Defining a Framework for Holistic Life Cycle Assessment of Building Components

Authors: Naomi Grigoryan, Alexandros Loutsioli Daskalakis, Anna Elisse Uy, Yihe Huang, Aude Laurent (Webanck)

Abstract:

In response to the building and construction sectors accounting for a third of all energy demand and emissions, the European Union has placed new laws and regulations in the construction sector that emphasize material circularity, energy efficiency, biodiversity, and social impact. Existing design tools assess sustainability in early-stage design for products or buildings; however, there is no standardized methodology for measuring the circularity performance of building components. Existing assessment methods for building components focus primarily on carbon footprint but lack the comprehensive analysis required to design for circularity. The research conducted in this paper covers the parameters needed to assess sustainability in the design process of architectural products such as doors, windows, and facades. It maps a framework for a tool that assists designers with real-time sustainability metrics. Considering the life cycle of building components such as façades, windows, and doors involves the life cycle stages applied to product design and many of the methods used in the life cycle analysis of buildings. The current industry standards of sustainability assessment for metal building components follow cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment (LCA), track Global Warming Potential (GWP), and document the parameters used for an Environmental Product Declaration (EPD). Expanding on the MCI with additional indicators such as the Water Circularity Index (WCI), the Energy Circularity Index (ECI), the Social Circularity Index (SCI), Life Cycle Economic Value (EV), and calculating biodiversity risk and uncertainty, the assessment methodology of an architectural product's impact can be targeted more specifically based on product requirements, performance, and lifespan. Broadening the scope of LCA calculation for products to incorporate aspects of building design allows product designers to account for the disassembly of architectural components. For example, the MCI for architectural products such as windows and facades is typically low due to the impact of glass, as 70% of glass ends up in landfills due to damage in the disassembly process. The low MCI can be combatted by expanding beyond cradle-to-grave assessment and focusing the design process on disassembly, recycling, and repurposing with the help of real-time assessment tools. Design for Disassembly and Urban Mining has been integrated within the construction field on small scales as project-based exercises, not addressing the entire supply chain of architectural products. By adopting more comprehensive sustainability metrics and incorporating uncertainty calculations, the sustainability assessment of building components can be more accurately assessed with decarbonization and disassembly in mind, addressing the large-scale commercial markets within construction, some of the most significant contributors to climate change.

Keywords: Architectural products, early-stage design, life cycle assessment, material circularity indicator.

References:

[1] Kenway, S. J., Pamminger, F., Yan, G., Hall, R., Lam, K. L., Skinner, R., Olsson, G., Satur, P., & Allan, J. (2023, August 23). Opportunities and challenges of tackling scope 3 “indirect” emissions from Residential Hot Water. Water Research X. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2589914723000282
[2] Warrier, G. A., Palaniappan, S., & Habert, G. (2024, January 11). Classification of sources of uncertainty in building LCA. Energy and Buildings https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0378778824000082
[3] “Introduction to EC3 Uncertainty | ACLCA.” (2023). Building Transparency, aclca.org/wp-content/uploads/Introduction-to-EC3-Uncertainty.pdf. Accessed 24 Jan. 2024.
[4] Haas, C., Hartmann, T., Rausch, C., & Sanchez, B. (2021). A framework for BIM-based disassembly models to support reuse of building components. Retrieved from: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0921344921004341.
[5] Espinoza, L. T., Rostek, L., Loibl, A., & Stijepic, D. (2020, November 1). The promise and limits of Urban Mining. www.isi.fraunhofer.de. https://www.isi.fraunhofer.de/content/dam/isi/dokumente/ccn/2020/Fraunhofer_ISI_Urban_Mining.pdf
[6] Vetter, M. (2019). REWINDOW. Retrieved from https://rewindo.de/
[7] Concular. (2020). Zirkuläres Bauen für zukunftssichere Immobilien. Retrieved from: https://concular.de/.
[8] COOL-LITE® ORAÉ®. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.saint-gobain-glass.com/products/ORAE.
[9] BS EN 17213:2020 Windows and doors Environmental Product Declarations Product category rules for windows and pedestrian doorsets (2020, March 31). https://www.en-standard.eu/bs-en-17213-2020-windows-and-doors-environmental-product-declarations-product-category-rules-for-windows-and-pedestrian-doorsets/
[10] MacArthur, Ellen, and Granta Design. “(PDF) Circularity Indicators: An Approach to Measuring Circularity.” Material Circularity Indicator, Ellen Macarthur Foundation, Granta design, LIFE financial instrument of the European Union., 1 May 2015, Circularity-Indicators-Methodology.
[11] World’s fastest Building Life Cycle Assessment software - One Click LCA. (2001). One Click LCA® Software. https://www.oneclicklca.com/
[12] Sustainability, Operational Risk Management & EHS Software. Sphera. (2023). https://sphera.com/
[13] Ellen MacArthur Foundation, IDEO. (2017). The Circular Design Guide. https://www.circulardesignguide.com/
[14] Makersite | AI-Powered Product Lifecycle Intelligence. (2018). Makersite GmbH.
[15] Säwén, T., Magnusson, E., Sasic Kalagasidis, A., & Hollberg, A. (2022). Tool Characterisation Framework for Parametric Building LCA (Review of Tool Characterisation Framework for Parametric Building LCA).
[16] Tally® LCA App for Autodesk® Revit® Software development KT InnovationsAwards:2016 Architect R+D Award 2014 AIA Technology in Architectural Practice Building Information Modeling Award. (2014a, April 8). Tally® LCA APP FOR AUTODESK® Revit®: Kierantimberlake. KIERAN TIMBERLAKE. https://kierantimberlake.com/page/tally
[17] González, A., Sendra, C., Herena, A., Rosquillas, M., & Vaz, D. (2021). Methodology to assess the circularity in building construction and refurbishment activities. Resources, Conservation & Recycling Advances, 12, 200051. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rcradv.2021.200051
[18] Asociacion Espanola del Aluminio y Tratamientos de Superficie (2020). (PDF) Environmental Product Declaration. Retrieved from: 2023-12-12 Global EPD 1.23mx1.48m.pdf.
[19] Pereda, L. (2022, June 8). Environmental Product Declaration. The international EPD system. https://api.environdec.com/api/v1/EPDLibrary/Files/b2f94eb5-3deb-4ce3-79f8-08da491c4cdf/Data.
[20] Ruokamo, E., Savolainen, H., Seppala, J., Sironen, S., Raisanen, M., & Auvinen, A.-P. (2022, December 6). Exploring the potential of circular economy to mitigate pressures on biodiversity. Global Environmental Change. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0959378022001637
[21] Cradle to Cradle Certified, version 4.0. Cradle to Cradle Certified, Version 4.0 - Cradle to Cradle Products Innovation Institute. (2021). https://c2ccertified.org/the-standard/version-4-0