Indicators as Early Warning Signal Performance to Solve Underlying Safety Problem before They Emerge as Accident Risks

Authors: Benson Chizubem

Abstract:

Because of the severe hazards that substantially impact workers' lives and assets lost, the oil and gas industry has established a goal of establishing zero occurrences or accidents in operations. Using leading indicators to measure and assess an organization's safety performance is a proactive approach to safety management. Also, it will provide early warning signals to solve inherent safety issues before they lead to an accident in the study industry. The analysis of these indicators' performance was based on a questionnaire-based methodology. A total number of 1000 questionnaires were disseminated to the workers, of which 327 were returned to the researcher team. The data collected were analysed to evaluate their safety perceptions on indicators performance. Data analysis identified safety training, safety system, safety supervision, safety rules and procedures, safety auditing, strategies and policies, management commitment, safety meeting and safety behaviour, as potential leading indicators that are capable of measuring organizational safety performance and as capable of providing early warning signals of weak safety area in an operational environment. The findings of this study have provided safety researchers and industrial safety practitioners with helpful information on the improvement of the existing safety monitoring process in the oil and gas industry, both locally and globally, as proactive actions.

Keywords: Early warning, safety, accident risks, oil and gas industry.

References:

[1] Robertson and Leon, S. Injury Epidemiology (Fourth Edition Ed.). Lulu Books (2015).
[2] Benson, C.; Argyropoulos, C.D.; Nicolaidou, O.; Boustras, G. Impact of Weak Signals on the Digitalization of Risk Analysis in Process Safety Operational Environments. Processes (2022), 10, 631
[3] Nicolaidou, O., Dimopoulos, C., Mikellidou, C. V., Boustras, G., & Mikellides, N. The use of weak signals in occupational safety and health: An investigation. Saf. Sci, (2021), 139, 105253.
[4] IPCC: Internal governmental Panel of Climate Change Report, (2012).
[5] Øien, K. (2008). Development of early warning indicators based on incident investigation. 9th International Conference on Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management. PSAM, 1809-16.
[6] Rausand, M. Risk Assessment - Theory, Methods, and Applications (1 Ed.). Hoboken, New Jersey, USA: John Wiley & Sons. (2011).
[7] IAEA. Operational safety performance indicators for nuclear power plants IAEA-TECDOC. Vienna: International Atomic Energy Agency. (2000).
[8] Benson, C., Argyropoulos, C. D., Dimopoulos, C., Mikellidou, C. V., & Boustras, G. Safety and risk analysis in digitalized process operations warning of possible deviating conditions in the process environment. Process Saf. Environ. Prot, (2021), 149, 750–757.
[9] Markatos, N. C., Christolis, N., & Argyropoulos, C. D. Mathematical modelling of toxic pollutants dispersion from large tank fires and assessment of acute. (2009).
[10] Argyropoulos, C. D., Christolis, M. N., Nivolianitou, Z.,& Markatos, N. C. A hazards assessment methodology for large liquid hydrocarbon fuel tanks. J Loss Prev. Process Ind., (2012). 35, 329-335.
[11] Reader, T. W., & Connor, P. O. The Deepwater Horizon explosion: non-technical skills, safety culture, and system complexity. Journal of Risk Research, (2013), 17(3), 37–41.
[12] Martínez-Val, & et al, J. M. An analysis of the physical causes of the Chornobyl accident. Nucl. Technol, (2017), 90 (3).
[13] Cullen, T. The public inquiry into the Piper Alpha disaster. London: H.M. Stationery Office, (1990) 2, 488.
[14] Le Coze, J. New models for new times. An anti-dualist move. Saf. Sci., (2013) 59, 200-218.
[15] Ahiuma, Y. Safety and Health; Issues and Perspectives. Benin City Nigeria. Nigeria Union of Journalists on Health and Safety issues in Nigeria (2012).
[16] Ngwa, J. Framework for Occupational Health and Safety in Nigeria: The Implication for the Trade Union Movement. Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development, (2016), 7(11), 113-121.
[17] Benson C., Christos Dimopoulos, Christos D. Argyropoulos, Cleo Varianou Mikellidou, Georgios Boustras. Assessing the common occupational health hazards and their health risks among oil and gas workers. Saf. Sci. (2021), 140, 105284.
[18] Energy Mix Report (2013).
[19] Rig zone Report (2013).
[20] HSE. Process Safety Indicators, a Step-by-step Guide for the Chemical and Major Hazards Industries, HSG 254 The Office of Public Sector Information, Information Policy Team, Kew, Richmond, and Surrey. HSE (2006).
[21] Huang, Y. Safety Climate: How can you measure it, and why does it matter? Professional Safety, (2017), 28–35.
[22] CCPS. Center for Chemical Process Safety. The layer of Protection Analysis: Simplified Process Risk Assessment. Wiley: New York, NY USA. (201).
[23] Paltrinieri, N., & Haskins, C. (2017). Dynamic Security Assessment: Benefits and Limitations. In Security Risk Assess.
[24] Sklet, S., Vinnem, J. E., & Aven, T. Barrier and operational risk analysis of hydrocarbon releases (BORA-Release): Part II: Results from a case study. J. Hazard. Mater, (2006). 137, 692–708.
[25] Øien, K. A framework for the establishment of organizational risk indicators. Reliab Eng Syst Safe, (2001). 74, 147-67.
[26] Delvosalle, C., Fievez, C., & Pipart, A. ARAMIS Accidental Risk Assessment Methodology for Industries. Elsevier: Amsterdam, the Netherlands, (2006), 1-60.
[27] Øien, K. Remote operation in environmentally sensitive areas: development of early warning indicators. Journal of Risk Research, (2013), 16, 323-36.
[28] Rausand, M. Theory, Methods, and Applications (1 Ed.) New Jersey, USA: John Wiley & Sons, (2011).
[29] Øien, K., Utne, I. B., Tinmannsvik , R. K., & Massaiu, S. Building Safety indicators: Part 2 - Application, practices and results. Safety Science, (2011), 49, 162-71.
[30] Vinnem, J. E. Risk indicators for major hazards on offshore installations. Safety Science, (2010), 48, 770-87.
[31] Skogdalen, J. E., Utne, I. B., & Vinnem, J. E. Developing safety indicators for preventing offshore oil and gas deepwater drilling blowouts. Safety Science, (2011), 49, 1187-99.
[32] Reiman, T., & Pietikainen, E. Leading indicators of system safety - Monitoring and driving the organizational safety potential. Safety Science, (2012), 50, 1993-2000.
[33] Hassan, J., & Khan, F. Risk-based asset integrity indicators. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries, (2012). 25, 544-54.
[34] Øien, K. (2013). Risk indicators as a tool for risk control. Reliab Eng Syst Safe, 74, 129-45.
[35] Rockwell, T. Safety performance measurement. J. Ind. Eng., (1959), 10 (1), 12-16.
[36] Tarrants, W. An Evaluation of the Critical Incident Technique as a Method for Identifying Industrial Accident Causal Factors Doctoral dissertation. New York University, New York, (1963).
[37] Hopkins, A. Thinking about process safety indicators. Safety Science, (2009), 47, 460-5.
[38] DHSG. Final Report on the Investigation of the Macondo Well Blowout. Berkeley, California, USA: Deepwater Horizon Study Group, Center for Catastrophic Risk Management (CCRM). The University of California, (2011).
[39] Knegtering, B., & Pasman, H. The safety barometer. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries, (2013), 26, 821-9.
[40] GEMI. Measuring Environmental Performance: A Primer and Survey of Metrics in Use. Retrieved from Global Environmental Management Initiative, (2019). http://gemi.org/Resources/MET_101.pdf.
[41] De Cieri, H. et al. (2015). Leading indicators of occupational health and safety: A report on a survey of Australia Nursing and Midwifery Federation (Victorian Branch) members, prepared for the. Melbourne. Monash University.
[42] CCPS. Process Safety Leading and Lagging Metrics. You Don't Improve What You Don't Measure. AIChE, New York, (2011).
[43] EPSCEuropean Process Safety Centre. Safety-Critical Measures, (2012).
[44] OGP. Process Safety, Recommended Practice on Key Performance Indicators. The report, (2011), 456, November, London
[45] OECD. Guidance on Developing Safety Performance Indicators Related to Chemical Accident Prevention, Preparedness and Response. OECD Environment, Health and Safety Publications, Series on Chemical Accidents No. 198 Guidance for Industry, Environment Directorate, Paris, (2008).
[46] ANSI/API. Process Safety Performance Indicators for the Refining and Petrochemical Industries. (First Ed.) (2010) ANSI/API RP 754.
[47] IOGP. Safety performance indicators data. International Association of Oil & Gas Producers, (2015).
[48] Middlesworth, M. A Short Guide to Leading and Lagging Indicators of Safety Performance, (2018). Retrieved from Ergoplus: https://ergo-plus.com/leading-lagging-indicators-safety-preformance/.
[49] Hinze, J., Hallowell, M., & Baud, K. “Construction-safety best practices and relationships to safety performance.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage, (2013), 139(10), 1943-7862.
[50] Goh, Y. M., & Chua, D. “Neural network analysis of construction safety management systems: A case study in Singapore.” Constr. Manage. Econ. (2013). 31(5), 460-470.
[51] Alarcon, L. F., Acuna, D., Diethelm, S., & Pellicer, E. “Strategies for improving safety performance in construction firms.” Accid. Anal. Prev., (2016), 94, 107-118.
[52] Rajendran, S. “Enhancing construction worker safety performance using leading indicators.”. Pract. Period. Struct. Des. Constr., (2012), 18(1), 45–51.
[53] Salas, R., & Hallowell, M. “Predictive validity of safety leading: Empirical assessment in the oil and gas sector. J. Constr. Eng. Manage, (2016), 142(10).
[54] Lingard, H., Hallowell, M., Salas, R., & Pirzad, P. “Leading or lagging? Temporal analysis of safety indicators on a large infrastructure construction project.”. Saf. Sci., (2016), 91, 206–220.