Accounting Practice’ in Carsberg B. and Hope A. Current Issues in Accounting, Philip Allan, 1984, pp. 39-53.
[73] Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (1969), Statement of Intent on Accounting Standards in the 1970s, reproduced in Accountancy, January 1970, pp. 2-3.
[74] Courtis, John K; Salleh Hassan (2002), ‘Reading ease of bilingual annual reports’, The Journal of Business Communication, Oct pp. 394-413.
[75] Aishah Sheikh Abu Bakar, Rashid Ameer (2011), ‘Readability of Corporate Social Responsibility communication in Malaysia’, Corporate Social - Responsibility and Environmental Management, Vol. 18, Iss. 1; Jan/Feb, pp. 50-57.
[76] England, G. W., Thomas, M. and Paterson, D. G. (1953), Reliability of the Original and the Simplified Flesch Reading Ease Formulas’, Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol. 37, No. 2, pp. 111-118. 1982.
[77] Farr, J. N., Jenkins, J. J. and Paterson, D. G. (1951), ‘Simplification of Fleseb Reading Ease Formula’, Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol. 35, pp. 333-335.