The Ethio-Eritrea Claims Commission on Use of Force: Issue of Self-Defense or Violation of Sovereignty

Authors: Isaias Teklia Berhe

Abstract:

A decision that deals with international disputes, be it arbitral or judicial, has to properly reflect objectivity and coherence with existing rules of international law. This paper shows the decision of the Ethio-Eritrea Claims Commission on the jus ad bellum case is bereft of objectivity and coherence, which contributed a disservice to international law on many aspects. The Commission’s decision that holds Eritrea in contravention to Art 2(4) of the UN Charter based on Ethiopia’s contention is flawed. It fails to consider: the illegitimacy of an actual authority established over contested territory through hostile acts, the proper determination of effectivites under international law, the sanctity of colonially determined boundaries, Ethiopia’s prior firm political recognition and undergirds to respect colonial boundary, and Ethio-Eritrea Border Commission’s decision. The paper will also argue that the Commission confused Eritrea’s right of self-defense with the rule against the non-use of force to settle territorial disputes; wherefore its decision sanitizes or sterilizes unlawful change of territory resulted through unlawful use of force to the effect of advantaging aggressions. The paper likewise argues that the decision is so sacrilegious that it disregards the ossified legal finality of colonial boundaries. Moreover, its approach toward armed attack does not reflect the peculiarity of the jus ad bellum case rather it brings about definitional uncertainties and sustains the perception that the law on self-defense is unsettled.

Keywords: Armed attack, self-defense, territorial integrity, use of force.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1125763

References:

[1] Paul H. Robinson and Adil Ahmad Haque, Advantaging Aggressors: Justice and Deterrence in International Law (2011) 3 Harvard National Security Journal, 143, available from www.harvardnsj.org/wp-content/uploads/vol.-3Robinson_haquel.pdf.
[2] Eritrea-Ethiopia Claims Commission, Partial Award Jus ad bellum (Ethiopia’s Claims 1-8) Between the Federal Republic of Ethiopia and the State of Eritrea, The Hague, December 19, 2005, available from www.pca-cpa.org/showfile.asp?fil_id=158 (last visited May 2014).
[3] Christine Gray, The Eri-Ethiopian Claims Commission Oversteps its Boundaries: A Partial Award? (2006) 17(4) European Journal of International Law, 699, available from www.ejil.org/pdfs/17/4/96.pdf.
[4] Sean D murphy, The Jus Ad Bellum and the Initiation of the1998 Eri-Ethiopia War, (forthcoming Oxford press) (2012) George Washington University Law School, available from www.papers.ssrn.com/so13/papers.cfm?Abstract_d=2045791.
[5] Hilaire McCoubrey and Nigel D White, International Law and Armed Conflict (Dartmouth Publishing Company, 1992).
[6] W. H. Riesman, ‘Allocating Competences to Use Coercion in the Post-Cold War World,’ in Lori Fisler Damrosch & David J. Scheffer (eds), Law and Force in the New International Order (Westview Press; American Society of International Law).
[7] Carsten Stahn, Jus ad bellum’, ‘jus in bello’…‘jus post bellum’? Rethinking the Conception of the Law of Armed Force (2007) 17(5) The European Journal of International Law, 921, available from www.ejil.org/pdfs/17/5/111.pdf.
[8] Christen Gray, ‘the Use of force and the International Legal Order’, in Malcolm D. Evans (ed), International Law (Oxford University Press, 2003).
[9] Charter of the United Nations Charter, available from https://www.un.org/en/documents/charter/‎ (visited 3 August 2013).
[10] Anthony Clark Arend and Robert J. Beck, International Law and the use of Force (Routledge publishing, 1993) at 51.
[11] Christopher Greenwood, International Law and the Pre-emptive Use of Force: Afghanistan, Al-Qaida, and Iraq, (2003) 4 San Diego International Law Journal, 7 available from www.peacepalacelibrary.nl/plinklet/index.php?sid=related&pp
[12] Albrecht Randelzhofer: Article 2(4), in Bruno Simma (ed), The Charter of the United Nations, A Commentary (Oxford University Press, 1994).
[13] Oscar Schachter, International Law in Theory and Practice (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1991).
[14] Independent International Fact-Finding Mission on the Conflict in Georgia, Volume II, 2009, at 172, available from http://www.ceiig.ch/pdf/IIFFMCG_Volume_II.pdf
[15] Malcolm Shaw, International Law, 6th Ed (Cambridge University Press, 2008).
[16] Eustace Chikere Azubuike, Probing the Scope of Self Defense in International Law (2011) XVII Annual Survey of International & Comparative Law, available from www.digitalcommons.law.ggu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article.
[17] Leung Fiona Nga Woon, Resolving the conundrums in Articles 2(4) and 51 of the Charter of the United Nations–A Matter of Treaty Interpretation, In Memory of Sir Ian Brownlie (1932-2010) available from http://lbms03.cityu.edu.hk/oaps/slw2010-4635-lnw806.pdf
[18] Rene Vark, The Use of Force in Modern Work: Recent Developments and Legal Regulations of the Use of Force, (2003) 2(10) Baltic Defense Review, 23 available from www.bdcol.ee/files/docs/bdreview/bdr-2003-10-sections2-articles2.pdf.
[19] United Nations Declaration on Principles of International Law concerning Friendly Relations and Cooperation Among States in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations, adopted by the General Assembly on 24 October 1970 (resolution 2625 (XXV)), available from www.legal.un.org/avl/ha/dpilfrcscun/dpilfrcscun.html.
[20] Dino Kritsiotis, When States Use Armed Force, in Christian Reus-Smit (ed) The Politics of International Law, (Cambridge University Press, 2004) 45-79.
[21] Sean D Murphy, Principles of International Law (Thomson West, 2006), at 446.
[22] Tyler B Musselman, Skirmishing for Information: The Flaws of the International Legal System as Evidenced by the Russian-Georgian Conflict of 2008, (2010) 19 Transnational Law & Contemporary Problems, 318, available from www.uiowa.edu/.../musselman.finalfinal.mlb.022710
[23] Yoram Dinstein, War, Aggression and Self-Defense, (Cambridge; Cambridge University Press, 3rd ed 2003).
[24] The 1974 Declaration on the Definition of Aggression, General Assembly Resolution (No. 3314) Adopted: By the United Nations in 14 December 1974, available from www1.umn.edu/humanrts/instree/GAres3314.html (visited 3 August 2013).
[25] Alemseged Tesfai, The Cause of the Eritrean-Ethiopian Border Conflict, available from www.dehai.org/conflict/analysis/alemsghed1.html. (last visited on 21 January 2016)
[26] The Origin and the Development of Border Crises between Eritrea and Ethiopia,’ Prepared by Eritrea Center for Strategic Studies, July 1998.
[27] Michael Tekie, Legitimate Military Objective under the Laws of War; the case of Hirgigo Power Station Bombardment as Decided By the Eri-Ethiopia Claims Commission, (LLB thesis on file at Faculty of Law, University of Asmara, 2007) at 40.
[28] Agreement on Cessation of Hostilities between the Federal Republic Government of Ethiopia and The State of Eritrea, available from www.refworld.org/pdfid/4a54bbecd.pdf. (last visited 24 March 2015 )
[29] Agreement between the Governments of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia And The Government Of The State Of Eritrea (Algiers Agreement), available from www.pca-cpa.org/showfile.asp?fil_id=138 (last visited March 2016)
[30] Eritrea-Ethiopia Claims Commission-Preliminary Decisions, decision number 1 of august 2001, The Commission’s mandate/Temporal scope of Jurisdiction (Reports of International Arbitral Awards: United Nations, 2009), available from www.legal.un.org/riaa/cases/vol_XXVI/1-22.pdf‎ (visited 27 August 2013).
[31] Andrew Byrnes and Gabrielle Simm, Peoples’ Tribunals: International Law and the Use of Force, (2013) 36 UNSW Law Journal, 715, available from www.ahrcentre.org/topics/peoples’-tribunals-and-international-law.
[32] Malcolm Shaw, Title to Territory in Africa: International Legal Issues (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1986).
[33] Andebrhan Weldegiorgis, A Commentary: ‘Border and Territorial Conflicts Between Eritrea and Ethiopia’: Background, facts and Prospects (2004) 4 Eritrean Studies Review, 160 available from www.dehai.org/conflict/.../Andebrhan_Weldegiorgis_border_and_territo
[34] Francis Nguendi Ikome, ‘Africa’s International Borders as Potential Sources Of Conflict, (2012) Institute for Security Studies, 233, available from www.mercury.ethz.ch/serviceengine/Files/ISN/145411/.../Paper_233.pdf,
[35] Kalewongel Minale Gedamu, Ethiopia and Eritrea: The Quest for Peace and Normalisations: Thesis Submitted for the Degree of Master of Philosophy in Peace and Conflict Transformation (Faculty of Social Sciences University of Tromsø, Norway) available from www.munin.uit.no/bitstream/handle/10037/.../Thesis.pdf
[36] David Shine, ‘let’s bring Eritrean in from cold, but it is harder than it sound’, 2014, available from http://africanarguments.org/2014/01/13time-to-bring-eritrea-in-from-cold-but-its-harder-than-it-sounds-by-david-shinn/. (visited 14 February 2014)
[37] Simulation on Conflict Prevention in the Greater Horn of Africa, United States Institute of Peace, availble from www.usip.org/sites/default/files/africza.pdf (visited 20 January 2014)
[38] Richard Reid, Old Problems in New Conflicts: Some Observations on Eritrea and Its Relations with Tigray, From Liberation Struggle to Inter-State War, (2003) 73(3) Journal of the International African Institute, 369, available from http://www.jstor.org/stable/3556909.
[39] Kevin Hamilton, Beyond the Border War: the Ethio-Eritrean Conflict and International Mediation Efforts, available from www.princeton.edu/jpia/past-issues-1/.../7.p (visited 20 January 2014).
[40] Margaret Fielding, Bad Times in Badme: Bitter Warfare Continues along the Eritrea-Ethiopia Border, (1999) IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin, available from www.dur.ac.uk/resources/ibru/publications/full/bsb7-1_fielding.pdf
[41] Ruth Iyob, The Ethiopian–Eritrean Conflict: Diasporic vs. Hegemonic States in the Horn of Africa, (2000) 38(4) The Journal of Modern African Studies, 659, available from www.jstor.org/stable/161513
[42] ‘Weyin’, Official Gazette of Ethiopia, 22nd year, No. 267, printed on 12th October1990 of the Ethiopian Calendar (October 1997 of Gregorian Calendar).
[43] Jon Stephenson Eritrea and Ethiopia A Continued Conflict, available from www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/war/eritrea.html (visited 14 January 2014).
[44] Fiction Vs Fiction: The Dueling Ethiopian Stories, 1999, available from www.denden.com/Conflict/newscom/fiction_vs_fiction.html (visited 14 February 2014)
[45] Research and Documentation Center of Eritrea (RDCE), ‘Ethiopia War on Eritrea’ (Sabur printing Service, Asmara Eritrea)
[46] Hans van der Splinter, Background to border dispute between Eritrea and Ethiopia, available from www.eritrea.be/old/eritrea-ethiopia.htm. (visited 3 August 2014)
[47] New Map of Tigray, available from www.eritrea.be/old/greater-tigray.jpg (visited on 3 August 2014).
[48] Judge Abdulqawi A Yusuf, Separate Opinion, Frontier Dispute (Burkina Faso V. Niger) available from www.legal.un.org/ICJsummaries/documents/english/197_e.pdf (last visited 14 September 2015).
[49] Markus Kornprobst, The Management of Border Disputes in African Regional Sub-Systems: Comparing West Africa and the Horn of Africa, 40(3) The Journal of Modern African Studies, 369 (2002).
[50] Richard M. Trivelli, ‘Divided Histories-Opportunistic Alliances: Background Notes on the Ethiopian-Eritrean War,’ (1998) 33(3) Institute of African Affairs at GIGA Hamburg, 257, at 287, available from www.jstor.org/stable/40174776
[51] Leenco Lata, The Ethiopia-Eritrea War (2003) 30(97) Review of African Political Economy, 369, available from www.jstor.org/stable/4006982.
[52] Organisation of African Union, AHG/Res. 16(I), Border Disputes Among African States: ‘The assembly of Heads of State and Government meeting in its First Ordinary Session in Cairo, UAR,’ (17-21 July 1964) available from www.au.int/.../ASSEMBLY_EN_17_21_JULY_1964_AS... (last visited 12 January 2015)
[53] Leenco Lata (ed), The Search for Peace: The Conflict between Ethiopia and Eritrea, Proceedings of Scholarly Conference held on the Ethiopia and Eritrea Conflict, (Fafo-report, 2007).
[54] Eritrea-Ethiopia Claims Commission, Partial Award, Central Front Ethiopia’s Claim 2, available from www.pca-cpa.org/showfile.asp?fil_id (last visited 27 May 2015)
[55] Eritrea-Ethiopia Border Commission (EEBC) Decision, available from www.refworld.org/pdfid/4a54bbec0.pdf
[56] Eritrea- Ethiopia Boundary Commission Observations, available from http://legal.un.org/riaa/cases/vol_XXV/216-224.pdf (accessed 20 September 2013).
[57] Nejib Jibril, The Binding Dilemma: From Bakassi to Badme-Making States Comply with Territorial Decisions of International Judicial Bodies (2003) 19(3) American University International Law Review, 633, available from www.digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/.../viewco ‎
[58] Jon Abbink, Badme and the Ethio-Eritrean Border: The Challenge of Demarcation in the Post-War Period (2003) 228, available from https://openaccess.leidenuniv.nl/bitstream/handle/1887/9474/ASC_1242160_002.pdf?sequence=1
[59] Natalia Ochoa-Ruiz and Esther Salamanca-Aguado, Exploring the Limits of International Law relating to the use of Force in Self-defense (2005) 16(3) European Journal of International Law, 499, available from www.ejil.org/pdfs/16/3/306.pdf‎
[60] André de Hoogh, Georgia’s Short-Lived Military Excursion into South Ossetia: The Use of Armed Force and Self-Defense, (2009) European Journal of International Law Reports, available from www.ejiltalk.org/georgia%E2%80%99s-short-lived-military-excursion-into-south-ossetia-the-use-of-armed-force-and-self-defence/
[61] Wondwosen Teshome, Colonial Boundaries of Africa: The Case of Ethiopia’s Boundary with Sudan: (2009) 9(1) Ege Ege Academic Review, 337, available from www.papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract
[62] Ramtane Lamamra, ‘Foreword’, Delimitation and Demarcation of Boundaries in Africa: General Issues and Case Studies, (2013) Commission of the African Union, Department of Peace and Security, available from www.peaceau.org/.../au2013-en-delim-a-demar-of-bound-gen-iss-a-studi... (accessed 6 March 2014)
[63] Annette Weber, Boundaries with Issues: Soft Border Management as a Solution? (2012) Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung: Africa Department, 2, available from www.library.fes.de/pdf-files/iez/08869.pdf ‎
[64] A Complied Statements of Issued by the Governments of Eritrea and Ethiopia in the Border Dispute, Eritrean Ministry of Foreign Affairs Press Release Asmara, May 15, May 20 and June 19, 1998
[65] John Donaldson, ‘Executive Summary’, in Delimitation and Demarcation of Boundaries in Africa: General Issues and Case Studies, (2013) Commission of the African Union, Department of Peace and Security 25, available from www.peaceau.org/.../au2013-en-delim-a-demar-of-bound-gen-iss-a-studi...
[66] Philip White, The Eritrea-Ethiopia Border Arbitration, (2002) 29(92) Review of African Political Economy, 345, available from www.jstor.org/stable/4006821
[67] Malcolm N Shaw, Peoples Territorialism and Boundaries, (1997) 3 European Journal of International Law 478, available from www.ejil.org/pdfs/8/3/1457.pdf
[68] Eyal Benvenisti, the International Law of Occupation (Princeton University Press, 1993).
[69] Victor Kattan, Israel, Hezbollah and the Conflict in Lebanon: An Act of Aggression or Self-Defense? 29, available from www.wcl.american.edu/hrbrief/.../1kattan.pdf
[70] International Law Association: ‘Final Report on the Meaning of Armed Conflict in International Law,’ (2010) The Hague Conference Use of Force, available from www.ilahq.org/en/committees/index.cfm/cid/1022‎ (last visited 17 December 2014)
[71] Bonnie K. Holcomb and Sisai Ibssa, the Invention of Ethiopia, the making of a Dependent Colonial State in Northeast Africa (Red Sea Press 1990).
[72] Abdulrahman Mohammed Babu, The Eritrean Question in the Context of African Context and Superpower Rivalries, in Lionel Cliffe and Basil Davidson (eds), The long struggle of Eritrea for Independence and Constructive Peace, (The Red Sea Press, Inc, 1988) 47-63.
[73] Bocresion Hail, the Collusion on Eritrea, (Asmara- Sabur Printing Service, 2nd edn 2007).
[74] Chatham House Principles of International Law on Use of Force in Self-Defense, available from www.chatham-house.org.uk/publications/papers/view/-/id/308 (last visited 26 March 2015).
[75] Solon Solomon, The Great Oxymoron: Jus In bello Violations as Legitimate Non-Forcible Measures of Self-Defense: The Post-Disengagement Israeli Measures towards Gaza as a Case Study, available from http://chinesejil.oxfordjournals.org/
[76] Richard N. Gardner, Commentary on the Law of Self-Defense, in Lori Fisler Damrosch and David J. Scheffer (eds), Law and Force in the New International Order (West Review Press, American Society of International Law).
[77] David Kretzmer, The inherent right of self-defense and proportionality (2013) 24(2) European Journal of International Law, 235, available from http://ejil.oxfordjournals.org.
[78] Andrew Arwood-Gowers, Did the ICJ Miss the Boat on the Law on the Use of Force? Case Note—Oil Platforms, (2004) 5 Melbourne Journal of International Law, available from www.law.unimelb.edu.au/.../download...
[79] J. Combacau, the Exception of Self-defense in UN Practice, in Antonio Cassese (ed), The Current Legal Regulation of the Use of Force, (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1986).
[80] Shabtai Rosenne, the Perplexities of Modern International Law, The Hague Academy of International Law (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2004).
[81] See Badme Border War (Eritrean-Ethiopian) 1998, available from www.tachwar.wordpress.com/resources/war-justifications-archive/badme-border-war-eritrean-ethiopian-1998/?blogsub=confirming#subscribe-blog
[82] Richard Reid, Caught in the Headlights of History: Eritrea, the EPLF and the Post-War Nation-State, (2005) 43(3) Journal of Modern African Studies, 467.
[83] Araya Tsegai, the History of Eritrean Struggle, in Lionel Cliffe and Basil Davidson (eds), The long struggle of Eritrea for independence and constructive peace (The Red Sea Press, Inc, 1988) 67-84.
[84] Semere Haile, Historical background to the Ethiopia-Eritrea conflict, in Lionel Cliffe and Basil Davidson (eds), The long struggle of Eritrea for independence and constructive peace (The Red Sea Press, Inc, 1988) 11-31.
[85] Alain Fenet, the Right of Eritrean People to Self-determination, in Lionel Cliffe and Basil Davidson (eds), the Long Struggle of Eritrea for Independence and Constructive Peace (the Red Sea Press Inc. 1988) 33-45.
[86] Okbazghi Yohannes, The Eritrean Question: A Colonial Case (1987) 25 (4) the Journal of Modern African Studies, 643, available from www.jstor.org/stable/160948
[87] Franklin Berman, The UN Charter and the Use of Force (2006) 10 Singapore Year Book of International Law, 9, available from www.commonlii.org/sg/journals/SGYrBkIntLaw/2006/3.pdf
[88] Robert D. Sloane, The Cost of Conflation: Preserving the Dualism of Jus Ad Bellum and Jus In Bello in the contemporary Law of War, (2009) 34 The Yale Journal of International Law, 47, available from www.ajol.ingo/index.php/pelj/article/dawnloads/43467/27002.
[89] Richard Reid, Eritrea’s role and foreign policy in the Horn of Africa: past and present perspectives, in Richard Reid (ed), Eritrea’s External Relations: Understanding Its Regional Role and Foreign Policy, (United Kingdom: Royal Institute of International Affairs, 2009) 10, available from www.chathamhouse.org/publications/books/.../63394