Financial Information and Collective Bargaining: Conflicting or Complementing?

Authors: Humayun Murshed, Shibly Abdullah

Abstract:

The research conducted in early seventies apparently assumed the existence of a universal decision model for union negotiators and furthermore tended to regard financial information as a ‘neutral’ input into a rational decision making process. However, research in the eighties began to question the neutrality of financial information as an input in collective bargaining rather viewing it as a potentially effective means for controlling the labour force. Furthermore, this later research also started challenging the simplistic assumptions relating particularly to union objectives which have underpinned the earlier search for universal union decision models. Despite the above developments there seems to be a dearth of studies in developing countries concerning the use of financial information in collective bargaining. This paper seeks to begin to remedy this deficiency. Utilising a case study approach based on two enterprises, one in the public sector and the other a multinational, the universal decision model is rejected and it is argued that the decision whether or not to use financial information is a contingent one and such a contingency is largely defined by the context and environment in which both union and management negotiators work. An attempt is also made to identify the factors constraining as well as promoting the use of financial information in collective bargaining, these being regarded as unique to the organisations within which the case studies are conducted.

Keywords: Collective Bargaining, Developing Countries, Disclosures, Financial Information.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1337687

References:

[1] D. C. Hawkins, “The future of collective bargaining”, Industrial Relations Journal, pp. 22-39, 1977.
[2] P. F. Pope, and D. A. Peel, “The optimal use of information collective bargaining and disclosure debate,” Managerial Finance, vol. 7, No. 2, pp. 17-21, 1981.
[3] T. Climo, “Disclosure of information to employees representatives: a wage bargaining decision model,” Unpublished University of Kent, 1982.
[4] D. Cooper and S. Essex, “Accounting information and employee decision making,” Accounting , Organizations and Society, Vol. 2, No. 3, pp. 202-217, 1977.
[5] J. R. Palmer, “The use of accounting information in labor negotiations,” New York: National Association of Accountants, 1977.
[6] B. J. Foley, and K. T. Maunders, “Accounting information disclosure and collective bargaining,” London, Macmillan, 1977.
[7] F. Mitchell, K. T. Sams, D. P. Tweedie, and P. J. White, “Disclosure of information- some evidence from case studies,” Industrial Relations Journal, Vol.11, no.5, pp. 53-62, 1980.
[8] R. Moore, M. Gold, and H. Levie, “Constraints upon the acquisition and use of company information trade unions,” Occasional Paper No. 67, Trade Union Research Unit, Ruskin College, Oxford, 1981.
[9] J. Jackson-Cox, J. McQueeney, and J. E. M. Thirkell, “The disclosure of company information to trade unions – the relevance of ACAS code of practice on disclosure,” Accounting. Organizations and Society, Vol.9 No.3, pp. 253-273, 1984.
[10] R. Gray, D. Owen, and K. Maunders, “Corporate social reporting, accounting and accountability,” Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1987.
[11] P. D. Bougen, and S. G. Ogden, “Power in organizations: some implications for the use of accounting in industrial relations,” Managerial Finance, Vol. 7 No. 2, pp. 22-26, 1981.
[12] M. D. Cohen, J.G. March, and J.P. Olsen, “A Garbage can Model of Organizational Choice,” Administrative Science Quarterly., pp. 1-25, March 1972.
[13] J. A. Craft, Information disclosure and role of the accountant in collective bargaining,” Accounting, Organisation and Society, Vol. 6, No. 1, PP. 97-197, 1981.
[14] G. Jenkins, “Disclosure of information: stratification and collective bargaining,” Industrial Relation Journal, Vol. 13, NO.3 pp. 57-62, 1982.
[15] D. L. Owen and A. J. Lloyd, “The use of financial information by trade union negotiators in plant level collective bargaining,” Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 10 , NO.3, pp. 329-350, 1985.
[16] J. G. Birnberg, L. Turopolec, and S. M. Young, “The Organizational context of Accounting,”Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 8, NO. 2/3, pp.111-129, 1983.
[17] P. Prakash and A. Rappaport, “Information inductance and its significance for accounting,” Accounting, Organisation and Society, Vol. 2, No. 1, PP. 29-38.
[18] ILO, “Conciliation and Arbitration Procedures in Labour Disputes: A Comparative Study,” Geneva: ILO, 1980
[19] P. Waterman, “Third world strikes: an invitation to discussion,” Development and Change, Vol. 7, NO.3, pp 331-344, 1976.
[20] J. Barbash, “The Elements of Industrial Relations,” Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1984.
[21] Yesufu, “The state and industrial relations in developing countries” in A. M. Ross(ed.), Industrial Relations and Economic Development, London: Macmillan, pp. 90, 1966.
[22] D. Bhattacharjee, “Industrial workers’ wage in Bangladesh; an analysis of criteria, polices and dynamics,” The Dhaka University Studies, Part – C, Vol. 7, No. 1, pp. 133-149, 1986.
[23] M. F. Alam, “Some aspects of trade of trade union structure in Bangladesh,” Chittagong University Studies, Vol. 6, No.4, pp. 46-68, 1987.
[24] R.P. Dore, “British factory – Japanese factory,” London: Allen and Unwin, 1973.
[25] E. Shorter, and C. Tilly, “Strikes in France. 1830- 1968,” Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1974.
[26] H. A. Clegg, “Trade unionism under collective bargaining,” Oxford: Blackwell, 1976.
[27] J. Schregle, “Negotiating development: labour relations in southern asia,” Geneva: ILO, 1982.
[28] Government of Bangladesh, “Industrial Relations Ordinance,” Dhaka; Government of Bangladesh, pp.17, 1983.
[29] Government of Bangladesh, “Labour Policy,” Dhaka: Government of Bangladesh, 1974.
[30] N. Chowdhury, “Towards an effective wage policy for Bangladesh,” Journal of Management, Business and Economics, vol. 11, No. 2, pp 40- 48, 1985.
[31] M. Ahmad, “Labour – management relations in Bangladesh,” A study in participation, Dhaka: Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies, pp. 201, 1977.
[32] G. Starr, “Minimum wage fixing,” Geneva, ILO, 1981.
[33] Government of Bangladesh, “Report of the minimum wage commission,” Dhaka, pp. 6, 1986.
[34] J. C. S. Das, “Work stoppages and their effects on the economy of Bangladesh,” The Dhaka University Studies. Part- C, Vol. 2, No. 1, 1981.
[35] Government of Bangladesh, “Third Five Year Plan,” Dhaka; Government of Bangladesh, 1985.
[36] H.I. Chowdhury, “Multinational enterprise in Bangladesh,” The Bangladesh Observer, 24th April, pp.10, 1983.
[37] M.Z. Rahman, “Accounting policy choice and. profit manipulation: multinational enterprise behavior in Bangladesh,” University Studies, Part c 9, Vol.2, No. 1, pp. 40-59, 1983.
[38] A.R. Negandhi, “International Management,” Boston: Allyn and Bacon inc., 1987.
[39] S. Lall, “The multinational corporation,” London: Macmillan, 1980.
[40] A. M. Rugman, “International diversification and the multinational enterprise,” Lexington, Mass.: D.C.Heath and Co., 1979.
[41] J. S. Chandler, and H.P. Holzer, “Accounting in the third world” in H.P. Holzer (ed.), International Accounting, New York: Harper and Row Publishers, 1984.
[42] D. J. Cooper, M. J. Sherer, “The value of corporate accounting reports: arguments for a political economy of accounting,” Accounting, Organizatins and Society, Vol. 9, No. ¾, pp. 207-232, 1984.
[43] J. Amernic, R. Craig, “Roles and social construction of accounting in industrial relations,” The Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 47, No. 1, pp. 77-92, March 2005.
[44] R. J. Briston, “The evolution of accounting in developing countries,” The International Journal of Accounting Education and Research, Fall, pp. 105-120, 1978.