A Comparison of Marginal and Joint Generalized Quasi-likelihood Estimating Equations Based On the Com-Poisson GLM: Application to Car Breakdowns Data

Authors: N. Mamode Khan, V. Jowaheer

Abstract:

In this paper, we apply and compare two generalized estimating equation approaches to the analysis of car breakdowns data in Mauritius. Number of breakdowns experienced by a machinery is a highly under-dispersed count random variable and its value can be attributed to the factors related to the mechanical input and output of that machinery. Analyzing such under-dispersed count observation as a function of the explanatory factors has been a challenging problem. In this paper, we aim at estimating the effects of various factors on the number of breakdowns experienced by a passenger car based on a study performed in Mauritius over a year. We remark that the number of passenger car breakdowns is highly under-dispersed. These data are therefore modelled and analyzed using Com-Poisson regression model. We use the two types of quasi-likelihood estimation approaches to estimate the parameters of the model: marginal and joint generalized quasi-likelihood estimating equation approaches. Under-dispersion parameter is estimated to be around 2.14 justifying the appropriateness of Com-Poisson distribution in modelling underdispersed count responses recorded in this study.

Keywords: Breakdowns, under-dispersion, com-poisson, generalized linear model, marginal quasi-likelihood estimation, joint quasi-likelihood estimation.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1332924

References:

[1] Guikema, S. " Formulating informative data -based priors for failure probability estimation in reliability analysis", Reliability Engineering and System Safety, Vol 92, 490-502,2007.
[2] Jowaheer,V and Mamode Khan,N. " Estimating Regression Effects in Com-Poisson Generalized Linear Model", International Journal of Computational and Mathematical Sciences, Vol 3:4, 2009
[3] Kadane,J , Shmueli,G, Minka,G, Borle,T and Boatwright,P. " Conjugate analysis of the Conway Maxwell Poisson distribution", Bayesian analysis, Vol 1, 363-374,2006.
[4] Lord,D, Guikema,S and Geedipally,S. "Application of the Conway- Maxwell-Poisson Generalized Linear Model for Analyzing Motor Vehicle Crashes". Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 40, 1123-1134,2008
[5] Shmueli,G, Minka,T, Borle,J and Boatwright,P. " A useful distribution for fitting discrete data, Journal of Royal Statistical Society, 2005.
[6] Road accidents in Mauritius: statistics and analysis, Ministry of Public Infrastructure, Land Transport and Shipping Traffic management and Road safety unit, July 2006.
[7] RAC patrol report: motoring organisation, United Kingdom, 2008