Auto-Selective Three Term Control of Position and Compliance of a Pneumatic Actuator

Authors: M. G. Papoutsidakis, G. Chamilothoris, A Pipe

Abstract:

Due to their high power-to-weight ratio and low cost, pneumatic actuators are attractive for robotics and automation applications; however, achieving fast and accurate control of their position have been known as a complex control problem. The paper presents a methodology for obtaining controllers that achieve high position accuracy and preserve the closed-loop characteristics over a broad operating range. Experimentation with a number of conventional (or "classical") three-term controllers shows that, as repeated operations accumulate, the characteristics of the pneumatic actuator change requiring frequent re-tuning of the controller parameters (PID gains). Furthermore, three-term controllers are found to perform poorly in recovering the closed-loop system after the application of load or other external disturbances. The key reason for these problems lies in the non-linear exchange of energy inside the cylinder relating, in particular, to the complex friction forces that develop on the piston-wall interface. In order to overcome this problem but still remain within the boundaries of classical control methods, we designed an auto selective classicaql controller so that the system performance would benefit from all three control gains (KP, Kd, Ki) according to system requirements and the characteristics of each type of controller. This challenging experimentation took place for consistent performance in the face of modelling imprecision and disturbances. In the work presented, a selective PID controller is presented for an experimental rig comprising an air cylinder driven by a variable-opening pneumatic valve and equipped with position and pressure sensors. The paper reports on tests carried out to investigate the capability of this specific controller to achieve consistent control performance under, repeated operations and other changes in operating conditions.

Keywords: Classical selective controller, long-termexperimentation, pneumatic actuator, position accuracy.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1329641

References:

[1] Richard E., Scavarda, S.,1996, Comparison Between Linear and Nonlinear Control of an Electropneumatic Servodrive ,Journal of Dynamic Systems, Measurementand Control,Vol.118, pp.245-118.
[2] Jihog Wang, Junsheng Pu, Philip Moore, ''Accurate Position Control of Servo Pneumatic Actuator Systems'', Control Engineering Practice, 1999, pp. 699-706.
[3] J. E. Bobrow, B.W. McDonell, ''Modeling, Identification and Control of a Pneumatically Actuated, Force Controllable Robot'', draft Thesis 1990,California University, USA.
[4] M.G. Papoutsidakis, G.E. Chamilothoris, A.G. Pipe, F. Dailami and N. Larsen, ''Fuzzy Gain-Scheduling for Proportional Position Control of a PneumaticActuator'', Recent Advances in Soft Computing 2004, Nottingham, UK.
[5] Huang Wenmei, Yang Yong, Tang Yali, ''Adaptive neuron control based on predictive model in pneumatic servo system'', IEEE Transaction on systems, Man,and Cybernetiecs, 1991, vol. 8 (3): 239-265.
[6] Sarmad Aziz, Gary Bone, ''Automatic Tuning of Pneumatic Servo Actuators'', Advanced Robotics, 2000, Vol 13, No 6, PP 563-576.
[7] Hip├▓lit Moreno Llagostera, 'Control of a pneumatic servosystem using fuzzy logic', International Conference on Advanced Mechatronics, 1996.
[8] Ming-Chang Shih and Niarn-Liarng Luor, 'Self-Tuning Neural Fuzzy Control the Position of a Pneumatic Cylinder Under Vertical Load' , IEEE Trans. on IE,Vol. 39, No. 6, pp. 472-489, 1992.
[9] Richer E. and Hurmuzlu Y., ''A High Performance Force Actuator System Part 1 Nonlinear Mathematical Model', ASME Journals of Dynamics Systems Measurement and Control, 2000, Vol. 122, No3, pp. 416-425.
[10] Belforte G., Mattiazzo G., Mauro S., ''Design criteria for flow proportional control valves'', Proceedings of sixth triennual international symposium on Fluid control, Measurement and Visualization, Flucome 2000, August 13-17, Sherbrooke, Canada.
[11] H. Olsson, K. J. Astrom, C. Canoudas de Wit, M.Gafvert, P. Lischinsky, ''Friction Models and Friction Compensation'', European Journal of Control, 1998.
[12] C. Canudas de Wit, H. Olsson, K. J. Astrom, P. Lischinsky, ''A New Model for Control of Systems with Friction'', IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 40, pp.419-425.
[13] K. Hamiti, A. Besancon, H. Buisson, ''Position Control of a Pneumatic Actuator under the Influense of Stiction'', Control Engineering Practice, 1999, pp. 1079-1088.