Illicit Return Practices of Irregular Migrants from Greece to Turkey

Authors: Enkelejda Koka, Denard Veshi

Abstract:

Since 2011, in the name of ‘humanitarianism’ and deaths in the Mediterranean Sea, the legal and political justification delivered by Greece to manage the refugee crisis is pre-emptive interception. Although part of the EU, Greece adopted its own strategy. These practices have also created high risks for migrants generally resulting in non-rescue episodes and push-back practices having lethal consequences to the life of the irregular migrant. Thus, this article provides an analysis of the Greek ‘compassionate border work’ policy, a practice known as push-back. It is argued that these push-back practices violate international obligations, notably the ‘right to life’, the ‘duty to search and rescue’, the prohibition of inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment and the principle of non-refoulement.

Keywords: Greece, migrants, push-back policy, violation of international law.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3669146

References:

[1] European Commission, The Global Approach to Migration and Mobility, COM (2011) 743 final, 6.
[2] Andersson, Ruben. Europe's failed ‘fight’ against irregular migration: ethnographic notes on a counterproductive industry. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 2016, 42.7: 1055-1075.
[3] Ackland. (2015). If Europe Listens to Tony Abbott, the Future for Refugees Will Be Cruel’ (The Guardian, 21 April 2015) https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/apr/21/if-europe-listens-to-tony-abbott-the-future-for-refugees-will-be-cruel accessed on 30 September 2019.
[4] European Council, 2018, Eastern Mediterranean Route, https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/migratory-pressures/eastern-mediterranean-route/# accessed on 30 September 2019.
[5] IOM 2018. Mediterranean Migrant Arrivals Reach 86,436 in 2018; Deaths Reach 1,783 https://www.iom.int/news/mediterranean-migrant-arrivals-reach-86436-2018-deaths-reach-1783 accessed on 30 September 2019.
[6] UNHCR, 2018 “Refugees/Migrants Emergency Response-Mediterranean, Deaths 3,151” accessed on 30 September 2019
[7] Eurostat, Asylum quarterly report, https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/Asylum_quarterly_report#Main_trends_in_the_number_of_asylum_applicants accessed on 30 September 2019
[8] Heller, Charles; Jones, Chris. Eurosur: Saving lives or reinforcing deadly borders. Statewatch Journal, 2014, 23.3/4: 9-11.
[9] BBC, ‘Migrant Crisis: Boat Sinking off Didim, Turkey Claims 25 lives’ (6 March 2016) http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-35739555 accessed on 30 September 2019.
[10] HRW, 2015. ‘Greece: Attacks on Boats Risk Migrant Lives, Masked Assailants Attack, Disable Boats, Abuse Passengers’ 22 October 2015 https://www.hrw.org/news/2015/10/22/greece-attacks-boats-risk-migrant-lives accessed on 30 September 2019.
[11] MEE 2018, Syrian migrants allege illegal Greek pushback to Turkey, https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/syrian-migrants-allege-illegal-greek-pushback-turkey-1480060668 accessed on 30 September 2019.
[12] Amnesty International, “The Human Cost of Fortress Europe, Human Rights Violations against Migrants and Refugees at Europe’s Borders” (July 2014) 20 https://www.amnesty.ch/de/themen/asyl-und-migration/festung-europa/dok/2015/die-kampagne-sos-europa/bericht-the-human-cost-of-fortress-Europe accessed on 30 September 2019, 20;
[13] Koka, Enkelejda; Veshi, Denard. Irregular Migration by Sea: Interception and Rescue Interventions in Light of International Law and the EU Sea Borders Regulation. European Journal of Migration and Law, 2019, 21.1: 26-52.
[14] Van Liempt, Ilse; Sersli, Stephanie. State responses and migrant experiences with human smuggling: A reality check. Antipode, 2013, 45.4: 1029-1046.
[15] Bigo, Didier. The (in) securitization practices of the three universes of EU border control: Military/Navy–border guards/police–database analysts. Security Dialogue, 2014, 45.3: 209-225.
[16] Watch the Med Alarm Phone, “Illegal Push-Back Operation with Frontex Present” (15 June 2016) https://alarmphone.org/en/2016/06/15/watchthemed-alarm-phone-denounces-illegal-push-back-operation-with-frontex-present/ accessed on 30 September 2019.
[17] ASYL, Pro. Pushed back. Systematic Human Rights Violations against Refugees in the Aegean Sea and at the Greek-Turkish Land Border, 2013.
[18] Pallister‐Wilkins, Polly. The humanitarian politics of European border policing: Frontex and border police in Evros. International Political Sociology, 2015, 9.1: 53-69.
[19] Little, Adrian; Vaughan-Williams, Nick. Stopping boats, saving lives, securing subjects: Humanitarian borders in Europe and Australia. European Journal of International Relations, 2017, 23.3: 533-556.
[20] Ferrer-Gallardo, Xavier; Van Houtum, H. J. The deadly EU border control. 2014.
[21] Administrative Court of Munich, 17 July 2019, M 11 S 19.50722, M 11 S 19.50759
[22] Dutch Council of State, 17 July 2019, 201902302/1/V3
[23] Regulation (EU) No 604/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 June 2013 establishing the criteria and mechanisms for determining the Member State responsible for examining an application for international protection lodged in one of the Member States by a third-country national or a stateless person
[24] Euronews, 2019, 'Masked men beat us with batons': Greece accused of violent asylum seeker pushbacks, https://www.euronews.com/2019/05/11/masked-men-beat-us-with-batons-greece-accused-of-violent-asylum-seeker-pushbacks
[25] ECtHR, Sharifi v Italy and Greece Application no 16643/09.
[26] UNHCR, ‘UNHCR Urges Continued International Protection for Asylum-seekers from Somalia’ (Dan Maclsaac, 28 January 2014) http://www.unhcr.org/news/latest/2014/1/52e7adda9/unhcr-urges-continued-international-protection-asylum-seekers-somalia.html accessed on 30 September 2019.
[27] AIDA, Access to the Territory and Push Backs, 2017, https://www.asylumineurope.org/reports/country/greece/asylum-procedure/access-procedure-and-registration/access-territory-and-push accessed on 30 September 2019.
[28] UNHCR 2017, UNHCR deeply concerned at reports of informal forced returns from Greece to Turkey, https://www.unhcr.org/gr/en/6244-unhcr-deeply-concerned-reports-informal-forced-returns-greece-turkey.html accessed on 30 September 2019.
[29] Greek Council for Refugees, 2018 https://www.asylumineurope.org/reports/country/greece/asylum-procedure/access-procedure-and-registration/access-territory-and-push accessed on 30 September 2019.
[30] Ombudsman Decision No. 105, 9 June 2017, https://www.synigoros.gr/resources/20170609-apof-ayt-ereyn-epanaprooth--2.pdf accessed on 30 September 2019.
[31] Commissioner for Human Rights, 2017 https://twitter.com/CommissionerHR/status/872380520495280129
[32] Stockholm Center for Freedom, Greece has Adopted Illegal Border Push-Back for Erdogan Critics, 4 June 2017, https://stockholmcf.org/greece-has-adopted-illegal-border-push-back-for-erdogan-critics/ accessed on 30 September 2019.
[33] The Alarmphone, Statement: Four Push-Back Operations at the Greek-Turkish Land Border Witnessed by the Alarm Phone, 6 July 2018, https://alarmphone.org/en/2018/07/06/four-push-back-operations-at-the-greek-turkish-land-border-witnessed-by-the-alarm-phone/ accessed on 30 September 2019.
[34] Greek Council for Refugees, 2017, Reports of systematic pushbacks in the Evros region https://www.gcr.gr/en/ekdoseis-media/reports/reports/item/790-reports-of-systematic-pushbacks-in-the-evros-region accessed on 30 September 2019.
[35] Amnesty International, ‘Greece: Farmakonisi Migrant Tragedy – One Year on and Still no Justice for Victims’ 20 January 2015 https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2015/01/greece-farmakonisi-migrant-tragedy-one-year-and-still-no-justice-victims/ accessed on 30 September 2019
[36] ECRE, ‘12 Refugees Die during Alleged Push-back Operation off Greek Island’ (24 January 2014) http://www.ecre.org/component/content/article/70-weekly-bulletin-articles/574-12-refugees-die-during-alleged-push-back-operation-off-greek-island.html accessed on 30 September 2019.
[37] The Guardian, ‘Greek Minister: Migrant Survivors of Boat Accident Have Changed Stories’ (24 January 2014) http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jan/24/migrant-survivors-boat-sinking-changed-stories-marine-minister accessed on 30 September 2019.
[38] ENETENGLISH, “European Rights Watchdog ‘Shocked and Distressed’ at Migrant Drowning’s: Nils Muižnieks says Government Must Stick to Promises to Stop Push-backs” (22 January 2014) http://www.enetenglish.gr/?i=news.en.article&id=1722 accessed on 30 September 2019.
[39] Ministry of Shipping and the Aegean changed to Ministry of Shipping and Island Policy from 23 September 2015 https://www.yen.gr/ accessed on 30 September 2019.
[40] Penna K, ‘Farmakonisi Migrant Tragedy Sparks EU policy Debate’ (Equal Times, 19 March 2014) http://www.equaltimes.org/farmakonisi-migrant-tragedy-sparks-eu-policy-debate?lang=en#.VdXCtfmqpHw accessed on 30 September 2019.
[41] Watch the Med, “They Want to See Us Drown” (Alarm Phone Investigation 25/26 October 2014) http://watchthemed.net/reports/view/84 accessed on 30 September 2019.
[42] Euronews, 2015, “Turkish Fisherman Claims Greek Officials Intentionally Sank Migrant Boat” https://www.euronews.com/2015/08/14/turkish-fisherman-claims-greek-officials-intentionally-sank-migrant-boat accessed on 30 September 2019.
[43] Daily Sabah, Fourth Migrant Found Dead near Border, Greek ‘Pushback’ Suspected, 7 December 2018, https://www.dailysabah.com/investigations/2018/12/07/fourth-migrant-found-dead-near-border-greek-pushback-suspected accessed on 30 September 2019.
[44] ECtHR, McCann and Others v. the United Kingdom (Application No. 18984/91)
[45] UN Human Rights Committee, 2004, General Comment No 31 The Nature of the General Legal Obligation Imposed on States Parties to the Covenant 26 May 2004, CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.13
[46] UN General Assembly, 2000, Protocol against the Smuggling of Migrants by Land, Sea and Air, supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime
[47] Regulation (EU) No 656/2014 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 15 May 2014 establishing rules for the surveillance of the external sea borders in the context of operational cooperation coordinated by the European Agency for the Management of Operational Cooperation at the External Borders of the Member States of the European Union
[48] ECtHR, Nachova and Others v Bulgaria Application nos 43577/98 and 43579/98
[49] Basaran, Tugba. The saved and the drowned: Governing indifference in the name of security. Security Dialogue, 2015, 46.3: 205-220.
[50] Dijk, Pieter Van; Godefridus, JH Van Hoof; Heringa, A. W. Theory and Practice of the European Convention of Human Rights,(4. bs.). UK: Intersentia, 2006.
[51] Sari, Aurel. Untangling extra-territorial jurisdiction from international responsibility in Jaloud v. Netherlands: old problem, new solutions. Mil. L. & L. War Rev., 2014, 53: 287.
[52] Ahlborn, Christiane. To share or not to share? The allocation of responsibility between international organizations and their member states. Die Friedens-Warte, 2013, 45-75.
[53] ICJ, the Corfu case, judgement of 9 April 1949.
[54] Mungianu, Roberta. Frontex and non-refoulement: The international responsibility of the EU. Cambridge University Press, 2016.
[55] UNHCR 2017, UNHCR deeply concerned at reports of informal forced returns from Greece to Turkey, https://www.unhcr.org/gr/en/6244-unhcr-deeply-concerned-reports-informal-forced-returns-greece-turkey.html accessed on 30 September 2019.
[56] ECtHR, applications nos. 8675/15 and 8697/15
[57] Comité de los Derechos del Niño, ‘Dictamen aprobado por el Comité en relación con el Protocolo Facultativo de la Convención sobre los Derechos del Niño relativo a un procedimiento de comunicaciones respecto de la Comunicación Núm. 4/2016, February 2019
[58] ECtHR, Application no 55798/16 A.A. and Others against the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia and 4 other applications
[59] FIDH, Migreurop, EMHRN, “Frontex between Greece and Turkey: at the Border of Denial” 17 July 2014, 29
[60] ECtHR, Dikme v Turkey, Application no 20869, paragraph 93.
[61] CAT, H.K. v Switzerland (2013) Communication no 432/2010, paragraph 7.4.
[62] Mariño Menéndez, Fernando M. Recent jurisprudence of the United Nations Committee against Torture and the international protection of refugees. Refugee Survey Quarterly, 2015, 34.1: 61-78.
[63] ECtHR, Tekin v Turkey, Application no 22496/93
[64] ECtHR, Selmouni v France, Application no 25803/94
[65] ECtHR, Valašinas v Lithuania, Application no 44558/98
[66] ECtHR, Labita v Italy, Application no 26772/95
[67] ECtHR, Chahal v the United Kingdom, Application no 45276/99
[68] ECtHR, The Greek case, Applications nos. 3321, 3322, 3323, 3344
[69] International Tribunal for the Law of The Sea, M/V Saiga (No 2) (St Vincent and the Grenadines v Guinea)
[70] ECtHR, H.A. and others v. Greece, Application no. 19951/16.
[71] ECtHR, Tyrer v UK, Application no. 5856/72.
[72] ECtHR, Hurtado v Switzerland, Application no 17549/90
[73] ECtHR, Tomasi v France, Application no 12850/87
[74] ECtHR, Pruneanu v Moldova, Application no 6888/03
[75] ECtHR, Assenov v Bulgaria, Application no 24760/94,
[76] ECtHR, Sakir v Greece, Application no 48475/09
[77] Committee against Torture Communication No. 368/2008