Investigating the Impact of Augmented and Virtual Reality on Learning in a Multivariable Calculus Classroom

Authors: Burcu Karabina, Lynn Long, Amanda Garcia

Abstract:

Augmented reality (AR) and virtual reality (VR) applications were offered as supplemental learning experiences to a second-year multivariable calculus class. A framework of research-informed best practices was used to guide selection and application of AR and VR learning technologies. Student feedback indicated that both AR and VR enhanced learning, both would be of value to future students, and learning may be most enhanced when AR and VR are used as complementary learning tools. The simpler technology, AR, was generally preferred, but for specific topics, students felt that the more immersive VR learning experience was especially beneficial. Immersion in the virtual learning environment minimized distractions, allowed students to feel more connected to their learning, and enhanced their ability to visualize and interact with 3D objects. Resolution of identified accessibility concerns could improve students’ overall experience with VR. Future research will explore ways to optimize the complementary effects of the two technologies. Application of research-informed framework of best practices was modelled throughout the study. Results and key resources informed revision and refinement of the framework.

Keywords: Accessibility, augmented reality, best practices, pedagogy, virtual reality.

References:

[1] S. Radović, M. Radojičić, K. Veljković and M. Marić, "Examining the Effects of Geogebra Applets on Mathematics Learning Using Interactive Mathematics Textbook," Interactive Learning Environments, vol. 28, no. 1, pp. 32-39, 2020.
[2] J. W. Lai and K. Cheong, "Adoption of Virtual and Augmented Reality for Mathematics Education: A Scoping Review," IEEE Access, vol. 10, pp. 13693-13703, 2022.
[3] A. Herur-Raman, N. D. Almeida, W. Greenleaf, D. Williams and A. Kars, "Next-generation Simulation—Integrating Extended Reality Technology Into Medical Education," Frontiers in Virtual Reality, vol. 2, pp. 1-14, 2021.
[4] A. Logeswaran, C. Munsch, Y. J. Chong, N. Ralph and J. McCrossna, "The Role of Extended Reality Technology in Healthcare Education: Towards a Learner-centred Approach," Future Healthcare Journal, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. e79-e84, 2020.
[5] J. Pomerantz, "Learning in Three Dimensions: Report on the EDUCAUSE/HP Campus of the Future Project," Educause, 2018.
[6] J. Radianti, T. Majchrzak, J. Fromm and I. Wohlgenannt, "A Sstematic Review of Immersive Virtual Reality Applications for Higher Education: Design Elements, Lessons Learned, and Research Agenda," Computers & Education, p. 147, 2020.
[7] L. Long and A. Tsinakos, "Modelling the Application of Best Practices for Choosing Extended Reality Learning Applications in the Covid-19 Context," in Proceedings of Innovate Learning Summit 2020, 2021.
[8] S. Kavanagh, A. Luxton-Reilly, B. Wuensche and B. Plimmer, "A Systematic Review of Virtual Reality in Education," Themes in Science and Technology Education, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 85-119, 2017.
[9] I. MacGillivray, "Daydream Labs: Teaching Skills in VR," 2017. (Online). Available: https://www.blog.google/products/daydream/daydream-labs-teaching-skills-vr.
[10] E. Ünal and H. Çakır, "Use of Dynamic Web Technologies in Collaborative Problem-solving Method at Community Colleges," in Student-Centered Virtual Learning Environments in Higher Education, Hershey, IGI Gl, 2019, pp. 185-209.
[11] Y. Xie, Y. Chen and L. Hui Ryder, "Effects of Using Mobile-based Virtual Reality on Chinese L2 Students’ Oral Proficiency," Computer Assisted Language Learning, vol. 1, no. 21, pp. 225-245, 2019.
[12] B. Xin, G. Chen, Y. Wang, G. Bai, X. Gao and J. Chu, "The Efficacy of Immersive Virtual Reality Surgical Simulator Training for Pedicle Screw Placement: A Randomized Double-blind Controlled Trial," World Neurosurgery, p. 124, 2019.
[13] G. Makransky, T. S. Terkildsen and R. E. Mayer, "Adding Immersive Virtual Reality to a Science Lab Simulation Causes More Presence but Less Learning," Learning and Instruction, vol. 60, pp. 225-236, 2019.
[14] J. Parong and R. E. Mayer, "Learning Science in Immersive Virtual Reality," Journal of Educational Psychology, vol. Advance online publication, pp. 785-797, 2018.
[15] O. A. Meyer, M. K. Omdahl and G. Makransky, "Investigating the Effect of Pre-training when Learning Through Immersive Virtual Reality and Video: A Media and Methods Experiment," Computers & Education, vol. 140, 2019.
[16] A. Ahmad and W. Yahaya, "Multimedia Design Principles in Ceveloping Virtual Reality Learning Applications to Increase Students’ Knowledge in Islamic Funeral Rites," vol. (Scholarly project), 2015.
[17] J. Hedberg and S. Alexander, "Virtual Reality in Education: Defining Researchable Issues," Educational Media International, vol. 31, no. 4, pp. 214-220, 1994.
[18] E. Quintero, P. Salinas, E. González-Mendívil and H. Ramírez, "Augmented Reality App for Calculus: A Proposal for the Development of Spatial Visualization," Procedia Computer Science, vol. 75, pp. 301-305, 2015.
[19] L. M. M. Herrera, J. Castro Perez and S. Juarez Ordóñez,, "Developing Spatial Mathematical Skills through 3D Tools: Augmented Reality, Virtual Environments and 3D Printing," International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing, vol. 13, p. 1385–1399, 2019.
[20] P. Salinas and E. González-Mendívil, "Augmented Reality and Solids of Revolution," International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing, vol. 11, no. 4, pp. 829-837.
[21] A. Martin-Gonzalez, A. Chi-Poot and V. Uc-Cetina, "Usability Evaluation of an Augmented Reality System for Teaching Euclidean Vectors," Innovations in Education and Teaching International, vol. 53, no. 6, pp. 627-636.
[22] L. M. M. Herrera, M. Aguilar Abalo and S. Juarez Ordóñez, "Learning Calculus with Augmented Reality and Virtual Environments," in Proceedings of the 2019 11th International Conference on Education Technology and Computers, 2019.
[23] R. Capone and M. Lepore, "Augmented Reality to Increase Interaction and Participation: A Case Study of Undergraduate Students in Mathematics Class," 2022. (Online). Available: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-58468-9_15.
[24] F. del Cerro Velázquez and “. G. G. Morales Méndez, "Application in Augmented Reality for Learning Mathematical Functions: A Study for the Development of Spatial Intelligence in Secondary Education Students," Mathematics, vol. 9, no. 4, p. 369, 2021.
[25] N. Long and J. Becnel, "Calculus in virtual reality (CalcVR)," in Improving Undergraduate STEM Education Initiative.
[26] I. Maheshwari and P. Maheshwari, "Effectiveness of Immersive VR in STEM Education," in 2020 Seventh International Conference on Information Technology Trends, 2020.
[27] "CalcVR (Calculus in Virtual Reality)," (Online). Available: https://calcvr.org.
[28] "About GeoGebra," 2023. (Online). Available: https://www.geogebra.org/about.
[29] "The UDL Guidelines," 2022. (Online). Available: https://udlguidelines.cast.org/.
[30] E. Fassbender, D. Richards, A. Bilgin, W. Thompson and W. Heiden, "VirSchool: The Effect of Background Music and Immersive Display Systems on Memory for Facts Learned in an Educational Virtual Environment," Computers & Education, vol. 58, no. 1, p. 490, 2012.
[31] K. Rivenburgh, "WCAG 101: Understanding the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines," 2022. (Online). Available: https://wcag.com/resource/what-is-wcag/#:~:text=The%20Web%20Content%20Accessibility%20Guidelines%20%28WCAG%29%20are%20technical,industry%2C%20disability%20.
[32] "Reducing Cybersickness in Virtual Reality," Qualcomm Developer Network, 2022. (Online). Available: https://developer.qualcomm.com/system/files/ebook_cybersickness_qdn_vfinal2.pdf.
[33] S. Weech, J. Parokaran Varghese and M. Barnett-Cowan, "Estimating the Sensorimotor Components of Cybersickness," Journal of Neuorphsycology, vol. 120, pp. 2201-2217, 2018.
[34] P. Zeni, M. J. Justice and K. Wilson, "How Do We Create Accessible Online Learning Experiences?," CEL UX Honeycomb - Accessible, (Online). Available: https://cms.cel.uwaterloo.ca/honeycomb/accessible.aspx.
[35] A. W. Bates, Teaching in a Digital Age: Guidelines for Designing Teaching and Learning, 3rd ed., Tony Bates Associates Ltd, 2022.
[36] L. Chittaro and R. Ranon, "Web3D Technologies in Learning, Education and Training: Motivations, Issues, Opportunities," Computers & Education, vol. 49, no. 1, pp. 3-18, 2007.