Directors’ Duties, Civil Liability, and the Business Judgment Rule under the Portuguese Legal Framework

Authors: Marisa Catarina da Conceição Dinis

Abstract:

The commercial companies’ management has suffered an important material and legal transformation in the last years, mainly related to the changes in the Portuguese legal framework and because of the fact they were recently object of great expansion. In fact, next to the smaller family businesses, whose management is regularly assumed by partners, companies with social investment highly scattered, whose owners are completely out from administration, are now arising. In those particular cases, the business transactions are much more complex and require from the companies’ managers a highly technical knowledge and some specific professionals’ skills and abilities. This kind of administration carries a high-level risk that can both result in great success or in great losses. Knowing that the administration performance can result in important losses to the companies, the Portuguese legislator has created a legal structure to impute them some responsibilities and sanctions. The main goal of this study is to analyze the Portuguese law and some jurisprudence about companies’ management rules and about the conflicts between the directors and the company. In order to achieve these purposes we have to consider, on the one hand, the legal duties directly connected to the directors’ functions and on the other hand the disrespect for those same rules. The Portuguese law in this matter, influenced by the common law, determines that the directors’ attitude should be guided by loyalty and honesty. Consequently, we must reflect in which cases the administrators should respond to losses that they might cause to companies as a result of their duties’ disrespect. In this way is necessary to study the business judgment rule wich is a rule that refers to a liability exclusion rule. We intend, in the same way, to evaluate if the civil liability that results from the directors’ duties disrespect can extend itself to those who have elected them ignoring or even knowing that they don´t have the necessary skills or appropriate knowledge to the position they hold. To charge directors’, without ruining entrepreneurship, charging, in the same way, those who select them reinforces the need for more responsible and cautious attitudes which will lead consequently to more confidence in the markets.

Keywords: Duty of loyalty, duty of care, business judgment rule, civil liability of directors.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1339283

References:

[1] Cfr. Abreu, Coutinho, Responsabilidade Civil dos Administradores de Sociedades, 2ª edição, IDET/Cadernos, n.º 5, Almedina, Coimbra, 2010, p. 15.
[2] Frada, Carneiro da, Direito Civil. Responsabilidade Civil. O método do caso. Almedina, Coimbra, 2006, p. 121.
[3] Vasconcelos, Pedro Pais de, «Responsabilidade Civil dos Gestores das Sociedades Comerciais«, DSR 1, 2009, pp 60-61.
[4] Antunes, Engrácia, Direito das Sociedades. Parte Geral., 2010, pp 323-324.
[5] Costa, Ricardo, “Deveres gerais dos administradores e “gestor criterioso e ordenado”, I Congresso Direito das Sociedades em Revista, Almedina, Coimbra, 2011, p. 163
[6] Cfr. Abreu, Coutinho, Responsabilidade Civil dos Administradores de Sociedades, 2ª edição, IDET/Cadernos, n.º 5, Almedina, Coimbra, 2010, p. 18.
[7] Abreu, Coutinho de, Deveres de Cuidado e de Lealdade dos Administradores e Interesse Social, Reformas do Código das Sociedades, Instituto de Direito das Empresas e do Trabalho, Almedina, 2007, p. 21.
[8] Costa, Ricardo, «Responsabilidade dos Administradores e Business Judgment Rule», Reformas do Código das Sociedades, Colóquios do IDET, Almedina, Coimbra, 2007, pp. 70 a 71.
[9] http://www.dgsi.pt/jstj.nsf/954f0ce6ad9dd8b980256b5f003fa814/f615d83cb0a607b580257cad004ef0a4?OpenDocument (accessed last time in April 28, 2016).
[10] Barton, Nancy, Block, J. Dennis, E. and Radin, Stephen A., The business judgment rule: fudiciary duties of corporate directors, Aspen Law & Business, 1998, pp. 148-152.
[11] Vasconcelos, Pedro Pais, «Business judgment rule, deveres de cuidado e de lealdade, ilicitude e culpa e o artigo 64.º do Código das Sociedades Comerciais», in DSR, Ano 1, vol. II, 2009, pp. 44-46.
[12] http://www.dgsi.pt/jstj.nsf/954f0ce6ad9dd8b980256b5f003fa814/0b422d8f5e52e6ba80257d6300470f78?OpenDocument (accessed last time in April 28, 2016).
[13] Articles 254.º and 398.º of the Portuguese Companies’ Code.
[14] Articles 397.º, 423.º H, 428.º and 445.º of the Portuguese Companies’ Code.
[15] Cfr. Frada, Carneiro da, “A business judgment rule no quadro dos deveres gerais dos administradores”, A Reforma do Código das Sociedades Comerciais: Jornadas em Homenagem ao Professor Doutor Raul Ventura, Almedina, Coimbra, 2007.
[16] Vasconcelos, Pedro Pais de, D&O Insurance: o seguro de responsabilidade civil dos administradores e outros dirigentes da sociedade anónima, Almedina, Coimbra, 2007.
[17] Faria, Clara, “O Seguro D&O e a Proteção ao Patrimônio dos Administradores”, 2ª edição, Almedina, 2016.
[18] Abreu, Coutinho, Comentário ao artigo 72.º do CSC, Código das Sociedades Comerciais em Comentário, Volume I (Artigos 1º a 84º), sob coordenação de Coutinho de Abreu, Almedina, Coimbra, 2010, p. 846.