Preferences of Electric Buses in Public Transport; Conclusions from Real Life Testing in Eight Swedish Municipalities

Authors: Sven Borén, Lisiana Nurhadi, Henrik Ny

Abstract:

From a theoretical perspective, electric buses can be more sustainable and can be cheaper than fossil fuelled buses in city traffic. The authors have not found other studies based on actual urban public transport in Swedish winter climate. Further on, noise measurements from buses for the European market were found old. The aims of this follow-up study was therefore to test and possibly verify in a real-life environment how energy efficient and silent electric buses are, and then conclude on if electric buses are preferable to use in public transport. The Ebusco 2.0 electric bus, fitted with a 311 kWh battery pack, was used and the tests were carried out during November 2014-April 2015 in eight municipalities in the south of Sweden. Six tests took place in urban traffic and two took place in more of a rural traffic setting. The energy use for propulsion was measured via logging of the internal system in the bus and via an external charging meter. The average energy use turned out to be 8% less (0,96 kWh/km) than assumed in the earlier theoretical study. This rate allows for a 320 km range in public urban traffic. The interior of the bus was kept warm by a diesel heater (biodiesel will probably be used in a future operational traffic situation), which used 0,67 kWh/km in January. This verified that electric buses can be up to 25% cheaper when used in public transport in cities for about eight years. The noise was found to be lower, primarily during acceleration, than for buses with combustion engines in urban bus traffic. According to our surveys, most passengers and drivers appreciated the silent and comfortable ride and preferred electric buses rather than combustion engine buses. Bus operators and passenger transport executives were also positive to start using electric buses for public transport. The operators did however point out that procurement processes need to account for eventual risks regarding this new technology, along with personnel education. The study revealed that it is possible to establish a charging infrastructure for almost all studied bus lines. However, design of a charging infrastructure for each municipality requires further investigations, including electric grid capacity analysis, smart location of charging points, and tailored schedules to allow fast charging. In conclusion, electric buses proved to be a preferable alternative for all stakeholders involved in public bus transport in the studied municipalities. However, in order to electric buses to be a prominent support for sustainable development, they need to be charged either by stand-alone units or via an expansion of the electric grid, and the electricity should be made from new renewable sources.

Keywords: Sustainability, Electric, Bus, Noise, GreenCharge.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1112119

References:

[1] K. H. Robèrt, G. I. Broman, and G. Basile, “Analyzing the concept of planetary boundaries from a strategic sustainability perspective: How does humanity avoid tipping the planet?,” Ecology and Society, 2013.
[2] S. Alvemo, S. Borén, and Q. Gu, “The SEAT approach to Strategic Guidance for Planning towards Sustainable Transportation” Blekinge Institute of Technology, Karlskrona, 2010.
[3] S. Borén, “Development of sustainable transport in South East Baltic ‘Food for thoughts to achieve green transport in Blekinge 2030’,” Region Blekinge, Karlskrona, Nov. 2011.
[4] G. Cars, J. Oldmark, and K.-H. Robèrt, “Sustainable Planning in Communities at Any Scale,” The Natural Step Sw, Stockholm, Oct. 2012.
[5] K.-H. Robèrt, S. Borén, H. Ny, and G. Broman, “A strategic approach to sustainable transport system development - Part 1: attempting a generic community planning process model,” Journal of Cleaner Production, no. Systematic Leadership towards Sustainability. Karlskrona. Submitted for review.
[6] L. Nurhadi, S. Borén, and H. Ny, “Advancing from Efficiency to Sustainability in Swedish Medium-sized Cities: An Approach for Recommending Powertrains and Energy Carriers for Public Bus Transport Systems,” presented at the Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2014, vol. 111, no. 0, pp. 586–595.
[7] Ebusco, “Ebusco 2.0,” Ebusco.eu, 2013. (Online). Available: http://www.ebusco.eu/en/electric-buses/ebusco-2-0. (Accessed: 03-Jun-2015).
[8] Ebusco, “YTP-1,” Ebusco.eu, 2013. (Online). Available: http://www.ebusco.eu/en/electric-buses/ytp-1. (Accessed: 03-Jun-2015)
[9] United Nations, “Status of United Nations Regulation ECE 51-02,” InterRegs Ltd, Nov. 2013.
[10] SAE International, “SAE J366,” SAE International, Sep. 2011.
[11] M. Lundgren, “Väderleken” SMHI.se, 18-Feb-2015. (Online). Available: http://www.smhi.se/bloggar/vaderleken/2015/02/18/vintern-2015-mild-eller-mycket-mild/. (Accessed: 01-Jun-2015).
[12] N. Haraldsson, “Bullermätning linjebussar” Nitro Consult, 1532 5990 R01, Apr. 2015.
[13] D. Checkel, “Hybrid Diesel-Electric Bus / Trolley Bus Demonstration Project: Technical Comparison of In-Use Performance” University of Alberta, Edmonton, Apr. 2008.
[14] The Larson Institute, “Federal Transit Bus Test” The Larson Institute, Duncansville, LTI-BT-R1307, 2014.
[15] The Larson Institute, “Federal Transit Bus Test” The Thomas D. Larson Pennsylvania Transportation Institute, LTI-BT-R1406, Mar. 2015.
[16] The Larson Institute, “STURAA Test” The Thomas D. Larson Pennsylvania Transportation Institute, PTI-BT-R1108, 2012.
[17] The Larson Institute, “Federal Transit Bus Test” The Thomas D. Larsson Pennsylvania Transportation Institute, LTI-BT-R1402, 2015.
[18] The Larson Institute, “Federal Transit Bus Test” The Thomas D. Larsson Pennsylvania Transportation Institute, LTI-BT-R1313, 2013.
[19] The Larson Institute, “Partial STURAA test” The Thomas D. Larson Pennsylvania Transportation Institute, PTI-BT-R1211, 2012.
[20] The Larson Institute, “Federal Transit Bus Test” The Thomas D. Larsson Pennsylvania Transportation Institute, LTI-BT-R1401, 2014.
[21] The Larson Institute, “Federal Transit Bus Test” The Thomas D. Larsson Pennsylvania Transportation Institute, LTI-BT-R1403-P, 2014.
[22] The Larson Institute, “STURAA Test” The Thomas D. Larson Pennsylvania Transportation Institute, LTI-BT-R1310, 2014.
[23] S. Borén, “Enkätsvar GreenCharge elbusstest 2014-15.” Blekinge Institute of Technology, Karlskrona, Nov-2014.
[24] S. Borén, “Green Charge - demotest i fält med elbuss” Blekinge Institute of Technology, Karlskrona, Aug. 2015.
[25] X. C. Wang and J. A. González, “Assessing Feasibility of Electric Buses in Small and Medium-Sized Communities,” International Journal of Sustainable Transportation, vol. 7, no. 6, pp. 431–448, Nov. 2013.