The Ballistics Case Study of the Enrica Lexie Incident

Authors: Diego Abbo

Abstract:

On February 15, 2012 off the Indian coast of Kerala, in position 091702N-0760180E by the oil tanker Enrica Lexie, flying the Italian flag, bursts of 5.56 x45 caliber shots were fired from assault rifles AR/70 Italian-made Beretta towards the Indian fisher boat St. Anthony. The shots that hit the St. Anthony fishing boat were six, of which two killed the Indian fishermen Ajesh Pink and Valentine Jelestine. From the analysis concerning the kinematic engagement of the two ships and from the autopsy and ballistic results of the Indian judicial authorities it is possible to reconstruct the trajectories of the six aforementioned shots. This essay reconstructs the trajectories of the six shots that cannot be of direct shooting but have undergone a rebound on the water. The investigation carried out scientifically demonstrates the rebound of the blows on the water, the gyrostatic deviation due to the rebound and the tumbling effect always due to the rebound as regards intermediate ballistics. In consideration of the four shots that directly impacted the fishing vessel, the current examination proves, with scientific value, that the trajectories could not be downwards but upwards. Also, the trajectory of two shots that hit to death the two fishermen could not be downwards but only upwards. In fact, this paper demonstrates, with scientific value: The loss of speed of the projectiles due to the rebound on the water; The tumbling effect in the ballistic medium within the two victims; The permanent cavities subject to the injury ballistics and the related ballistic trauma that prevented homeostasis causing bleeding in one case; The thermo-hardening deformation of the bullet found in Valentine Jelestine's skull; The upward and non-downward trajectories. The paper constitutes a tool in forensic ballistics in that it manages to reconstruct, from the final spot of the projectiles fired, all phases of ballistics like the internal one of the weapons that fired, the intermediate one, the terminal one and the penetrative structural one. In general terms the ballistics reconstruction is based on measurable parameters whose entity is contained with certainty within a lower and upper limit. Therefore, quantities that refer to angles, speed, impact energy and firing position of the shooter can be identified within the aforementioned limits. Finally, the investigation into the internal bullet track, obtained from any autopsy examination, offers a significant “lesson learned” but overall a starting point to contain or mitigate bleeding as a rescue from future gunshot wounds.

Keywords: Impact physics, intermediate ballistics, terminal ballistics, tumbling effect.

References:

[1] ITLOS- International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea “The Enrica Lexie Incident” (Italy vs India) “Provisional Measures Hamburg – Germany- June 2015 URL: https://www.itlos.org/en/main/cases/list-of-cases/case-no-24/
[2] Dizionario Treccani, su treccani.it.
[3] UNCLOS – United Nations Conventions on the Law of the Sea – Article 97, Montego Bay Jamaica, 10th December 1982
[4] UNCLOS – United Nations Conventions on the Law of the Sea – Article 94, Montego Bay Jamaica, 10th December 1982
[5] ANNEX 14 to Annex A-26 June 2015, ITLOS- International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea –Dispute concerning the Enrica Lexie Incident The Italian Republic v. the Republic of India
[6] BILOSLAVO Fausto on the Italian Newspaper IL GIORNALE on 21st February 2012 Published by the Judicial Expert Luigi DI STEFANO URL: httP://WWW.SEeninside.net/piracy/it-fatt-rapp-l.htm
[7] ABBO Diego, “Marò the exhaustive analysis of the incident” YouTube film – minute 2.47 URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QguiHoMXLSo&list=UUWZjHlCMHRJCBtTO4DyJnWA
[8] Integration of the act n. 051695 (filed with the Public Prosecutor of the Court of Rome on March 13, 2013 by the Judicial Expert Luigi DI STEFANO
[9] Annex 48 scene of crime -26 JUNE 2015 ITLOS- International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea –
[10] Beretta ARX-160 su www.esercito.difesa.it Archiviato il 22 luglio 2010 in Internet Archive.
[11] 223 REMINGTON - 55 GRAIN ~ TRAJECTORY CHART - URL:https://www.sierrabullets.com/223-remington-55-grain-trajectory-chart/
[12] ANNEX 8 Scene Examination Report NO. Bl-873/FSU2012, 19 APRIL 2012
[13] Bettin Cristian; “I proiettili Tecnologia e Balistica” tipografia Imprimenda Padova , Italy Edition June 2015
[14] Cranz, K. J. Lehrbuch “der Ballistik, vol.” Ristampa anastatica 1910
[15] Kneubuehl B.P. “Das abprallen von Geschossen aus forensischer” Sicht I.D. Universität Lausanne, Ecole des Sciences Criminelles 1999
[16] Baillargeon Y., Eng M., Bergeron G. “Prediction of projectile ricochet behavior after water impact” J Forensic Sci, vol. 57, no.6, p.1556-1561 2012
[17] Haag L.C. “Bullet ricochet from water” AFTE J., Vol. 11, No. 3, pp. 26–34
[18] Soliman A.S., Reid S.R., Johnson W. “The effect of spherical projectile speed in ricochet off water and sand” Int. J.of mech. Sciences, 18, 279-284 Site consulted on 04/10/2015, NO LOnger available today URL: hTTp://WWW.Nj.gov/oAG/Dcj/njpdRESOURces/pdfs/wallboard_test.pdf -
[19] Enciclopedia delle armi - TRECCANI - http://www.earmi.it/balistica/lungo.htm
[20] The Small Arms Review vol.10, no.2 November 2006
[21] Site consulted on 04/10/2015, URL:http://www.nj.gov/oag/dcj/njpdresources/pdfs/wallboard_test.pdf -
[22] Bettin Cristian “Le Ferite da arma DA fuoco - Manuale di balistica lesionale”, Padua Italy Edition 2018
[23] The Piroli Report -. Published by the Judicial Expert Luigi Di Stefano URL: HTTP://WWW.SEENINside.nET/Piracy/iT-PIRO1.htm
[24] Sellier K (1982) “Schusswaffen und Schusswirkungen I, Second Edition, Schmidt –Römhild, Lübeck.
[25] Beyer JC (1962), “Wound ballistics”. Off. of the Surg General , Dep. Army, Washington DC.
[26] Harger JH, Huelke DF (1970) “Femoral Fractures produced by Projectiles; the effects of mass and diameter on target damage”. J Biomech 3: 487-493.
[27] Journee C (1907) Rapport entre la force vive des balle set la gravitè des blessure,qu’elles peuvent causer. Revue d’artillerie 70: 81-120
[28] Kneubuehl BP, Coupland RM, Rotschild MA, Thali MJ (2008) – “Wundballistik – Grundlagen und Anwendungen”, Springer Heidelberg
[29] Woodruff CE (1896), The causes of the explosive effect on modern small-caliber bullets, NY Med J 67: 593-601.
[30] Annex 4 Post-Mortem Report of MR Ajeesh and MR Valentine. 16 February 2012
[31] QUORA What is the dimension of a 14.2 kg LPG cylinder in India? https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-dimension-of-a-14-2-kg-LPG-cylinder-in-India