Civil Society and Democratization in Africa: The Role of the Civil Society in the 2005 Election in Ethiopia

Authors: Wondwosen Teshome B.

Abstract:

One of the approaches to democratization is the fostering of civil society organizations. In Africa, civil society organizations did not fully play their role in the continent-s democratization process due to many factors including the repressive regulations imposed on them by governing parties. In Ethiopia, for the first time in the country-s political history, the civil society played a very active role in the 2005 multi-party election. The involvement of the civil society in this election has far-reaching consequences. One of the objectives of this paper is to assess the consequences of such involvement for both the civil society and the political society in the country. The paper also examines the peculiarities of civil society formation in Africa in general, and in Ethiopia in particular by assessing both the “traditional" and “modern" civil society organizations.

Keywords: Africa, Civil Society, CSO, Democratization, Election, Ethiopia, NGO, Western donors.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1329753

References:

[1] Robert Layton (2004): "Civil Society and Social Cohesion: A Reassessment". Working paper No.63, Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology Working papers.
[2] E. Gellner (1996): Conditions of liberty: civil society and its rivals. Harmondsworth: Penguin (first published 1994).
[3] A. Seligman (1992): The idea of civil society. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
[4] K. Tester (1992): Civil Society. London: Routledge
[5] J. Locke (1689/1960): Two treatises of government. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. (First published 1689).
[6] A. Ferguson (1767/1995): An essay on the history of civil society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. First published 1767.
[7] M. Buchowski (1996): "The shifting meanings of civil and civic society in Poland." In: Hann, C. and E. Dunn (eds.) Civil Society: challenging western models, pp. 79-98. London: Routledge.
[8] R. Mc. Netting (1981): Balancing on an Alp: ecological change and continuity in a Swiss mountain community. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
[9] H.G. Rosenberg (1988): A negotiated world: three centuries of change in a French Alpine community. Toronto, University of Toronto Press.
[10] Marina Ottaway (2005): "Civil Society," in: Politics in the Developing World, Burnell, Peter and Vicky Randall (eds), Chapter 8, pp. 121-135.
[11] J. Howell and Pearce, J. (2001): Civil Society and Development: Exploring a Complex Relationship, Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
[12] H. Kovach, C. Neligan and S. Burall (2003): The Global Accountability Report: Power Without Accountability? London, One World Trust
[13] S. Zadek (2003): In Defense of Non-Profit Accountability. Ethical Corporation Magazine. September. p. 34-36.
[14] Thomas Carothers and Marina Ottaway (2002): "Defining Civil Society: The Elusive Term," The World Bank: Development Outreach
[15] Waldemar Nielsen (1979): The Endangered Sector. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
[16] Helmut K. Anheier (1990): "Themes in International Research on the Nonprofit Sector." Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 19(4): 371-91.
[17] L. Salamon (1990): "The Nonprofit Sector and Government: The American Experience in Theory and Practice", in: H.K. Anheimer and W. Seibel (eds). The Third Sector: Comparative Studies of Nonprofit Organizations, Berlin and New York: The Gruyter.
[18] ] Lester M. Salamon (1992): America-s Nonprofit Sector: A Primer. New York, NY: The foundation Center.
[19] Julie Fisher (1993): The Road from Rio: Sustainable Development and the Nongovernmental Movement in the Third World. CT: Praeger Publishers
[20] Stuart E. Eizenstat (2004): "Non governmental organizations as the Fifth State," Seton Hall Journal of Diplomacy and International Relations. (Accessed 14 September 2008).
[21] Terry Bergdall (n.d): Civil Society Strengthening in Africa, MAP Consultations.
[22] The World Bank (1997): International Center for Not-for-profit Law, 1997. Handbook on Good Practices Relating to Non-Governmental Organizations, Washington.
[23] Saad Eddin Ibrahim (September 1998): Nurturing Civil Society at the World Bank: An Assessment of Staff Attitudes towards Civil Society. Social Development Papers, paper Number 24, The World Bank,Washington.
[24] Sanam Naraghi Anderlini and Judy El-Bushra (n.d): "Civil Society", In: Justice, Governance and Civil Society. Inclusive Security, Sustainable Peace: A Toolkit for Advocacy and Action, pp. 48-63.
[25] Commonwealth Foundation (1995): "Non-Governmental organization: Guidelines for Good Policy and Practice," London.
[26] Commission of European Communities (2001): European Governance: White paper, COM, 428, Brussels, 25.7.2001.
[27] A. van Rooy (1998) Civil Society and the Aid Industry. London:Earthscan.
[28] TI Source Book (2000): "Civil Society".
[29] Geoffrey McNicoll (1995): "Demography in the Unmaking of Civil Society." Working paper 79. The Population Council, Research Division, New York.
[30] L. Diamond (February 1995): Rethinking civil society, quoted in Crossroads, USIS Newsletter, Lagos, pp 9-10.
[31] Edmond J. Keller (1996): "Structure, Agency and Political Liberalization in Africa" Afr. J. Polit. Sci., Vol. 1, No. 2, pp. 202-216.
[32] Gordon White (1994):"Civil Society, Democratization and Development (I): Clearing the Analytical Ground," Democratization, vol. 1, no. 3 (Autumn 1994).
[33] J.F. Bayart (1986): "Civil Society in Africa", In: Political Domination in Africa. Patrick Chabal (Ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[34] Nicola De Jagar (2004): "Removing the feet of the watchdog: Civil Society and the African Union", "Electronic Briefing Paper, No. 35, CIPS (Centre for International Political Studies).
[35] Dessalegn Rahmato (2002): "Civil Society Organizations in Ethiopia". In: Ethiopia: The Challenge of Democracy from Below. Bahru Zewde and Siegfried Pausewang (Eds.). Nordiska Afrikainstitute and Forum for Social Studies, pp. 103-119.
[36] Fatoumtta M-boge and Sam Gbaydee Doe (August 2004): "African Commitments to Civil Society Engagement: A Review of Eight NEPAD countries". African Human Security Initiative (AHSI paper) 6.
[37] Michael Foley and Bob Edwards (July 1996): "The Paradox of Civil Society," Journal of Democracy, vol. 7, no. 3, pp. 38-52.
[38] Bruce Baker (2001): "The Political Dynamics of Pro-poor Change in Uganda", Paper for the ECPR Conference, Kent, September 6-10.
[39] Kimberly Ludwig and Lise Rakner (2000): "From Cooptation to Atomization? Interest Groups in Africa-s New Democracies". Paper presented at the American Political Science Association-s Annual Meeting, Washington DC, September 1-3.
[40] Stephen Orvis (2001): "Civil Society in Africa or African Civil Society?", in: Journal of Asian and African Studies, Vol. 36, No. 1, 17-38.
[41] Mark Robinson, and Steven Friedman (April 2005): "Civil Society, demonstration and foreign aid in Africa" IDS Discussion paper 383. Institute of development studies, Brighton.
[42] Kwadwo Appiagyei-Atua (n.d): "Civil Society, Human Rights and Development in Africa: A Critical Analysis." (Accessed 4 September 2008)
[43] B. Gournay, Kesler, J.F. and Siwek-Pouydesseau, J. (1967): Administration publique. Paris, Presses Universitaires de la France.
[44] Ray Bush (May 2004): "Civil Society and the Uncivil State: Land Tenure Reform in Egypt and the Crisis of Rural Livelihoods," Civil Society and Social Movements, Programme Paper, Number 9.
[45] Kassahun Berhanu (2002): "The Role of NGOs in promoting Democratic Values The Ethiopian Experience". Ethiopia: The Challenge of Democracy from Below. Bahru Zewde and Siegfried Pausewang. (Eds.). Nordiska Afrikainstitutet and Forum for Social Studies. Pp. 120- 129.
[46] Olivier Nana Nzepa (2003): "Building the Future: civil society-s contribution towards the emergence of the information society in Cameroon", The Association for Progressive Communications (APC) Africa ICT Policy Monitor Project, African Country Research Papers
[47] A. Costy (1996): "Who Governs? NGOs in Rural Mozambique." Southern Africa Report, 11(4).
[48] Julie Hearn (1999): Foreign aid, Democratization and Civil Society in Africa: A study of South Africa, Ghana and Uganda: Discussion paper 368. Institute of Development Studies.
[49] Ndangwa Noyoo (n.d): "Civil Society and Poverty Reduction in South Africa", A research conducted for the Fondation Maison des Science de L-Homme, Paris, France.
[50] Khulu Mbongo (2000): The Role of Civil Society in Promoting decent Work.: Lessons from innovative Partnerships in Ireland, Newzeland and South Africa. The Case of South Africa. Discussion Papers DP/124/2000
[51] Alex Thomson (2006): "Counterbalancing the African State? Should the Concept of Civil Society Still Feature Prominently in Donor Policy Thinking?" In: Journal of Sustainable Development in Africa, vol. 8, No. 3, pp. 273-287.
[52] Hussein Solomon and Sally Matthews (n.d.): "Civil Society, the State and Conflicts in Africa", CIPS (Center for International Political Studies) (Accessed 15 August 2008).
[53] Abel Ezeoha (2006): "Can NGOs Aid Good Governance and Sustainable Development in Africa? Some Theoretical Insights", Journal of Sustainable Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No.3, pp. 128- 147.
[54] T. Carothers (1997):”Democracy assistance: the question of strategy”, Democratization, 4(3):109-32.
[55] N. Chazan (1992): “Africa’s Democratice Challenge”, World Policy Journal, vol. 9, No. 2, pp. 279-307
[56] Sub-Saharan Informer (08 July 2005): “EHRCO Senior Investigators Released on Bail,” Vol. IV, No. 024.
[57] CRDA (2006): “Assessment of the Operating Environment for CSO/NGOs in Ethiopia.”
[58] CRDA and DPPC (Disaster Prevention and Preparedness Commission (March 2004): Information Package on NGO contributions, Addis Ababa.
[59] Business Daily Africa (07 January 2009): “Ethiopia now clips wings of NGOs.”
[60] The Carter Centre (September 2005): “Final Statement on the Carter Centre Observation of the Ethiopia 2005 National Elections.”
[61] ]The Ethiopian Herald (26 July 2005): “Somali State Chief calls on Public to Register for upcoming Election. Training offered for Election Executives.” Vol. LXI, No. 273.
[62] The Ethiopian Herald (5 June 2005): “VECOD says May 15 Election Deserves to be a Model for Africa”. Vol. LXI, No. 230
[63] Capital (29 May 2005): “All Parties Should Know Better than Confusing the Public.” Vol. 7, No. 338.
[64] The Reporter (28 May 2005): “The Parties are in no position to pronounce that the Board is Independent or Not”. Vol. IX, No. 455
[65] IRIN (12 April 2005): “Ethiopia: Election board criticized for barring local observers. “
[66] Addis Tribune (24 June 2005): “CRDA Issues Position Statement on Current Situation in Ethiopia. “
[67] Mail & Guardian (09 May 2005): “Observers praise peaceful Ethiopian vote run-up.”
[68] BBC (2005/05/06): “Ethiopia PM Warns of ‘hate’ Poll.”.
[69] Black Britain (24-06-2005): “Anger as Ethiopia election probes are dropped.”
[70] SABC News (10 May 2005): “Ethiopian Opposition Vows to Tackle Poverty.”
[71] Sudan Tribune (7 May 2005): “Ethiopians rally in support of govt. after opposition slams abuses.”
[72] Mail & Guardian (14 May 2005): “Third Time Lucky?”.
[73] BBC (16 May 2005): “Ethiopia poll prompts protest ban: Ethiopian Prime Minister Meles Zenawi has ordered a month-long ban on demonstrations, following an election disputed by the opposition.”
[74] Sudan Tribune (15 May 2005): “Ethiopian PM bans demonstrations in Addis Ababa”.
[75] The Ethiopian Herald (16 July 2005): “Overt Display of Political Affinity is a Constitutional Right: Ministry.” Vol. LXI, No. 265.
[76] The Ethiopian Herald (14 August 2005): “Ministry to Scrutinize CRDA Statement”, Vol. LXI, No. 290.
[77] The Reporter (03 January 2008): “Court sentences two activists to prison terms”.
[78] WIC (Walta Information Center) (19 July 2008): “Draft Law will benefit NGOs, says Minister.”
[79] ENA (Ethiopian News Agency) (6 January 2009): “House endorses Bill governing NGOs, Civil societies”.
[80] BBC (6 January 2009): “Ethiopia imposes aid agency curbs.”
[81] NED (National Endowment for Democracy) (8 June 2006): The Backlash against Democracy Assistance: A Report prepared by the National Endowment for Democracy for Senator Richard G. Lugar, Chairman Committee on Foreign Relations United States Senate.
[82] Florini, Ann (14 March 2000): Transparency and civil society project, Carnegie endowment for international peace, transnational civil society networks, Managing global issues seminar series
[83] ODI (Overseas Development Institute) (20 January 2006): Donors face tough choices in Ethiopia (Accessed 10/5/2008).
[84] J Weaver, Rock, M. and Kusterer, K. (1997): Achieving Broad-Based Sustainable Development: Governance Environment, and Economic Growth with Equity. West Hartford, CT: Kumarian Press.
[85] Kofi Annan (21 March 2005): In larger freedom, towards development, security and humanrights for all United Nations General Assembly, Fifty-ninth session. New York, Paragraph 162 (Accessed 3 January 2009).
[86] Andrew Clayton, Peter Oakley Jon Taylor (October 2000): Civil Society Organizations and Service Provision, Civil Society and Social Movements Programme, Paper Number 2. United Nations Research Institute for Social Development.
[87] S. Tarrow (1995): Power in movement: Social Movements, Collective Action and Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[88] Reuters (01 July 2008): “Ethiopia: Government Prepares Assault on Civil Society”.
[89] AI (Amnesty International), Public Statement (1 July 2008): “Ethiopia: Government Prepares Assault on Civil Society: Repressive New Legislation Should Be Amended or Scrapped.” AI Index: AFR 25/006/2008.
[90] EMFA (Ethiopian Ministry of Foreign Affairs) (4-7-2008): “Accountability not restriction for NGOs” (Accessed 8/19/2008).
[91] VOA (Voice of America) (01 July 2008): “Rights Groups warn of New NGO Restrictions in Ethiopia”.
[92] Kumlachew Dagne (n.d.): “Observations on the Draft CSO Law.” (Accessed 25 December 2008).
[93] The Reporter (21 June 2008): “The Role of the Civic Organizations is Crucial in Cementing a Firm base for the building of a democracy”.
[94] Zdenka Mansfeldova (2006): “Political and administrative accountability in the Czech Republic,” in: Participation of Civil Society in New Modes of Governance. The case of the New EU Member States. Heiko Pleines (Ed.), No.74, part 2: Questions of Accountability, Forschingsstelle Osteuropa an der Universität Bremen. pp.22-
[95] Alfredo Sfeir-Younis (2004): “The Role of Civil Society in Foreign Policy: A New Conceptual Framework,” Seton Hall Journal of Diplomacy and International Relations, pp-29-32 Summer/Fall.
[96] Monty Narsoo (1992): Doing what comes naturally: a development role for the civic movement, Johannesburg: Centre for policy Studies
[97] T. Carothers (2000): “Civil Society-the Key to Political, Economic and Societal Success? Deutschland, 5 October/November 12-17.
[98] Muntean Aurelian and Andrei Gheorghiţă (2005): Romanian Civil Society and Its Active Role in the 2004 Elections: From Monitoring to Blackmail Potential.Prepared for delivery at the 2005 Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, September 1-4, 2005, Washington, D.C. AP (06-11-2005): “Africans Give Cautious Welcome to G8 Debt-Relief Package”.
[99] L. Crawford (6 February 2004): “Charities under Accountability’s Microscope.” Financial Times.
[100] S. Zadek (2003): From Fear and Loathing to Social Innovation. @lliance Vol. 8, No. 4. p. 21-24.
[101] Julian Lee (19 October 2004): “NGO Accountability: Rights and Responsibilities”, Center for Applied studies in International Negotiations (CASIN), Geneva.
[102] D. Brown (2003): A Framework for Strengthening NGO Accountability. Presentation to the Asia Pacific Philanthropy Consortium. Manila. (Accessed 10 May 2007).
[103] DPMF (Development Policy Management Forum): (December 2002): Report of the Conference on: “The Challenges of Globalization in Africa: What Role for Civil Society and Other Stakeholders?”.
[104] Jason McLure (6 January 2008): “Ethiopia law curbs promotion of rights, democracy, critics say”, Bloomberg.com.
[105] C. Nungwa Kuzuwe (1998): “The Role of NGOs in Democratization and Education in Peace-time (Rwanda”, in: Journal of Social Development in Africa, vol. 13, No. 1, pp. 37-40.
[106] The Reporter (25 October 2008): “Opposition Forum blasts EPRDF over exclusionary politics”.
[107] The Reporter (26 October 2008): “Ehadeg bemengist habit abalatin....” (EPRDF Recruits Members by Using State Resources....”).
[108] Hayal Alemayehu (06 September 2008): “South Korean ‘telecom fraud’ case turns “more complicated,” The Reporter.
[109] Hayal Alemayehu (25 October 2008): “Police officers, sub-city officials, individuals apprehended over alleged housing scam”, The Reporter
[110] Tesfaye Gebreab (2009): “Yegazetegnaw Mastawosha” (“Journalist’s Memoir”). Cape Town.
[111] ABC News (27 March 2008): “Ethiopia arrests 26 over fake gold in national bank vault”.
[112] Elizabeth Blunt (26 March 2008): “Arrests over Ethiopia’s fake gold”, BBC.
[113] Elizabeth Blunt (13 March 2008): “Fake fears over Ethiopia’s gold,” BBC.
[114] John Barkdull and Lisa Dicke (2004): “Globalization, Civil Society, and Democracy?: An Organizational Assessment,” in: Seton Hall Journal of Diplomacy and International Relations, pp. 33-50.
[115] Robert Putnam (1993): Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy. Princeton: Princeton University Press, A seminal work on social capital.
[116] Larry Diamond (1999): Developing Democracy toward Consolidation. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
[117] Aili Mari Tripp (2000): Women and Politics in Uganda. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
[118] Negarit Gazetta (24 September 2008): “The Revised Parties Registration Proclamation, Proclamation No. 573/2008, Addis Ababa.
[119] Political Parties Registration Proclamation (No. 46/1993).
[120] Wondwosen Teshome B. (2008): “Democracy and Elections in Africa: Critical Analysis.” In: International Journal of Human Sciences, vol. 5, issue 2, pp. 1-14.
[121] Manfred Nowak and Ingeborg Schwarz (1994): “The Contribution of Non-Governmental Organizations”, in: Manfred Nowak (ed), World Conference on Human Rights, Vienna: Manzsche Verlag-und Universitätsbuch handlung.
[122] M. Robinson (1996): 'The role of aid donors in strengthening civil society' in A. Clayton (ed.) NGOs, Civil Society and the State: Building Democracy in Transitional Societies, Oxford: INTRAC.
[123] Udaya Wagle (1999): “The Civil Society Sector in the Developing World”. Public Administration and Management: An Interactive Journal 4.4., pp. 525-546.
[124] MCB (Ministry of Capacity Building) (May 2004): “Civil Society Organizations’ Capacity Building Program”. Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia, Ministry of Capacity Building, Program Design.
[125] Stoas International Wageningen and Royal Netherlands Embassy (2003): Identification mission report for a support programme for farmer organizations and agricultural marketing in Ethiopia“ Annex.
[126] Sudan Tribune (6 May 2008): “Ethiopia: Zenawi Accuses Opposition of Agitating for Poll Violence.”
[127] BBC (2005-05-14): “Arrests ahead of Ethiopian Poll: Election observers have been arrested across Ethiopia on the eve of Sunday’s poll, opposition members say. “
[128] The Reporter, “CSOs Denounce ‘hate speech’ “There is no Rwanda Situation Here” CSO’s.” (Accessed 11-07-05)
[129] IRIN (14 June 2005): “US condemns use of force as MP is killed.”
[130] AI (Amnesty International) (04 January 2008): “Ethiopia: Amnesty Outraged by Conviction of Human Rights Defenders.”
[131] Mandeep S. Tiwana (2008): “Analysis of the Ethiopia Charities and Societies Proclamation 00/2008”, CIVICUS: World Alliance for Citizen Participation.
[132] M. Bratton (1994): “Civil Society and Political Transitions in Africa,” in: John W. Harbeson, Donald Rothchild, and Naomi Chazan, (eds.), Civil Society and the State in Africa. Boulder: Lynne Rienner
[133] EHRCO (Nehase/August/ 2000EC): “Yebego adragot dirijitoch mahiberat rekik hign asmelkito keesemegu yetesete asteyayet” (“EHRCO’s Suggestion on the Charities and Society Draft Proclamation”).
[134] EMFA (30-05-2008): “Ethiopia’s Charities and Societies draft law: the Prime Minister meet NGOs.” (Accessed 8-19-2008).
[135] EMFA (6-6-2008): A Week in the Horn: More discussions on the Charities and Societies draft bill.
[136] VOA (06 January 2009): “Ethiopian parliament approves law criminalizing many NGO activities”.
[137] The Reporter (24 January 2009): “EWLA in Dilemma”.
[138] Berhanu Nega (1998 EC): Yenetsanet Goh Siked. Likelebes Yetemokerew Ye Ethiopia Democracy (in Amharic) (“The Dawn of Freedom”).
[139] Cohen, J. (2004) Governance by and of NGOs. London, Accountability.
[140] David Lane (2006): “Civil Society formation and Accountability in the New post-Socialist EU Member States”, in: Participation of Civil Society in New Modes of Governance. The Case of the New EU Member States. Heiko Pleines (Ed.), No.74, part 2: Questions of Accountability, Forschingsstelle Osteuropa an der Universität Bremen. Pp. 7-21.
[141] Gamal Nkrumah (16-22 August 2007): “Abba Paulos: Smash the Idols”, Al-Ahram Weekly, Issue No. 858.
[142] Addis Fortune (19 October 2008): “National Food Reserve Shrinks to Record Low”.
[143] The Reporter (29 June 2008): “Dirkun YagenenutYemeyad Hig Endaytsedk Yemifelgu Wegenoch Nachew.’”(“Those who exaggerated the famine are the one who don’t like the Societies’ law”).
[144] Seeye Abraha, “Yeselamawi yetigel amarach, yeselamawi politikawi shigigir tiyake ena yeselamawi tigil melkochina tegbarainetachew beethiopia” (“Peaceful Struggle Alternative, Peaceful Struggle and their Implementation in Ethiopia”). (Accessed 6 January 2009).
[145] The Reporter (21 September): “Ehadeg behizib ginigunet sira...” (“EPRDF in Public Relations Work....”).
[146] Abugida, “yeandinet partyn enkisikase bemefrat ehadeg hizbun bemola begideta abal eyaderege new“ (“EPRDF is forcfully recruiting members fearing the Unity party“), (Accessed 29 November 2008):
[147] Gebriye Tesfaye (5 September 2007): “Ethiopians unwanted in Ethiopia: hard to believe but true” (Accessed 06-09-07).
[148] The Reporter (14 September 2008): “Eihadeg Begubaew Limekribachew Yemigeba asir Abeyt Dikmetoch” (“Ten weaknesses of the EPRDF that need consultation”)
[149] Martina Fischer (October 2006): “Civil Society in Conflict Transformation: Ambivalence, Potentials and Challenges,” Berghof Research Center for Conflict Management.