Re-interpreting Ruskin with Respect to the Wall

Authors: Anjali Sadanand, R. V. Nagarajan

Abstract:

Architecture morphs with advances in technology and the roof, wall, and floor as basic elements of a building, follow in redefining themselves over time. Their contribution is bound by time and held by design principles that deal with function, sturdiness, and beauty. Architecture engages with people to give joy through its form, material, design structure, and spatial qualities. This paper attempts to re-interpret John Ruskin’s “Seven lamps of Architecture” in the context of the architecture of the modern and present period. The paper focuses on the “wall” as an element of study in this context. Four of Ruskin’s seven lamps will be discussed, namely beauty, truth, life, and memory, through examples of architecture ranging from modernism to contemporary architecture of today. The study will focus on the relevance of Ruskin’s principles to the “wall” in specific, in buildings of different materials and over a range of typologies from all parts of the world. Two examples will be analyzed for each lamp. It will be shown that in each case, there is relevance to the significance of Ruskin’s lamps in modern and contemporary architecture. Nature to which Ruskin alludes to for his lamp of “beauty” is found in the different expressions of interpretation used by Corbusier in his Villa Stein façade based on proportion found in nature and in the direct expression of Toyo Ito in his translation of an understanding of the structure of trees into his façade design of the showroom for a Japanese bag boutique. “Truth” is shown in Mies van der Rohe’s Crown Hall building with its clarity of material and structure and Studio Mumbai’s Palmyra House, which celebrates the use of natural materials and local craftsmanship. “Life” is reviewed with a sustainable house in Kerala by Ashrams Ravi and Alvar Aalto’s summer house, which illustrate walls as repositories of intellectual thought and craft. “Memory” is discussed with Charles Correa’s Jawahar Kala Kendra and Venturi’s Vana Venturi house and discloses facades as text in the context of its materiality and iconography. Beauty is reviewed in Villa Stein and Toyo Ito’s Branded Retail building in Tokyo. The paper thus concludes that Ruskin’s Lamps can be interpreted in today’s context and add richness to meaning to the understanding of architecture.

Keywords: Beauty, design, façade, modernism.

References:

[1] Craven, Jackie. (2020, August 27). 5 Themes in the Works of John Ruskin. Retrieved from https://www.thoughtco.com/themes-in-works-of-john-ruskin-177883 (Accessed 12 Feb 2021).
[2] "John Ruskin Influencer Overview and Analysis". (Internet). 2021. TheArtStory.org, Content compiled and written by Sarah Ingram Edited and revised, with Summary and Accomplishments added by Kate Stephenson, Available from: https://www.theartstory.org/influencer/ruskin-john/ First published on 20 Jan 2020. Updated and modified regularly (Accessed 12 Feb 2021).
[3] John Ruskin, The seven lamps of architecture April 18, 2011 (EBook #35898), https://www.gutenberg.org/files/35898/35898-h/35898-h.htm (Accessed 12 feb2021).
[4] Clarke, Roger, Christopher, Modernity, New York, Routledge, 1988, pp.559-60.
[5] Kite, Stephen “Building Texts + Reading Fabrics: Metaphor, Memory, and Material in John Ruskin’s Stones of Venice, https://www.ideals.illinois.edu/bitstream/handle/2142/89741/61.2.kite.pdf?sequence=2 (Accessed 12thFeb2021).
[6] Ruskin,John,1851,The stones of Venice,Volume1,-retreived from readcentral.com, https://www.readcentral.com/chapters/John-Ruskin/The-Stones-of-Venice-Volume-I-of-3/006
[accessed12Feb2021]
[7] Chatterjee, P, retrieved from https://www.academia.edu/732436/New_Ways_of_Looking_John_Ruskins_Visual_and_Textual_Strategies_for_Writing_a_History_of_Architecture.) Accessed 12th Feb2021
[8] Chatterjee, Anuradha, Assembled, John Ruskin’s architectural ideal, https://www.sahanz.net/wp-content/uploads/chatterjee-a-assembled.pdf, Accessed 12Feb2021.
[9] Chapter 2 Lamp of truth, 14 July 2010, http://www.victorianweb.org/authors/ruskin/7lamps/2.html Accessed 12Feb2021.
[10] Curtis, William J.R. Modern architecture since 1900, London, Phaidon Press, 1987, p.403.
[11] Palmyra House, Studio Mumbai, https://www.archdaily.com/62136/palmyra-house-studio-mumbai, Accessed 12Feb2021.
[12] https://archnet.org/sites/6454/publications/2015 Accessed12thFeb2021.
[13] Stier, HagenAD Classics: IIT Master Plan and Buildings / Mies van der Rohe, archdaily.com https://www.archdaily.com/59816/ad-classics-iit-master-plan-and-buildings-mies-van-der-rohe Accessed 12feb2021.
[14] https://www.contemporist.com/palmyra-house-by-studio-mumbai-architects, 27 May 2010, Accessed 12feb 2021.
[15] Chapter 6 Lamp of memory, 14 july 2010, http://www.victorianweb.org/authors/ruskin/7lamps/2.html Accessed 12Feb2021.
[16] A Glass and glitzy ‘modern’ Jawahar Kala kendra artists, visitors voice protest, http://architectureupdate.in/a-glass-artists-visitors-voice-protest/#.YCa7eWgzZPY/ accessed 12 feb2021.
[17] Davie, Colin, Houses of the twentieth century: plans, sections and elevations, 2006, Laurence King, UK. pg142.
[18] Goldblatt, Steven, 16 July 2015, Journal of the American Institute for Architects, Vanna venturi house listed for $1.75million https://www.architectmagazine.com/design/buildings/vanna-venturi-house-listed-for-175-million_o accessed 12feb2021.
[19] Chapter 4 Lamp of beauty, 14 July 2010, http://www.victorianweb.org/authors/ruskin/7lamps/2.html Accessed 12Feb2021.
[20] Extrait de Le Corbusier, Oeuvre complète, volume 1, 1910-1929 http://www.fondationlecorbusier.fr/corbuweb/morpheus.aspx?sysId=13&IrisObjectId=5525&sysLanguage Accessed 12Feb2021.
[21] Le Corbusiers Villa Stein, https://www.moma.org/momaorg/shared/pdfs/docs/press_archives/4559/releases/MOMA_1970_July-December_0079.pdf Accessed 12Feb2021.
[22] Dimao, Judy, Case study Villa Stein de Monzie https://www.judydimaio.com/villa-steinde-monzie/ Accessed 12Feb2021.
[23] Fig. 20. Drawing 1086 of the villa at Garches (1927), Le Corbusier. Figures for Roger Herz-Fischler's Proportions in the Architecture Curriculum retrieved from Nexus Network Journal, https://www.emis.de/journals/NNJ/RHF-fig20.html Accessed12Feb2021.
[24] Hildner, Claudia, Interview: Toyo Ito, retrieved from Architectural review, https://www.architectural-review.com/essays/interview-toyo-ito/ Accessed 12Feb2021.
[25] http://www.chambres-hotes-morin-salome.fr/IMAG-INT/archi/Dedans-Dehors-conf/Ito-2004-Tokyo-Tod's/Index of /IMAG-INT/archi/Dedans-Dehors-conf/Ito-2004-Tokyo-Tod's Accessed 12 Feb2021.
[26] Chapter 5 Lamp of life, 14 July 2010, http://www.victorianweb.org/authors/ruskin/7lamps/2.html Accessed 12Feb2021.
[27] Gogoi, Angelika, 27 April 2020, Bamboo and 90% recycled waste, Kerala architect builds home in 4 months, Accessed 12Feb2021.
[28] bKreative, 2017, https://brickarchitecture.com/about-brick/brick-news/muuratsalo-experimental-house-by-alvar-aalto-