Assessing Efficiency Trends in the Indian Sugar Industry

Authors: S. P. Singh

Abstract:

This paper measures technical and scale efficiencies of 40 Indian sugar companies for the period from 2004-05 to 2013-14. The efficiencies are estimated through input-oriented DEA models using one output variable—value of output (VOP) and five input variables—capital cost (CA), employee cost (EMP), raw material (RW), energy & fuel (E&F) and other manufacturing expenses (OME). The sugar companies are classified into integrated and non-integrated categories to know which one achieves higher level of efficiency. Sources of inefficiency in the industry are identified through decomposing the overall technical efficiency (TE) into pure technical efficiency (PTE) and scale efficiency (SE). The paper also estimates input-reduction targets for relatively inefficient companies and suggests measures to improve their efficiency level. The findings reveal that the TE does not evince any trend rather it shows fluctuations across years, largely due to erratic and cyclical pattern of sugar production. Further, technical inefficiency in the industry seems to be driven more by the managerial inefficiency than the scale inefficiency, which implies that TE can be improved through better conversion of inputs into output.

Keywords: Sugar industry, companies, technical efficiency, data envelopment analysis, targets.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1125439

References:

[1] Arora N and Kumar S., “Does Factor Accumulation or Productivity Change Drive Output Growth in the Indian Sugar Industry? An Inter-state Analysis”, Contemporary Economics, vol. 7 (2), 2013, pp.85-98.
[2] Attwood D W, “Peasants versus Capitalists in the Indian Sugar Industry: The Impact of the Irrigation Frontier”, The Journal of Asian Studies, vol. 45(1), 1985, pp.59-80.
[3] Banker, R. D., A. Charnes and W.W. Cooper, “Some Models for Estimating Technical and Scale Inefficiencies in DEA”, Management Science, vol. 30(9), 1984, pp.1078-1091.
[4] Baru S., “State Intervention in the Sugar Economy during the Regime of Partial Decontrol”, Social Scientist, vol. 6(4), 1977, pp.26-45.
[5] Baru S., State and Industrialisation: Political Economy of Sugar Policy, 1932-47, Economic and Political Weekly, vol. 18 (5), 1983, pp. PE2-PE18.
[6] Borrell, B. and Ronald C. Duncan, “A Survey of the Costs of World Sugar Policies”, The World Bank Research Observer, vol. 7(2), 1992, pp. 171-194.
[7] Care Ratings, Indian Sugar Industry – Bitter Sweetener, 2015 http://www.careratings.com/upload/NewsFiles/SplAnalysis/Indian%20Sugar%20Industry%20-%20An%20Update%20-%20June%202015.pdf
[8] Charnes, A., W.W. Cooper and E.Rhodes, “Measuring the Efficiency of Decision Making Units”, European Journal of Operation Research, vol. 2(6), 1978, pp.429-444.
[9] Coelli, T., D.S.P. Rao and G. E. Battese, An Introduction to Efficiency and Productivity Analysis, Kulwer Academic Publishers, Boston, 1998.
[10] Dawar K. R., “Returns to Scale and Factor Productivity in the Cooperative Sugar Industry in Punjab and Haryana”, Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, vol. 26(2), 1990, pp. 166-174.
[11] Datta, S.K., V.P. Sharma, S.N. Ghosh, P. Sharma, and M. Gandhi, Economic Efficiency of Indian Sugar Industry, CMA Monograph No. 211, Centre for Management in Agriculture, IIM, Ahmedabad, 2003.
[12] Desai, R., “CES Production Function for Indian Sugar Industry and Regional Efficiency”, Anvesak,vol.1(2), 1971, pp. 265-273.
[13] Devadoss, S. and J. Kropf , “Impact of Trade Liberalizations under the Uruguay Round on the World Sugar Market”, Agricultural Economics, vol.15, 1996, pp.83-96.
[14] Ferrantino, M.J. and Ferrier, G.D., “The Technical Efficiency of Vacuum-Pan Sugar Industry of India: An Application of a Stochastic Frontier Production Function Using Panel Data”, European Journal of Operational Research, vol.80 (3), 1995, pp.639-653.
[15] GAIN, “India: Sugar Annual 2015”, Global Agricultural Information Network (GAIN) Reprot No: IN5050, 2015. http://www.liquid-energy.ch/wp/wp-content/uploads/2015-04-21-India-Sugar-Annual.pdf
[16] Government of India, Report of the High-Powered Committee on Sugar Industry (Mahajan Committee), Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food & Public Distribution, Department of Sugar & Edible Oils, New Delhi, 1998.
[17] Government of India, Report of the Committee on Revitalization of Sugar Industry (Tuteja Committee), Ministry of Food, Consumer Affairs & Public Distribution, Department of Food & Public Distribution, New Delhi, 2004.
[18] Government of India, Report of the Committee on the Regulation of Sugar Sector in India: The Way Forward (Rangarajan Committee), New Delhi, 2012.
[19] ISMA, “Government Taking Initiative to Set Sugar Industry Back to Growth Trajectory” 2015. (http://www.indiansugar.com/NewsDetails.aspx?nid=4875)
[20] Jeffrey C., “Caste, Class, and Clientelism: A Political Economy of Everyday Corruption in Rural North India”, Economic Geography, vol.78 (1), 2002, pp.21-41.
[21] Kamath S. J., “Concealed Takings: Capture and Rent-Seeking in the Indian Sugar Industry”, Public Choice, vol.62 (2), 1989, pp.119-138.
[22] KPMG, “The Indian Sugar Industry Sector Roadmap 2017”, 2007. http://www.in.kpmg.com/pdf/indian_sugar_industry.pdf
[23] Kumar A., Sugar Industry and Government Intervention, Economic and Political Weekly, vol.15(40), 1980, pp.1664-1668.
[24] Kumar S and Arora N, “Assessing Technical Efficiency of Sugar Industry in Uttar Pradesh: An Application of Data Envelopment Analysis”, Indian Economic Review, vol.46 (2), 2011, pp.323-353.
[25] Larson, D.F. and B. Borrell, Sugar Policy and Reform, The World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 602, World Bank, 2001.
[26] Mehta, S.S., “Analysis of Sugar Industry-A Production Function Approach”, Anvesak, vol.4 (2), 1974, pp. 197-205.
[27] Mitchell, D., Sugar Policies: Opportunity for Change, The World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 3222, World Bank, 2004.
[28] Oxfam, Dumping on the World: How EU Sugar Policies Hurt Poor Countries, Oxfam Briefing Paper, 2004. http://www.oxfam.org.uk/what_we_do/issues/trade/downloads/bp61_sugar_dumping.pdf
[29] Pursell G. and Gupta A., Trade Policies and Incentives in Indian Agriculture: Background Paper 1 on Sugar and Sugarcane, Policy Research Working Paper No. 1953, The World Bank, 1998.
[30] Rakshit S., “Cost of Protecting India's Sugar Industry”, Economic and Political Weekly, vol.15(20), 1980, pp. 893-899.
[31] Ray S., “Reviewing Performance of Indian Sugar Industry: An Economic Analysis Food Science and Quality Management vol 3, 2013 (online), www.iiste.org
[32] Singh, N.P., Singh, P. and Pal, S., “Estimation of Economic Efficiency of Sugar Industry in Uttar Pradesh: A Frontier Production Function Approach”, Indian Journal of Agriculture Economics, vol. 62(2), 2007, pp.232-243.
[33] Singh, S.P., “Technical and Scale Efficiencies in the Indian Sugar Mills: An Inter-State Comparison”, Asian Economic Review, vol. 48 (1), 2006, pp.87-99.
[34] Singh, S.P., “Performance of Sugar Mills in Uttar Pradesh by Ownership, Size and Location”, Prajnan, vol.34 (4), 2007, pp. 333-360.
[35] Singh, S.P. and Agarwal, S., “Total Factor Productivity Growth, Technical Progress and Efficiency Change in Sugar Industry of Uttar Pradesh”, The Indian Economic Journal, vol. 54(2), 2006, pp.59-82.
[36] Subramanyan, G., “An Inter State Production Study for Indian Sugar Industry: An Econometric Approach”, The Indian Journal of Economics, vol.61, 1980, pp.293-312.
[37] Sukhtankar S., “Sweetening the Deal? Political Connections and Sugar Mills in India”, Applied Economics, vol.4 (3), 2012, pp. 43-63.
[38] http://www.indiastat.com/, Datanet India PVT. Ltd., Mumbai, (accessed on November, 12, 2015 from IIT Roorkee).