Regret, Choice, and Outcome

Authors: Olimpia Matarazzo, Lucia Abbamonte

Abstract:

In two studies we challenged the well consolidated position in regret literature according to which the necessary condition for the emergence of regret is a bad outcome ensuing from free decisions. Without free choice, and, consequently, personal responsibility, other emotions, such as disappointment, but not regret, are supposed to be elicited. In our opinion, a main source of regret is being obliged by circumstance out of our control to chose an undesired option. We tested the hypothesis that regret resulting from a forced choice is more intense than regret derived from a free choice and that the outcome affects the latter, not the former. Besides, we investigated whether two other variables – the perception of the level of freedom of the choice and the choice justifiability – mediated the relationships between choice and regret, as well as the other four emotions we examined: satisfaction, anger toward oneself, disappointment, anger towards circumstances. The two studies were based on the scenario methodology and implied a 2 x 2 (choice x outcome) between design. In the first study the foreseen short-term effects of the choice were assessed; in the second study the experienced long-term effects of the choice were assessed. In each study 160 students of the Second University of Naples participated. Results largely corroborated our hypotheses. They were discussed in the light of the main theories on regret and decision making.

Keywords: Choice, outcome, regret.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1074950

References:

[1] N. J. Roese and A. Summerville, "What we regret most . . . and why", Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 31, pp. 1273-1285, 2005.
[2] M. Zeelenberg and R. Pieters "A theory of regret regulation" 1.0. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 17,pp. 3-18, 2007.
[3] M. Zeelenberg, W.W. van Dijk, and A.S.R. Manstead, "Reconsidering the relation between regret and responsibility," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 74, pp. 254-272, 1998a.
[4] D.E Bell, "Regret in decision making under uncertainty," Operations Research, 30, pp. 961-981, 1982.
[5] G. Loomes and R. Sugden, "Regret theory: An alternative theory of rational choice under uncertainty," Economic Journal, 92, pp. 805-824, 1982.
[6] D. Kahneman, "Varieties of counterfactual thinking," in What might have been: The social psychology of counterfactual thinking, N.J. Roese, J.M. Olson Eds. Mahwah: Erlbaum, 1995.
[7] D. Kahneman and A. Tversky, "The psychology of preferences," Scientific American, 246, pp. 160-173, 1982.
[8] N. J. Roese, "Counterfactual thinking," Psychological Bulletin, 121, pp.133-148, 1997.
[9] N. J. Roese and J. M. Olson Eds., What might have been: The social psychology of counterfactual thinking. Mahwah: Erlbaum, 1995.
[10] D. T. Gilbert, C.K. Morewedge, J.L. Risen, and T.D. Wilson, "Looking forward to looking. backward: The misprediction of regret," Psychological Science, 15, pp. 346-350, 2004.
[11] R. Sugden, "Regret, recrimination and rationality," Theory and Decision, 19, pp. 77-99, 1985.
[12] D.E. Bell, "Disappointment in decision making under uncertainty," Operations Research, 33, pp. 1-27, 1985.
[13] G. Loomes and R. Sugden, "Testing for regret and disappointment in choice under uncertainty," Economic Journal, 97, pp. 118-129, 1987.
[14] J. J. Inman, J. S. Dyer, and J. Jia, "A generalized utility theory model of disappointment and regret effects on post-choice valuation," Marketing Science, 6, pp. 97-11, 1997.
[15] M. Tsiros and V. Mittal, "Regret: A model of its antecedents and consequences in consumers decision making," Journal of Consumer Research, 26, pp. 401-417, 2000.
[16] N. H Frijda, P. Kuipers, and E. Ter Schure, "Relations among emotion, appraisal, and emotional action readiness," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 57, pp. 212-228, 1989.
[17] T. Gilovich and V.H. Medvec, "The temporal pattern to the experience of regret", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 67, pp. 357- 365, 1994.
[18] I. J. Roseman, C. Wiest, and T. S. Swartz, "Phenomenology, behaviors, and goals differentiate discrete emotions," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 67, pp. 206-221, 1994.
[19] M. Zeelenberg and R. Pieters, "Beyond valence in customer dissatisfaction: A review and new findings on behavioral responses to regret and disappointment in failed services," Journal of Business Research, 57, pp. 445-455, 2004a.
[20] M. Zeelenberg, W.W. van Dijk, A.S.R. Manstead, and J. van der Pligt, "The psychology of regret and disappointment," Cognition and Emotion, 12, 221-230, 1998b.
[21] M. Zeelenberg, W.W. van Dijk, and A.S.R. Manstead, "Regret and responsibility resolved? Evaluating Ord├│├▒ez and Connolly-s (2000) conclusions," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 81, 143-154, 2000.
[22] R. Pieters and M. Zeelenberg, "A theory of regret regulation 1.1." Journal of Consumer Psychology, 17, 29-35, 2007.
[23] R.C. Solomon, The passions. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1976.
[24] A.O. Rorty, "Agent regret" in Explaining emotions, A.O. Rorty, Ed. Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1980, pp.489-506.
[25] G. Taylor, Pride, shame and guilt: The emotions of self-assessment. New York: Oxford University Press, 1985.
[26] J. Landman, Regret: The persistence of the possible. New York: Oxford University Press, 1993.
[27] T. Connolly, L.D. Ord├│├▒ez and R. Couglan, "Regret and responsibility in the evaluation of decision outcomes," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 70, pp. 73-85, 1997.
[28] L.D Ord├│├▒ez , T. Connolly, "Regret and responsibility: A reply to Zeelenberg et al. (1998)," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 81, pp. 132-142, 2000.
[29] W.W. Van Dijk and M. Zeelenberg, "Investigating the appraisal patterns of regret and disappointment". Motivation and Emotion, 26, pp. 321- 331, 2002.
[30] T. Connolly and M. Zeelenberg, "Regret and decision making". Current Directions in Psychological Science, 11, pp. 212-216, 2002.
[31] T. Connolly and J. Reb, "Regret in cancer-related decisions," Health Psychology, 24, (4, suppl), S29-S34, 2005.
[32] J. J. Inman and M. Zeelenberg, "Regret in repeat versus switch decisions: The attenuation role of decision justifiability," Journal of Consumer Research, 29, pp. 116-128, 2002.
[33] R. Pieters and M. Zeelenberg, "On bad decisions and deciding badly: When intention-behavior inconsistency is regrettable," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 97, pp. 18-30, 2005.
[34] L. Festinger, Conflict, decision, and dissonance. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1964.
[35] S.C. Thompson, W. Armstrong, and C. Thomas, "Illusions of control, underestimations, and accuracy: A control heuristic explanation". Psychological Bulletin, 123, pp.143-161, 1998.
[36] E.J. Langer, "The illusion of control", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 32, pp. 311-328, 1975.
[37] B. Zeigarnik, "Das Behalten erledigter und unerledigter Handlungen", Psychologische Forschung, 9, pp. 1-85, 1927.
[38] K. Savitsky, V. H. Medvec, and T. Gilovich, T., "Remembering and regretting: The Zeigarnik effect and the cognitive availability of regrettable actions and inactions," Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 23, 248-57, 1997.
[39] T. Connolly and D. Butler, "Regret in economic and psychological theories of choice," Journal of Behavioural Decision Making, 19, pp. 139-154, 2006.
[40] B.A. Mellers, "Choice and the relative pleasure of consequences", Psychological Bulletin, 126, pp. 910-924, 2000.
[41] M. Tsiros, "Effect of Regret on Post-choice Valuation: The Case of More Than Two Alternatives," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 76, pp. 48-69, 1998.
[42] C.E., Izard, The psychology of emotions. New York: Plenum. 1991.
[43] R.M. Baron and D.A. Kenny, "The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations". Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 51, pp.1173-1182, 1986.
[44] D.P. MacKinnon, J.L. Krull, and C. M. Lockwood, "Equivalence of the mediation, confounding, and suppression effect". Prevention Science, 1, pp. 73-181, 2000.