Safety Assessment of Traditional Ready-to-Eat Meat Products Vended at Retail Outlets in Kebbi and Sokoto States, Nigeria
Commenced in January 2007
Frequency: Monthly
Edition: International
Paper Count: 32797
Safety Assessment of Traditional Ready-to-Eat Meat Products Vended at Retail Outlets in Kebbi and Sokoto States, Nigeria

Authors: M. I. Ribah, M. Jibir, Y. A. Bashar, S. S. Manga


Food safety is a significant and growing public health problem in the world and Nigeria as a developing country, since food-borne diseases are important contributors to the huge burden of sickness and death of humans. In Nigeria, traditional ready-to-eat meat products (RTE-MPs) like balangu, tsire, guru and dried meat products like kilishi, dambun nama, banda, were reported to be highly appreciated because of their eating qualities. The consumption of these products was considered as safe due to the treatments that are usually involved during their production process. However, during processing and handling, the products could be contaminated by pathogens that could cause food poisoning. Therefore, a hazard identification for pathogenic bacteria on some traditional RTE-MPs was conducted in Kebbi and Sokoto States, Nigeria. A total of 116 RTE-MPs (balangu-38, kilishi-39 and tsire-39) samples were obtained from retail outlets and analyzed using standard cultural microbiological procedures in general and selective enrichment media to isolate the target pathogens. A six-fold serial dilution was prepared and using the pour plating method, colonies were counted. Serial dilutions were selected based on the prepared pre-labeled Petri dishes for each sample. A volume of 10-12 ml of molten Nutrient agar cooled to 42-45°C was poured into each Petri dish and 1 ml each from dilutions of 102, 104 and 106 for every sample was respectively poured on a pre-labeled Petri plate after which colonies were counted. The isolated pathogens were identified and confirmed after series of biochemical tests. Frequencies and percentages were used to describe the presence of pathogens. The General Linear Model was used to analyze data on pathogen presence according to RTE-MPs and means were separated using the Tukey test at 0.05 confidence level. Of the 116 RTE-MPs samples collected, 35 (30.17%) samples were found to be contaminated with some tested pathogens. Prevalence results showed that Escherichia coli, salmonella and Staphylococcus aureus were present in the samples. Mean total bacterial count was 23.82×106 cfu/g. The frequency of individual pathogens isolated was; Staphylococcus aureus 18 (15.51%), Escherichia coli 12 (10.34%) and Salmonella 5 (4.31%). Also, among the RTE-MPs tested, the total bacterial counts were found to differ significantly (P < 0.05), with 1.81, 2.41 and 2.9×104 cfu/g for tsire, kilishi, and balangu, respectively. The study concluded that the presence of pathogenic bacteria in balangu could pose grave health risks to consumers, and hence, recommended good manufacturing practices in the production of balangu to improve the products’ safety.

Keywords: Ready-to-eat meat products, retail outlets, safety assessment, public health.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI):

Procedia APA BibTeX Chicago EndNote Harvard JSON MLA RIS XML ISO 690 PDF Downloads 1128


[1] M. I. Ribah, M. Jibir, N. Muhammad and B. A. Shinkafi “Effect of Tenderizers on Organoleptic Properties of Banda- Nigerian Dehydrated Meat”. Proc. of the 18th Ann. Conf. of the Ani. Sci. Ass. of Nig., Abuja, 8th – 12th Sept. 2013.
[2] G. Lorentzen Effects of Salt-curing, Rehydration and Thermal Treatment on Survival, Growth and Invasiveness of Listeria spp. A PhD dissertation submitted to the Faculty of Biosciences, Fisheries and Economics. Norwegian College of Fishery Science. University of Tromsø, 2010.
[3] FSAI. The Control and Management of Listeria monocytogenes Contamination of Food. Published by Food Safety Authority of Ireland. 2005; P. 104.
[4] R. K. Gupta Food Preservation: Food and Industrial Microbiology. Ram Lal Anand College, Dhuala Kuan, NewDelhi-110021; 2007.
[5] WHO. Food safety and foodborne illness. A fact sheet publication of World Health Organisation; 2002. Accessed May 12, 2014; Available:
[6] S. O. Akano, D. D. Moro, A. M. Deji-Agboola and A. Oluwadun “Public Health Implication of Listeria species and Other Bacteria Isolates of Abattoir Effluent in Lagos, Nigeria”. Int. Res. J. of Microbiol., 2013;4(7):162-167.
[7] J. O. Igene, E. O. Abulu “Nutritional and bacteriological characteristics of tsire-type-suya, a popular Nigerian meat product”. J. Food Protect., 1984;47:193-196.
[8] J. M. Collard, S. Bertrand, K. Dierick, C. Godard, C. Wildemauwe, K. Vermeersch, et al. “Drastic Decrease of Salmonella enteritidis Isolated from Humans in Belgium in 2005, Shift in Phage Types and Influence on Foodborne Outbreaks”. Epid. and Infect; 2008; 136: 771-781.
[9] H. I. Chiang. Genomic Approaches to Study Innate Immune Response to Salmonella Enteritidis Infection in Chickens. (Unpublished PhD Thesis), Department of Poultry Science. Texas A&M University; 2008.
[10] M. D. Salihu, A. U. Junaidu, S. B. Manga, M. L. Gulumbe, A. A. Magaji, A. Ahmed et al. “Occurrence of Listeria monocytogenes in smoked fish in Sokoto, Nigeria”. Afr. J. Biotech,2008;7(17):3082-3084.
[11] Edema MO, Osho AT and Diala CI. Evaluation of microbial hazards associated with the processing of Suya (a grilled meat product). Sci. Res. and Essay, 2008;3(12):621-626.
[12] Egbebi AO, and Seidu KT. Microbiological evaluation of Suya (dried smoked meat) sold in Ado and Akure, South West Nigeria. Europ. J. of Exp. Biology, 2011;1(4):1-5.
[13] Ogbonna IO, Danladi MS, Akinmusire O and Odu CE. Microbiological Safety and Proximate Composition of Suya Stored at Ambient Temperature for Six Hours from Maiduguri, Northern Nigeria. Internet J. Food Saf., 2012;14:11-16.
[14] Tafida Y, Kabir J, Kwaga, JK, Bello M, Umoh VJ, Yakubu SE et al. Occurrence of Salmonella in Retail Beef and Related Meat roducts in Zaria, Nigeria. F. Contr., 2013;32:119-124.
[15] Jhalka K, Tara CS and Dipendra T. Staphylococcus aureus and Staphylococcal Food-Borne Disease. An Ongoing Challenge in Public Health: Review. BioMed Res. Int., 2014;3(4):432-438.
[16] Collins B. Nigeria Maps. Published by Spectrum books Limited, Ibadan, Nigeria;2005.
[17] Roger B. Traditional Livestock Breeds: Geographical Distribution and Dynamics in Relation to the Ecology of West Africa. Overseas Development Institute, Portland House. Stag Place. Working Paper 122. October, 1999.
[18] Lawal-Adebowale OA. Livestock Production. Dynamics of Ruminant Livestock Management in the Context of the Nigerian Agricultural System (Chapter 4). Khalid, J. (Ed.). Published under CCBY. Pp 324.2012.
[19] Muhammad BF and Umar AM. Processing Beef into Tsire and Balangu: Effects on Proximate Composition and Amino Acid Profile. Sav. J. Agric., 2010;5:61-69.
[20] Kebbi and Sokoto states. Retrieved on 5th April, 2017 from http://www.googlem/maps/places
[21] Salihu MD, Junaidu AU, Magaji AA, Aliyu RM, Yakubu Y, Shittu A et al. Bacteriological Quality of Traditionally Prepared Fried Ground Beef (Dambun nama) in Sokoto, Nigeria. Adv. J. Food Sci. and Tech., 2010;2(3): 145-147.
[22] FSSAI. Manual of Methods of Analysis of Foods. Food safety and standards of india. Lab manual-14. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, New Delhi, India. P 105; 2012.
[23] Ruangpan L. and Tendencia EA. Bacterial Isolation, Identification and Storage. In Laboratory manual of standardized methods for antimicrobial sensitivity tests for bacteria isolated from aquatic animals and environment (pp. 3–11);2010.
[24] HPA. Guidelines for Assessing the Microbiological Safety of Ready-to-Eat Foods. Health Protection Agency. 7th Floor, Holborn Gate. 330 High Holborn, London WC1V 7PP. P34;2009.
[25] Yusuf MA and Abdul Hamid TA. Isolation and Identification of Listeria spp. from Ready-to-eat (rte) Kilishi in Retail Outlet in Bauchi, Nigeria. Int. J Pharm. Sci. Invention, 2013; 2(1):22-25.
[26] Adegunloye DV. Carrier Rate of Enteric Bacteria Associated with Diarrhoea in Children and Pupils in Akure, Ondo State, Nigeria. Afr. J Biotech, 2006;5(2):162-164.
[27] Adesiji YO, Alli OT, Adekanle MA and Jolayemi JB. Prevalence of Arcobacter, Escherichia coli, Staphylococcus aureus and Salmonella species in Retail Raw Chicken, Pork, Beef and Goat meat in Osogbo, Nigeria. S. Leone J Biomed. Res., 2011;3(1):8-12.
[28] Achy OK and Madubuike CN. Prevalence and Antimicrobial Resistance of Staphylococcus aureus Isolated from Retail Ready-To-Eat Foods in Nigeria. Res. J Microbio., 2007;2(6):516-523.
[29] Majolagbe ON, Idowu SA, Adebayo E, Ola I, Adewoyin AG and Oladipo EK. Prevalence and Antibiotic Resistance of Bacteria Isolated from Ready-to-eat (RTE) Food Samples of Highly Patronized Eateries in Ogbomoso-Oyo State, Nigeria. Europ. J Exper. Biol., 2011, 1 (3):70-78.
[30] Kim NH, Yun AR and Rhee MS. Prevalence and Classification of Toxigenic Staphylococcus aureus Isolated from Refrigerated Ready-to-eat Foods (sushi, kimbab and California rolls) in Korea. J. of App. Micro., 2011; 111:1456–1464.
[31] Yusuf MA, Tengku Haziyamin AA and Ibrahim H. Isolation and Identification of Bacteria Associated with Balangu (Roasted Meat Product) Sold in Bauchi. Nigeria. IOSR J Pharm., 2012;2(6):38-48.
[32] Sangoyomi TE, Bello-Olusoji OA, Ajani F, Owoseni AA and Odeniyi O. Bacterial Contamination in Vended Animal Food Products around Motor Parks in Ibadan, South West Nigeria. J. Med.& Appl. Biosci., 2012;4:459-66.
[33] Syne S, Adash R and Abiodun AA. Microbiological Hazard Analysis of Ready to eat Meats Processed at a Food Plant in Trinidad, West Indies. Infect. Ecol. and Epidem., 2013;3: 204-210.
[34] Senait G and Moorty ARS. Isolation and Identification of Staphylococcus Species from Ready-To-Eat Meat Products in and Around Debre-Zeit, Ethiopia. Int. J. Res. in Agr. & For, 2016;3(4): 6-16.
[35] Stewart CM. Staphylococcus aureus and staphylococcal enterotoxins. Ch 12 In: Hocking A.D. (ed) Foodborne microorganisms of public health significance. 6th ed, Australian Institute of Food Science and Technology (NSW Branch), Sydney, p. 359–380;2003.
[36] Montville TJ and Matthews KR. Food microbiology: An introduction. Second Edition, ASM Press, Washington D. C. USA; 2008.
[37] Gelsomino R, Vancanneyt M, Cogan TM, Condon S and Swings J. Source of enterococci in a farmhouse raw-milk cheese. Appl. Envir. Microbiol,. 2002;68: 3560-3565.
[38] Ukut IOE, Okonko IO, Ikpoh IS, Nkang AO, Udeze AO, Babalola TA, et al. Assessment of Bacteriological Quality of Fresh Meats Sold in Calabar Metropolis, Nigeria. Electr. J. Envir., Agri. & Food Chem., 2010;9(1): 89-100.
[39] Ali A, Uzma S, Shabir A, Imran A, Muhammad IK, Tanrawee P et al. Presence of Escherichia coli in Poultry Meat: A Potential Food Safety Threat. Int. Food Res. J., 2014;21(3):941-945.
[40] Hassanin FS, Reham AA, Shawky NA and Goma WM. Incidence of Escherichia coli and Salmonella in Ready to eat Foods. Benha Vet. Med. J., 2014;7(1):84‐91.
[41] Zhao C, Ge B, De Villena J, Sudler R, Yeh E, Zhao S, et al. Prevalence of Campylobacter spp., Escherichia coli, and Salmonella Serovars in Retail Chicken, Turkey, Pork, and Beef from the Greater Washington, D. C., Area. Appl. and Envir. Micr., 2001;67(12):5431–5436.
[42] Khaitsa ML, Kegode RB and Doetkott DK. Occurrence of Antimicrobial-Resistant Salmonella Species in Raw and Ready to Eat Turkey Meat Products from Retail Outlets in the Midwestern United States. Foodborne Path. & Dis., 2007;4(4):517-525.
[43] David GW, Shaohua Z, Robert S, Sherry A, Sharon F. Sheng C, et al. The Isolation of Antibiotic-Resistant Salmonella From Retail Ground Meats. The New Eng. J. of Med., 2001; 345(16):1147-1154.
[44] Mohamed K. Prevalence of Salmonella in Meat Products. Glo. Veterinaria, 2013;11(5):685-688.
[45] Adeyanju GT and Ishola O. Salmonella and Escherichia coli Contamination of Poultry Meat from a Processing Plant and Retail Markets in Ibadan, Oyo State, Nigeria. SpringerPlus, 2014;3:139-148.
[46] Rihab RT, Saeed MA, Yasmin NA. Incidence and Distribution of Salmonella Serogroups in Some Local Food in Sana’a–Yemen. Authorized By Al-Nasser University's Research Office;2015. Pp21.
[47] Mahangaiko M, Mabi N, Bakana M and Nyongombe U. Food Contamination with Salmonella and Human Health in Kinshasa City, Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). J. of Appl. Biosci., 2015; 94:8809 – 8814.
[48] Umoru FP, Agbaye AW, Lamidi AS, Ajibade ASA, Labaeka AA, Falade R A, et al. Body weight and carcass characteristics of broiler chicken fed mixture of ginger (zingiber officinale) and garlic (Allium sativum) in diets. Proceedings of the 47th Annual Conference of the Agricultural Society of Nigeria, badan, 2013;1101-1105.
[49] Ndelekwute EK, Uzegbu HO, Assam ED and Udorok UE. Influence of black pepper (Piper nigrum) as growth promoter on performance of starter broiler chicks. Proc. 40th Ann. Conf. Nigerian Society for Animal Production, 15-19th March, NAPRI/ABU, Zaria: 2015; 330-333.
[50] Inyang CU, Igyor, MA. and Uma EN. Bacteria Quality of a Smoked Meat Product ‘Suya‟, Nig. Food J., 2005; 23:239-240.
[51] ICMSF. Microorganisms in foods 2. Sampling for microbiological analysis: Principles and specific applications. International Commission on Microbiological Specification for foods, University of Toronto press;1996.
[52] Yuksek N, Evrensel SS, Temelli S, Anar S and Sen MKC. A Microbiological Evaluation on the Ready-To-Eat Red Meat and Chicken Donair Kebabs from a Local Catering Company in Bursa. J. Biol. & Envir. Sci., 2009; 3(7): 7-10.