In Search of High Growth: Mapping out Academic Spin-Off´s Performance in Catalonia

Authors: F. Guspi, E. García

Abstract:

This exploratory study gives an overview of the evolution of the main financial and performance indicators of the Academic Spin-Off’s and High Growth Academic Spin-Off’s in year 3 and year 6 after its creation in the region of Catalonia in Spain. The study compares and evaluates results of these different measures of performance and the degree of success of these companies for each University. We found that the average Catalonian Academic Spin-Off is small and have not achieved the sustainability stage at year 6. On the contrary, a small group of High Growth Academic Spin-Off’s exhibits robust performance with high profits in year 6. Our results support the need to increase selectivity and support for these companies especially near year 3, because are the ones that will bring wealth and employment. University role as an investor has rigid norms and habits that impede an efficient economic return from their ASO investment. Universities with high performance on sales and employment in year 3 not always could sustain this growth in year 6 because their ASO’s are not profitable. On the contrary, profitable ASO exhibit superior performance in all measurement indicators in year 6. We advocate the need of a balanced growth (with profits) as a way to obtain subsequent continuous growth.

Keywords: Academic Spin-Off (ASO), University Entrepreneurship, Entrepreneurial University, high growth, New Technology Based Companies (NTBC), University Spin-Off.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1100537

References:

[1] European Commission, Green Paper on Innovation, 1995.
[2] M. Wright, B. Clarysse, P. Mustar, A. Lockett, Academic Entrepreneurship in Europe. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, 2007.
[3] European Commission, University spin-outs in Europe. Overview and good practice, Luxembourg, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, 2002.
[4] D. J., Storey, “Impact on the local economy”, Entrepreneurship and the new firm (pp. 167–180). London: Croom Helm, 1982.
[5] D. J. Storey, “The role of small and medium-sized enterprises in european job creation: Key issues for policy and research.” Small and medium size enterprises and regional development, pp. 140–160. London: Routledge, 1988.
[6] S. Birley, “New ventures and employment growth”. Journal of Business Venturing, 2(2), pp. 155–165, 1987.
[7] B. A. Kirchhoff, & B. D. Phillips, “Research applications of the small business data base of the U.S. small business administration”, The state of the art of entrepreneurship, pp. 243–267, Boston, MA, 1992.
[8] S. B. White, & P. D. Reynolds, “Government programs and high growth new firms”. Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research, pp. 621–635, 1996.
[9] C. A. Kent, “Entrepreneurship in economic development”, Encyclopedia of entrepreneurship, pp. 237–256, New York: Prentice-Hall, 1982.
[10] D. L. Sexton, “Role of Entrepreneurship in Economic Development”, Entrepreneurship, Intrapreneurship, and Venture Capital, pp. 27–39, Massachusetts: Heath andCompany, 1986.
[11] D. J. Storey, “Understanding the small business sector”, Employment, pp. 160–203, London: Routledge, 1994.
[12] S. Wennekers, & R. Thurik, “Linking entrepreneurship and economic growth”. Small Business Economics, 13(1), pp. 27–55, 1999.
[13] I. Brinkley & N. Lee, “The knowledge economy in Europe” The work foundation, London, 2006.
[14] European Commission “Towards a European research area science, technology and innovation” (EC publication no. 22572). Luxembourg: Office for publications of the European Commission, 2007.
[15] F. Ndonzuau, F. Pirnay, & B. Surlemont, “A stage model of academic spin-off creation”. Technovation, 22, pp. 281–289, 2002.
[16] H. Löfsten & P. Lindelöf, “Science parks and the growth of new technology-based firms-academic-industry links, innovations and markets”. Research Policy, 31, pp. 859-876, 2002.
[17] Etzkowitz, H. (2004). The evolution of the entrepreneurial university. International Journal of Technology & Globalisation, 1(1), 64-77.
[18] A. D. Meyers & S. Pruthi, “Academic entrepreneurship, entrepreneurial universities and biotechnology” Journal of Commercial Biotechnology, 17, pp. 349 – 357, 2011
[19] Smilor, R. Gibson, D. V. & Dietrich, G. B. “Spin-out Companies: Technology Start-ups from UT-Austin”, Journal of Business Venturing, nº. 5 (1), pp. 63-76, 1990.
[20] A. Brett, D. Gibson, & Smilor, R., “University Spin-off Companies: Economic Development”, Faculty Entrepreneurs, and Technology Transfer, 1991.
[21] E. Roberts & D. Malone, “Policies and Structures for Spinning Off New Companies from Research and Development Organizations”, R&D Management 26 (1), 1996.
[22] S. E. G Carayannis, E. M Rogers, K. Kurihara, & M. M. Allbritton “High Technology spin-offs: From government R&D laboratories and research universities”, Technovation, nº. 18 (1), pp. 1-11, 1998.
[23] J. Degroof, & E. Roberts, “Overcoming Weak Entrepreneurial Infrastructures for Academic Spin-Off Ventures”, Journal of Technology Transfer, nº. 29, pp. 327-352, 2004.
[24] A. Lockett, M. Wright, & S. Franklin, “Technology transfer and universities, spin-out strategies”, Small Business Economics, nº.20 (2), pp. 185, 2003.
[25] R. Stankiewicz, “Academic Entrepreneurs: Developing University- Industry Relations”, London: Frances Pinter Publishers, 1986.
[26] R. Stankiewicz, “Spin-off companies from universities”, Science and Public Policy, nº. 21(2), pp. 99-107, 1994.
[27] F.T. Rothaermel, D.A. Shanti, and L. Jiang, 2007) “University entrepreneurship: a taxonomy of the literature” Industrial and Corporate Change, Volume 16, Number 4, pp. 691–791
[28] D. Djokovic, & V. Souitaris, “Spinouts from academic institutions: a literature review with suggestions for further research”. J. Technol Transfer 2008) 33:225–247, 2008.
[29] M. Perkmann, et al., “Academic engagement and commercialization: A review of the literature on university–industry relations”, Research Policy 42, pp. 423– 442, 2013
[30] S. Shane, “Encouraging university entrepreneurship. The effect of the Bayh–Dole Act on university patenting in the United States”, Journal of Business Venturing, nº. 19 (1), pp. 127-151, 2004
[31] B. Callan, “Generating Spin-Offs: Evidence from the OECD” Science Technology Industry Review. Special Issue on Fostering High Tech Spin-Offs: A Public Strategy for Innovation 26, 13–56, 2001.
[32] M. J. Bray & J. N. Lee, “University Revenues from Technology Transfer: Licensing Fees vs Equity Positions”, Journal of Business Venturing, nº. 15(5–6), pp. 385-392, 2000.
[33] P. Condom, & P. Barceló, “Modelos de apoyo a la creación de spinoffs”, Iniciativa emprendedora, nº 41, Octubre-Noviembre-Diciembre 2003, Deusto, pp. 34-53, 2003.
[34] Red OTRI survey, “Informe de la encuesta de investigación y transferencia de conocimiento 2011 de las universidades españolas”, 2011.
[35] C. Camisón & I. March, “Estrategias de cooperación y de innovación con soporte territorial y parques tecnológicos: un estudio empírico”, Revista Europea de Dirección y Economía de la Empresa, Vol. 4, nº 1, pp. 11-33, 1995.
[36] D. Rodeiro, La creación de empresas en el entorno universitario español y la determinación de su estructura financiera, Tesis doctoral, Universidad de Santiago de Compostela, 2008.
[37] J.M. Beraza & A. Rodríguez, “Estructuras de intermediación para la transferencia de conocimiento universitario: las oficinas de transferencia tecnológica”, Revista Propiedad intelectual, Año IX, nº 13, pp. 152-176, 2010.
[38] J. Ruiz, F. Solé, & J. M., Veciana, Creación de Empresas y Universidad (1st ed.). Cádiz: Fundación Universidad Empresa de la Provincia de Cádiz, 2004.
[39] A. Corduras et al., “The relationship between university support to Entrepreneurship with entrepreneurial activity in Spain: A Gem data based analysis” Int Adv Econ Res, 14:395–406, 2008.
[40] A. Lockett, M. Wright & S. Franklin, “Technology transfer and universities, spin-out strategies”, Small Business Economics, nº.20 (2), pp. 185, 2003.
[41] A. Lockett, M. Wright & A. Vohora, “Resources, capabilities, risk capital and the creation of university spin-out companies”, SPRUScience and Technology Policy Research, University of Sussex documents, 2004.
[42] A. Lockett & M. Wright, “Resources, capabilities, risk capital and the creation of university spin-out companies”, Research Policy, nº. 34 (7), pp. 1043-1057, 2005.
[43] R. P. O´Shea, T. J. Allen, A. Chevalier & F. Roche, “Entrepreneurial orientation, technology transfer and spin-off performance of U.S. universities”, Research Policy, nº. 34 (7), pp. 994-1009, 2005.
[44] J. Powers & P. McDougall, “University start-up formation and technology licensing with firms that go public: a resource based view of academic entrepreneurship”, Journal of Business Venturing, nº. 20 (3), pp. 291-311, 2005.
[45] D. Di Gregorio & S. Shane, “Why do some universities generate more start-ups than others?”, Research Policy, nº. 32, pp. 209-227, 2003.
[46] A. N. Link & J. T. Scott, “Opening the ivory tower's door: An analysis of the determinants of the formation of U.S. university spin-off companies”, Research Policy, nº. 34 (7), pp. 1106-1112, 2005.
[47] M. O. Gonzalez & G. J. Álvarez, “Pautas de creación de spin-offs en las universidades españolas”, VII Congreso Nacional de Economía, Europa en una economía global, estrategias para el siglo XXI, A Coruña, 28-30 septiembre, 2005.
[48] B. Y. Montañez, “Factores condicionantes de la creación de spin-off universitarias: un estudio exploratorio”, III Jornada de Precomunicaciones a Congresos de Economía y Administración de Empresas, 29 junio, Barcelona, 2006.
[49] Red OTRI, “Indicadores en transfererncia de conocimiento” Cuadernos técnicos RedOTRI, 2010.
[50] J. M. Beraza, A. Rodríguez, “Types of spin-offs in a university context: a classification proposal” Cuadernos de Gestión, Vol. 12 - N.º 1, pp. 39- 57, 2012.
[51] D. S. Siegel, D. Waldman, L. Atwater & A. N. Link, “Commercial knowledge transfers from universities to firms: improving the effectiveness of university–industry collaboration”, Journal of High Technology Management Research, nº. 14, pp. 111-133, 2003.
[52] A. Vohora, M. Wright & A. Lockett, “Critical junctures in the development of university high-tech spinout companies”, Research Policy, nº. 33, pp. 147-175, 2004.
[53] B. Clarysse, M. Wright, A. Lockett, E. Van De Elde & A. Vohora, “Spinning out new ventures: a typology of incubation strategies from European research institutions”, Journal of Business Venturing, nº. 20, pp. 183–216, 2005.
[54] R.T. Harrison, C. Leitch, “Voodoo institution or entrepreneurial university? Spin-off companies, the entrepreneurial system and regional development in the UK”. Regional Studies, 44.9, pp. 1241–1262, 2010.
[55] J.J. Chrisman, T. Hynes & S. Fraser, “Faculty entrepreneurship and economic development: the case of the University of Calgary”. Journal of Business Venturing, 10, pp.267–281, 1995.
[56] M. D. Ensley, K. M. Hmieleski, “A comparative study of new venture top management team composition, dynamics and performance between university-based and independent start-ups”, Research Policy, 34, pp. 1091–1105, 2005.
[57] J. Zhang, “The performance of university spin-offs: an exploratory analysis using venture capital data”. Journal of Technology Transfer, 34, pp. 255–285, 2009.
[58] P. Ortín-Angel, & F. Vendrell-Herrero, “University spin-offs vs. Other NTBFs: Total factor productivity differences at outset and evolution”, Technovation, 34, pp. 101–112, 2014.
[59] World Economic Forum, 2011. Global Competitiveness Index 2011. Retrieved from http://www.weforum.org/issues/global competitiveness.
[60] D. Urbano, & M. Guerrero, “Entrepreneurial Universities: Socioeconomic Impacts of Academic Entrepreneurship in a European Region” Economic Development Quarterly, pp. 40-55, 2013.
[61] M. Klofsten, & D. Jones-Evans, “Comparing Academic Entrepreneurship in Europe-The Case of Sweden and Ireland”, Small Business Economics, 14(4), 299, 2000.
[62] M. van Geenhuizen, D. P.Soetano, “Academic spin-offs at different ages: A case study in search of key obstacles to growth”, Technovation 29, pp. 671–681, 2009.
[63] R. Smilor, V. Gibson, G. Dietrich, “University spin-out companies: Technology start-ups from UT-Austin” Original Research Article, Journal of Business Venturing, Volume 5, Issue 1, pp. 63-76, 1990.
[64] A. Lindholm, “Growth and inventiveness in technology-based spin-off firms”, Original Research Article, Research Policy, Volume 26, Issue 3, pp. 331-344, October 1997.
[65] S. Shane, "Academic Entrepreneurship: University Spinoffs and Wealth Creation". Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, 2004.
[66] P.S. Vincett, "The economic impacts of academic spin-off companies, and their implications for public policy", Research Policy, vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 736-747, 2010
[67] G. N., Chandler, A. McKelvie & P. Davidsson, “Asset specificity and behavioral uncertainty as moderators of the sales growth — employment growth relationship in emerging ventures”, Journal of Business Venturing, 24(4), pp. 373-387, 2009.
[68] J. Sutton, “Gibrat's Legacy”, Journal of Economic Literature, 35(1), pp. 40-59, 1997.
[69] P. E. Hart, & N. Oulton, “Growth and size of firms”. Economic Journal, 106(438), pp. 1242-1252, 1996.
[70] M. Teruel Carrizosa, “Firm growth, persistence and multiplicity of equilibria: an analysis of Spanish manufacturing and service industries”. Doctoral Thesis. Universitat Rovira i Virgili. Departament d'Economia, 2006.
[71] F. Lotti, E. Santarelli, M. Vivarelli, “Defending Gibrat’s Law as a longrun regularity”, Small Business Economics, v. 32, iss. 1, pp. 31-44, January, 2009.
[72] A. Singh, & G. Whittington, “Growth, profitability and valuation”, Department of Applied Economics, University of Cambridge, Occasional Paper, No 7. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1968.
[73] J. Wagner, “Firm size, firm growth, and the persistence of chance: Testing Gibrat’s Law with establishment data for Lower Saxony, 1978– 1989”. Small Business Economics, 4, pp. 125–132, 1992.
[74] D. Smallbone, R. Leig & D. North, "The characteristics and strategies of high growth SMEs", International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour & Research, Vol. 1 Iss: 3, pp. 44 – 62, 1995.
[75] J. Dahlqvist, P. Davidsson, & J. Wiklund, “Initial Conditions as Predictors of New Venture Performance: A Replication and Extension of the Cooper et al. study”, Enterprise & Innovation Management Studies, 1(1), 2000.
[76] D. Birch, “Job Generation Process”, Cambridge, MA: Joint Center for Neighbourhood and Regional Development, MIT, 1979.
[77] F, Garnsey, “A Theory of the Early Growth of the Firm”, Industrial and Corporate Change, Volume 7, Number 3, pp. 523-556, 1998.
[78] Delmar, F., Davidsson, P., & Gartner, W. B., 2003. Arriving at the highgrowth firm. Journal of Business Venturing, 18(2), 189-216.
[79] E. Garnsey, E. Stam & P. Heffernan, “New firm growth: exploring processes and paths”, Industry and Innovation, 13, 1–20, 2006.
[80] L. Hull, & R. Arnold, “New Zealand firm growth as change in turnover”. Wellington, NZ: Ministry of Economic Development, 2008.
[81] J. Spender, C. Grant, M. Robert “Knowledge and the firm” Strategic Management Journal. Winter96 Special Issue, Vol. 17, p5-9. 5p., 1996.
[82] S.C. Parker, D.J. Storey & A. van Witeloostuijn “What happens to gazelles? The importance of dynamic management strategy” Small Bus. Econ. 35, pp.203–226, 2010.
[83] Z. J. Acs, W. Parsons & S. Tracy, “High impact firms: Gazelles revisited”, Washington D.C., Small Business Administration, 2008.
[84] A. M. Moreno & J. C. Casillas, “High growth SMEs versus no-high growth SMEs”, Entrepreneurship and Regional Development, 19, pp. 69–88, 2007.
[85] H. Littunen, & T. Tohmo, “The High Growth in New Metal-Based Manufacturing and Business Service Firms in Finland”. Small Business Economics, 21(2), 187, 2003.
[86] S. Feindt, J. Jeffcoate & C. Chappell, “Identifying Success Factors for Rapid Growth in SME E-commerce” Small Business Economics, Volume 19, Issue 1, pp 51-62, August 2002.
[87] Entrepreneurship, National Commission on, High-Growth Companies: “Mapping America's Entrepreneurial Landscape”, July 1, 2001, Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1260389 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1260389
[88] V.H. Fried, G.D. Bruton, R.D. Hisrich, “Strategy and the board of directors in venture-backed firms”. J. Bus. Venturing 13, pp. 493–503, 1998.
[89] Dávila et al., “Venture capital financing and the growth of startup firms”, Journal of Business Venturing 18 pp. 689–708, 2003.
[90] M. Colombo, L. Grilli, “On growth drivers of high-tech start-ups: Exploring the role of founders' human capital and venture capital” Journal of Business Venturing, 2009.
[91] A. Heirman & B. Clarysse, “The imprinting effect of initial resources and market strategy on the early growth path of start-ups”. Academy of Management Proceedings, pp. A1–A6, 2005.