The Emergence of Construction Mafia in South Africa: The Implication on the Construction Industry

Authors: Thandokazi Nyangiwe, Christopher Amoah, Charles P. Mukumba

Abstract:

The South African construction sector is threatened by emerging black business forums called construction mafias. The emergence of the construction mafia has culminated in the disruptions and abandonment of construction sites resulting in the loss of jobs for construction workers. The paper examines the origin of construction mafias and their impact on the construction sector, including the potential ways to cope with their operations. A qualitative research approach was adopted for this study using open-ended interview questions to gather information from 30 key construction industry stakeholders, including contractors, subcontractors, consultants, and the construction project communities. Content and thematic analyses were used to analyses the data collected. The findings suggest that most participants do not fully understand the existence and operations of construction mafias in the construction industry. Construction mafias claim to be part of the local business forums. They disrupt construction projects and demand a certain amount, usually 30% of the construction value. Construction mafias frequently resort to intimidation and violence if their demands are unmet. Their operations have resulted in delayed completion of construction projects, abandonment of projects, and loss of income for the contractor and jobs for the construction workers. The interviews were limited to construction stakeholders. Because of the nature of the mafias’ operations, they could not be accessed for interviews for fear of being identified because of the connotation attached to their role as construction mafias. Construction project owners face disruptions of projects resulting in loss of equipment, materials, and income. Therefore, there is a need to sensitize the construction stakeholders in the construction industry regarding the existence and operations of the construction mafia and the implications on construction project performance and delivery. The findings will give insight into the operations of the construction mafias in the South African construction industry, which has caused disruptions in construction project sites. Stakeholders must find solutions to address the construction mafias’ disruptive actions on construction projects. The study presents an initial inquiry that will come up with how to manage and cope with the growing operations of construction mafias in the South African construction industry.

Keywords: Black business forums, construction mafia, South African construction industry.

References:

[1] R. Watermeyer, and S. Phillips, Public infrastructure delivery and construction sector dynamism in the South African economy. Background Paper, NPC’s Economy Series. Pretoria: NPC. 2020.
[2] T. O. Osunsanmi, C. Aigbavboa, and A, Oke, A., “Construction 4.0: the future of the construction industry in South Africa.” International Journal of Civil and Environmental Engineering, 12(3), 2018, pp.206-212.
[3] CIDB Construction Monitor, “Supply and Demand Q1.2019.” 2019, Available from: http://www.cidb.org.za/publications/Documents/Construction%20Monitor%20-%20April%202019.pdf
[4] L. Wood, South Africa’s construction industry, 2019: Features profiles of 69 industry players. United States: Globe Newswire, 2020
[5] W. Mfebe, Engineering news. (Online). South Africa. Available from https://www.engineeringnews.co.za/article/construction-industry-in-rapid-decline-as-work-wanes-mafia-takes-over-warns-safcec-2019-04-08, May, 2021
[6] N. Harinarain, “Despair during the COVID-19 lockdown for the South African construction industry.” Journal of Construction, 13(1), pp.52-63, 2020
[7] O. Adebowale and J. Agumba, “Labour productivity in construction SMEs: perspectives from South Africa.” Acta Structilia, 30(1), pp.62-89, 2023
[8] Y. Zabyelina and K.L. Thachuk, eds., Private Sector and Organized Crime: Criminal Entrepreneurship, Illicit Profits, and Private Sector Security Governance. Taylor & Francis, 2022
[9] Z.S. Elov, and D.S. Berdiyeva, “Psychological reasons for suicide motivation in adolescents with deviant behaviour.” Oriental renaissance: Innovative, educational, natural and social sciences, 2(2), pp.1003-1009, 2022.
[10] A. Hubschle, Organised crime in Southern Africa. Germany, 2010
[11] M. Shaw, “South Africa: Origins of the mafia state-Political transition, organised crime and the impact on democracy. Handbook of organised crime and politics, pp.321-334, 2022
[12] C. Bueger, and T. Edmunds, Blue crime: Conceptualising transnational organised crime at sea. Marine Policy, 119, p.104067, 2020
[13] I. Waller, Less Law, More Order. The truth about reducing crime. Praeger, 2006
[14] L. Paoli, “What makes mafias different?. Crime and Justice, 49(1), pp.141-222, 2020
[15] V. Tenti, Framing mafia infiltration in the public construction industry in Italy. Montreal, 2012
[16] E. U. Savona, Infiltration of the public construction industry by Italian organized crime. Willan Publishing 2010.
[17] P. Steyn, LEXAfrica. Available from South Africa’s BBBEE Act and Codes explained: https://www.lexafrica.com/2018/09/south-africas-bbbee-act-and-codes-explained/#:~:text=The%20primary%20purpose%20of%20the,in%20the%20South%20African%20economy, 2018
[18] N. Schoeman-Louw, BBBEE Compliance: The Construction Sector code – What you need to Know. Available from Polity: https://www.polity.org.za/page/schoeman-law-inc, 2019
[19] W. Pocock, “The construction mafia: how to deal with revolting protestors.” Without Prejudice, 18(8), pp.6-7 2019
[20] S. Ngobeni, Available from https://sarf.org.za/construction-industry-under-siege/ , 2020.
[21] S. Theunissen, How to deal with the ‘construction mafia’. Daily Maverick. Available from https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/opinionista/2020-09-03-how-to-deal-with-the-construction-mafia/, 2020
[22] K. Ramakgopa, 2020. SA’s ‘Construction Mafia’ Is Out of Control. (J. Stone, Interviewer), 2020.
[23] V. Cavotta and N. Phillips, All that glitters: a call for more research on corrupt entrepreneurship. Innovation, pp.1-23, 2022
[24] SA Commercial Prop News. Available from http://www.sacommercialpropnews.co.za/construction-industry/9219-construction-industry-continues-to-grapple-with-mafias.html
[25] G. Mulaudzi and C. Lancaster, South Africa’s construction mafia trains its sights on local government: justice and Violence Prevention, ISS Pretoria, 2021.
[26] K. Bullock, R. Clark and N. Tilley, Situational Prevention of Organised Crimes. New York: Routledge, 2012.
[27] G. K. Muhammad, The condemnation of Blackness: Race, crime, and the making of modern urban America, with a new preface. Harvard University Press 2019.
[28] R. Bougie and U, Sekaran, Research methods of business. Chichester, UK: John & Sons, 2016
[29] B. Foley, Survey tips: Purposive sampling 101. Available from Alchemer: https://www.alchemer.com/resources/blog/purposive-sampling-101/, 2018.
[30] J. Corbin and A. Strauss, Basics of qualitative research: Techniques and principles for developing grounded theory. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2015.
[31] J. W. Creswell, Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative and Mixed Methods Approaches, 4th ed., Sage, Los Angeles, 2014.
[32] L. Paoli, The Oxford Handbook of Organized Crime. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014.
[33] C. Amoah, “The impact of the Black Economic Empowerment concept in the South African public procurement systems on black construction professionals.” International Journal of Procurement Management, 16(1), pp.115-135, 2023
[34] E.T. Boadu, C.C. Wang and R.Y. Sunindijo, “Characteristics of the construction industry in developing countries and its implications for health and safety: An exploratory study in Ghana.” International journal of environmental research and public health, 17(11), p.4110, 2020
[35] A. Kithatu-Kiwekete and S. Phillips, “The effect of public procurement on the functioning of a national evaluation system: The case of South Africa.” International Journal of Social Sciences and Humanity Studies, 12(1), pp.18-33, 2020.
[36] M. Catino, Mafia Organizations: The Visible Hand of Criminal Enterprise. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2021.
[37] B. Sibanda and N. Tshikovhi, “Supply chain performance and preferential procurement in Gauteng government departments.” Journal of Transport and Supply Chain Management, 16, p.702, 2022.
[38] L. Shai, C. Molefinyana and G. Quinot, “Public procurement in the context of Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (BBBEE) in South Africa—Lessons learned for sustainable public procurement.’ Sustainability, 11(24), p.7164, 2019.
[39] A.L. Olanrewaju, A.R. Abdul-Aziz, A.L. Olanrewaju and A.R. Abdul-Aziz, 2015. An overview of the construction industry. Building Maintenance Processes and Practices: The Case of a Fast-Developing Country, pp.9-32.
[40] C. Duan and B. Chen, B, 2020. Driving factors of water-energy nexus in China. Applied Energy, 257, p.113984.