A Comparative Analysis of Solid Waste Treatment Technologies on Cost and Environmental Basis

Authors: Nesli Aydin

Abstract:

Waste management decision making in developing countries has moved towards being more pragmatic, transparent, sustainable and comprehensive. Turkey is required to make its waste related legislation compatible with European Legislation as it is a candidate country of the European Union. Improper Turkish practices such as open burning and open dumping practices must be abandoned urgently, and robust waste management systems have to be structured. The determination of an optimum waste management system in any region requires a comprehensive analysis in which many criteria are taken into account by stakeholders. In conducting this sort of analysis, there are two main criteria which are evaluated by waste management analysts; economic viability and environmentally friendliness. From an analytical point of view, a central characteristic of sustainable development is an economic-ecological integration. It is predicted that building a robust waste management system will need significant effort and cooperation between the stakeholders in developing countries such as Turkey. In this regard, this study aims to provide data regarding the cost and environmental burdens of waste treatment technologies such as an incinerator, an autoclave (with different capacities), a hydroclave and a microwave coupled with updated information on calculation methods, and a framework for comparing any proposed scenario performances on a cost and environmental basis.

Keywords: Decision making, economic viability, environmentally friendliness, stakeholder, waste management systems.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1130411

References:

[1] J. Colon., E. Cadena, A.B. Colazo, R. Quiros, A. Sanchez, X. Font, and A. Artola (2015). “Toward the implementation of new regional biowaste management plans: Environmental assessment of different waste management scenarios in Catalonia” Resources, Conservation and Recycling (Online). (95) pp. 143–155.
[2] R.M. Deus, R.A.G. Battistelle and G.H.R. Silva (2016). “Current and future environmental impact of household solid waste management scenarios for a region of Brazil: carbon dioxide and energy analysis” Clean Techn Environ Policy. (Online). Pp. 1-10 doi:10.1007/s10098-016-1205-0
[3] N. Ciplak, (2015) “Assessing future scenarios for healthcare waste management using a multi- criteria decision analysis tool: A case study in the Turkish West Black-Sea Region”. The Journal of Air and Waste Management Association (Online). 65(8) pp. 919-929 Available: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26211633 (access date: 21st December 2016)
[4] J. Tao, “The research of environment economy decision supportive system based on GIS”. 1st International Conference on E-Business and E-Government, ICEE 2010, 7-9 May, Guangzhou, China, IEEE Computer Society.
[5] H. Sugiyama, U. Fischer, E. Antonijuan, V.H. Hoffmann, M. Hirao, and K. Hungerbuhler (2009) "How do different process options and evaluation settings affect economic and environmental assessments? A case study on methyl methacrylate (MMA) production processes." Process Safety and Environmental Protection 87(6) pp. 361-370.
[6] IPCC (2006). Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories, Volume 5: Waste. Chapter 5: Incineration and Open Burning of Waste. (Online): http://www.ipcc-nggip.iges.or.jp/public/2006gl/index.html (access date: 19th December 2016)
[7] S. Critten, (2007). “Exeter Energy from Waste Facility”. Carbon Analysis Final. (Online) http://www.devon.gov.uk/graceroad-carbonanalysis.pdf (access date: 21st December 2016)
[8] N. Ritchie and C. Smith (2009). “Comparison of Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Waste-to-Energy Facilities and the Vancouver Landfill”. Technical Memorandum. (Online) http://pentz.com/NoIncinerator/greenhouse%20Emmissions.pdf
[9] K. Spokas, J. Bogner, J.P. Chanton, M. Morcet, C. Aran, C. Graff, Y. Moreau-Le Golvan, and I. Hebe (2006). "Methane mass balance at three landfill sites: What is the efficiency of capture by gas collection systems?" Waste Management 26(5) pp516-525.
[10] S. Manfredi, T.H. Christensen, H. Scharff and J. Jacobs (2010). "Environmental assessment of low-organic waste landfill scenarios by means of life-cycle assessment modelling (Easewaste)." Waste Management & Research 28(2) pp. 130-140.
[11] IPCC (2000). Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). Good Practice Guidance and Uncertainty Management in National Greenhouse Gas Inventories. Chapter 5 Waste Section. Montreal. Accessed from: http://www.ipccnggip.iges.or.jp/public/gp/english/ (access date: 1st December 2016)
[12] M. Ritzkowski and R. Stegmann, (2010). "Generating CO2-credits through landfill in situ aeration." Waste Management 30(4) pp. 702-706.
[13] R. Couth, C. Trois, J. Parkin, L.J. Strachan, A. Gilder and M. Wright, (2011). "Delivery and viability of landfill gas CDM projects in Africa-A South African experience." Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 15(1) pp. 392-403.
[14] F.J. Maciel and J.F.T. Juca, (2011). "Evaluation of landfill gas production and emissions in a MSW large-scale Experimental Cell in Brazil." Waste Management 31(5) pp. 966-977.
[15] UNFCCC (1998). United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Kyoto Protocol Article 12. http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/convkp/kpeng.pdf
[16] Sathaye, J., Murtishaw, S., Price, L., Lefranc, M., Roy, J., Winkler, H. and SpaidingFecher, R. (2004). "Multiproject baselines for evaluation of electric power projects." Energy Policy 32(11): 1303-1317.
[17] E.H. Rau, R.J. Alaimo, P.C. Ashbrook, S.M. Austin, N. Borenstein, M.R. Evans, H.M. French, R.W. Gilpin, J. Hughes, S.J. Hummel, A.P. Jacobsohn, C.Y. Lee, S. Merkle, T. Radzinski, R. Sloane, K.D. Wagner and L.E. Weaner (2000). "Minimization and management of wastes from biomedical research." Environmental Health Perspectives 108 pp. 953-977.
[18] T. Kerr, R. Morgan, J. Haydel. And B. Thapa, (2002). Average Displaced Emissions Rate (ADER): Approach and Methodology. http://www.epa.gov/ttnchie1/conference/ei11/poster/morgan.pdf (access date: 1st December 2016)
[19] S. Sharma and R.M. Shrestha (2006). "Baseline for electricity sector CDM projects: Simplifying estimation of operating margin emission factor." Energy Policy 34(18) pp 4093-4102.
[20] T. Lelyveld and P. Woods (2010). Carbon emission factors for fuels –Methodology and values for 2013 & 2016. http://www.zerocarbonhub.org (access date: 21st December 2016)
[21] Wallis, T. (2010). Personal Communication. Mr Wallis is a project manager for Hydroclave Systems Corp. Ltd, Kingston, Ontario, Canada
[22] Moynihan, M. (2010). Personal Communication Mr Moynihan is a general manager for Incinco Limited, Welwyn, Hertfordshire, UK.
[23] K. Fisher, M. Collins, S. Aumônier, B. Gregory (2006). Carbon Balances and Energy Impacts of the Management of UK Wastes. Defra R&D Project WRT 237. http://randd.defra.gov.uk/ (access date: 21st December 2016)