Measuring Principal and Teacher Cultural Competency: A Needs Assessment of Three Proximate PreK-5 Schools

Authors: Teresa Caswell

Abstract:

Throughout the United States and within a myriad of demographic contexts, students of color experience the results of systemic inequities as an academic outcome. These disparities continue despite the increased resources provided to students and ongoing instruction-focused professional learning received by teachers. We postulated that lower levels of educator cultural competency are an underlying factor of why resource and instructional interventions are less effective than desired. Before implementing any type of intervention, however, cultural competency needed to be confirmed as a factor in schools demonstrating academic disparities between racial subgroups. A needs assessment was designed to measure levels of individual beliefs, including cultural competency, in both principals and teachers at three neighboring schools verified to have academic disparities. The resulting mixed method study utilized the Optimal Theory Applied to Identity Development (OTAID) model to measure cultural competency quantitatively, through self-identity inventory survey items, with teachers and qualitatively, through one-on-one interviews, with each school’s principal. A joint display was utilized to see combined data within and across school contexts. Each school was confirmed to have misalignments between principal and teacher levels of cultural competency beliefs while also indicating that a number of participants in the self-identity inventory survey may have intentionally skipped items referencing the term oppression. Additional use of the OTAID model and self-identity inventory in future research and across contexts is needed to determine transferability and dependability as cultural competency measures.

Keywords: Cultural competency, identity development, mixed method analysis, needs assessment.

References:

[1] L. Darling-Hammond, “Want to close the achievement gap? Close the teaching gap,” American Educator, vol. 38, no. 4, pp. 14-18, 2015.
[2] E. R. Peterson, C. Rubie-Davies, D. Osborne, and C. Sibley, “Teachers' explicit expectations and implicit prejudiced attitudes to educational achievement: Relations with student achievement and the ethnic achievement gap,” Learning and Instruction, vol. 42, pp. 123-140, 2016.
[3] D. S. Jacoby-Senghor, S. Sinclair, and N. J. Shelton, “A lesson in bias: The relationship between implicit racial bias and performance in pedagogical contexts,” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, vol. 63, pp. 50–55, 2016.
[4] G. Ladson-Billings, “Toward a theory of culturally relevant pedagogy,” American educational research journal, vol. 32, no. 3, pp. 465-491, 1995.
[5] V. M. Mayfield and D. Garrison-Wade, “Culturally responsive practices as whole school reform,” Journal of Instructional Pedagogies, vol. 16, pp. 1-17, 2015.
[6] R. M. JohnBull, “The relationship between cultural competence and teacher efficacy,” Unpublished dissertation. University of Virginia, 2012.
[7] T. D. Sevig, P. S. Highlen, and E. M. Adams, “Development and validation of the Self-Identity Inventory (SII): A multicultural identity development instrument,” Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology, vol. 6, no. 2, 2000.
[8] T. A. Caswell, “Critically reflecting on equity- and identity-focused professional learning to increase cultural competency: A pilot study,” Unpublished dissertation. Johns Hopkins University, 2021.
[9] L. J. Myers, S. L. Speight, P. S. Highlen, C. I. Cox, A. L. Reynolds, E. M. Adam, and P. Hanley, “Identity development and worldview: Toward an optimal conceptualization,” Journal of Counseling & Development, vol. 70, pp. 54-63, 1991.
[10] E. Horevitz, J. Lawson, and J. C.-C. Chow, “Examining cultural competence in health care: Implications for social workers,” Health & Social Work, vol. 38, no. 3, 135, 2013.
[11] L. Feize and J. Gonzalez, “A model of cultural competency in social work as seen through the lens of self-awareness,” Social Work Education, vol. 37, no. 4, pp. 472–489, 2018.
[12] S. S. Dietz, K. P. Dotson-Blake, D. Enselman, L. Jones, E. H. Sexton Jr, M. S. Waller, and M. E. Richardson, “An international learning experience: Looking at multicultural competence development through the lens of relational-cultural theory,” Journal of Counselor Practice, vol. 8 no.1, pp. 22-44, 2017.
[13] M. Byrd and B. S. Olivieri, “Measuring teacher cultural competence,” International Review of Social Sciences and Humanities, vol. 8, no.1, pp. 55-67, 2014.
[14] K. P. Kozlowski, “Culture or teacher bias? Racial and ethnic variation in student teacher effort assessment Match/Mismatch,” Race and Social Problems, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 43-59, 2015.
[15] T. M. Scott, N. Gage, R. Hirn, and H. Han, “Teacher and student race as a predictor for negative feedback during instruction,” School Psychology Quarterly, May 2018.
[16] R. L. Pope and A. L. Reynolds, “Multidimensional identity model revisited: Implications for student affairs,” New Directions for Student Services, vol. 157, pp. 15–24, 2017.
[17] K. Crenshaw, “Mapping the margins: Intersectionality, identity, and violence against women of color,” Stanford Law Review, vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 1241–1300, 1991.
[18] D. W. Carbado, K. W. Crenshaw, V. M. Mays, and B. Tomlinson, “Intersectionality: Mapping the movements of a theory,” Du Bois review: social science research on race, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 303-312, 2013.
[19] J. W. Creswell and V. L. Plano Clark, Designing and conducting mixed methods research. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2011.
[20] North Carolina Department of Public Instruction. 2018-19 School assessment and other indicator data (Data file). Available from http://www.ncpublicschools.org/accountability/reporting.
[21] K. M. Brown, J. Benkovitz, A. J. Muttillo, and T. Urban, “Leading schools of excellence and equity: Documenting effective strategies in closing achievement gaps,” Teachers College Record, vol. 113, no.1, pp. 57-96. 2011.
[22] L. M. Desimone and K. C. Le Floch, “Are we asking the right questions? Using cognitive interviews to improve surveys in education research,” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, vol. 26, 2004.
[23] W. E. Wagner III, Using IBM® SPSS® statistics for research methods and social science statistics. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 2017.
[24] B. W. Hartman, D. R. Fuqua, and S. J. Jenkins, “The problems of and remedies for nonresponse bias in educational surveys,” The Journal of Experimental Education, vol. 54, no. 2, pp. 85-90, 1986.
[25] S. R. Porter, M. E. Whitcomb, and W. H. Weitzer, “Multiple surveys of students and survey fatigue,” New directions for institutional research, vol. 121, pp. 63-73, 2004.
[26] M. B. Miles, A. M. Huberman, and J. Saldana, Qualitative data analysis: A Methods Sourcebook, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 2014.