An Interpretative Historical Analysis of Asylum and Refugee Policies and Attitudes to Australian Immigration Laws

Authors: Kamal Kithsiri Karunadasa Hewawasam Revulge

Abstract:

This paper is an interpretative historical analysis of Australian migration laws that examines asylum and refugee policies and attitudes in Australia. It looks at major turning points in Australian migration history, and in doing so, we reviewed relevant literature on the aspects crucial to highlighting the current trend of Australian migration policies. The data was collected using secondary data from official government sources, including annual reports, media releases on immigration, inquiry reports, statistical information, and other available literature to identify critical historical events that significantly affected the systematic developments of asylum seekers and refugee policies in Australia and to look at the historical trends of official thinking. A reliance on using these official sources is justified as those are the most convincing sources to analyse the historical events in Australia. Additional literature provides us with critical analyses of the behaviour and culture of the Australian immigration administration. The analytical framework reviewed key Australian Government immigration policies since British colonization and the settlement era of 1787–the 1850s and to the present. The fundamental basis for doing so is that past events and incidents offer us clues and lessons relevant to the present day. Therefore, providing a perspective on migration history in Australia helps analyse how current policymakers' strategies developed and changed over time. Attention is also explicitly focused on Australian asylum and refugee policy internationally, as it helped to broaden the analysis. The finding proved a link between past events and adverse current Australian government policies towards asylum seekers and refugees. It highlighted that Australia's current migration policies are part of a carefully and deliberately planned pattern that arose from the occupation of Australia by early British settlers. In this context, the remarkable point is that the historical events of taking away children from their Australian indigenous parents, widely known as the 'stolen generation' reflected a model of assimilation, or a desire to absorb other cultures into Australian society by fully adopting the settlers' language, their culture, and losing indigenous people's traditions. Current Australian policies towards migrants reflect the same attitude. Hence, it could be argued that policies and attitudes towards asylum seekers and refugees, particularly so-called 'boat people' to some extent, still reflect Australia's earlier colonial and 'white Australia' history. 

Keywords: migration law, refugee law, international law, administrative law

References:

[1] Phillips Jane, Social Policy Section, ‘Asylum seekers and refugees: what are the facts?’ (Parliamentary Library, Parliament of Australia, Canberra, 2017).
[2] Dwayne M et al (eds), ‘The Indigenous World – 2021: PART 1 – Region and country reports – Australia’ (The International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs, 2021).
[3] Australian Bureau of Statistics, Migration Australia 2019/20 (2020).
[4] Snyder et al, ‘Identifying categories of service innovation: A review and synthesis of the literature’ (2016) 69 Journal of Business Research.
[5] Webster, J, R.T. Watson, R T, ‘Analyzing the past to prepare for the future: Writing a literature review’ (2002) 26 Management Information Systems Quarterly 3.
[6] Fullagar et al, ‘History Australia’ (2021) 18 (1) Taylor and Francis journals.
[7] Ozdowski S, Relevance of Australian Immigration and Multicultural Experience to Poland and Contemporary Europe (Adam Mickiewicz University-Poznan, 2016).
[8] Rule of Law Education Centre, European Settlement and Terra Nullius (2022) .
[9] Australian Law Reform Commission, Recognition of Aboriginal Customary Laws, ALRC, Report 31 (1986).
[10] Lavery D, The British acquisition of New Holland: a residuum of allodial sovereignties? (PhD thesis, James Cook University, 2015).
[11] Clarkson et al, ‘Human occupation of northern Australia by 65,000 years ago’ (Faculty of Science, Medicine, and Health - Papers: part A. 4803, 2017).
[12] Mellor D and Bretherton D, ‘Reconciliation between Aboriginal and Other Australians: The Stolen Generations’ Journal of Social Issues (2006) 62 (1).
[13] Rowley C D The destruction of Aboriginal Society (ANU Press, 1970).
[14] Jupp J, From white Australia to Woomera: the story of Australian immigration (Cambridge University Press, 2002).
[15] Pedersen et al, ‘Attitudes toward Indigenous Australians and asylum seekers: The role of false beliefs and other social-psychological variable’ Australian Psychologist (2005) 40 (3).
[16] Museums Victoria, Journeys to Australia - Immigration Museum (Australia Museums, 2024).
[17] Elliot D, ‘Transported to Botany Bay: Imagining Australia in Nineteenth-Century Convict Broadsides’ Victorian Literature and Culture (2015) 43(2).
[18] Commonwealth of Australia, A History of the Department of Immigration–Managing Migration to Australia (2017).
[19] Castles S, ‘Demographic change, and the development of a multicultural society in Australia’ (Occasional Paper 15, Centre for Multicultural Studies, University of Wollongong, 1988).
[20] Goodman D, Gold seeking: Victoria and California in the 1850s (Stanford University Press, 1994).
[21] Adcock W E, The Gold Rushes of the Fifties (Poppet Head Press, 1977).
[22] ‘Gold in Australia’, London News, 29 May 1852.
[23] The University of Melbourne, The Cultural Heritage Unit, a nation’s heritage (2015) .
[24] Bolger D D, Race Politics: Australian Government Responses to Asylum Seekers and Refugees from White Australia to Tampa (Doctoral dissertation, Western Sydney University, 2016).
[25] Huynha K and Neyland S, ‘Australian Whiteness and Refugee Politics’ (2020) 66 (1) Australian Journal of Politics and History.
[26] Partington, G, ‘The Aetiology of Mabo, in Upholding the Australian Constitution’, Proceedings of The Samuel Griffith Society, (1994).
[27] Phillips J et al, ‘Migration to Australia since Federation: a guide to the statistics’ Background note, Parliamentary Library, Commonwealth of Australia Canberra (2017).
[28] Australian Human Rights Commission, Human Rights, Refugees and Asylum Seekers (2011).
[29] United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, ‘UNHCR Resettlement Handbook’ (UNHCR, revised ed, 2011).
[30] Jayasuriya L, Walker D and Gothard J (eds), ‘Legacies of White Australia: Race, Culture and Nation’ (University of Western Australia Press, 2003).
[31] Commonwealth of Australia, Yearbook of the Commonwealth of Australia, 1901-1907 (Commonwealth Bureau of Census and Statistics, Melbourne, 1908).
[32] York B, ‘Australia, and Refugees, 1901-2002: An Annotated Chronology Based on Official Sources’ (Commonwealth of Australia, 2003).
[33] Ozdowski S, ‘Relevance of Australian Immigration and Multicultural Experience to Poland and Contemporary Europe’ (Adam Mickiewicz University-Poznan, 2016).
[34] Immigration Restriction Act 1901.
[35] Pacific Island Labourers Bill 1901.
[36] Naturalization Act 1903.
[37] Kose K, ‘Australia and the 1951 Refugee Convention’ (Lowy Institute for International Policy, 2015).
[38] Education Service Australia Limited and the National Archives of Australia, Refugees from East Timor arrive in Darwin (2010) < https: //www.naa.gov.au/learn/learning-resources/learning-resource-themes/society-and-culture/migration-and-multiculturalism/refugees-east-timor-arrive-darwin>.
[39] Phillips J and Spinks H, ‘Boat arrivals in Australia since 1976’ (Parliamentary Library, Commonwealth of Australia, 2013).
[40] War-time Refugees Removal Act 1949.
[41] Phillips J and Spinks H, ‘Boat arrivals in Australia since 1976’ (Parliamentary Library, Commonwealth of Australia, 2013).
[42] Immigration Restriction Act 1966.
[43] Asylum Insight, Evolution of asylum policy in Australia (2013) .
[44] Refugee Convention 1951.
[45] Parliament of Australia, Expert Panel on Asylum Seekers, Report of the Expert Panel on Asylum Seekers (2012).
[46] Parliament of Australia, Refugee resettlement to Australia: what are the facts? (2016).
[47] York B, Australia, and Refugees, 1901-2002: An Annotated Chronology Based on Official Sources (Commonwealth of Australia, 2003).
[48] Phillips J and Spinks H, Boat arrivals in Australia since 1976 (Parliamentary Library, Commonwealth of Australia, 2013).
[49] O’Sullivan M, ‘The End of Off-Shore Detention, the implications of the Papua New Guinea Supreme Court decision’ Monash University, Castan Centre for Human Rights Law, blog (2016).
[50] Australian Bureau of Statistics, Migration Australia 2017/18 (2019).
[51] Migration Legislation Amendment Act 1989.
[52] Migration Reform Act 1992.
[53] Phillips J, Asylum seekers and refugees: What are the facts? (Parliamentary Library, Commonwealth of Australia, 2017).
[54] Asylum Seeker Resource Centre, Operation Sovereign Borders (2014) .
[55] Migration Legislation Amendment Act (No. 1) 1999.
[56] Border Protection Legislation Amendment Act 1999.
[57] Rudd K, ‘Kevin Rudd announces new asylum seeker processing and refugee settlement deal with Nauru’ Media release, ABC News, 3 August 2013.
[58] Asylum Insight, Facts, and analysis (2021) .
[59] McAdam J ‘Australia and Asylum Seekers ‘International Journal of Refugee Law (2013) 25 (3).
[60] Jones B, 2017, ‘What was the White Australian Policy and how does it still affect us now? NITV 23 October 2017).
[61] Jong A et al, ‘Structural Synergies of Power and Australia’s Policy of Offshore Processing of Asylum Seekers’ on Beyond the Horizon International Strategic Studies Group (2018) .
[62] M Gleeson, ‘PNG court decision forces Australia to act on Manus Island detainees’, The Conversation, (2016).
[63] The Refugee Council of Australia (RCOA), Refugee Council welcomes the historic High Court ruling finding indefinite immigration detention unlawful (2023) .
[64] Commonwealth of Australia, ‘Guide to Australian Maritime Security Arrangements’ (Maritime Border Command Canberra, 2020).
[65] Bianca Hall and Jonathan Swan, ‘Kevin Rudd to send asylum seekers who arrive by boat to Papua New Guinea’, The Sydney Morning Herald 19 July 2013.
[66] Hirsch L A, ‘The Borders Beyond the Borders, Australia’s extraterritorial migration control’ Refugee Survey Quarterly (2017).
[67] Klein N, Assessing Australia's push back the boats policy under international law: legality and accountability for maritime Interceptions of irregular migrants Melbourne Journal of International Law (2014) 15(2).