Social Security Reform and Management: The Case of Three Member Territories of the Organisation of Eastern Caribbean States

Authors: Cleopatra Gittens

Abstract:

It has been recognized that some social security and national insurance systems in the Eastern Caribbean are experiencing ageing populations and economic and other crises that will present a financial challenge of being unable to pay pension benefits in fifteen to twenty years. This has implications for the fiscal and economic positions of the countries themselves. Hence, organizations would need to address the issue urgently. The study adds to the body of knowledge on social security systems and social security reforms in Small Island Developing States (SIDS). It also makes recommendations for the types of reforms that social security systems in other SIDS can implement given their special circumstances. Secondary research is used to gather financial and other related information on three social security schemes in the Eastern Caribbean. Actuarial and financial reports and other documents of the social security systems are analysed to obtain financial and static data on each of the schemes. The findings show that the three schemes studied are experiencing steady increases in benefit expenditure versus contributions and increasing pensioner to insured ratios. The schemes will deplete their reserves between 2038 and 2050. Two of the schemes have increased their retirement age while the other has not embarked on any reforms. One scheme has made changes to its contribution percentages. Due to their small size, small populations and other unique circumstances, the social security schemes in the identified territories are not likely to be able to take advantage of all of the reform initiatives that the developed world embarked on when faced with similar problems. These schemes will need to make incremental changes that align with the timeframes recommended by the actuarial studies.

Keywords: Pension benefits, pension, Small Island Developing States, Social Security Reform.

References:

[1] Attanasio, O., Kitao, S. and Violante, G.L., (2007) Global Demographic Trends and Social Security Reform Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol 54, Issue 1, January 2007, Pages 144-198. Global demographic trends and social security reform - ScienceDirect
[2] Koutronas and Yew, The Malaysian Journal of Economic Studies 54(1): 2017.
[3] Gruber, J. and Wise D.A. (2007). Social Security Programs and Retirement Around the World: Fiscal Implications of Reform. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
[4] Farrell Grupo De Consultoria, S.C. (2019). 12th Actuarial Review of the Antigua and Barbuda Social Security Fund as at December 31, 2017. Centro Interamericano de Estudios de Seguridad Social.
[5] Henry, V.E. (2004). An Investigation into the Structure, Governance and Performance of the Social Security Organisations in the Caribbean. University of Toronto Press.
[6] Organisation of Eastern Caribbean States. Who we are. (https://oecs.org/en/who-we-are/history)
[7] https://www.eccb-centralbank.org/p/about-the-eccb
[8] Williams C. A., Coudouel A., Ludovic S. (2013). Tailoring Social Protection to Small Island Developing States Lessons Learned from the Caribbean, World Bank Discussion paper 1306, August 2013.
[9] International Monetary Fund (2022) IMF Executive Board 2022 Article IV Consultation on Common Policies of Member Countries of the Eastern Caribbean Currency Union. https://www.imf.org/en/News/Articles/2022/06/02/mcs060222-eccu-imf-staff-concluding-statement-of-2022-art-iv-consultation-on-common-policies
[10] https://www.eccb-centralbank.org/statistics/dashboard-datas/
[11] https://www.stats.gov.kn/topics/demographic-social-statistics/population/households-population-and-average-household-size-by-parish-2001-2011/
[12] Population projection at mid-year estimates 2011 to 2025 – Antigua and Barbuda (gov.ag)
[13] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.TOTL?locations=LC
[14] https://www.socialsecurity.gov.ag/our-history/
[15] https://www.stlucianic.org/home/act-and-regulations/
[16] https://socialsecurity.kn/about-intro/
[17] LifeWorks (2021). St. Christopher-Nevis Social Security Board: 13th Actuarial Review of the Social Security Fund as of December 31, 2020. LifeWorks Formerly Morneau Shepell. 13th Actuarial Review – Saint Christopher and Nevis Social Security Board.
[18] Gruat, J. V. (1998) Maintaining Prosperity in an Ageing Society: The OECD study on the policy implications of ageing WORKING PAPER AWP 3.1, 1998 https://www.oecd.org/els/public-pensions/2428459.pdf
[19] Galasso, V. and Profeta, P. (2003). Lessons for an Aging Society: The Political Sustainability of Social Security System. IGIER - Università Bocconi, Via Salasco 5, 20136 Milano –Italy, 2003 (http://www.igier.uni-bocconi.it)
[20] Zhou Hong. (2007) Parametric Pension Reform in Public Pension Schemes. EU-China Social Protection Reform Project – Component 1. Vol 1., 2007 (ParametricEN.pdf (sprp-cn.eu))
[21] Gill, I., Packard, T., Pugatch T., Yermo, J. (2005). Rethinking Social Security in Latin America. International Social Security Review. Vol.58 2-3/2005.Blackwell Publishing Ltd. Oxford, U.K.
[22] Orszag, P. R. (Sebago Associates, Inc.) Stiglitz J. E (1999). (The World Bank) "Rethinking Pension Reform:Ten Myths About Social Security Systems". World Bank Conference,1999
[23] Jgeremaia, E., Mourao, P., Verulava, T. (2014) Pension System in Southern European Countries – Challenges and Opportunities. Journal of International Affairs and Global Strategy, Vol. 24, 2014, www.iiste.org
[24] Oran, S.S. (2016) Financialisation and Turkish Pension Reform. Master’s Thesis, University of London. 2016. Unpublished.
[25] Alonso J. Domenecha R. Tuestaa D. (2011) Public Pension Systems and the Fiscal Crisis in the Euro Zone: Lessons for Latin America. BBVA Research and Universidad de Valencia, España, May 2, 2011
[26] Holzman, R. (2012) Global Pension Systems and their Reform. World Bank Discussion Paper No,1213, 2012.
[27] European Commission (2012). An Agenda for Adequate, Safe and Sustainable Pensions. White Paper, 2012. Brussels: COM.
[28] https://www.caricom.org
[29] Soto M. Thakoor V., Petri, M., David (2015) Pension Reforms in Mauritius Fair and Fast—Balancing Social Protection and Fiscal Sustainability, 2015 https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/journals/001/2015/126/article-A001-en.xml
[30] Weber, B., (2017). Sustainability of Pension Systems in Small Island Developing States: The Case of Mauritius. Master Thesis, Erasmus University Rotterdam. Unpublished, 2017
[31] Paddison, O. (2006). Social Security in the English-speaking Caribbean. United Nations ECLAC, 2006. https://repositorio.cepal.org/bitstream/handle/11362/3678/1/S2006025_en.pdf
[32] Rofmann, R.l and Oliveri, M. L. (2012). La cobertura de los sistemas previsionales en América Latina: conceptos e indicadores. Series de Documentos de Trabajo sobre Políticas Sociales No. 7. Buenos Aires: World Bank, 2012.
[33] Hinz, R., Zviniene, A., Biletsky, S., Bogomolova, T. (2009). “The Impact of the Financial Crisis on Public Pension Systems: Stress Testing Models of Mandatory Pension Systems in Middle Income and Developing Countries”. Social Protection & Labor Department. Washington, DC: World Bank. Mimeo, September 2009.
[34] Börsch-Supan, A. (2013): “Entitlement Reforms in Europe: Policy Mixes in the Current Pension Reform Process”, In: Alesina, Alberto, Giavazzi, Francesco, (eds.), Fiscal Policy after the Crisis, 2017. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp. 405-435.
[35] Coile, C. C., Milligan K.S., and Wise D.A. (forthcoming). Social Security and Retirement Programs Around the World: Working Longer. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2018
[36] International Monetary Fund (2021). Assessing Chile’s Pension System: Challenges and Reform Options. September 2021. IMF Working Paper, WHD.
[37] Morneau Shepell (2015). 10th & 11th Actuarial Reviews of the Antigua and Barbuda Social Security Fund as of December 31, 2014. 10th & 11th Actuarial Reviews of the Antigua-Barbuda Social Security Fund as of December 31, 2014 | Antigua and Barbuda Social Security Board (gov.ag)
[38] Antigua and Barbuda Social Security Board Public Notice - https://www.socialsecurity.gov.ag, 2017
[39] National Insurance Corporation St. Lucia, 2014. https://www.stlucianic.org
[40] National Insurance Corporation St. Lucia (2020). NIC St.Lucia 2020 Annual Report. NIC-2020-Annual-Report.pdf (stlucianic.org). (https://www.stlucianic.org/wp-content)/uploads/2022/NIC…)
[41] Eastern Caribbean Central Bank (2020) Annual Economic and Financial Review https://easterncaribbean-centralbank.org
[42] https://imf.org/en/news/articles/2022/02/16IMF Staff Concludes Virtual Visit to Antigua and Barbuda, 2022