Indirect Relationship Between Perfectionism and Depression Through Self-Silencing and Guilt: A Cross-Cultural Study

Authors: Elham Davoodi, Kylie King, Laura Jobson

Abstract:

Depression is one of the most common mental health disorders. Self-silencing theory adopts a socio-cultural lens to examine the development and maintenance of depression. Self-silencing can be a vulnerability factor in depression, and personality vulnerabilities (e.g., perfectionism) and moral emotions (e.g., guilt) are strongly related to self-silencing and depression. Yet, the relationships between all four variables among different cultural groups are not clear. We aimed to address this gap by examining whether perfectionism and depression are related indirectly through self-silencing and guilt and whether cultural group moderates these associations. Participants (N = 288) from either European Australian or Iranian Australian cultural backgrounds completed an online survey assessing self-silencing, guilt, perfectionism, and depression. First, we found an indirect relationship between perfectionism and depression through self-silencing. Second, using a serial mediation model, we found an indirect association between perfectionism and depression through self-silencing and guilt. There was no evidence that cultural groups moderated these indirect relationships. Our findings leave an important question for future longitudinal studies to answer; that is, whether the association between self-silencing and depression is oversimplified and whether moral emotions in this relationship have been overlooked.

Keywords: Perfectionism, depression, self-silencing, culture and guilt.

References:

[1] World Health Organisation. Depression and Other Common Mental Disorders. 2017 31 October 2023; Available from: https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/depression-global-health-estimates.
[2] Bueno-Notivol, J., et al., Prevalence of depression during the COVID-19 outbreak: A meta-analysis of community-based studies. International journal of clinical and health psychology, 2021. 21(1): p. 100196-11.
[3] Jack, D.C., Silencing the self: women and depression. 1991, Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press.
[4] Flett, G.L., et al., Perfectionism, silencing the self, and depression. Personality and individual differences, 2007. 43(5): p. 1211-1222.
[5] Maji, S. and S. Dixit, Self-silencing and women’s health: A review. International Journal of Social Psychiatry, 2019. 65(1): p. 3-13.
[6] Shrivastava, A. and S. Rathore, Self-Silencing with its roots in automatic thoughts: A study on women. ENSEMBLE, 2021. 2.
[7] Emran, A., N. Iqbal, and I.A. Dar, ‘Silencing the self’ and women’s mental health problems: A narrative review. Asian journal of psychiatry, 2020. 53: p. 102197.
[8] Smith, M.M., et al., Is perfectionism a vulnerability factor for depressive symptoms, a complication of depressive symptoms, or both? A meta-analytic test of 67 longitudinal studies. Clinical psychology review, 2021. 84: p. 101982-101982.
[9] APA Dictionary of Psychology. Perfectionism. 2018 cited 19 April, 2024; Available from: https://dictionary.apa.org/perfectionism.
[10] Rnic, K., Hewitt, P. L., Chen, C., Flett, G. L., Jopling, E., & LeMoult, Study Findings on Psychology Are Outlined in Reports from University of British Columbia (Examining the Link Between Multidimensional Perfectionism and Depression: a Longitudinal Study of the Intervening Effects of Social Disconnection). Psychology & Psychiatry Journal, 2021: p. 496.
[11] Hewitt, P.L., et al., Specific Formulation Feedback in Dynamic-Relational Group Psychotherapy of Perfectionism. Psychotherapy (Chicago, Ill.), 2018. 55(2): p. 179-185.
[12] Hewitt, P.L., et al., Perfectionism and Its Role in Depressive Disorders. Canadian journal of behavioural science, 2022. 54(2): p. 121-131.
[13] APA Dictionary of Psychology. Guilt. 2018 19 April 2024; Available from: https://dictionary.apa.org/guilt.
[14] Maji, S. and S. Dixit, Exploring self-silencing in workplace relationships: A qualitative study of female software engineers. The Qualitative Report, 2020. 25(6): p. 1505-1525.
[15] Dunford, E. and C. Granger, Maternal Guilt and Shame: Relationship to Postnatal Depression and Attitudes towards Help-Seeking. Journal of child and family studies, 2017. 26(6): p. 1692-1701.
[16] Gambin, M. and C. Sharp, The relations between empathy, guilt, shame and depression in inpatient adolescents. Journal of affective disorders, 2018. 241: p. 381-387.
[17] Li, J., J.N. Tendeiro, and M. Stroebe, Guilt in bereavement: Its relationship with complicated grief and depression. International journal of psychology, 2019. 54(4): p. 454-461.
[18] Mesquita, B. and R. Walker, Cultural differences in emotions: a context for interpreting emotional experiences. Behaviour research and therapy, 2003. 41(7): p. 777-793.
[19] Beck, A.T. and K. Bredemeier, A Unified Model of Depression: Integrating Clinical, Cognitive, Biological, and Evolutionary Perspectives. Clinical psychological science, 2016. 4(4): p. 596-619.
[20] Chentsova-Dutton, Y.E., A.G. Ryder, and J. Tsai, Understanding depression across cultural contexts, in Handbook of depression, 3rd ed. 2014, The Guilford Press: New York, NY, US. p. 337-354.
[21] Hwang, W.-C., et al., A conceptual paradigm for understanding culture's impact on mental health: The cultural influences on mental health (CIMH) model. Clinical psychology review, 2008. 28(2): p. 211-227.
[22] DiBartolo, P.M. and M.J. Rendón, A critical examination of the construct of perfectionism and its relationship to mental health in Asian and African Americans using a cross-cultural framework. Clinical psychology review, 2012. 32(3): p. 139-152.
[23] Jack, D.C. and A. Ali, Silencing the self across cultures: Depression and gender in the social world. 2010: Oxford University Press.
[24] Australian Bureau of Statistics. Cultural diversity of Australia. 2022 April 19, 2024]; Available from: https://www.abs.gov.au/articles/cultural-diversity-australia.
[25] Foo, S.Q., et al., Prevalence of Depression among Migrants: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2018. 15(9): p. 1986.
[26] Australian Bureau of Statistics. People in Australia who were born in Iran. 2021 6 August 2024]; Available from: https://www.abs.gov.au/census/find-census-data/quickstats/2021/4203_AUS.
[27] Stern, A.F., The hospital anxiety and depression scale. Occup Med (Lond), 2014. 64(5): p. 393-4.
[28] Cassiani-Miranda, C.A., O. Scoppetta, and D.F. Cabanzo-Arenas, Validity of the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) in primary care patients in Colombia. General Hospital Psychiatry, 2022. 74: p. 102-109.
[29] Djukanovic, I., J. Carlsson, and K. Årestedt, Is the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) a valid measure in a general population 65–80 years old? A psychometric evaluation study. Health and quality of life outcomes, 2017. 15: p. 1-10.
[30] Montazeri, A., et al., The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS): translation and validation study of the Iranian version. Health and quality of life outcomes, 2003. 1(1): p. 1-5.
[31] Jack, D.C. and D. Dill, The Silencing the Self Scale: Schemas of intimacy associated with depression in women. Psychology of women quarterly, 1992. 16(1): p. 97-106.
[32] Zabihidan, S., The relationship between family comminication patterns and loneliness with mediational effects of self-criticism and self-silencing 2011, Shiraz University: Shiraz, Iran.
[33] Stober, J., The Frost Multidimensional Perfectionism Scale revisited: More perfect with four (instead of six) dimensions. Personality and individual differences, 1998. 24(4): p. 481-491.
[34] Akhavan Abiri, F., M.R. Shairi, and M. Gholami Fesharaki, The investigation of psychometric properties of Frost Multidimensional Perfectionism Scale (FMPS). Shenakht Journal of Psychology and Psychiatry, 2019. 6(1): p. 87-106.
[35] Jones, W.H., A.K. Schratter, and K. Kugler, The Guilt Inventory. Psychological Reports, 2000. 87(3_suppl): p. 1039-1042.
[36] Naziri, G., An examination of guilt feelings and their role in obsessive-compulsive behavior and perfectionist parenting, in Tehran Psychiatric Institute. 1996, Iran university of medical sciences: Tehran, Iran.
[37] Hayes, A.F., Introduction to mediation, moderation, and conditional process analysis: A regression-based approach. 2017: Guilford publications.
[38] Hewitt, P.L., A. Besser, and G.L. Flett, Chapter 13 Silencing the Self and Personality Vulnerabilities Associated with Depression. 2010, Oxford University Press: New York.
[39] Pulcu, E., R. Zahn, and R. Elliott, The role of self-blaming moral emotions in major depression and their impact on social-economical decision making. Frontiers in psychology, 2013. 4: p. 310-310.