Reliability of Eyewitness Statements in Fire and Explosion Investigations

Authors: Jeff D. Colwell, Benjamin W. Knox

Abstract:

While fire and explosion incidents are often observed by eyewitnesses, the weight that fire investigators should place on those observations in their investigations is a complex issue. There is no doubt that eyewitness statements can be an important component to an investigation, particularly when other evidence is sparse, as is often the case when damage to the scene is severe. However, it is well known that eyewitness statements can be incorrect for a variety of reasons, including deception. In this paper, we reviewed factors that can have an effect on the complex processes associated with the perception, retention, and retrieval of an event. We then review the accuracy of eyewitness statements from unique criminal and civil incidents, including fire and explosion incidents, in which the accuracy of the statements could be independently evaluated. Finally, the motives for deceptive eyewitness statements are described, along with techniques that fire and explosion investigators can employ, to increase the accuracy of the eyewitness statements that they solicit.

Keywords: Explosion, eyewitness, fire, reliability.

References:

[1] Robins, P. J. (2009) Eyewitness Reliability in Motor Vehicle Crashes: A Primer for Practitioners, 2nd Ed, Lawyers & Judges Publishing Company, Inc., Tucson.
[2] Loftus, E. F., Doyle, J. M and Dysart, J. E. (2013) Eyewitness Testimony – Civil and Criminal, 5th Ed, LexisNexis, Danvers.
[3] Benignus, V. A. (1994) Behavioral Effects of Carbon Monoxide: Meta Analyses and Extrapolations. Journal of Applied Physiology, 76(3), 1310-1316.
[4] Jewett, M. E., Wyatt, J. K., Ritz‐De Cecco, A., Khalsa, S. B., Dijk, D. J., and Czeisler, C. A. (1999). Time Course of Sleep Inertia Dissipation in Human Performance and Alertness. Journal of Sleep Research, 8, 1-8.
[5] Simons, D. J., and Chabris, C. F. (1999) Gorillas in Our Midst: Sustained Inattentional Blindness for Dynamic Events. Perception, 28, 1059-1074.
[6] Loftus, E. F. (1996) Eyewitness Testimony, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
[7] English, D. and Kuzel, M. (2014) Reliability of Eyewitness Reports to a Major Aviation Accident. International Journal of Aviation, Aeronautics, and Aerospace, 1(4).
[8] Woolnough, P. S. and MacLeod, M. D. (2001) Watching the Birdie Watching You: Eyewitness Memory for Actions using CCTV Records of Actual Crimes. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 15, 395-411.
[9] Nachson, I. and Slavutskay-Tsukerman, I. (2010) Effect of Personal Involvement in Traumatic Events on Memory: The Case of the Dolphinarium Explosion. Memory, 18(3), 241-251.
[10] Riniolo, T. C., Koledin, M., Drakulic, G. M., and Payne, R. A. (2003) An Archival Study of Eyewitness Memory of the Titanic’s Final Plunge. The Journal of General Psychology, 130(1), 89-95.
[11] Garzke, W. H., Brown, D. K., Sandiford, A. D., Woodward, J., and Hsu, P. K. (1996) The Titanic and Lusitania: A Final Forensic Analysis. Marine Technology, 33(4), 241-289.
[12] Hjelmsater, E. R. A., Ohman, L. and Granhag, P. A. (2016) The Sinking of the M/V Estonia: An Archival Study of the Survivors’ Witness Reports. Nordic Psychology, 68(4), 244-256.
[13] Garrett, B. L. (2011) Convicting the Innocent – Where Criminal Prosecutions go Wrong, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
[14] Wells, G. L., Malpass, R. S., Lindsay, R. C. L., Fisher, R. P., Turtle, J. W. and Fulero, S. M. (2000) From the Lab to the Police Station – A Successful Application of Eyewitness Research. American Psychologist, 55(6), 581-598.
[15] U.S. Department of Justice (1999) Eyewitness evidence - A Guide for Law Enforcement, U.S. Department of Justice. Washington, DC.
[16] Buckhout, R. (1977) Eyewitness Identification and Psychology in the Courtroom. Criminal Defense, 4(5), 5-10.
[17] Ainsworth, P. B. (1998) Psychology, Law and Eyewitness Testimony, John Wiley & Sons, Chichester.
[18] Redsicker, D. R. and O’Connor, J. J. (1997) Practical Fire and Arson Investigation, 2nd Ed, CRC Press, Boca Raton.
[19] Mares, A. C., and Turvey, B. E. (2018) The Psychology of Lying. In Turvey, B. E., Savino, J. O., and Mares, A. C., editors, False Allegations. Academic Press, London.
[20] Levine, T. R., Ali, M. V., Dean, M., Abdulla, R. A. and Garcia-Ruano, K. (2016) Toward a Pan-Cultural Typology of Deception Motives. Journal of Intercultural Communication Research, 45(1), 1-12.
[21] Ekman, P. (1997) Lying and Deception. In Stein, N. L., Ornstein, P. A., Tversky, B. and Brainerd, C., editors, Memory for Everyday and Emotional Events, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah.
[22] Best, R. L. (1977) Reconstruction of a Tragedy – The Beverly Hills Supper Club Fire. National Fire Protection Association, Boston.
[23] Roberts, A. F. (1992) The King’s Cross fire: A Correlation of Eyewitness Accounts and the Results of the Scientific Investigation. Fire Safety Journal, 18, 105-121.
[24] Fahy, R. F. and Proulx, G. (2005) Federal Building and Fire Safety Investigation of the World Trade Center Disaster – Analysis of Published Accounts of the World Trade Center Evacuation. NIST NCSTAR 1-7A.
[25] Colwell, J. D., Mongia, R. and Reza, A. (2005) Case Study on Evacuation Rates within the World Trade Center Towers on September 11, 2001. 49th Annual Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Conference, Orlando, FL, September 26–30.
[26] Fahy, R. F., Proulx, G. and Flynn, J. (2011) The Station Nightclub Fire – An Analysis of Witness Statements. Fire Safety Science-Proceedings of the Tenth International Symposium, 197-210.
[27] Geiman, J. A. and Lord, J. M. (2012) Systematic Analysis of Witness Statements for Fire Investigation. Fire Technology, 48, 219-231.
[28] Memon, A., Meissner, C. A., and Fraser, J. (2010). The Cognitive Interview: A Meta-Analytic Review and Study Space Analysis of the Past 25 Years. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 16(4), 340-372.
[29] Behavioral Analysis Training Institute (2019) Advanced Cognitive Interviewing & Forensic Statement Analysis. Penn Valley.
[30] Edelstein, R. S., Alexander, K. W., Goodman, G. S., Newton, J. W. (2004) Emotion and Eyewitness Memory. In Reisberg, D. and Hertel, P., editors, Memory and Emotion, Oxford University Press, New York.