Designing a Socio-Technical System for Groundwater Resources Management, Applying Smart Energy and Water Meter

Authors: S. Mahdi Sadatmansouri, Maryam Khalili

Abstract:

World, nowadays, encounters serious water scarcity problem. During the past few years, by advent of Smart Energy and Water Meter (SEWM) and its installation at the electro-pumps of the water wells, one had believed that it could be the golden key to address the groundwater resources over-pumping issue. In fact, implementation of these Smart Meters managed to control the water table drawdown for short; but it was not a sustainable approach. SEWM has been considered as law enforcement facility at first; however, for solving a complex socioeconomic problem like shared groundwater resources management, more than just enforcement is required: participation to conserve common resources. The well owners or farmers, as water consumers, are the main and direct stakeholders of this system and other stakeholders could be government sectors, investors, technology providers, privet sectors or ordinary people. Designing a socio-technical system not only defines the role of each stakeholder but also can lubricate the communication to reach the system goals while benefits of each are considered and provided. Farmers, as the key participators for solving groundwater problem, do not trust governments but they would trust a fair system in which responsibilities, privileges and benefits are clear. Technology could help this system remained impartial and productive. Social aspects provide rules, regulations, social objects and etc. for the system and help it to be more human-centered. As the design methodology, Design Thinking provides probable solutions for the challenging problems and ongoing conflicts; it could enlighten the way in which the final system could be designed. Using Human Centered Design approach of IDEO helps to keep farmers in the center of the solution and provides a vision by which stakeholders’ requirements and needs are addressed effectively. Farmers would be considered to trust the system and participate in their groundwater resources management if they find the rules and tools of the system fair and effective. Besides, implementation of the socio-technical system could change farmers’ behavior in order that they concern more about their valuable shared water resources as well as their farm profit. This socio-technical system contains nine main subsystems: 1) Measurement and Monitoring system, 2) Legislation and Governmental system, 3) Information Sharing system, 4) Knowledge based NGOs, 5) Integrated Farm Management system (using IoT), 6) Water Market and Water Banking system, 7) Gamification, 8) Agribusiness ecosystem, 9) Investment system.

Keywords: Design Thinking, Human Centered Design, participatory management, Smart Energy and Water Meter (SEWM), socio-technical system, water table drawdown, Internet of Things, Gamification

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1316588

References:

[1] “The Global Risks Report 2015- 10th Edition”- World Economic Forum, REF: 090115. This report and an interactive data platform are available at www.weforum.org/risks., Accessed on 2016.12.11
[2] Business recorder, “War and water: top threat in next decade”, January 26, 2015, http://www.brecorder.com/br-research/999:all/5119:war-and-water-top-threat-in-next-decade/?date=2015-01-26; last access: December 07, 2016
[3] “The Global Risks Report 2016- 11th Edition”- World Economic Forum, REF: 080116; The report and an interactive data platform are available at http://wef.ch/risks2016 , Accessed on 2016.12.12
[4] WWAP: World Water Assessment Programme (2009). The United Nations World Water Development Report 3: “Water in a changing World”. Paris: UNESCO, and London: Earthscan.
[5] H. Nazarboland Jahromi, M. Jafari Hamedani, S. F. Dolatabadi, P. Abbasi; “Smart Energy and Water Meter: a novel vision to groundwater monitoring and management”; 13th Biennial Groundwater Division Conference and Exhibition
[6] Smart Water Metering (SWM) Inc, “An Innovative, Robust, and Comprehensive Water Management Network to Reduce Groundwater Overexploitation and Increase Farm Profits in the MENA Region”; December 2015; Official proposal for USAID Middle East Water Security Initiative (MWSI) – Funds for NGOs
[7] M. E. Porter, J. E. Heppelmann; “How Smart, Connected Products Are Transforming Competition”, Harvard Business Review, November 2014 Issue
[8] P. Vermaas, P. Kroes, I. van de Poel, M. Franssen, and W. H. Copyright “A Philosophy ofTechnology, FromTechnical Artifacts to Socio-technical Systems”; © 2011 by Morgan & Claypool vermas, ISBN: 9781608455997 ebook, Chapter 5, pg 67-80
[9] D. Meadows; “Leverage Points: Places to Intervene in a System”;
[10] A. Edalat; “Hypothesis of the Tragedization: The Long-Lasting Impact of Mongolos Tragedy on the Political, Social, and Scientific History of Iran”, Bokhara Magazine, No.77,78, 2010, (in Persian language), pg 227-259
[11] E. Ostrom; “Governing The Commons; The evolution of institutions for collective action”; Cambridge University Press, pg 1-3
[12] IDEO.org; “Human-Centered-Design (HCD) Toolkit, 2nd Edition”
[13] P. Jenkins; “How to gamify your marketing with the 6Cs framework” - Webinar Recording; accessible in: https://vimeo.com/130436450 , Accessed on 2016.12.12
[14] G. Ropohl; “Philosophy of Socio-Technical Systems”, Phil & Tech 4:3 Spring 1999
[15] G. Hardin, “The Tragedy of the Commons”, Science #13, December 1968: Vol. 162 no. 3859 pp. 1243-1248, DOI: 10.1126/science.162.3859.1243
[16] W. N. Dunn, R. M. Kelly; “Advances in Policy Studies Since 1950”; Page 86, Transaction Publishers
[17] M. OLSON; “The Logic Of Collective Action, Public Goods and The Theory of the Groups”; Harvard University Press, Twentieth printing 2002, pg 1-2
[18] P. Jenkins; “How to gamify your marketing using the 6 Cs framework #gamification #ContentStrategy”, Posted on Jul 11, 2015;.http://tayloringit.com/2015/07/how-to-gamify-your-marketing-using-the-6-cs-framework gamification-contentstrategy/ Accessed on 2016.12.12
[19] T. Brown; “Design Thinking”, Harvard Business Review, June 2008
[20] IDEO.org “The Field Guide to Human-Centered Design”;, 1st Edition © 2015, ISBN: 978-0-9914063-1-9