Holistic Approach to Assess the Potential of Using Traditional and Advance Insulation Materials for Energy Retrofit of Office Buildings

Authors: Marco Picco, Mahmood Alam

Abstract:

Improving the energy performance of existing buildings can be challenging, particularly when facades cannot be modified, and the only available option is internal insulation. In such cases, the choice of the most suitable material becomes increasingly complex, as in addition to thermal transmittance and capital cost, the designer needs to account for the impact of the intervention on the internal spaces, and in particular the loss of usable space due to the additional layers of materials installed. This paper explores this issue by analyzing a case study of an average office building needing to go through a refurbishment in order to reach the limits imposed by current regulations to achieve energy efficiency in buildings. The building is simulated through dynamic performance simulation under three different climate conditions in order to evaluate its energy needs. The use of Vacuum Insulated Panels as an option for energy refurbishment is compared to traditional insulation materials (XPS, Mineral Wool). For each scenario, energy consumptions are calculated and, in combination with their expected capital costs, used to perform a financial feasibility analysis. A holistic approach is proposed, taking into account the impact of the intervention on internal space by quantifying the value of the lost usable space and used in the financial feasibility analysis. The proposed approach highlights how taking into account different drivers will lead to the choice of different insulation materials, showing how accounting for the economic value of space can make VIPs an attractive solution for energy retrofitting under various climate conditions.

Keywords: Vacuum insulated panels, building performance simulation, payback period, building energy retrofit.

References:

[1] Brunner, S., Simmler, H.: In situ performance assessment of vacuum insulation panels in a flat roof construction. Vacuum, 82, 700-707. (2008).
[2] Alotaibi, S. S., Riffat, S.: Vacuum insulated panels for sustainable buildings: a review of research and applications. International Journal of Energy Research, 38, 1-19. (2014).
[3] Alam, M., Singh, H., Limbachiya, M. C.: Vacuum Insulation Panels (VIPs) for building construction industry – a review of the contemporary developments and future directions. Applied Energy, 88,3592-3602. (2011).
[4] Brunner, S., Wakili, K. G., Stahl, T., Binder B.: Vacuum insulation panels for building applications – continuous challenges and developments. Energy and Buildings, 85, 592-596. (2014)
[5] Mujeebu, M. A., Ashraf, N., Alsuwayigh, A.: Energy performance and economic viability of nano aerogel glazing and nano vacuum insulation panel in multi-story office building. Energy, 113, 949-956 (2016).
[6] Alam, M., Singh, H., Suresh, S., Redpath, D.A.G.: Energy and economic analysis of Vacuum Insulation Panels (VIPs) used in non-domestic buildings. Applied Energy, 188, 1-8. (2017)
[7] Lim, T., Seok, J., Kim, D. D.: A Comparative Study of Energy Performance of Fumed Silica Vacuum Insulation Panels in an Apartment Building. Energies 10(12):2000. DOI: 10.3390/en10122000. (2017).
[8] Fantucci, S., Garbaccio S., Alice Lorenzati, A.: Thermo-economic analysis of building energy retrofits using VIP - Vacuum Insulation Panels. Energy and Building, 196, 269-279. (2019)
[9] Biswas, K., Patel, T., Shrestha, S., Smith, D., Desjarlais, A. Whole building retrofit using vacuum insulation panels and energy performance analysis. Energy and Building, 203, 109430, (2019).
[10] Picco, M., Marengo, M.: A fast response performance simulation screening tool in support of early stage building design. Building Simulation 2019, September 2nd-4th, 2019, Rome, Italy (2019).
[11] The Building Regulations 1985 no. 1065, https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1985/1065/pdfs/uksi_19851065_en.pdf, last accessed 2020/12/07
[12] Approved Document L2B: Conservation of fuel and power in existing buildings other than dwellings, 2010 edition (incorporating 2010, 2011, 2013 and 2016 amendments), https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/540329/BR_PDF_AD_L2B_2013_with_2016_amendments.pdf, last accessed 2020/12/07
[13] The London Office Market Report Q2 2019. https://www.knightfrank.com/research/report-library/the-london-office-market-report-q2-2019-6580.aspx, last accessed 2020/11/17
[14] Spotlight Madrid Offices Q3 2019. https://pdf.euro.savills.co.uk/spain/nat-eng-2019/savills-an-madrid-offices-spotlight-q3-2019-eng.pdf, last accessed 2020/11/17
[15] Toronto 2019 Q1 Office Market Report. https://pdf.euro.savills.co.uk/usa/market-reports/research-mim-toronto-q1-2019.pdf last accessed 2020/11/17