Quantifying the Second-Level Digital Divide on Sub-National Level
Authors: Vladimir Korovkin, Albert Park, Evgeny Kaganer
Digital divide, the gap in the access to the world of digital technologies and the socio-economic opportunities that they create is an important phenomenon of the XXI century. This gap may exist between countries, regions within a country or socio-demographic groups, creating the classes of “digital have and have nots”. While the 1st-level divide (the difference in opportunities to access the digital networks) was demonstrated to diminish with time, the issues of 2nd level divide (the difference in skills and usage of digital systems) and 3rd level divide (the difference in effects obtained from digital technology) may grow. The paper offers a systemic review of literature on the measurement of the digital divide, noting the certain conceptual stagnation due to the lack of effective instruments that would capture the complex nature of the phenomenon. As a result, many important concepts do not receive the empiric exploration they deserve. As a solution the paper suggests a composite Digital Life Index, that studies separately the digital supply and demand across seven independent dimensions providing for 14 subindices. The Index is based on Internet-borne data, a distinction from traditional research approaches that rely on official statistics or surveys. The application of the model to the study of the digital divide between Russian regions and between cities in China have brought promising results. The paper advances the existing methodological literature on the 2nd level digital divide and can also inform practical decision-making regarding the strategies of national and regional digital development.
Keywords: Digital transformation, second-level digital divide, composite index, digital policy.Procedia APA BibTeX Chicago EndNote Harvard JSON MLA RIS XML ISO 690 PDF Downloads 246
 J. Shepherd, "What is the Digital Era?," in Social and Economic Transformation in the Digital Era, IGI Global, 2004, pp. 1-18.
 Y. Yoo, "Computing in Everyday Life: A Call for Research on Experiential Computing.," MIS Quarterly, vol. 34, no. 2, pp. 212 - 231, 2010.
 World Economic Forum, "The COVID-19 pandemic has changed education forever. This is how," 29 April 2020. (Online). Available: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/04/coronavirus-education-global-covid19-online-digital-learning/.
 J. Wu, "The Pandemic Is a Perfect Time to Address the Digital Divide," 18 August 2020. (Online). Available: https://www.forbes.com/sites/junwu1/2020/08/18/the-pandemic-is-a-perfect-time-to-address-the-digital-divide/?sh=a37d11e61298.
 Wired, "The Pandemic Is Forcing Everyone to Face the Digital Divide," 19 September 2020. (Online). Available: https://www.wired.com/story/the-pandemic-is-forcing-everyone-to-face-the-digital-divide/.
 CNN, "Families find throwing laptops and Wi-Fi at students isn't enough to bridge digital divide," 23 January 2021. (Online). Available: https://edition.cnn.com/2021/01/23/us/education-digital-divide-in-coronavirus/index.html.
 O. B. Azubuikea, O. Adegboyeb and H. Quadric, "Who gets to learn in a pandemic? Exploring the digital divide in remote learning during the COVID-19 pandemic in Nigeria," International Journal of Educational Research Open, p. In press, 2020.
 G. Burgess, "Beyond the Pandemic #2. Tackle the Digital Divide," 2020. (Online). Available: https://www.cam.ac.uk/stories/BeyondThePandemic_digitaldivide.
 A.-B. Gran, P. Booth and T. Bucher, "To be or not to be algorithm aware: a question of a new digital divide?," Information, Communication & Society, vol. 24, no. 12, pp. 1779-1796, 2021.
 M. Blomberg, D. Altschwager, H. Seo, E. Booton and M. Nwachukwu, "Digital divide and marginalized women during COVID-19: a study of women recently released from prison," Information, Communication & Society, vol. 24, no. 14, pp. 2113-2132, 2021.
 H. M. Mabweazara, "Towards reimagining the ‘digital divide’: impediments and circumnavigation practices in the appropriation of the mobile phone by African journalists," Information, Communication & Society, vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 344-364, 2021.
 NTIA, "Falling Through the Net: Defining the Digital Divide. A Report on the Telecommunications and Information Technology Gap in America," National Telecommunications and Information Administration • U.S. Department of Commerce, Washington DC, 1999.
 S. Raveesh, "Raveesh, S. (2013). Digital Divide - "Haves" and "Have-Nots": A Modern Inequality of 21st Century," European Academic Research, vol. 1, no. 7, pp. 1753-1769, 2013.
 OECD, "Understanding the Digital Divide," 2001. (Online). Available: http://www.oecd.org/internet/ieconomy/1888451.pdf.
 A. H. Ali, "The Power of Social Media in Developing Nations: New Tools for Closing the Global Digital Divide and Beyond," Harvard Human Rights Journal, 2011.
 M. H. Lopez, A. Gonzalez-Barrera and E. Patten, "Closing the Digital Divide: Latinos and Technology Adoption," Pew Research Center, Washington DC, 2013.
 R. Gallardo, "2015 Digital Divide Index," Mississippi State University Intelligent Community Institute, 2015.
 R. Gallardo, L. Beaulieu and I. Kumar, "Digital Divide in the US.," no. 3, pp. Purdue University, Research & Policy Insights, 2018.
 E. Hargittai, "Second-level digital divide: differences in people online skills," First Monday, vol. 7, no. 4, 2002.
 A. J. A. M. van Deursen and E. J. Helsper, "The Third-Level Digital Divide: Who Benefits Most from Being Online?," Communication and Information Technologies Annual (Studies in Media and Communications, Vol. 10), pp. 29-52, 2015.
 R. G. Harris, "The Internet as a GPT: Factor Market Implications," in General Purpose Technologies and Economic Growth, Cambridge, Mass. and London, England, The MIT Press, 1998, pp. 145-166.
 M. Hilbert, "Mapping out the Transition toward Information Societies: Social Nature, Growth, and Policies," A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the USC Graduate School University of Southern California, 2012.
 J. A. van Dijk, "A theory of the digital divide," in The Digital Divide. The internet and social inequality in international perspective, London and Ney York, Routledge, 2013, pp. 29-52.
 C. Fuchs, "The Role of Income Inequality in a Multivariate Cross-National Analysis of the Digital Divide.," Social Science Computer Review, pp. 41-58, 2008.
 T. Hüsing and H. Selhofer, "The Digital Divide Index—A Measure of Social Inequalities in the Adoption of ICT," in Proceedings of the 10th European Conference on Information Systems, Information Systems and the Future of the Digital Economy, Gdansk, Poland, 2002.
 P. Norris, "The worldwide digital divide: information poverty, the Internet and development," in Paper for the Annual Meeting of the Political Studies Association of the UK, London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK, 2000.
 V. Korovkin, "National digital economy strategies: a survey of Africa," ORF Issue Brief, vol. 313, pp. 1-5, 2019.
 V. Korovkin and E. Kaganer, "Digital Life of Russian Megapolises: Model. Dynamics. Cases.," 2016. (Online). Available: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3104638 .
 IEMS HKUST, "Digital Life Index in China," Institute for Emerging Market Studies, HKUST Working Paper, Hong Kong, China, 2019.
 V. Korovkin, "The Digital Life of Russian Regions: What Defines the Digital Divide?," SKOLKOVO Institute for Emerging Market Studies (IEMS), 2020, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3622335, 2020.
 S. Dasgupta, S. Lall and D. Wheeler, "Policy reform, economic growth and the digital divide," The World Bank Development Research Group, 2001.
 D. Gunkel, "Second thoughts: toward a critique of digital divide," New media & society, vol. 5, no. 4, pp. 499 - 522, 2003.
 C. Srinuan and E. Bohlin, "Understanding the digital divide: A literature survey and ways forward PDF Logo," in 22nd European Regional ITS Conference, Budapest, 2011.
 E. N. Mwim and E. Kritzinger, "Views of Digital Divide: A Literature Review," in 2nd African conference on information systems & technology (ACIST), Accra, Ghana, 2016.
 A. Scheerder, A. van Deursen and J. van Dijk, "Determinants of Internet skills, uses and outcomes. A systematic review of the second- and third-level digital divide," Telematics and Informatics, vol. 34, no. 8, pp. 1607-1624, 2017.
 T. Childer, The Information Poor in America, Metuchen, N. J.: Scarecrow Press, 1975.
 L. Yu, "Understanding information inequality: making sense of the literature on information and digital divide," Journal of Librarianship and Information Science, vol. 38, pp. 229-252, 2006.
 D. B. Hindman, "The rural-urban digital divide," Journalism & Mass Communications Quarterly, vol. 77, no. 3, p. 549–560., 2000.
 M. Warschauer, "Reconceptualizing the digital divide," First Monday, vol. 7, no. 7, 2002.
 P. Dimaggio, E. Hargittai, C. Celeste and S. Shafer, "Digital inequality: from unequal access to differentiated use," in Social Inequality, Russell Sage Foundation, 2004, pp. 355-400.
 J. van Dijk and K. Hacker, "The digital divide as a complex and dynamic phenomenon," The Information Society, vol. 19, no. 4, pp. 315-326, 2003.
 S. Livingstone and E. Helsper, "Gradations in digital inclusion: children, young people and the digital divide," new media & society, vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 671 - 696, 2007.
 APEC, "APEC E-Commerce Readiness Assessment Guide," APEC Telecommunications and Information Working Group, 2000.
 European Commission, "SINE. Statistical Indicators for the New Economy," Directorate-General Information Society Statistical Office of the European Communities, 2000.
 P. Wolcott, L. Press, W. McHenry, S. Goodman and W. Foster, "A Framework for Assessing the Global Diffusion of the Internet," Journal of the Association of the Information Systems, vol. 2, 2001.
 R. D. Atkinson and R. Coduri, "The 2002 State New Economy Index. Benchmarking Economic Transformation in the States," Progressive Policy Institute, 2002.
 K. Mossberger, C. J. Tolbert and M. Stansbury, Virtual Inequality: Beyond the Digital Divide, Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press, 2003.
 Z. Song, T. Song, Y. Yang and Z. Wang, "Spatial–Temporal Characteristics and Determinants of Digital Divide in China: A Multivariate Spatial Analysis," Sustainability, vol. 11, 2019.
 M. Martínez-Domínguez and J. Mora-Rivera, "Internet adoption and usage patterns in rural Mexico," Technology in Society, vol. 60, p. 101226, 2020.
 A. Hidalgo, S. Gabaly, G. Morales-Alonso and A. Urueña, "The digital divide in light of sustainable development: An approach through advanced machine learning techniques," Technological Forecasting & Social Change, vol. 150, 2020.
 S. K. Maji and A. Laha, "State of Digital Economy in Asia-Pacific Region: Delineating the Role of Digital Skill," International Journal of Public Administration in the Digital Age, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 38 - 46, 2020.
 W. Welch, "The Information Society Index (ISI) 2000," 2000. (Online). Available: http://www.gsid.nagoya-u.ac.jp/sotsubo/Information_Society_Index.pdf.
 J. Jin and C. Xiong, "Digital Divide in National Informatization Quotient: The Perspective of Mainland China," in International Conference on the Digital Divide: Technology & Politics in the Information Age, 2002.
 ITU, "Measuring the Information Society. ICT Development Index," International Telecommunication Union, Geneva, Switzerland, 2009.
 M. L. A. Lustria, S. A. Smith and C. C. Hinnant, "Exploring digital divides: An examination of eHealth technology use in health information seeking, communication and personal health information management in the USA," Health Information Journal, 2011.
 M. J. Menou, "An Overview of Social Measures of Information," Journal of the American Society for Information Studies, vol. 36, no. 3, pp. 169-177, 1985.
 B. Bazar and G. Boalch, "A preliminary model of Internet diffusion within developing countries," in AusWeb97: Third Australian World Wide Web Conference, Lismore, 1997.
 P. Norris, Digital Divide: Civic Engagement, Information Poverty, and the Internet Worldwide, Cambridge University Press, 2001.
 R. Cullen, "Addressing the digital divide.," Online Information Review, vol. 25, no. 5, pp. 311-320, 2001.
 C. Fuchs and E. Horak, "Informational capitalism and the digital divide in Africa," Masaryk University Journal of Law and Technology, 2008.
 C. Fuchs and E. Horak, "Africa and the digital divide," Telematics and Informatics, vol. 25, pp. 99-116, 2008a.
 J. B. Pick and A. Sarkar, The Global Digital Divides, Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer, 2015.
 A. Normore and A. I. Lahera, Crossing the Bridge of Digital Divide: A Walk with Global Leaders, Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing, 2019.
 Department of Information Technology, "INDIA: E-Readiness Assessment Report 2004 For States/Union Territories," Department of Information Technology, Ministry of Communications and Information Technology, Government of India, New Delhi, 2004.
 R. Agarwal, A. Animesh and K. Prasad, "Social Interactions and the 'Digital Divide': Explaining Regional Variations in Internet Use," Robert H. Smith School of Business Working paper no. RHS-06-024, 2005.
 R. Gallardo, "Digital Divide Index.," 2020. (Online). Available: http://pcrd.purdue.edu/ddi.
 T. Hirvonen and L. Frank, "Measuring the Information Society in Europe: From Definitions to Description.," in European Regional Science Association, ERSA conference papers, 2006.
 G. Žilinskas, "Lietuvos Respublikos Darnaus Vystymosi Politika: Skaitmeninės Atskirties Problemos Regioninis Aspektas," Management theory and studies for rural business and infrastructure, vol. 1 (25), 2011.
 T. Nishida, J. Pick and A. Sarkar, "Spatial and Multivariate Analysis of Japan’s Prefectural Digital Divide," in AMCIS 2012 Proceedings, 2012.
 J. B. Pick, A. Sarkar and J. Johnson, "Information Technology Availability and Use in the United States: A Multivariate and Geospatial Analysis by State," in 47th Hawaii International Conference on System Science, Honolulu, Hawaii, 2014.
 Swinburne University & Telstra, "Australian Digital Inclusion Index Discussion Paper," Swinburne University, Melbourne, Australia, 2015.
 J. Thomas, J. Barraket, C. Wilson, I. Holcombe-James, J. Kennedy, E. Rennie, S. Ewing and T. MacDonald, "Measuring Australia’s Digital Divide: The Australian Digital Inclusion Index," RMIT and Swinburne University of Technology, Melbourne, Australia, 2020.
 M. Dezuanni, J. Burgess, J. Thomas, J. Barraket, A. Marshall, C. Wilson, S. Ewing and T. MacDonald, "Measuring Queensland’s Digital Divide − The Australian Digital Inclusion Index 2017: Queensland," RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia, 2017.
 V. Korovkin and E. Kaganer, "Digital Life of Russian Megapolises: Model. Dynamics. Cases.," Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3104638 2016.
 H. Fidan, "Türkiye Bölgesel Sayısal Bölünme Düzeylerinin Belirlenmesinde Gini Yaklaşımı," Business and Economics Research Journal, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 49-62, 2017.
 G. Blank, M. Graham and C. Calvino, "Local Geographies of Digital Inequality," Social Science Computer Review, vol. 36, no. 1, pp. 82-102, 2018.
 W. Szymanowski and G. Brudniak, "Foresight of Information Society: The Knowledge-Based Economy. An attempt at measuring with the use of the example of spatial diversity of Poland's voivodships (2009-2015)," Economic and Environmental Studies, Opole University, Faculty of Economics, vol. 18, no. 2, pp. 909-924, 2018.
 Z. Song, C. Wang and L. Bergmann, "China’s prefectural digital divide: Spatial analysis and multivariate determinants of ICT diffusion," International Journal of Information Management, vol. 52, 2020.
 P. DiMaggio and E. Hargittai, "From the “digital divide” to digital inequality: Studying Internet use as penetration increases," Working Paper 15. Center for Arts and Cultural Policy Studies, Princeton University., Princeton, NJ, 2001.
 J. A. G. M. van Dijk, "Digital divide research, achievements and shortcomings," Poetics, vol. 34, pp. 221-235, 2006.
 F. Cruz-Jesus, T. Oliveira and F. Bacao, "Digital divide across the European Union," Information & Management, vol. 49, pp. 278-291, 2012.
 M. Akiyoshi, M. Tsuchiya and T. Sano, "Missing in the midst of abundance. The case of broadband adoption in Japan," in The Digital Divide. The internet and social inequality in international perspective, London and New York, Routledge, 2013, pp. 85-104.
 M. Büchi, N. Just and M. Latzer, "Modeling the second-level digital divide: A five-country study of social differences in Internet use," New Media & Society, vol. 18, no. 11, p. 2703–2722, 2016.
 Economist Intelligence Unit, "Executive Summary," 2020. (Online). Available: https://theinclusiveinternet.eiu.com/.
 S. Anand and A. Sen, "Concepts of Human Development and Poverty: A Multidimensional Perspective," in Poverty and Human Development: Human Development Papers 1997, New York, United Nations Development Programme, 1997, pp. 1-20.
 S. Dutta and B. Lanvin, "The Network Readiness Index 2020: Accelerating Digital Transformation in a post-COVID Global Economy," Potrulans Institute, 2020.
 G. Davey Smith, D. Gordon, M. Kelly, S. Nandy and S. Subramanian, "Inequalities in Health in India: the methodological construction of indices and measures.," UK Department for International Development, 2003.
 K. Barzilai-Nahon, "Gaps and Bits: Conceptualizing Measurements for Digital Divide/s," The Information Society, vol. 22, pp. 269-278, 2006.
 A. Sharpe, "Literature Review of Frameworks for Macro-indicators," Centre for the Study of Living Standards, Ottawa, Ontario, 2004.
 M. Kovacevic, "Measurement of Inequality in Human Development – A Review," UNDP Human Development Research Paper 2010/35, 2010.
 P. B. Coulter, Measuring Inequality. A Methodological Handbook, New York: Routledge, 1989.
 M. Saisana and S. Tarantola, "State-of-the-Art Report on Current Methodologies and Practices for Composite Indicator Development," European Commission Institute for the Protection and the Security of the Citizen Technological and Economic Risk Management Unit, Ispra, Italy, 2002.
 J. Salzman, "Methodological Choices Encountered in the Construction of Composite Indices of Economic and Social Well-Being," Center for the Study of Living Standards, 2003.
 Federal Agency on Press and Mass Communications, "Internet v Rossii v 2017 godu (Internet in Russia in 2017)," Federal Agency on Press and Mass Communications, Moscow, Russia, 2018.
 R. P. Yu, N. B. Ellison, R. J. McCammon and K. M. Langa, "Mapping the two levels of digital divide: Internet access and social network site adoption among older adults in the USA," Information, Communication & Society, vol. 19, no. 10, pp. 1145-1464, 2016.
 M. L. Ruiu and M. Ragnedda, "Digital capital and online activities: An empirical analysis of the second level of digital divide," First Monday, vol. 25, no. 7, 2020.
 B. Yu, A. Ndumu and Z. Fan, "E-inclusion or digital divide: an integrated model of digital inequality," Journal of Documentation, vol. 74, pp. 552-574, 2018.
 M. Hilbert, "The end justifies the definition: the manifold outlooks on the digital divide and their practical usefulness for policy making," Telecommunications Policy, vol. 35, no. 8, pp. 715-736, 2011.
 D. M. Grigorovici, J. R. Schement, and R. Taylor, "Weighing the Intangible: Towards a Theory-Based Framework for Information Society Indices," in Global Economy and Digital Society, Elsivier, 2004.
 I. Permanyer, "Uncertainty and robustness in composite indices rankings," Oxford Economic Papers, vol. 64, pp. 57-79, 2012.
 J. E. Foster, M. McGillivray and S. Seth, "Rank Robustness of Composite Indices: Dominance and Ambiguity," Oxford Poverty & Human Development Initiative. OPHI Working Paper no. 26b, 2012.
 S. Seth and M. McGillivray, "Composite indices, alternative weights, and comparison robustness," Social Choice Welfare, vol. 51, pp. 657-679, 2018.
 J. James, "The ICT Development Index and the digital divide: How are they related?," Technological Forecasting & Social Change, vol. 79, pp. 587-594, 2012.
 T. J. Gerpott and N. Ahmadi, "Composite indices for the evaluation of a country's information technology development level: Extensions of the IDI of the ITU," Technological Forecasting & Social Change, vol. 98, pp. 174-185, 2015.
 M. Dobrota, M. Martic, M. Bulajic and V. Jeremic, "Two-phased composite I-distance indicator approach for evaluation of countries’ information development," Telecommunications Policy, vol. 39, pp. 406-420, 2015.
 P. Townsend, Poverty in the United Kingdom: A Survey of Household Resources and Standards of Living, Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1979.
 B. Hallerod, "A New Approach to the Direct Consensual Measurement of Poverty," Social Policy Research Center, Discussion paper No. 50, 1994.
 B. Halleröd, D. Larsson, D. Gordon and V.-M. Ritakallio, "Relative deprivation: a comparative analysis of Britain, Finland and Sweden," Journal of European Social Policy, vol. 16, no. 4, pp. 328-345, 2006.
 A. Gladkova and M. Ragnedda, "Online Information Review Exploring Digital Inequalities in Russia: an interregional comparative analysis," Online Information Review, vol. 44, no. 4, pp. 767-786, 2020.
 F. Hayek, "Scientism and the Study of Society. Part I.," Economica, vol. 9, no. 35, pp. 267-291, 1942.
 F. Collin, Social Reality, London & New York: Routledge, 1997.
 V. Korovkin, "Natsionalniye programmy tsifrovizatsii stran Blizhnego Vostoka (National programs of digitalization of the countries of the Middle East)," Ars Administrandi, vol. 1, 2019.
 H. Ono, "Digital Inequality in East Asia: Evidence from Japan, South Korea, and Singapore," Asian Economic Papers, 2005.
 Brazilian Internet Steering Committee, "Survey on the Use of Information and Communication Technologies in Brazil 2005," 2005. (Online). Available: https://www.cetic.br/media/docs/publicacoes/10/pal2006sant.pdf.
 M. Ragnedda and G. W. Muschert, The Digital Divide. The internet and social inequality in international perspective, Londong and New York: Routledge, 2013.
 V. Kalmus, K. Talves and P. Pruulmann-Vengerfeldt, "Behind the slogan of “e-State”: Digital stratification in Estonia," in The Digital Divide. The internet and social inequality in international perspective, London and New York, Routledge, 2013, pp. 191-203.
 A. Emrouznejad, E. Cabanda and R. Gholami, "An alternative measure of the ICT-Opportunity Index," Information & Management, vol. 47, no. 4, pp. 246-254, 2010.
 G. Bruno, E. Esposito, A. Genovese and K. L. Gwebu, "A Critical Analysis of Current Indexes for Digital Divide Measurement," The Information Society, vol. 27, pp. 16-28, 2011.
 J. Witte, M. Kiss and R. Lynn, "The Internet and social inequalities in the U.S.," in The Digital Divide. The internet and social inequality in international perspective, London and New York, Routledge, 2013, pp. 67-84.
 A. Singleton, A. Alexiou and R. Sava, "Mapping the geodemographics of digital inequality in Great Britain: An integration of machine learning into small area estimation," Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, vol. 82, 2020.
 D. M. Grigorovici, C. Constantin, K. Jayakar, R. D. Taylor and J. R. Schement, "InfoMetrics: a Structural Equation Modeling approach to information indicators and “e-readiness” measurement," in 15th Biennial Conference of the International Telecommunication Society, Berlin, Germany, 2004.
 R. A. Hill, I. Owens, P. Beynon-Davies and M. D. Williams, "Beyond Access: Bridging the Digital Divide," in Proceedings of the 13th European Conference on Information Systems, The European IS Profession in the Global Networking Environment, ECIS 2004, Turku, Finland, 2004.
 World Summit on Information Society, "Final Conclusions," in WSIS Thematic Meeting on "Measuring the Information Society", Geneva, 2005.
 P. Hanafizadeh, M. R. Hanafizadeh and M. Khodabakhshi, "Taxonomy of e-readiness assessment measures," International Journal of Information Management, vol. 29, pp. 189-195, 2009.
 ESCAP, "Measuring the Digital Divide in the Asia-Pacific Region for the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP," United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific, Bangkok, Thailand, 2019.
 D. Archibugi and A. Coco, "A New Indicator of Technological Capabilities for Developed and Developing Countries (ArCo)," CEIS Tor Vergata - Research Paper Series, Vol. 15, No. 44, 2004.
 M. R. Hanafizadeh, A. Saghaei and P. Hanafizadeh, "An index for cross-country analysis of ICT infrastructure and access," Telecommunications Policy, vol. 33, pp. 385-405, 2009.
 M. Petrović, N. Bojković, I. Anić and D. Petrović, "Benchmarking the digital divide using a multi-level outranking framework: Evidence from EBRD countries of operation," Government Information Quarterly, vol. 29, pp. 597-607, 2012.
 Regnum. “Nazvany naibolee vosgrebovannuye u zhitelei RF Internet-servisy” (“The Internet services which are most demanded by Russians were named”), Regnum, 20/09/2019, https://regnum.ru/news/society/2725288.html
 Ruward. “Rating top-100 Internet-magazinov Rossii” (“Raiting of top-100 online stores in Russia”), 2015, https://ruward.ru/ecommerce-index-2015/
 Medialogia. “Reitingi regionalnykh SMI” (“Ratings of regional media”), 2020, https://www.mlg.ru/ratings/media/regional/