Impact of Revenue Reform on Vulnerable Communities in Tonga

Authors: Pauliasi Tony Fakahau

Abstract:

This paper provides an overview of the impact of the revenue reform programme on vulnerable communities in the Kingdom of Tonga. Economic turmoil and mismanagement during the late 1990s forced the government to seek technical and financial assistance from the Asian Development Bank to undertake a comprehensive Economic and Public Sector Reform (EPSR) programme. The EPSR is a Western model recommended by donor agencies as the solution to Tonga’s economic challenges. The EPSR programme included public sector reform, private sector growth, and revenue generation. Tax reform was the main tool for revenue generation, which set out to strengthen tax compliance and administration as well as implement a value-added consumption tax. The EPSR is based on Western values and ideology but failed to recognise that Tongan cultural values are important to the local community. Two participant groups were interviewed. Participant group one consisted of 51 people representing vulnerable communities. Participant group two consisted of six people from the government and business sector who were from the elite of Tongan society. The Kakala Research Methodology provided the framework for the research, and the Talanoa Research Method was used to conduct semi-structured interviews in the homes of the first group and in the workplaces of the second group. The research found a heavy burden of the consumption tax on the purchasing power of participant group one (vulnerable participants), having an impact on nearly every financial transaction they made. Participant group one’s main financial priorities were kavenga fakalotu (obligations to the church), kavenga fakafāmili (obligations to the family) and kavenga fakafonua (obligations to cultural events for the village, nobility, and royalty). The findings identified inequalities of the revenue reform, especially from consumption tax, for vulnerable people and communities compared to the elite of society. The research concluded that government and donor agencies need ameliorating policies to reduce the burden of tax on vulnerable groups more susceptible to the impact of revenue reform.

Keywords: Tax reform, Tonga vulnerable community revenue, revenue reform, public sector reform.

References:

[1] S. Johansson-Fua. Kakala research framework: A garland in celebration of a decade of rethinking education. In M. 'Otunuku, U. Nabobo-Baba, & S. F. Johansson-Fua. 2014.
[2] T. Vaioleti. Talanoa research methodology: A developing position on Pacific research. Waikato Journal of Education, 2006, pp. 12, 21-34.
[3] Asian Development Bank. Asian Development Bank annual report 1999. Retrieved from https://www.adb.org/documents/adb-annual-report, 1999.
[4] International Monetary Fund. Tonga: IMF staff country report No. 01/02. Washington DC: IMF, 2001.
[5] S. Naidu. Economic contribution and analysis of supply chain of Tongan squash pumpkin industry. Asian Journal of Management Research,1(1), 2010, pp.139-156.
[6] Asian Development Bank. Tonga: Agriculture Sector Review. ADB Technical Assistance Consultant's Report, TA no 4112 (37124). Retrieved from https://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/project-document/70404/37124-ton-tacr.pdf, 2003.
[7] V. Fakava. Trade and environment dimensions in the squash and vanilla industries in Tonga. Paper presented at the United Nations Trade Environment Meeting Asia 6 July 2006 Session 10, Fiji.
[8] M. Felemi. Constraints, challenges and prospects for development of the squash export industry in Tonga. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the Regional Workshop on the Constraints, Challenges, and Prospects for Commodity Based Development, Diversification, and Trade in the Pacific Island Economies, Nadi, Fiji, 2001.
[9] P.V. Grijp. Leaders in squash export: Entrepreneurship and the introduction of a new cash crop in Tonga. Pacific Studies, 1997, Vol 20(1), pp.29.
[10] W. E. Murray. The second wave of globalisation and agrarian change in the Pacific Islands. Journal of Rural Studies, 2001, Vol 17(2), pp.135-148.
[11] D. Storey, & W. E. Murray. Dilemmas of development in Oceania: The political economy of the Tongan agro‐export sector. Geographical Journal, 2001, Vol 167(4), pp.291-304.
[12] V. Fakava, P.L. Nuthall, & G. Nartea. Objectives, subsistence and farm development: the case of Tonga. Lincoln, New Zealand: Lincoln University, 2001, pp.1174-8796.
[13] S. ’Utoikamanu. Statement by the Hon. Siosiua T.T. 'Utoikamanu. Minister of Finance and Governor for Tonga at 2002 Annual Meetings of the IMF and World Bank. Retrieved from www.imf.org/external/am/2002/speeches/pr25e.pdf, 2002.
[14] World Bank. Pacific Islands regional economic report: Embarking on a global Voyage: Trade liberalization and complementary reforms in the Pacific. Retrieved from http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/512981468763155953/pdf/multi0page.pdf, 2002.
[15] S. ’Utoikamanu. Consumption tax - The Tongan experience Pacific Islands Report. Retrieved from http://www.pireport.org/articles/2007/07/27/consumption-tax-tongan-experience, 2007.
[16] C. Hood & M. Jackson. The new public management: A recipe for disaster? In D. H. Parker & J. Handmer (Eds.), Hazard management and emergency planning: Perspectives on Britain, New York, NY: James and James Science Publishers Ltd, 1992, pp. 109-125.
[17] M. Minogue. Changing the state: Concepts and practice in the reform of the public sector. Manchester, UK: Institute for Development Policy and Management, University of Manchester, 1998.
[18] K. Murray, R. Oliver & S. Wyatt. Evaluation of taxation reform in the Pacific. Retrieved from https://www.mfat.govt.nz/assets/Aid-Prog-docs/Research/Tax-Reform-in-the-Pacific-Synthesis-Report.pdf, 2014.
[19] Ministry of Finance. Budget Statement 2001. Nuku'alofa, Tonga: Government of Tonga, 2001.