Medical Negligence Disputes in Malaysia: Resolving through Hazards of Litigation or through Community Responsibilities?

Authors: Puteri Nemie Jahn Kassim, Khadijah Mohd Najid

Abstract:

Medical negligence disputes in Malaysia are mainly resolved through litigation by using the tort system. The tort system, being adversarial in nature has subjected parties to litigation hazards such as delay, excessive costs and uncertainty of outcome. The dissatisfaction of the tort system in compensating medically injured victims has created various alternatives to litigation. Amongst them is the implementation of a no-fault compensation system which would allow compensation to be given without the need of proving fault on the medical personnel. Instead, the community now bears the burden of compensating and at the end, promotes collective responsibility. For Malaysia, introducing a no-fault system would provide a tempting solution and may ultimately, achieve justice for the medical injured victims. Nevertheless, such drastic change requires a great deal of consideration to determine the suitability of the system and whether or not it will eventually cater for the needs of the Malaysian population

Keywords: Medical Disputes, Litigation, Malaysia, No-Fault Compensation.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1330463

References:

[1] P.N. Jahn Kassim, "Mediating medical negligence claims in Malaysia: An option for reform," Malayan Law Journal Articles, vol. 2008(4), pp. cix-cxxvi, 2008.
[2] T.D. Lytton, R.L. Rabin and P.H. Schuck, "Tort as a litigation lottery: A misconceived metaphor," Boston College Law Review, vol. 52, pp. 267- 288, 2011.
[3] J. O-Connell, The Lawsuit Lottery: Only the Lawyers Win. New York: The Free Press, 1979, p. 8.
[4] Salgo v Leland Stanford Jr. University Board of Trustees (1960) 317 P 2d 1093.
[5] J. Fleming, "Is there a future for tort?" Louisiana Law Review, vol. 44, pp. 1193 - 1212, 1984, p. 1198.
[6] Hotson v East Berkshire Health Authority (1987) 2 All ER, at p. 913.
[7] J.G. Logie, "Proof of causation in medical negligence cases," Scots Law Times, vol. 4, pp. 25-30, 1988, p. 28.
[8] A. Meisel, "The expansion of liability for medical accidents: From negligence to strict liability by way of informed consent," Nebraska Law Review, vol. 56, pp. 51-152, 1977, pp. 53 - 54.
[9] T. Drabsch, "No-Fault Compensation (Published)," in NSW Parliamentary Library Briefing Paper 6/05, Sydney, May 2005.
[10] Foo Fio Na v Hospital Assunta & Anor (1999) 6 MLJ.
[11] P. Cane, Atiyah-s Accidents, Compensation and the Law (6th ed.). London, Edinburgh and Dublin: Butterworths, 1992, p. 348.
[12] M.A. Kupeli, "Tort Law - No-fault compensation: an unrealistic elixir to the medical malpractice ailment," Suffolk Transnational Law Review, vol. 19, pp. 559-572, Summer 1996, p. 563.
[13] S.M. Idris, "Can doctors be trusted? How to protect yourself against medical error". Consumers- Association of Penang, 2004.
[14] A. Matta, "Informed consent in medical treatment: The need to bring about rationality", in Issues in Medical Law and Ethics, P.N Jahn Kassim and A.H Mohamed Abdullah, Eds. Kuala Lumpur: IIUM, 2003, pp. 17-27.
[15] J.M. Shepherd, "Tort reforms' winners and losers: the competing effects of care and activity levels", UCLA Law Review vol. 55, no. 4, pp. 905- 978, 2008, p. 906.
[16] A. Silversides, "Fault/no fault: bearing the brunt of medical mishaps," CMAJ News, vol. 179, no. 4, pp. 309-311, August 12, 2008.
[17] Whitehouse v Jordan (1981) 1 W.L.R. 246 at 659
[18] S. Gupta, "More treatment, more mistakes," New York Times, August 1, 2012. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/01/opinion/more-treatment-moremistakes. html?_r=0.
[19] http://www.avma.org.uk.
[20] Ministry of Health Malaysia, "Ministry of Health Malaysia Annual Report 2010," Ministry of Health Malaysia Website, 2010. Retrieved from http://www.moh.gov.my/images/gallery/publications/md/ar/2010- 2.pdf.
[21] H.R. Abdullah, "Court awards RM870,000 to couple and son over medical negligence," The Star Online, January 21, 2011. Retrieved from http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/1/21/nation/201101211 41028&sec=nation.
[22] T.S. Chin, "Insurance for Doctors," The Star Online, December 16, 2012. Retrieved from http://thestar.com.my/health/story.asp?file=/2012/12/16/health/1228096 8&sec=health.
[23] Medical Defence Malaysia Berhad, "Membership Subscription Rates 2013," MDM Website, 2013. Retrieved from http://www.mdm.org.my/rates.php.
[24] V. Devindran, "Drop in obstetricians as fear of legal suits rise, says group chief," The Star Online, June 7, 2012. Retrieved from http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2012/6/7/sarawak/11429436,
[25] M. Carvalho, "Medical (Amendment) Bill 2012 passed," The Star Online, June 18, 2012. Retrieved from http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2012/6/18/nation/201206181 73359&sec=nation.
[26] Anonymous, "Amendment to Section 20 of the Medical (Amendment) Act 2012." MMA Website, 2012. Retrieved from http://www.mma.org.my/Portals/0/Amendment%20to%20the%20Medic al%20Act.pdf.
[27] I. Englard, "Alternative compensation systems", in The Philosophy of Tort Law. Brookfield, Vermont: Darmouth Publishing Company, 1993, p. 110.
[28] H.E. Menyawi, "Public tort liability: An alternative to tort liability and no-fault compensation," Murdoch University Electronic Journal of Law, vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 1-21, Dec. 2002.
[29] E.J. Weinrib, "Corrective Justice," Iowa Law Review, vol. 77, pp. 403- 425, 1992.
[30] Whitehouse v Jordan (1980) 1 All ER 650, at 658.
[31] A.M. Farrell, S. Devaney and A. Dar, "No-fault compensation schemes for medical injury: A review," Scottish Government Social Research, pp. 1-85, 2010. Retrieved from http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Resource/0039/00394407.pdf.
[32] BMA Scotland, "No fault compensation will end the blame culture within the NHS, says BMA Scotland," BMA Website, 2011. Retrieved from http://web.bma.org.uk/pressrel.nsf/wlu/GGRT- 8E7LU8?OpenDocument.
[33] W.J. Gaine, "No-fault compensation systems". British Medical Journal, vol. 326, no. 7397, pp. 997-998, 2003. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1125962/#B10.
[34] A. Kachalia and M.M. Mello, "Beyond negligence: Avoidability and medical injury compensation." Social Science and Medicine, vol. 66, no. 2, pp. 387-402, 2008. Retrieved from http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2007.08.020.
[35] G. Siegal, M. Melloand, and D. Studdert, "Adjudicating severe birth injury claims in Florida and Virginia: The experience of a landmark experiment in personal injury compensation," American Journal of Law & Medicine, vol. 34, pp. 489-533, 2008.
[36] T. Tomizuka and R. Matsuda, "Introduction of No-Fault Obstetric Compensation." Health Policy Monitor, 2009. Retrieved from http://hpm.org/jp/a14/4.pdf.
[37] L.N. Klar, "Tort and No-Fault," Health Law Review 1997, vol. 5, no. 3, pp. 2-8, 1997, p. 2.
[38] C. Ham, R. Dingwall, P. Fenn, and D. Harris, Medical Negligence: Compensation and Accountability. London and Oxford: King's Fund and Centre for Socio-Legal Studies, 1988.
[39] T. Douglas, "Medical Injury Compensation: Beyond No-Fault," Medical Law Review, vol. 17, pp. 30-51, 2009.
[40] M. Bismark, and R. Paterson, "No-fault Compensation in New Zealand: Harmonising Injury Compensation, Provider Accountability and Patient Safety," Health Affairs, vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 278-283, 2006.
[41] The Scottish Government, "No fault compensation review group report and recommendations (Volume 1)," The Scottish Government Publications, 2011. Retrieved from: http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2012/08/4456/downloads.
[42] P.C. Weiler, "The case for no-fault medical liability," Maryland Law Review, vol. 52, pp. 101-143, 1993, p. 110.
[43] D.E. Seubert, L.T. Cohen, and J.M. LaFlam, "Is ÔÇÿno-fault- the cure for the medical liability crisis?" American Medical Association Journal of Ethics, Vol. 9, No. 4, pp. 315-321, April 2007, p. 316.
[44] P.N. Kassim, "No-fault compensation for medical injuries: The New Zealand experience" IIUM Law Journal,Vol. 11, pp. 83-95.
[45] P.N. Kassim, "Medical negligence litigation in Malaysia: Whither should we travel?," Journal of the Malaysian Bar,Vol. XXXIII, No. 1, pp 14-25, 2004.
[46] A. Damis, "Attorney-General wants to introduce a no-fault liability scheme for motor vehicle accidents." The Malaysian Bar, August 26, 2007. Retrieved from: http://www.malaysianbar.org.my/news_features/attorney_general_wants _to_introduce_a_no_fault_liability_scheme_for_motor_vehicle_accident s.html.
[47] A. Sreenevasan, "Press Statement: No-Fault Liability Scheme." The Malaysian Bar, Nov 2, 2007. Retrieved from: http://www.malaysianbar.org.my/press_statements/press_statement_no_ fault_liability_scheme.html.
[48] H. Witcomb, "No-fault compensation," New Law Journal, 109, 1991.
[49] W. Gelhorn, "Medical malpractice litigation (U.S.)--Medical mishap compensation (N.Z.)," Cornell Law Reiew, Vol. 73, No. 2, pp. 170-212, 1988, at p. 176, quoting from "ABA Special Comm. on the Tort Liability System, Towards a Jurisprudence of Injury: The Continuing Creation of a System of Substantive Justice in American Tort Law", 1984, at paragraph 3-16.
[50] The Royal Commission on Civil Liability and Compensation for Personal Injury (The Pearson Report), at p. 363.
[51] R. Mahoney, "Trouble in paradise: New Zealand-s Accident Compensation Scheme" in S.M. McLean, (edit.), Law Reform and Medical Injury Litigation, Aldershot: Dartmouth Publishing Company, 1995.
[52] R.E. Keeton, "Compensation for medical accidents," University of Pennsylvania Law Review, Vol. 121, pp. 590-617, 1973.