Mobile Learning in Developing Countries: A Synthesis of the Past to Define the Future

Authors: Harriet Koshie Lamptey, Richard Boateng

Abstract:

Mobile learning (m-learning) is a novel approach to knowledge acquisition and dissemination and is gaining global attention. Steady progress in wireless technologies and the portability of communication devices continue to broaden the scope and use of mobiles. With the convergence of Web functionality onto mobile platforms and the affordability and availability of mobile technology, m-learning has the potential of being the next prevalent channel of education in both formal and informal settings. There is substantive literature on developed countries but the state in developing countries (DCs) however appears vague. This paper is a synthesis of extant literature on mobile learning in DCs. The research interest is based on the fact that in DCs, mobile communication and internet connectivity are popular. However, its use in education is under explored. There are some reviews on the state, conceptualizations, trends and teacher education, but to the authors’ knowledge, no study has focused on mobile learning adoption and integration issues. This study examines issues and gaps associated with its adoption and integration in DCs higher education institutions. A qualitative build-up of literature was conducted using articles pooled from electronic databases (Google Scholar and ERIC). To enable criteria for inclusion and incorporate diverse study perspectives, search terms used were m-learning, DCs, higher education institutions, challenges, benefits, impact, gaps and issues. The synthesis revealed that though mobile technology has diffused globally, its pedagogical pursuit in DCs remains quite low. The absence of a mobile Web and the difficulty of resource conversion into mobile format due to lack of funding and technical competence is a stumbling block. Again, the lack of established design and implementation rules to guide the development of m-learning platforms in DCs is a hindrance. The absence of access restrictions on devices poses security threats to institutional systems. Negative perceptions that devices are taking over faculty roles lead to resistance in some situations. Resistance to change can be a hindrance to the acceptance and success of new systems. Lack of interest for m-learning is also attributed to lower technological literacy levels of the underprivileged masses. Scholarly works on m-learning in DCs is yet to mature. Most technological innovations are handed down from developed countries, and this constantly creates a lag for DCs. Lack of theoretical grounding was also identified which reduces the objectivity of study reports. The socio-cultural terrain of DCs results in societies with different views and needs that have been identified as a hindrance to research. Institutional commitment decisions, adequate funding for the necessary infrastructural development as well as multiple stakeholder participation is important for project success. Evidence suggests that while adoption decisions are readily made, successful integration of the concept for its full benefits to be realized is often neglected. Recommendations to findings were made to provide possible remedies to identified issues.

Keywords: Developing countries, higher education institutions, mobile learning, literature review.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1129069

References:

[1] Y. M Huang; P. S. Chiu; T. C. Liu & T. S. Chen, “The Design and Implementation of a meaningful Learning-based Evaluation method for Ubiquitous Learning.” Computers & Education, 57(4), 2291- 2302, 2011.
[2] A. Kukulska-Hulme, “Will Mobile Learning Change Language Learning?” ReCALL, 21(02), 157-165, 2009.
[3] K. Peters, (2009), “M-Learning: Positioning Educators for a Mobile Connected Future.” The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 8(2), 2009.
[4] S. Gulati, “Technology-enhanced Learning in Developing Nations: A Review. “The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 9(1), 2008.
[5] M. Ravallion, “Troubling Tradeoffs in the Human Development Index.” Journal of Development Economics, 99(2), 201- 209, 2012.
[6] W. Bank Report, “Global Trends in ICT and Education.” 2011. (Accessed on 10/12/2014) from http://www.worldbank.org/edutech/ 10-global-trends-in-ict-and-education
[7] W. Bank Report, “Surveying the Use of Mobile phones in Education Worldwide.” 2009. (Accessed on 5/09/2014) from http://www.worldbank.org/edutech/surveying-theme of mobile phones in education worldwide.
[8] U. Imtinan, V. Chang & T. Issa, T. “Characteristics of Mobile Learning Environments in Developing Countries. International Journal of Learning, 18, (5), 2012.
[9] G. M. Statistics, “Part A: Mobile Subscribers Worldwide.” 2014. (Accessed on 11/05/ 2014) from http://mobithinking.com/mobile-marketing-tools/ latest-mobile-stats /a#subscribers
[10] T. A. Koszalka & G. S. Ntloedibe‐Kuswani, “Literature on the Safe and Disruptive Learning Potential of Mobile Technologies. Distance Education, 31(2), 139-157, 2010.
[11] D. D. Minner, A. J. Levy & J. Century, “Inquiry- based Science Instruction- What is it and does it matter? Results from a Research Synthesis years 1984 to 2002.” Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 47(4), 474- 496, 2010.
[12] D. Bozdogan, D, “MALL Revisited: Current Trends and Pedagogical Implications.” Procedia- Social and Behavioral Sciences, 12(5), 932- 939, 2015.
[13] Y. C. Hsu & Y. H. Ching, “A Review of Models and Frameworks for Designing Mobile Learning Experiences and Environments.” Canadian Journal of Learning and Technology, 2015.
[14] E. Baran, “A Review of Research on Mobile Learning in Teacher Education.” Educational Technology & Society, 17(4), 17- 32, 2014.
[15] J. Dankasa, “Examining the Progression of Mobile Technologies and their Applications to Learning Environment: Implications for M-learning in Africa.” International Journal of Research Studies in Educational Technology, 3(2), 2014.
[16] J. L. Hung & K. Zhang, “Examining Mobile Learning Trends 2003–2008: A Categorical Meta-Trend Analysis using Text Mining Techniques.” Journal of Computing in Higher education, 24(1), 1- 17, 2012.
[17] G. J. Hwang & P. H. Wu, “Applications, Impacts and Trends of Mobile Technology-enhanced Learning: A Review of 2008–2012 Publications in selected SSCI Journals.” International Journal of Mobile Learning and Organization, 8(2), 83- 95, 2014.
[18] W. H. Wu, Y. C. J. Wu, C. Y. Chen, H. Y. Kao, C. H. Lin & S. H. Huang, “Review of Trends from Mobile Learning Studies: A Meta-Analysis.” Computers & Education, 59(2), 817- 827, 2012
[19] G. J. Hwang & C. C. Tsai, “Research Trends in Mobile and Ubiquitous Learning: A Review of Publications in selected Journals from 2001 to 2010.” British Journal of Educational Technology, 42(4), 65- 70, 2011.
[20] Y. C. Hsu & Y. H. Ching, “Mobile Computer‐supported Collaborative Learning: A Review of Experimental Research.” British Journal of Educational Technology, 44(5), 111- 114, 2013.
[21] H. Suri & D. Clarke, "Advancements in Research Synthesis Methods: From a methodologically Inclusive Perspective.” Review of Educational Research, 79(1), 395- 430, 2009.
[22] M. Sharples, “Methods for evaluating mobile learning.” Researching mobile learning: Frameworks, tools and research designs, 17- 39, 2009.
[23] A. Kukulska-Hulme, M. Sharples, M. Milrad, I. Arnedillo-Sánchez & G. Vavoula, “Innovation in Mobile Learning: A European Perspective.” International Journal of Mobile and Blended Learning (IJMBL), 1(1), 13-35. 2009.
[24] S. Wexler, J. Brown, D. Metcalf & E. Wagner, “The E-Learning Guild report on Mobile Learning,” 2008. Accessed (18/05/2010) from: http://www.elearningguild.com/research/archives/index.cfm?id=132&action=viewonly
[25] M. Kearney, S. Schuck, K. Burden & P. Aubusson, “Viewing Mobile Learning from a Pedagogical Perspective.” Research in learning technology, 20, 2012.
[26] D. Frohberg, C. Göth, & G. Schwabe, “Mobile Learning Projects: A Critical Analysis of the State of the Art.” Journal of computer assisted learning, 25(4), 307- 331, 2009.
[27] H. Peng, Y. J. Su, C. Chou & C. C. Tsai, "Ubiquitous Knowledge Construction: Mobile Learning Re‐defined and a Conceptual Framework.” Innovations in Education and Teaching International, 46(2), 171- 183, 2009.
[28] H. Crompton, “A Historical overview of Mobile Learning: Towards Learner-centered Education.” Handbook of mobile learning, 3- 14, 2013.
[29] T.H. Brown & L. S. Mbati, “Mobile Learning: Moving past the Myths and embracing the Opportunities. The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 16(2), 2015.
[30] V. Sridharan, “An Analysis of Socio-Technical Factors in Implementing Mobile Learning Solution at an Educational Institution: A Case Study of Mid-Tier MBA College in India. QScience Proceedings, 2013.
[31] F. C. Obodoeze, F. A. Okoye, C. N. Mba, S.C. Asogwa & F. E. Ozioko, “A Holistic Mobile Security Framework for Nigeria.” International Journal of Innovative Technology an Exploring Engineering (IJITEE), 2(3), 1- 11, 2013.
[32] Z. Du & T.C. Lin, “A Novel Adaptive Fuzzy Control Approach for Uncertain Multivariable Nonlinear Systems with Time Delays.” International Journal of Advancements in Computing Technology, 4(1), 2012.
[33] J. Wishart & D. Green, “Identifying Emerging Issues in Mobile Learning in Further and Higher Education. A Report to JISC, 2010. Accessed on 5/10/2010: 2014
[34] Y. Park, “A Pedagogical Framework for Mobile Learning: Categorizing Educational Applications of Mobile Technologies into Four types." The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 12(2), 78- 102, 2011.
[35] W. S. Shin & M. Kang, “The use of a Mobile Learning Management System at an On-line University and its Effect on Learning Satisfaction and Achievement.” The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 16(3), 2015.
[36] E. Bass-Fimmons & W. Kinuthia, “Mobile Learning in Ghana: A Content Analysis of YouTube Videos promoting Teacher Development Opportunities within Higher Education,” 2015. Accessed (15/04/2015) from: transform2015.net/live/Resources/Papers/Mobile%20Learning
[37] J. S. Mtebe & R. Raisamo, “Investigating Students' Behavioral Intention to Adopt and use Mobile Learning in Higher Education in East Africa.” International Journal of Education and Development using Information and Communication Technology, 10(3), 4, 2014.
[38] M. Alrasheedi & L. F. Capretz, “Determination of Critical Success Factors Affecting Mobile Learning: A Meta-Analysis Approach.” TOJET: The Turkish Online Journal of Educational Technology, 14(2), 2015.
[39] G. Adedoja, O. Adelore, F. Egbokhare & A. Oluleye, “Learners’ Acceptance of the use of Mobile phones to deliver Tutorials in a Distance Learning Context: A Case Study at the University of Ibadan.” The African Journal of Information Systems, 5(3), 3, 2013.
[40] D. S. Al Hamdani, “Mobile learning: A Good Practice.” Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 103, 665- 674, 2013.
[41] J. Cheon, S. Lee, S. M. Crooks & J. Song, “An Investigation of Mobile Learning readiness in Higher Education based on the Theory of Planned Behavior.” Computers & Education, 59(3), 1054- 1064, 2012.
[42] C. K. Looi, P. Seow, B. Zhang, H. J. So, W. Chen, W & L. H. Wong, “Leveraging Mobile Technology for Sustainable Seamless Learning: A Research Agenda.” British Journal of Educational Technology, 41(2), 154-169, 2010.
[43] A. Ramli, I. B. Ismail & R. M. Idrus, “Mobile Learning via SMS among Distance Learners: Does Learning Transfer Occur?” International Journal of Interactive Mobile Technologies (iJIM), 4(3), 30- 35, 2010.
[44] P. Kim, E. Buckner, H. Kim, T. Makany, N. Taleja & V. Parikh, “A Comparative Analysis of a Game-based Mobile Learning Model in low-Socioeconomic Communities of India.” International Journal of Educational Development, 32(2), pp. 329- 340, 2012.
[45] A. Kumar, A. Tewari, G. Shroff, D. Chittamuru, M. Kam & J. Canny, “An Exploratory Study of unsupervised Mobile Learning in Rural India.” In Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems. 743-752, 2010.
[46] E. Soleimani, K. Ismail & R. Mustaffa, “The Acceptance of Mobile Assisted Language Learning among Post Graduate ESL students in UKM.” Procedia- Social and Behavioral Sciences, 118, 457- 462, 2014.
[47] W. U. Hassan, M. T. Nawaz, T. H. Syed, M. I. Arfeen, A. Naseem & S. Noor, “Investigating Students' Behavioral Intention towards Adoption of Mobile Learning in Higher Education Institutions of Pakistan.” University of Engineering and Technology Taxila. Technical Journal, 20(3), 34, 2015.
[48] A. Abu-Al-Aish & S. Love, “Factors influencing Students’ Acceptance of M-learning: An investigation in Higher Education.” The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 14(5), 2013”
[49] T. D. Thomas, L. Singh & K. Gaffar, "The Utility of the UTAUT Model in explaining Mobile Learning Adoption in Higher Education in Guyana.” International Journal of Education and Development using Information and Communication Technology, 9(3), 71, 2013.
[50] A. B. Nassuora, “Students Acceptance of Mobile Learning for Higher Education in Saudi Arabia.” American Academic & Scholarly Research Journal, 4(2), 1, 2012.
[51] A. K. M. Almasri, Readiness and Mobile Learning Process for Higher Education Students in Jordanian Universities.” ZENITH International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research, 5(1), 85- 96, 2015.
[52] S. Iqbal & I. A. Qureshi, “M-learning Adoption: A Perspective from a Developing Country.” The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 13(3), 147-164, 2012.
[53] W. P. Mtega, R. Bernard, A. C. Msungu & R. Sanare, “Using Mobile phones for Teaching and Learning Purposes in Higher Learning Institutions: The case of Sokoine University of Agriculture in Tanzania.” UbuntuNet-Connect 2012 Promoting regional Research and Education Collaboration, 118, 2012.
[54] H. C. Chu, “Potential Negative Effects of Mobile Learning on Students' Learning Achievement and Cognitive Load: A Format Assessment Perspective.” Educational Technology & Society, 17(1), 332- 344, 2014.
[55] K. F. Hashim, F. B. Tan & A. Rashid, “Adult learners' Intention to Adopt Mobile Learning: A motivational Perspective.” British Journal of Educational Technology, 46(2), 381-390, 2015.
[56] S. Al- Shehri, “Connectivism: A New Pathway for Theorizing and Promoting Mobile Language Learning.” International Journal of Innovation and Leadership in the Teaching of Humanities, 1(2), 10- 31, 2011.
[57] M. Wang & R. Shen, “Message design for mobile learning: Learning Theories, Human Cognition and Design Principles.” British Journal of Educational Technology, 43(4), 561- 575, 2012.
[58] L. H. Wong & C. K. Looi, “What Seams do we remove in Mobile-assisted Seamless Learning? A Critical Review of the Literature.” Computers & Education, 57(4), 2364- 2381, 2011.
[59] Y. M. Huang, Y. T. Lin & S. C. Cheng, “Effectiveness of a Mobile Plant Learning System in a Science Curriculum in Taiwanese elementary education.” Computers & Education, 54(1), 47- 58, 2010.
[60] N. M. Suki, & N. M. Suki, “The Usage of Mobile Devices for Learning: A Case Study. IJUTFD (2010), 1(1), 1-11, 2010.
[61] A. Z. Klein, J. C. da Silva Freitas, V. Barbosa & J. Luis, “M-learning in Practice: Using SMS for Teaching and Learning in Undergraduate Courses.” Latin America Transactions, IEEE (Revista IEEE America Latina), 13(1), 321- 329, 2015.
[62] O. A. Santana L. R. T. & Peixoto, “Student Perspectives about Mobile Learning initiatives at Open University of Brazil: The Mobile Phone Issue.” Acta Scientiarum. Education, 32(2), 219- 223, 2010.
[63] S. Swaffield, S. Jull & A. Ampah-Mensah, “Using Mobile phone texting to support the Capacity of School Leaders in Ghana to Practice Leadership for Learning. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 103, 1295-1302, 2013.
[64] S. A. Shonola & M. Joy, “Security of m-learning system: A collective responsibility. International Journal of Interactive Mobile Technologies (iJIM), 9(3), 64-70, 2015.
[65] R. Nath, L. Chen & H. N. Muyingi, “An Empirical Study of the Factors that influence in-class Digital Distraction among University Students: A US–Namibia cross-cultural study.” Information Resources Management Journal (IRMJ), 28(4), 1- 18, 2015.
[66] L. M. Semali & T. L. Asino, “Post- literacy in the Digital Age: The use of Mobile phones to Support Literacy Practices in Namibia and Tanzania.” Prospects, 44(1), 81- 97, 2014.
[67] C. Scharff, J. M. Preira, R. Kay & S. H. Su, “Teaching Mobile Solution Development in a Global Context: Comparing Solutions proposed by Students in the Developed and Developing world.” In Frontiers in Education Conference (FIE), 2011 (pp. S1G-1), 2011.
[68] S. Motlik, “Mobile Learning in Developing Nations.” The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 9(2), 2008.
[69] M. Sharples, "Mobile Learning: Research, Practice and Challenges.” Distance Education in China, 3(5), 5- 11, 2013.
[70] C. Russell & Q. Jing, “Evaluating an Institutional Blended and Mobile Learning Strategy.” In Proceedings of ASCILITE, 2013.
[71] O. Morawczynski, “Exploring the Usage and Impact of “Transformational” Mobile Financial Services: The case of M-PESA in Kenya." Journal of Eastern African Studies, 3(3), 509-525, 2009.
[72] J. Traxler, “Mobile learning: Shaping the frontiers of Learning Technologies in Global Context.” In Reshaping Learning (pp. 237-251). Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2013.
[73] U. A. Ajidagba, A. Yusuf, & C. O. Olumorin, “Integrating Mobile Learning to achieve Effective Implementation of Nomadic Education Program in Nigeria.” African Journal of Historical Sciences in Education, 6(1), 2011.
[74] I. M. Santos, “Integrating Personal Mobile Devices in Teaching: The Impact on Student Learning and Institutional Support.” Learning and Teaching in Higher Education: Gulf Perspectives, 10(2), 2013.