Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis in Planning of Asbestos-Containing Waste Management

Authors: E. Bruno, F. Lacarbonara, M. C. Placentino, D. Gramegna

Abstract:

Environmental decision making, particularly about hazardous waste management, is inherently exposed to a high potential conflict, principally because of the trade-off between sociopolitical, environmental, health and economic factors. The need to plan complex contexts has led to an increasing request for decision analytic techniques as support for the decision process. In this work, alternative systems of asbestos-containing waste management (ACW) in Puglia (Southern Italy) were explored by a multi-criteria decision analysis. In particular, through Analytic Hierarchy Process five alternatives management have been compared and ranked according to their performance and efficiency, taking into account environmental, health and socio-economic aspects. A separated valuation has been performed for different temporal scale. For short period results showed a narrow deviation between the disposal alternatives “mono-material landfill in public quarry" and “dedicate cells in existing landfill", with the best performance of the first one. While for long period “treatment plant to eliminate hazard from asbestos-containing waste" was prevalent, although high energy demand required to achieve the change of crystalline structure. A comparison with results from a participative approach in valuation process might be considered as future development of method application to ACW management.

Keywords: Multi-criteria decision analysis, Hazardous wastemanagement, Asbestos.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1082099

References:

[1] Council Directive 1991/689/EEC of 12 December 1991 on hazardous waste, Official Journal of the European Communities L 377 , 31 December 1991.
[2] Italian law 22/97.
[3] P. Plescia, D. Gizzi, S. Benedetti, L. Camilucci, C. Fanizza, P. De Simone, F. Paglietti, "Mechanochemical treatment to recycling asbestoscontaining waste", Waste Management, vol. 23, pp. 209-218, 2003.
[4] Directive 2001/42/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 June 2001 on the assessment of the effects of certain plans and programes on the environment, Official Journal of the European Communities L 197/30, 21 July 2001.
[5] K.J. Arrow, "A Difficulty in the Concept of Social Welfare", Journal of Political Economy, vol. 58, no. 4, pp.328-346, Aug. 1950.
[6] L. F. Girard, "La città, tra conflitto, contraddizione e progetto", Architecture, City and Environment, vol.1, no. 1, pp. 46-59, 2006.
[7] A.G. Pereira and S.C. Quintana, "From technocratic to participatory decision support system: responding to the new governance initiatives", Journal of geographic information and decision analysis, vol.6, no.2, pp.95-107 (2002).
[8] T. Saaty, "An eigenvalue allocation model for prioritization and planning". Working paper, Energy Management and Policy Center, University of Pennsylvania (1972).
[9] T. Saaty, "The Analytic Hierarchy Process". New York, McGraw-Hill (1980).
[10] F. Zahedi, "The analytic hierarchy process: a survey of the method and its applications." Interface 16(4): 96-108 (1986).
[11] B. Golden, E. Wasil, et al. (1989). "The Analytic Hierarchy Process: Applications and Studies". Heidelberg, Springer-Verlag.
[12] J. Shim. "Bibliography research on the analytic hierarchy process (AHP)." Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 23(3): 161-167 (1989).
[13] L. Vargas, "An overview of the analytic hierarchy process and its applications." European Journal of Operational Research 48(1): 2-8 (1990).
[14] T. Saaty, and E. Forman. "The Hierarchon: A Dictionary of Hierarchies. Pittsburgh, RWS Publications (1992).
[15] E. Forman and S. Gass. "The Analytic Hierarchy Process - An Exposition." Operations Research 49(4): 469-486 (2001).
[16] S. Kumar and O. Vaidya. "Analytic hierarchy process: An overview of applications." European Journal of Operational Research 169(1): 1-29 (2006).
[17] V. Omkarprasad and K. Sushil. "Analytic hierarchy process: an overview of applications." European Journal of Operational Research 169(1): 1-29 (2006).
[18] W. Ho, "Integrated analytic hierarchy process and its applications - A literature review." European Journal of Operational Research 186(1): 211-228 (2008).
[19] M. Liberatore and R. Nydick. "The analytic hierarchy process in medical and health care decision making: A literature review." European Journal of Operational Research 189(1): 194-207 (2008).
[20] T.L. Saaty, "A scaling method for priorities in hierarchical structures." Journal of mathematical psychology 15(3): 234-281 (1977).
[21] Directive 2008/98/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 November 2008 on waste and repealing certain Directives (Text with EEA relevance), Official Journal of the European Communities L 312/3, 22 November 2008.
[22] Council Directive 1999/31/EC of 26 April 1999 on the landfill of waste, Official Journal of the European Communities L182/1, 16 July 1999.
[23] R. Ramanathan, "A note on the use of the analytic hierarchy process for environmental impact assessment", Journal of Environmental Management, vol.63, pp. 27-35, Mar 2001.