Decision Support for Modularization: Engineering Construction Case Studies

Authors: R. Monib, C. I. Goodier, A. Gibb

Abstract:

This paper aims to investigate decision support strategies in the EC sector to determine the most appropriate degree of modularization. This is achieved through three oil and gas (O&G) and two power plant case studies via semi-structured interviews (n = 59 and n = 27, respectively), analysis of project documents, and case study-specific semi-structured validation interviews (n = 12 and n = 8). Terminology to distinguish degrees of modularization is proposed, along with a decision-making support checklist and a diagrammatic decision-making support figure. Results indicate that the EC sub-sectors were substantially more satisfied with the application of component, structural, or traditional modularization compared with system modularization for some types of modules. Key drivers for decisions on the degree of modularization vary across module types. This paper can help the EC sector determine the most suitable degree of modularization via a decision-making support strategy.

Keywords: Modularization, engineering construction, case study, decision support.

References:

[1] A. Misiti, D. Hebert, Modular Construction in the Oil and Gas Industry. IEEEX, 2018.
[2] C.Y. Baldwin, K.B. Clark. “Design Rules: Volume 1- The power of modularity". Cambridge (Massachusetts): The MIT Press, 2000.
[3] A. Bondi, A. Magagnini, M. Mancini, G.J.L. Micheli, A. Travaglini, “Supporting decisions on industrial plant modularization: A case study approach in the Oil and Gas Sector”, IEOM Society International, 2016, pp. 742–753.
[4] J.T. O’Connor, W.J., O’Brien, J.O., Choi, “Critical success factors and enablers for optimum and maximum industrial modularization” Journal of Construction Engineering and Management 140 (6), 2014, 1–11.
[5] K. Holtta, E.S. Suh, O. Weck, “Trade off between modularity and performance for engineered systems and products”. 15th International Conference on Engineering Design. ICED 05, 2005, Melbourne. Australia.
[6] M. Murtaza, D.J. Fisher, M. Skibniewski, “Knowledge-Based Approach to Modular Construction Decision Support”, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 119 (1), 1993.
[7] J. Song, “Considering prework on industrial projects”, Journal Construction Engineering Management. 6(723), 2005, pp. 723–733.
[8] K. Vernikos, Realising Offsite Construction in the Civil Engineering and Infrastructure Sector. PhD Thesis. United Kingdom: Loughborough University, 2015.
[9] C.Y. Baldwin, K. B. Clark. “Managing in an age of modularity”. Harvard Business Review, 75(5), 1997, 84-93.
[10] C.H. Fine, B. Golany, and H. Naseraldin, “Modeling trade offs in three-dimensional concurrent engineering: A goal programming approach”. Journal of Operational Management. 23 (3-4), 2005, pp. 389-403.
[11] S.K. Vickery, X. Koufteros, C. Calantone, “Product modularity, process modularity, and new product introduction performance: Does complexity matters”, Production and Operation Management.0(0), 2015, pp,1-20.
[12] J. McKay, The Effect of Offsite Construction on Occupational Health and Safety. PhD thesis. United Kingdom: Loughborough University, 2010.
[13] D. Campagnolo, A. Camuffo, “The Concept of modularity in management studies: A literature review”, International Journal of Management Reviews, 12(3), 2009, 259-283X.
[14] J.K. Gershenson, G.J. Prasad, Y. Zhang, “Product modularity: definitions and benefits”. Journal of Engineering Design.14, 2003, pp.295-313.
[15] K. Holtta-Otto, O. Weck, “Degree of Modularity in Engineering Systems and Products with Technical and Business Constraints”, SAGE. 15 (2), 2007, pp.113-126.
[16] J. Tiihonen, T. Lehtonen, T. Soininen, A. Pulkkinn, R. Sulonen, A. Riitahuhta, “Modeling configurable product families”, 12 th International Conference on Engineering Design, ICED99, 1998.
[17] G. J. L. Micheli, P. Trucco, Y. Sabri, M. Mancini,. “Modularization as a system life cycle management strategy: Drivers, barriers, mechanisms and impacts” International Journal of Engineering Business Management. Volume II, 2019, 1-23.
[18] J. K. Gershenson, G.J. Prasad, Y. Zhang. “Product modularity: measures and design methods”. Journal of Engineering Design 15(1), 2004, pp.33-51.
[19] F. Salvador, “Toward a product system modularity construct: Literature review and reconceptualization”, IEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 54, 2007, pp. 219-240.
[20] J.H. Mikkola, “Capturing the degree of modularity embedded in product Architectures”, Journal of Product Innovation Management.23(2), 2016, pp.128-146.
[21] C.T. Haas, W.R. Fagerlund. Preliminary research on prefabrication, pre-assembly, modularization and off-site fabrication in construction. The United States of America: CII, 2002.
[22] M. Abdel-Wahab, RJ. Andrew, R.J. D. Stephen, I. Hazlehurst, “Trends of skills and productivity in the UK construction industry”, Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management, 15 (4), 2008, pp. 372-382.
[23] CII, Constructability improvement using prefabrication, preassembly, and modularization, Austin, TX, 1987,
[24] CII, Prefabrication, Preassembly, Modularization, and Offsite Fabrication (PPMOF)- Instructor’s Guide, Austin, TX, 2004
[25] CII. Constructability Implementation Guide, Austin, TX, 2006
[26] W. Pan, A.G. Gibb, A.R. Dainty, “Leading UK housebuilders’ utilization of offsite construction methods”, Building Research and Information,36(1), 2008, pp. 56-67.
[27] K. Vernikos, C. Goodier, A.G.F, Gibb, “Building information modelling and offsite construction in Civil Engineering”. ARCOM Doctoral Workshop on BIM Management and Interoperability. 167, June, 2013, pp. 1–10.
[28] M.R. Abdullah, C. Egbu, “The application of analytical hierarchy process (AHP) as a decision tool in choosing the type of industrialised building system (IBS) for housing projects”, 27th Annual ARCOM Conference, 2011, Bristol, UK.
[29] J.T. O’Connor, W.J. O’Brien, J.O. Choi, Industrial Modularization How to optimize; How to Maximize. The University of Texas at Austin, 1993.
[30] M. Mulrooney, G. Shahani, “Modularization: The key to success in today’s market”, Hydrocarbon Processing, 2016.
[31] K. B. Clark, C.Y. Baldwin, “Design Rules: The power of Modularity”, Cambridge: MIT Press, 1999.
[32] J. Molavi, D.L. Barral, “A Construction procurement method to achieve sustainability in modular construction”. International Conference on Sustainable Design, Engineering and Construction, 145, 2016, pp.1362-1369.
[33] R. Smith, “Offshore and Modular Construction Explained”, Whole Building Design Guide, Sep., 2016.
[34] D. Fisher, M. Skibniewski, Computerised Decision Support for Modularization of Industrial Construction, CII, United States, 1992.
[35] O. Gjepali. Developing an Early-Phase Decision Support Tool for the Client/Owner in the Engineering Construction Sector. Master Thesis. Italy: Milano University, 2015.
[36] CII, MODEX User’s Guide. The United States of America, 1992
[37] CII, Implementation the Prefabrication, Preassembly, Modularization, and Offsite Fabrication Decision Framework: Guide and Tool, Austin, TX. 2002
[38] W. Pan, A Decision Support Tool for Optimising the Use of Offsite Technologies in Housebuilding. PhD Thesis. United Kingdom: Loughborough University, 2012.
[39] W. Pan, A.R.J. Dainty, A.G.F., Gibb, “Establishing and Weighting Decision Criteria for Building System Selection in Housing Construction”, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, ASCE. 138 (11), 2012, PP. 1239–1250.
[40] P. Sharafi, M. Rashidi, B. Samali, H. Ronagh, “Identification of factors and decision analysis of the level of modularization in building construction”. Journal of Architectural Engineering. 24(2), 2018.