Disidentification of Historical City Centers: A Comparative Study of the Old and New Settlements of Mardin, Turkey

Authors: Fatma Kürüm Varolgüneş, Fatih Canan

Abstract:

Mardin is one of the unique cities in Turkey with its rich cultural and historical heritage. Mardin’s traditional dwellings have been affected both by natural data such as climate and topography and by cultural data like lifestyle and belief. However, in the new settlements, housing is formed with modern approaches and unsuitable forms clashing with Mardin’s culture and environment. While the city is expanding, traditional textures are ignored. Thus, traditional settlements are losing their identity and are vanishing because of the rapid change and transformation. The main aim of this paper is to determine the physical and social data needed to define the characteristic features of Mardin’s old and new settlements. In this context, based on social and cultural data, old and new settlement formations of Mardin have been investigated from various aspects. During this research, the following methods have been utilized: observations, interviews, public surveys, literature review, as well as site examination via maps, photographs and questionnaire methodology. In conclusion, this paper focuses on how changes in the physical forms of cities affect the typology and the identity of cities, as in the case of Mardin.

Keywords: Urban and local identity, historical city center, traditional settlements, Mardin, Turkey.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1130487

References:

[1] Eryazıcıoğlu E, Malkoç İ., “Matterns of Urban Identity and Disidentification in the Context of Urban Project, the Case of Istanbul” (Published Conference Proceedings style) in Proc. 1st International Urban Planning, Architecture-Desin Conf. , Turkey, 2014, pp. 125–139.
[2] Abdelsalam T, Rihan G. M., “The impact of sustainability trends on housing design identity of Arab cities”. HBRC Journal, 2013 vol:3, pp. 159–172.
[3] Yaldız E, Aydın D., “Loss of City Identities In The Process Of Change: The City Of Konya-Turkey”. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2014, vol: 140, pp. 221–233.
[4] Alioglu, F., “Mardin Sehir Dokusu ve Evleri,” 2000, History Foundation Publication.
[5] Numan, B., “Analysis of a Problematic City Block in Mardin: The Milli Settlement,” 2009, PhD dissertation, Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul, Turkey.
[6] Kayasü, M., “Regeneratıng the Hıstorıcal Fabrıc: A Proposal for a Hybrıd Infıll in Mardın,” 2005, PhD dissertation, METU, Ankara, Turkey.
[7] Yücel A., Rocky Mountain “Kenti Okumak, Kentliliği İnşa Etmek”, Arredamento Architecture, 2001, vol:132 pp. 96-98.
[8] Karagülle, C., “Yerel Verilerin Konut Tasarım Sürecinde Değerlendirilmesi: Mardin Örneği,” 2009, PhD dissertation, Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul, Turkey.
[9] Aslan, H., Karadoğan S. “Mardin Şehrinin Stüasyonu ve Yer Seçiminde Etkili Olan Coğrafi Faktörler,” 2007, Publication of the Mardin History Specialization Library, Istanbul.
[10] Cansever T. “Ev ve Şehir Üzerine Düşünceler,” 1994, Human Publications, İstanbul.
[11] Tural, M., “Mardin Geleneksel Yerleşim Dokusunun Kentsel Dış Mekân Kullanımları Bağlamında İncelenmesi,” 2009, MsC dissertation, Yıldız Technical University, Istanbul, Turkey.
[12] Gür M. O., “Dogu Karadeniz Örneğinde Konut Kültürü,” 2000. YEM Publication, Istanbul.
[13] Gündüz, V. D., “Applıcatıon Problems in Conservatıve Zonıng Plans: Case of Old Cıty Center of Mardin,”2013, MSc dissertation, Bahçeşehir University, Istanbul, Turkey.