The South African Polycentric Water Resource Governance-Management Nexus: Parlaying an Institutional Agent and Structured Social Engagement
South Africa, a water scarce country, experiences the phenomenon that its life supporting natural water resources is seriously threatened by the users that are totally dependent on it. South Africa is globally applauded to have of the best and most progressive water laws and policies. There are however growing concerns regarding natural water resource quality deterioration and a critical void in the management of natural resources and compliance to policies due to increasing institutional uncertainties and failures. These are in accordance with concerns of many South African researchers and practitioners that call for a change in paradigm from talk to practice and a more constructive, practical approach to governance challenges in the management of water resources. A qualitative theory-building case study through longitudinal action research was conducted from 2014 to 2017. The research assessed whether a strategic positioned institutional agent can be parlayed to facilitate and execute WRM on catchment level by engaging multiple stakeholders in a polycentric setting. Through a critical realist approach a distinction was made between ex ante self-deterministic human behaviour in the realist realm, and ex post governance-management in the constructivist realm. A congruence analysis, including Toulmin’s method of argumentation analysis, was utilised. The study evaluated the unique case of a self-steering local water management institution, the Impala Water Users Association (WUA) in the Pongola River catchment in the northern part of the KwaZulu-Natal Province of South Africa. Exploiting prevailing water resource threats, it expanded its ancillary functions from 20,000 to 300,000 ha. Embarking on WRM activities, it addressed natural water system quality assessments, social awareness, knowledge support, and threats, such as: soil erosion, waste and effluent into water systems, coal mining, and water security dimensions; through structured engagement with 21 different catchment stakeholders. By implementing a proposed polycentric governance-management model on a catchment scale, the WUA achieved to fill the void. It developed a foundation and capacity to protect the resilience of the natural environment that is critical for freshwater resources to ensure long-term water security of the Pongola River basin. Further work is recommended on appropriate statutory delegations, mechanisms of sustainable funding, sufficient penetration of knowledge to local levels to catalyse behaviour change, incentivised support from professionals, back-to-back expansion of WUAs to alleviate scale and cost burdens, and the creation of catchment data monitoring and compilation centres.
Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3346714Procedia APA BibTeX Chicago EndNote Harvard JSON MLA RIS XML ISO 690 PDF Downloads 288
 A. K. Biswas, “Integrated Water Resource Management: A reassessment. A Water Forum contribution,” Water International, vol. 29, no. 2, pp. 248-256, 2004.
 M. Falkenmark, “The massive water scarcity now threatening Africa: Why isn’t it being addressed?” Ambio, vol. 18, no. 2, pp. 112-118, 1989.
 M. Falkenmark., “Early focus on water strategies for the twenty-first century: IWRA as an interdisciplinary forerunner,” Water International, vol. 36, no. 7, pp. 776-781, 2011.
 W. B. Snellen and A. Schrevel. “Integrated Water Resources Management for sustainable use of water: 50 years on international experience with the concept of integrated water management,” Background document to the FAO/Netherlands Conference on Water for Food and Ecosystems, Wageningen, October 2004.
 A. V. Norstrőm, A. Dannenberg, G. Mccarney, M. Milkoreit, G. Engstrőm, R. Fischerman, J. Gars, E. Kyriakopoolou, V. Manoussi, K. Meng, M. Metjan, M. Sanctuary, M. Schlüter, M. Schoon, L. Schultz, and M. Sjőstedt, “Three necessary conditions for establishing effective sustainable development goals in the Anthropocene,” Ecology and Society, vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 8, 2014.
 W. Steffen, P. J. Crutzen and J. R. Mcneill. “The anthropocene: Are humans now overwhelming the great forces of nature?” Ambio, vol. 36, no. 8, pp. 614-621, 2007.
 M. R. Jury, “Climate trends in Southern Africa,” S Afr. J Sci., vol. 109, no 1/2), 2013.
 W. Maluleke, and R. J. Mokwena, “The effect of climate change on rural livestock farming: A case study of Giyani Policing Area, Republic of South Africa,” S Af. Jnl. Agric. Ext. vol. 45, no 1, 2014.
 N. Strydom, and J. Struweg, “Malthus revisited: Long-term trends in South African Population Growth and Agricultural Output,” Agrekon, vol. 55, no 1-2, pp. 34-61, 2016.
 L. K. Haywood, A. C. Brent, D. H. Trotter, and R. Wise, “Corporate sustainability: A social-ecological research agenda for South African business,” Journal of Contemporary Management, vol. 7, pp. 326-346, 2010.
 S. Hedden, and J. Cilliers, “Parched prospects: The emerging water crisis in South Africa,” African Features Paper 11. Institute for Security Studies, Pretoria, 2014.
 M. Muller, “The “nexus” as a step back towards a more coherent water resources management paradigm,” Water Alternatives, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 675-694, 2015.
 M. Chiloane, and P. Phakgadi, “Report: Water and Sanitation Department Bankrupt,” Eye Witness News, 27 February 2017. https://ewn.co.za/2017/02/12/report-water-and-sanitation-department-bankrupt (Accessed 2 March 2017).
 City Press, “Nomvula Mokonyane’s Watergate,” City Press, 10 July 2016. https://city-press.news24.com/News/nomvulas-watergate-20160710 (Accessed 2 March 2017).
 E. L. Bohensky, “A social-ecological systems perspective on water management in South Africa,” Unpublished PhD thesis. University of Pretoria, Pretoria, 2006.
 M. Burns, and A. Weaver, “Exploring sustainability signs: A South African perspective,” Stellenbosch, African Sun Media, 2008.
 C. Pahl-Wostl, P. Jeffrey, N. Isendahl, and M. Brugnach, “Maturing the new water management paradigm: Progressing from aspiration to practice,” Water Resources Management, vol. 25, no. pp. 837-856, 2011.
 S. Maasen, and O. Lieven, “Transdisciplinarity: A new mode of governing science,” Special issue of Science and Public Policy. August 2006.
 M. Muller, “Polycentric governance: Water management in South Africa,” Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers Management, Procurement and Law, vol. 165, no. MPO, pp. 1-8, 2012.
 E. Ostrom, “Nested externalities and polycentric institutions: Must we wait for global solutions to climate change before taking actions at other scales?” Econ Theory, vol. 49, pp. 353-369, 2012.
 M. D. Gerst, P. D. Raskin, and J. Rockstrőm, “Contours of resilient global future,” Sustainability, vol. 2014, no. 6, pp. 123-135, 2014.
 Government of South Africa, The Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, Act 108 of 1996, Republic of South Africa, 1996. https://www.ru.ac.za/media/rhodesuniversity/content/humanresources/documents/employmentequity/Constitution%20of%20the%20Republic%20of%20South%20Africa%201.pdf (Accessed 12 July 2016).
 Government of South Africa, National Water Act, Act 36 of 1998. Department of Water Affairs, Republic of South Africa, 1998.
 P. J. Ashton, A. R. Turton, and D. J. Roux, “Exploring the government, society and science interfaces in Integrated Water Resource Management in South Africa,” Journal of Contemporary Water Research and Education, vol. 135, pp. 28-35, 2006.
 E. L. Bohensky, “Discovering resilient pathways for South African water management: Two frameworks for a vision,” Ecology and Society, vol. 13, no. 1, pp. 19, 2008.
 M. Bourblanc, “Transforming water resources management in South Africa. Catchment Management Agencies and the ideal of democratic development,” Journal of International Development, vol. 24, no. 2112, pp. 637-648, 2012.
 B. Schreiner, “Viewpoint: Why has the South African National Water Act been so difficult to implement?” Water Alternatives, vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 239-245, 2013.
 G. Pegram, and G. Mazibuko, “Evaluation of the role of Water User Associations in water management in South Africa” Water Research Commission, Pretoria, April 2003.
 L. Rodina, and L. M. Harris, “Institutional and policy mapping of the water sector in South Africa: Program on Water Governance,” Working Paper, ResearchGate, 2016.
 M. C. Dent, “Catchment management agencies as crucibles in which to develop responsible leaders in South Africa,” Water SA, vol. 38, no. 2, 2012.
 M. Uys, “A legal review of the South African natural resources management mechanisms, towards integrated resources management. Water Research Commission Report number KV 176/06, Pretoria, 2008.
 CER, “Stop treading water: What civil society can do to get water governance in SA back on track?” Centre for Environmental Rights NPC, 8A Sussex Rd, Observatory, Cape Town., 2012.
 A. Driver, K. J. Sink, J. N. Nel, S. Holness, L. Van Niekerk, F. Daniels, Z. Jonas, P. A. Majiedt, L. Harris, and K. Maze. “National Biodiversity Assessment 2011: An assessment of South Africa’s biodiversity and ecosystems synthesis report,” South African National Biodiversity Institute and Department of Environmental Affairs, Pretoria, 2012.
 S. De Villiers, and M. De Wit, “H2O – CO2 – Energy equations for South Africa. Present status, future scenario’s and proposed solutions,” AEON report series number 2, Rondebosch, South Africa, University of Cape Town, 2010.
 N. Quinn, “Water governance, ecosystems and sustainability: A review of progress in South Africa,” Water International, vol. 37, no. 7, pp. 760-772, 2012.
 A. R. Turton, “Three strategic water quality challenges that decision-makers need to know about and how the CSIR should respond,” Keynote address, CSIR Conference, Pretoria, 18 November 2008.
 N. Segal, “Does South Africa face a water crisis?” Unpublished. A Report to Business Leadership South Africa. Business Leadership. Johannesburg, 2009.
 Van Ginkel, “Eutrophication: present reality and future challenges for South Africa,” Water SA, vol.37, no.5, January 2011. http://www.scielo.org.za/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1816-79502011000500010 (Accessed 1 November 2017)
 CER, “Zero Hour. Poor governance of mining and the violation of environmental rights in Mpumalanga,” Centre for Environmental Rights. Cape Town, 2016. Available: http://cer.org.za. (Accessed 18 November 2016).
 CER, “Response to DEA's statement about proposed coal mine inside Mabola Protected Environment,” Joint Media release: Centre for Environmental Rights. Cape Town, 2017. Available: http://cer.org.za. (Accessed 1 November 2017).
 S. De Villiers, and S.T. Mkwelo, “Has monitoring failed the Olifants River, Mpumalanga?” Water SA, vol. 35, no. 5 October, 2009.
 CDE Round Table, “Water: A looming crisis,” Edited proceedings of a Round Table. Convened by Business Leadership South Africa and the Centre for Development and Enterprise, The Centre for Development and Enterprise, Parktown. Johannesburg, South Africa, April 2010.
 C. Herhold, “The water crisis in South Africa,” Des Midgley Memorial Lecture. Civil Engineering, pp. 6-15, June 2010.
 C. Colvin, A. Burns, K. Schachtschneider, A. Maherry, and M. de Wit, “Coal and Water futures in South Africa. The case for protecting the headwaters in the Enkangala grasslands”. WWF Report 2011. WWF-SA, Cape Town. South Africa, 2011.
 L. Swatuk, “Political challenges to implementing IWRM in Southern Africa,” Physics and Chemistry of the Earth, vol. 30, no. 2005, pp. 872-880, 2005.
 M. V. Taljaard, “Van ontwikkeling tot gemeenskapsontwikkeling: ’n Toegepaste etiese ondersoek” Unpublished PhD Thesis, University of Stellenbosch, Stellenbosch, 1997.
 A. R. Turton, H.J.H., G. A. Maree, D. J. Roux, M. Claassen, and W. F. Strydom. (Eds). 2007. Governance as a Trialogue: Government-Society-Science in transition. CSIR, Pretoria. Springer, 2007.
 B. De Villiers, “Protecting minorities on a non-territorial basis: Recent international developments,” Beijing Law Review, vol. 2012, no. 3, pp. 170-183, 2012.
 J. Hoogesteger, “The politics of water democracy: Insights from grassroot struggles in the Ecuadorian Highlands,” Asia Pacific Viewpoint, October 2016. DOI: 10.1111/apv.12141.
 J. S. Kemerink, R. Ahlers, and P. Van Der Zaag, “Contested water rights in post-apartheid South Africa: The struggle for water at catchment level” Water SA, vol. 37, no. 4, pp. 585-594, October 2011,
 D. J. Merrey, “Is normative integrated water resources management implementable? Charting a practical course with lessons from South Africa,” Physics and Chemistry of the Earth, vol. 33, no. 2008, pp. 899-905, 2008.
 P. P. Mollinga, R. S. Meinzen-Dick and D. J. Merrey. “Politics, plurality and problem sheds: A strategic approach for reform of agricultural water resources management,” Development Policy Review, vol. 25, no. 6, pp. 699-719, 2007.
 M. Falkenmark, A. Jägerskog, and K. Scheider, “Over-coming the land water disconnect in water scarce regions: Time for IWRM to go contemporary,” International Journal of Water Resources Development, vol. 30, no. 3, pp. 391-408, 2014.
 K. Rogers, D. Roux, and H. Biggs, “Challenges for catchment management agencies: Lessons from bureaucracies, business and resource management,” Water SA, vol. 26, pp. 505-5111, 4 October 2000.
 N. Redelinghuys, and A. J. Pelser, “Challenges to co-operation on water utilisation in the Southern Africa region,” Water Policy, vol. 15, no. 2013, pp. 554-569, 2013.
 DWA, Proposed new nine Water Management Areas of South Africa, Government Gazette no 35517, 20 July 2012 https://www.greengazette.co.za/documents/national-gazette-35517-of-20-july-2012-vol-565_20120720-GGN-35517.pdf
 DWA, The Departement of Water Affairs, “National water policy review: Updated policy positions to overcome the water challenges of our developmental state to provide for improved access to water, equity and sustainability,” Government Gazette no 36798, Notice 888 of 2013, Pretoria, South Africa, 2013.
 Government of South Africa, Promotion of Administrative Justice Act, Act 3 of 2000. Republic of South Africa, 2000.
 T. Dietz, E. Ostrom, and P. C. Stern, “The struggle to govern the commons,” Science, vol. 302, pp. 1907-1912, 2003.
 J. Hoogesteger, “NGOs and the democratisation of Ecuadorian water governance: Insights from the Multi Stakeholder Platform el Foro de los Recursos Hidricos,” International Journal of Voluntary and Non-profit Organisations. March 2015. DOI: 10.1007/s11266-015-9559-1.
 J. Balsiger, and B. Debarbieu, “Major challenges in regional environmental governance research and practice,” Procedia Social and Behavioral Sciences, vol. 14, pp. 1-8, 2011.
 M. A. Max-Neef, “Foundations of transdisciplinarity,” Ecological Economics, vol. 53, no. 2005, pp. 5-16, 2005.
 M. Muller, “Water management institutions for more resilient societies,” Civil Engineering Special Issue, vol. 165, no. CE6, pp. 33-39, 2012.
 M. Van Rijswick, J. Edelenbos, P. Hellegers, M. Kok, and S. Kuks, “Ten building blocks for sustainable water governance: an integrated method to assess the governance of water,” Water International, vol. 39, no. 5, pp. 725-742, 2014.
 K. Bakker, and C. Morinville, “The governance dimensions of water security: A review,” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, vol. 371, 2013.
 B. Lankford, and N. Hepworth, “The cathedral and the bazaar: Monocentric and polycentric river basin management,” Water Alternatives, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 82-101, 2010.
 H. Nagendra, and E. Ostrom, “Polycentric governance of multifunctional forested landscapes” International Journal of the Commons, vol. 6, no. 2, 2012.
 E. Ostrom, “Polycentric systems for coping with collective action and global environmental change,” Global Environmental Change, vol. 20, no. 2010, pp. 550-557, 2010.
 D. Lindley, “Can expansive social learning processes strengthen organisation learning from improved wetland management in a plantation forestry?” PhD Thesis, unpublished, Rhodes University, 2014.
 A. R. Turton, “The political aspects of institutional developments in the water sector: South Africa and its international river basins,” Unpublished PhD Thesis, University of Pretoria, Pretoria, 2003.
 G. C. Daily, J. Polasky, P. M. Goldstein, H. A. Kareiva, L. Mooney, T. H. Pejchar, T. H. Rickets, J. Salzman and R. Schallenberger, “Ecosystem services in decision making: Time to deliver,” Front Ecol Environ, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 21-28, 2009.
 P. F. Bendassolli, “Theory building in qualitative research: Reconsidering the problem of induction,” Forum: Qualitative Social Research, vol. 14, no. 1, 2013.
 B. Blumberg, D. R. Cooper, and P. S. Schindler. Business Research Methods. London: McGraw-Hill Higher Education, 2008.
 B. Flyvberg, “Five misunderstandings about case-study research,” Qualitative Inquiry. Vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 219-245, 2006.
 P. Reason, and H. Bradbury, Eds. Action research: Participative inquiry and practice, London: Sage Publications, 2008, pp. 83-87.
 J. McNiff, and J. Whitehead, Action Research: Principles and practice, London: Routledge Falmer, 2002.
 P. Kumar, “An analytical study on Mintzberg’s Framework: Managerial roles,” International Journal of Research in Management & Business Studies, vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 12-19, 2015.
 H. Mintzberg, “Managerial Work: Analysis from Observation,” Management Science, vol. 18, no. 2, 1971.
 H. Tsoukas, “What is management? An outline of a metatheory,” British Journal of Management, vol. 5, no. 1994, pp. 289-301, 1994.
 G. Easton, “Critical realism in case study research,” Industrial Marketing Management. vol. 39, no. 2010, pp. 118-128, 2010.
 D. Scott, “Critical Realism and Empirical Research Methods in Education,” Journal of Philosophy of Education. Vol. 39, no. 4, pp. 633-646, 2005.
 R. I. Sutton, and B. M. Staw, “What theory is not,” Administrative Science Quarterly, vol. 40, no. 3, pp. 371-384, 1995.
 J. Blatter, “Innovations in case study methodology: Congruence analysis and the relevance of crucial cases,” Annual Meeting of the Swiss Political Science Association, Lucerne, 2-3 February 2012.
 C. Hart, Doing a literature review: Releasing the Social Science research imagination, London, SAGE Publications, 1998.
 J. G. Verlinden, Verifiers in everyday argument: An expansion of the Toulmin model, 1998. Available: http://sorrel.humboldt.edu/-jgvl/ME/verifiers.html (Accessed 27 September 2017)
 R. K. Yin, Case study research: Design and methods, Los Angeles: Sage, 2009.
 SAAFWUA, Information document: A roadmap on restructuring and reform of irrigation boards and water user associations (local water management institutions). P. O. Box 225, Jacobsdal, 8710, South Africa, 22 October 2015.
 SAAFWUA, Management Committee meeting , In Ons Tuiste, Dreyer Street, Belville, Cape Town, P. O. Box 234, Jacobsdal, 2345, South Africa, 27 November 2015.
 D. Slevin, and J. K. Pinto, “Balancing strategy and tactics in project implementation,” Sloan Management Review, vol. 29, no. 1, pp. 33-41, 1987.
 P. Lorange, “Strategy implementation: The new realities,” Long Range Planning, vol. 31, no. 1, pp. 18-29, 1998.
 D. Hillson, “Extending the risk process to manage opportunities,” International Journal of Project Management, vol. 20, pp. 235-240, 2002.
 E. Araral, and K. Hartley, “Polycentric governance for a new environmental regime: Theoretical frontiers in policy reform and public administration,” 1st International Conference on Public Policy, Grenoble, France, 2013.
 H. Bressers, and S. Kuks, “Water governance regimes: Dimensions and dynamics,” International Journal of Water Governance, vol. 1, no. 2013, pp. 133-156, 2013.
 B. Nykvist, “Does social learning lead to better natural resource management? A case study of the modern farming community of practice in Sweden,” Society and Natural Resources: An International Journal, vol. 27, no. 4, pp. 436-450, 2014.
 G. Teisman, A. Van Buuren, J. Edelenbos and J. Warner, “Water governance: Facing the limits of managerialism, determinism, water-centricity and technocratic problem-solving,” International Journal of Water Governance, vol. 1, no. 2013, pp. 1-11, 2013.
 SAAFWU, Chairman’s Report on the Management Committee Meeting, Outlook Lodge OR Tambo, P. O. Box 225, Jacobsdal, 8710, South Africa, 7 December 2017.