Project Management Maturity Models and Organizational Project Management Maturity Model (OPM3®): A Critical Morphological Evaluation

Authors: Farrokh J., Azhar K. Mansur

Abstract:

There exists a strong correlation between efficient project management and competitive advantage for organizations. Therefore, organizations are striving to standardize and assess the rigor of their project management processes and capabilities i.e. project management maturity. Researchers and standardization organizations have developed several project management maturity models (PMMMs) to assess project management maturity of the organizations. This study presents a critical evaluation of some of the leading PMMMs against OPM3® in a multitude of ways to look at which PMMM is the most comprehensive model - which could assess most aspects of organizations and also help the organizations in gaining competitive advantage over competitors. After a detailed morphological analysis of the models, it is concluded that OPM3® is the most promising maturity model that can really provide a competitive advantage to the organizations due to its unique approach of assessment and improvement strategies.

Keywords: Project management maturity, project managemen tmaturity models, competitive advantage.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1070695

References:

[1] Jugdev, K. and J. Thomas, Project Management Maturity Models: The Silver Bullets of Competitive Advantage? Project Management Journal, 2002. 33(4): pp. 4-14.
[2] PMI, Organizational Project Management Maturity Model: OPM3 Knowledge Foundation. 2003, Project Management Institute (PMI) Inc.: Newtown Square, Pennsylvania USA.
[3] PMI, 2010 Annual Report, in Building & Strengthening our Global Community. 2010, PMI.
[4] Peterson, A.S. The impact of PM maturity on integrated PM processes. in Proceedings of the 31st Annual Project Management Institute 2000 Seminars and Symposium. 2000. Houston, TX: PMI.
[5] Rosenstock, C., R.S. Johnston, and L.M. Anderson. Maturity model implementation and use: A case study. in Proceedings of the 31st Annual Project Management Institute 2000 Seminars and Symposium. 2000. Paris, France: PMI.
[6] Suares, I. A real world look at achieving project management maturity. in Proceedings of the 29th Annual project Management Institute 1998 Seminars and Symposium. 1998. Long Beach, CA: PMI.
[7] OGC, Portfolio, Programme & Project Management Maturity Model (P3M3). 2006, Office of Government Commerce.
[8] Ibbs, W.C. and J. Reginato. Can good project management actually cost less? in Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Project Management Institute 2002 Seminars and Symposium. 2002. San Antonio, TX: PMI.
[9] Ghorbanali, A., et al., Improving project management competency by using an OPM3 approach, in 2010 International Conference on Economics, Business and Management. 2011: Manila, Philippines.
[10] Humphrey, W., Managing the Software Process. 1989: Addison Wesley.
[11] Humphrey, W., Characterizing the software process: a maturity framework. IEEE Software, 1988. 5(2): p. pp. 73-79.
[12] Crosby, P.B., Quality is free. 1979, New York: Mc-Graw Hill.
[13] Crosby, P.B., Quality is still free: making quality certain in uncertain times. 1996, New York: Mc-Graw Hill.
[14] Paulk, M.C., et al., Capability Maturity Model SM for Software, Version 1.1. 1993, Software Engineering Institute: Pittusburg.
[15] Niazi, M., D. Wilson, and D. Zowghi, A maturity model for the implementation of software process improvement: an empirical study. The Journal of Systems and Software, 2005. 74(2).
[16] Macbeth, D.K. and N. Ferguson, Partnership sourcing: an integrated supply chain management approach, ed. N. Ferguson. 1994, London: Financial Times: Pitman.
[17] Szakonyi, R., Measuring R&D Effectiveness-1. Research-Technology Management, 1994a. 37(2): pp. 27-32.
[18] Szakonyi, R., Measuring R&D Effectiveness-II. Research-Technology Management, 1994b. 37(3): pp. 44-55.
[19] McGrath, M.E. and M.N. Romeri, The R&D effectiveness index: A metric for product development performance Journal of Product Innovation Management, 1994. 11(3): pp. 213-220.
[20] Fraser, P. and M. Gregory, A maturity grid approach to the assessment of product development collaboration, in 9th internatiuonal product development management collaborations. 2002: Sophia Antiplis.
[21] Sander, C.P. and C.A. Brombacher, Analysis of quality information flows in the product creation process of high-volume consumer products International Journal of Production Economics, 2000. 67(1): pp. 37-52.
[22] Tiku, S., M. Azarian, and M. Pecht, Using a reliability capability maturity model to benchmark electronics companies. International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, 2007. 24(5): pp. 547-563.
[23] Prado, A., MPCM - Maturity by Project Category Model, Available on: http://www.maturityresearch.com/novosite/en/index.html.
[24] Prado, D., Project Management Maturity Model (Prado-PMMM). 2006: INDG-Tecs.
[25] OGC, PRINCE2-Projects in Controlled Environments. 2004, Office of Government Commerce: UK.
[26] Garies, R., Compentencies in the project-oriented organization, Projekt Management Group.
[27] BMC, Project Management Maturity Model. 2003, Business Management Consultants (BMC).
[28] Voivedich, B. and M. Jones, Developing and Applying A Project Management Capability Maturity Model, PMCC Inc.
[29] Hillson, D. Benchmarking Organizational Project Management Capability. in Proceedings of the Project Management Institute Annual Seminars & Symposium. 2001. Nashville,Tenn.,USA.
[30] Martinelli, R. and J. Waddell, The Program Management Maturity Model: A Framework for Change, in PM World Today. March 2007.
[31] AIPM, National Competency Standards For Project Management. 2004, Australian National Training Authority.
[32] Kwak, Y.H. and C.W. IBBS, The Berkley Project Management Process Maturity Model: Measuring the Value of Project Management. 2000, IEEE.
[33] Kwak, Y.H. and C.W. Ibbs, Project Management Process Maturity (PM2) Model. Journal of Management in Engineering, 2002. 18(3).
[34] SEI, People Capability Maturity Model (P-CMM). 2009, Software Engineering Institute (SEI).
[35] BDII, Capability Maturity Model® for Business Development, Version 1.0. 2003, Business Development Institute Intenational.
[36] DTI, Innovation - Your Move: Company Focus; a Self Assessment Guide (Managing in the '90s). 1994, London: Great Britain Dept. of Trade and Industry.
[37] Shewhart, W.A., Economic control of quality of manufactured product. 1931, New York,: ASQ Quality Press.
[38] Gareis, R. and M. Huemann, Project Management Competences in the Project-oriented Organisation, in In: Turner JR, Sinister SJ, (Eds.), The Gower handbook of project management. 2000, Gower: Aldershot.
[39] Radice, R.A., et al., A programming process study. IBM Systems Journal, 1985. 24(2).
[40] Humphrey, W., Three process perspectives: Organizations, teams, and people. Annals of Software Engineering, 2002. 4: pp. 39-72..