Modernism’s Influence on Architect-Client Relationship: Comparative Case Studies of Schroder and Farnsworth Houses

Authors: Omneya Messallam, Sara S. Fouad

Abstract:

The Modernist Movement initially flourished in France, Holland, Germany and the Soviet Union. Many architects and designers were inspired and followed its principles. Two of its most important architects (Gerrit Rietveld and Ludwig Mies van de Rohe) were introduced in this paper. Each did not follow the other’s principles and had their own particular rules; however, they shared the same features of the Modernist International Style, such as Anti-historicism, Abstraction, Technology, Function and Internationalism/ Universality. Key Modernist principles translated into high expectations, which sometimes did not meet the inhabitants’ aspirations of living comfortably; consequently, leading to a conflict and misunderstanding between the designer and their clients’ needs. Therefore, historical case studies (the Schroder and the Farnsworth houses) involving two Modernist pioneer architects have been chosen. This paper is an attempt to explore some of the influential factors affecting buildings design such as: needs, gender, and question concerning commonalities between both designers and their clients. The three aspects and two designers explored here have been chosen because they have been influenced the researchers to understand the impact of those factors on the design process, building’s performance, and the dweller’s satisfaction. This is a descriptive/ analytical research based on two historical comparative case studies that involve several steps such as: key evaluation questions (KEQs), observations, document analysis, etc. The methodology is based on data collation and finding validations. The research aims to state a manifest to regulate the relation between architects and their clients to reach the optimum building performance and functional interior design that suits their clients’ needs, reflects the architects’ character, and the school they belong to. At the end, through the investigation in this paper, the different needs between both the designers and the clients have been seen not only in the building itself but also it could convert the inhabitant’s life in various ways. Moreover, a successful relationship between the architect and their clients could play a significant role in the success of projects. In contrast, not every good design or celebrated building could end up with a successful relationship between the designer and their client or full-fill the inhabitant’s aspirations.

Keywords: Architect’s character, Building’s performance, commonalities, client’s character, gender, modernist movement, needs.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1475018

References:

[1] https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/modernism. Accessed on 17/06/2017.
[2] Http://dictionary.cambridge.org/define.asp?key=51387&dict=CALD&topic=art-history-and-artistic-movements.Accessed on July, 2018.
[3] Greenhalgh, Paul, Modernism in Design (Reaktion Books Ltd). London: 1990.
[4] https://placeexploration.com/2015/10/28/a-house-is-a-machine-for-living-in/. Accessed on May, 2018.
[5] Norouzia, N., Shabakb, M., Embic, M. R., & Khand, T. H. The architect, the client and effective communication in architectural design practice. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences. Kuala Lumpur: 2015, 635 – 642.
[6] Ziegler, K., Ylitalo, J., & Mäki, E. Communication in interorganizational collaboration: a case study. Frontiers of E-Business Research 2004, (FeBR), 656–669.
[7] Jaffé, H. L. De Stijl 1917-1931: Visions of Utopia (Abrams). New York: 1982.
[8] Smithson, A. a. The Heroic Period of Modern Architecture. Rizzol, 1981.
[9] RIBA. Taking Action. August 2007.
[10] Shen, W. A. BIM-based Pre-occupancy Evaluation Platform (PEP) for facilitating designer-client communication in the early design stage. The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, 2011.
[11] Yu, A. T. W., Shen, Q., & Chan, E. H. W. An Analytical Review of the Briefing Practice in Hong Kong’s Construction Industry. International Journal of Construction Management, 2005, 5(1), 77–89.
[12] Tuan, Y., Space and Place: The Perspective of Experience, University of Minnesota Press: 2003.
[13] Bland, Adrian. Consuming Culture: The Meaning and Uses of „Things. Farnham. Lecture at University for the Creative Arts: 10 November 2009.
[14] De Botton, A., The Architecture of happiness, Hamish Hamilton Ltd: 2006.
[15] Friedman, Alice T. Your Place or Mine? The Client’s contribution to domestic architecture. In: Martin, Brenda ed. Woman’s Places: Architecture and Design 1860-1960. pp 69-86. London: 2003.