Augmenting Navigational Aids: The Development of an Assistive Maritime Navigation Application

Authors: A. Mihoc, K. Cater

Abstract:

On the bridge of a ship the officers are looking for visual aids to guide navigation in order to reconcile the outside world with the position communicated by the digital navigation system. Aids to navigation include: Lighthouses, lightships, sector lights, beacons, buoys, and others. They are designed to help navigators calculate their position, establish their course or avoid dangers. In poor visibility and dense traffic areas, it can be very difficult to identify these critical aids to guide navigation. The paper presents the usage of Augmented Reality (AR) as a means to present digital information about these aids to support navigation. To date, nautical navigation related mobile AR applications have been limited to the leisure industry. If proved viable, this prototype can facilitate the creation of other similar applications that could help commercial officers with navigation. While adopting a user centered design approach, the team has developed the prototype based on insights from initial research carried on board of several ships. The prototype, built on Nexus 9 tablet and Wikitude, features a head-up display of the navigational aids (lights) in the area, presented in AR and a bird’s eye view mode presented on a simplified map. The application employs the aids to navigation data managed by Hydrographic Offices and the tablet’s sensors: GPS, gyroscope, accelerometer, compass and camera. Sea trials on board of a Navy and a commercial ship revealed the end-users’ interest in using the application and further possibility of other data to be presented in AR. The application calculates the GPS position of the ship, the bearing and distance to the navigational aids; all within a high level of accuracy. However, during testing several issues were highlighted which need to be resolved as the prototype is developed further. The prototype stretched the capabilities of Wikitude, loading over 500 objects during tests in a major port. This overloaded the display and required over 45 seconds to load the data. Therefore, extra filters for the navigational aids are being considered in order to declutter the screen. At night, the camera is not powerful enough to distinguish all the lights in the area. Also, magnetic interference with the bridge of the ship generated a continuous compass error of the AR display that varied between 5 and 12 degrees. The deviation of the compass was consistent over the whole testing durations so the team is now looking at the possibility of allowing users to manually calibrate the compass. It is expected that for the usage of AR in professional maritime contexts, further development of existing AR tools and hardware is needed. Designers will also need to implement a user-centered design approach in order to create better interfaces and display technologies for enhanced solutions to aid navigation.

Keywords: Compass error, GPS, maritime navigation, mobile augmented reality.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1131701

References:

[1] Patraiko D, Wake P., Weintrit A, Guan K, Shi C, Wu S, Xu T, Zalewski P, Im N, Seo JH, Vejražka F. “e-Navigation and the Human Element.” Mar. Navig. Saf. Sea Transp. 2009 Jun 1;4:29.
[2] UK Hydrographic Office “IALA Maritime Buoyage System - Combined Cardinal and Lateral System.” 2012, NP735, ED-7.
[3] N. Bowditch. "The American Practical Navigator, Washington." 1995.
[4] “Navigation Aids”, Available at http://www.cattalini.com/topics.htm#ATON Retrieve on 9 December 2016.
[5] IALA “IALA BASIC Documents – Constitution”, Jun. 2016 June, ED-1
[6] Burrows KG. “Information Management in the Modern Hydrographic Office-A Challenge for the 21st Century.” The International Hydrographic Review. 2015 May 13;65(1).
[7] Han DI, T. Jung, A. Gibson. “Dublin AR: implementing augmented reality in tourism.” Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism 2014-2013 (pp. 511-523). Springer International Publishing.
[8] Y. Zornitza, D. Buhalis, and C. Gatzidis. "Engineering augmented tourism experiences." Information and communication technologies in tourism 2013. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2013. 24-35.
[9] T. Queeney , “Chart app augments reality” Ocean Navigator, Oct 2013
[10] JC. Morgère, "Mobile augmented reality system for maritime navigation." PhD diss., Lorient, 2015.
[11] T. Porathe. "3-D nautical charts and safe navigation.", 2006.
[12] C. Abras, D. Maloney-Krichmar, and J. Preece. "User-centered design." Bainbridge, W. Encyclopedia of Human-Computer Interaction. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications 37, no. 4 , 2004: 445-456.
[13] ARToolKit, Avaialable at https://artoolkit.org/documentation/ Retrived on 6 December 2016.