Recovery of Metals from Electronic Waste by Physical and Chemical Recycling Processes

Authors: Muammer Kaya

Abstract:

The main purpose of this article is to provide a comprehensive review of various physical and chemical processes for electronic waste (e-waste) recycling, their advantages and shortfalls towards achieving a cleaner process of waste utilization, with especial attention towards extraction of metallic values. Current status and future perspectives of waste printed circuit boards (PCBs) recycling are described. E-waste characterization, dismantling/ disassembly methods, liberation and classification processes, composition determination techniques are covered. Manual selective dismantling and metal-nonmetal liberation at – 150 µm at two step crushing are found to be the best. After size reduction, mainly physical separation/concentration processes employing gravity, electrostatic, magnetic separators, froth floatation etc., which are commonly used in mineral processing, have been critically reviewed here for separation of metals and non-metals, along with useful utilizations of the non-metallic materials. The recovery of metals from e-waste material after physical separation through pyrometallurgical, hydrometallurgical or biohydrometallurgical routes is also discussed along with purification and refining and some suitable flowsheets are also given. It seems that hydrometallurgical route will be a key player in the base and precious metals recoveries from e-waste. E-waste recycling will be a very important sector in the near future from economic and environmental perspectives.

Keywords: E-waste, WEEE, PCB, recycling, metal recovery, hydrometallurgy, pyrometallurgy, biohydrometallurgy.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1111987

References:

[1] Li J., Shrivastava P., Gao Z. and Zhang H.C., “Printed Circuit Board Recycling: A State of the Art Survey,” IEEE Transactions on Electronics Packaging Manufacturing, 27, 1 (2004), 33-42.
[2] Ghosh B., Ghosh M.K., Parhi P., Mukherjee P.S. and Mishra B.K., “Waste Printed Circuit Boards Recycling: An Extensive Assessment of Current Status,” Journal of Cleaner Production, 94, (2015), 5-19.
[3] Sum E.Y.L., “The Recovery of Metals from Electronic Scraps,” JOM, 43, 4, (1991), 53-61.
[4] Tenorio J.A.S., Menetti R.P., and Chaves A.P., “Production of Non-ferrous Metallic Concentrates from Electronic Scrap,” EPD Congress 1997, TMS, Warrendale, PA, USA, (1997), 505-509.
[5] Jianzhi L., Shrivastava P., Zong G. and Hong-Chao, Z., “Printed Circuit Board Recycling: A State-of-the-Art Survey.” Electron. Packag. Manufact., IEEE Trans. 27, (2004), 33–42. http://dx.doi.org/ 10.1109/TEPM.2004.830501.
[6] Veit H.M., Diehl T.R., Salami A.P., Rodrigues J.S., Bernardes A.M. and Tenório J.A.S., “Utilization of Magnetic and Electrostatic Separation in the Recycling of Printed Circuit Boards Scrap” Waste Management, 25 (2005) 67–74.
[7] Cui J. and Forssberg E., “Mechanical Recycling of Waste Electric and Electronic Equipment: A Review.” Journal of Hazardous Materials, 99 (3), (2003), 243–263.
[8] Guo C., Wang H., Liang W., Jiangang F. And Yi, X., “Liberation Characteristic and Physical Separation of Printed Circuit Board (PCB),” Waste Management, 31, (2011), 2161–2166. doi:10.1016/j.wasman.2011.05.011.
[9] Tan Z., He Y., Xie W., Duan C., Zhou E., Zheng Y., “Size Distribution of Wet Crushed Waste Printed Circuit Boards.” Mining Sci. Technol. (China) 21, (2011), 359–363. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.mstc. 2011.05.004.
[10] Kasper A.C., Berselli G.B.T., Freitas B.D., Tenório J.A.S., Bernardes A.M. and Veit H.M., “Printed Wiring Boards for Mobile Phones: Characterization and Recycling of Copper.” Waste Management, 31, (2011.), 2536– 2545. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016 /j.wasman.2011.08.013.
[11] Tilmatine A., Medles K., Bendimerad S.E., Boukholda F. and Dascalescu L., “Electrostatic Separators of Particles: Application to Plastic/Metal, Metal/Metal and Plastic/Plastic mixtures.” Waste Management, 29, (2009), 228–232. http://dx.doi.org/ 10.1016/j.wasman.2008.06.008.
[12] Cui J. and Zhang L., “Metallurgical Recovery of Metals from Electronic Waste: A Review.” J. Hazard. Mater. 158, (2008), 228–256. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat. 2008. 02.001.
[13] Tuncuk A., Stazi V., Akcil A., Yazici E.Y. and Deveci H., “Aqueous Metal Recovery Techniques from E-Scrap: Hydrometallurgy in Recycling.” Minerals Engineering, 25, (2012), 28–37. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.mineng.2011.09.019.
[14] Dorella G. and Mansur M. B., “A Study of the Separation of Cobalt from Spent Li-Ion Battery Residues.” Journal of Power Sources, 170, (2007), 210–215. http://dx.doi. org/10.1016/j.jpowsour.2007.04.025.
[15] Pranolo Y., Zhang W. and Cheng C.Y., “Recovery of Metals from Spent Lithium-ion Battery Leach Solutions with a Mixed Solvent Extractant System.” Hydrometallurgy, 102, (2010), (37–42. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.hydromet.2010. 01.007.
[16] Provazi K., Campos B. A., Espinosa D. C. R. and Tenório J. A. S., “Metal Separation from Mixed Types of Batteries using Selective Precipitation and Liquid–Liquid Extraction Techniques.” Waste Management 31, (2011), 59–64. http://dx.doi.org/ 10.1016/j.wasman.2010.08.021.
[17] Lister T. E., Wang P. and Anderko A., “Recovery of Critical and Value Metals from mobile Electronics Enabled by Electrochemical Processing”. Hydrometallurgy 149, (2014), 228–237. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.hydromet.2014. 08.011.
[18] William, J.H. and Williams, P.T., “Separation and Recovery of Materials from Scrap Printed Circuit Boards.” Resources Conservation and Recycling 51, (2007), 691–709.
[19] Murugan R.V., Bharat S., Deshpande, A.P. Varughese, S. and Haridoss P., “Milling and Separation of the Multi-Component Printed Circuit Board Materials and the Analysis of Elutriation based on a Single Particle Model.” Powder Technology, 183, (2008), 169–176.
[20] Ladou J., “Printed Circuit Board Industry.” International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health, 209, (2006), 211–219.
[21] Guo J., Guo J. and Xu Z., “Recycling of Non-metallic Fractions from Waste Printed Circuit Boards: A Review.” Journal of Hazardous Materials, 168, (2009), 567-590.
[22] Zhang S. and Forssberg E., “Mechanical Separation-Oriented Characterization of Electronic Scrap,” Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 21, (1997), 247-269.
[23] Marques A.C., Cabrera J.M. and Malfatti C.F., “Printed Circuit Boards: A Review on the Perspective of Sustainability,” Journal of Environmental Management, 131, (2013), 298-306.
[24] Guo F., “Composite Lead-free Electronic Solders,” Journal of Material Science, Mater. Electron., 18, (2007), 129-145.
[25] Huang H., Pan J., Liu Z., Song Z. and Liu G., “Study on Disassembling Approaches of Electronic Components Mounted on PCBs,” conference paper.
[26] Zhang S. and Forssberg E., “Intelligent Liberation and Classification of Electronic Scrap,” Powder Technology, 105, (1999), 295-301.
[27] Iji M. And Yokoyama S., “Recycling of Printed Circuit Board with Mounted Electronic Components,” Circuit World, 23, 3, (1997), 10-15.
[28] Mou, P., Wa, L., Xiang, D., Gao, J. and Duan, G., “A Physical Process for Recycling and Reusing Waste Printed Circuit Boards.” In: IEEE Conference Record, International Symposium on Electronic and the Environment, May 2004, pp. 237–242. doi:10.1109/ISEE.2004.1299722.
[29] Goosey M. and Kellner, R., “Recycling technologies for the treatment of end of life printed circuit boards (PCBs).” Circuit World, 29, (2003), 33–37.
[30] Sander S., Schubert G. and Jackel H.-G., 2004. “The Fundamentals of the Comminution of Metals in Shredders of the Swing-Hammer Type.” International Journal of Mineral Processing, 74S, 385–393.
[31] Schubert G. And Bernotat S., “Comminution of Non-brittle Materials,” International Journal of Mineral Processing, 74S, (2004), S19–S30.
[32] Ogunniyi I.O., Vermaak M.K.G. and Groot D.R., “Chemical Composition and Liberation Characterization of Printed Circuit Board Communition Fines for Beneficiation Investigations,” Waste Management, 29, (2009), 2140-2146.
[33] Koyanaka S., Ohya H., Lee J.-C., Iwata H. and Endoh S.,” Impact Milling of Printed Circuit Board Wastes for Resources Recycling and Evaluation of the Liberation using Heavy Medium Separation.” Journal of Soc. Powder Technology Japan, 36, (1999), 479-483.
[34] Yoo J.-M., Jeong J., Yoo K., Lee J.C. and Kim W., “Enrichment of the Metallic Components from Waste Printed Circuit Boards by a Mechanical Separation Process using a Stamp Mill.” Waste Management, 29, (2009), 1132-1137 (Oxford).
[35] Vidyadhar A. and Das A., “Kinetics and Efficacy of Froth Flotation for the Recovery of Metal Values from Pulverized Printed Circuit Boards.” In: XXVI International Mineral Processing Congress (IMPC), New Delhi, (2012), pp. 236-243.
[36] Zhou Y., Qiu K., “A New Technology for Recycling Materials from Waste Printed Circuit Boards, Journal of Hazardous Materials,” 175, (2010), 823–828.
[37] Yamane L.H., Moraes V.T. and Espinosa D.C.R., “Recycling of WEEE: Characterization of Spent Printed Circuit Boards from Mobile Phones and Computers,” Waste Management, 31, (2011), 2553-2558.
[38] Sum E.Y.L., The Recovery of Metals from Electronic Scrap, JOM, April, (1991), 53-60.
[39] Yoo J.M., Jeong J., Yoo K. Lee J.C. Kim W., “Enrichment of the Metallic Components from Waste Printed Circuit Boards by a Mechanical Separation using a Stamo Mill,” Waste Management, 29, (2009), 1132-1137.
[40] Li J., Shrivastava P., Gao Z. and Zhang H.C., “Printed Circuit Board Recycling: A State of the Art Survey,” IEEE Transactions on Electronics packaging Manufacturing, Vol: 27, No: 1, (2004), 33-42.
[41] Li J., Lu H., Liu S. and Xu Z., “Optimizing the Operating Parameters of Corona Electrostatic Separation for Recycling Waste Scraped Printed Circuit Boards by Computer Simulation of Electric Field”, Journal of Hazardous Materials, 153 (2008) 269–275.
[42] Hadi P., Xu M., Lin, C.S.K., Hui C.W., and McKay G., “Waste Printed Circuit Board Recycling Technologies and Product Utilization,” Journal of Hazardous Materials, 283, (2015), 234-243.
[43] Saitoh K., Nagano I. and Izumi S., “New Separation technique for Waste Plastic.” Resource Recovery and Conservation, 2, (1976), 127–145.
[44] Shent H., Pugh R.J. and Forssberg, E., “A Review of Plastics Waste Recycling and the Flotation of Plastics.” Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 25, (1999), 85–109.
[45] Dodbiba G., Haruki N., Shibayam A., Miyazaki T. and Fujita T., “Combination of Sink-Float Separation and Flotation Technique for Purification of Shredded PET bottle from PE or PP Flakes.” International Journal of Mineral Processing, 65, (2002), 11– 29.
[46] Alter H., “The Recovery of Plastics from Waste with Reference to Froth Flotation.” Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 43, (2005), 119–132.
[47] Kaya M., “The Use of Froth Flotation in Environment Protection,” 1st Inter. Conf. on Eng. for Waste Treatment, Albi-France, May 2005.
[48] Ogunniyi I.O., Vermaak K.K.G., “Improving Printed Circuit Board Physical Processing- An Overview,” In Proceeding EMC, Dusseldorf, Germany, (2007), 1645-1656.
[49] Zeng X., Zheng L., Xie H., Lu B., Xia K. Chao K., Li W., Yang J., Lin S. and Li J., “Current Status and Future Perspective of Waste Printed Circuit Boards Recycling,” Procedia Environmental Sciences, 16, (2012), 590-597.
[50] Bernardes A, Bohlinger I. and Rodrigez D., “Recycling of Printed Circuit Boards by Melting with Oxidising/Reducing Top Blowing Process,” in Proc. TSM Annual Meeting, B, Ed. B. Mishra, Orlando-FL., Feb. 9-13, (1997), 363-375.
[51] Theo L., “Integrated Recycling of Non-Ferrous Metals at Boliden Ltd. Ronnskar Smelter,” In Proc. of Inter. Sym. Electronics and the Environment, IEEE, Oak Brook, IL, 42-47.
[52] Hagelüken C., “Recycling of Electronic Scrap at Umicore’s Integrated Metals Smelter and Refinery,” World Erzmetall, 59, (2006), 152-161.
[53] Antrekowitsch H., Potesser M., Spruzina, W. and Prior F., “Metallurgical Recycling of Electronic Scrap.” In: Proceedings of the EPD Congress, San Antonio, Texas, (2006), pp. 899-908.
[54] Gramatyka P., Nowosielski R. and Sakiewicz, P., “Recycling of Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment.” Journal of Achiev. Mater. Manuf., 20, (2007), 535-538.
[55] Montero R., Guevara A. and de la Torre E., “Recovery of Gold, Silver, Copper and Niobium from Printed Circuit Boards using Leaching Column.” J. Earth Sci. Eng, 2, (2012), 590-595.
[56] Sheng P.P. and Etsell T.H., “Recovery of Gold from Computer Circuit Board Scrap using Aqua Regia,” Waste Management Res., 25, (2007), 380-383.
[57] Quinet P., Proost J. and Van Lierde A., “Recovery of Precious Metals from Electronic Scrap by Hydrometallurgical Processing Routes.” Minerals Metallurgical Process, 22, (2005), 17–22.
[58] Ficeriova J., Bal A.Z.P., Dutkova E. and Gock E., “Leaching of Gold and Silver from Crushed Au-Ag Wastes.,” Open Chem. J., 2, (2008), 6-9.
[59] Ficeriova J., Bal A.Z.P. and Gock E., “Leaching of Gold, Silver and Accompanying Metals from Circuit Boards (PCBs) Waste.,” Acta Montan. Slovaca, 16, (2011), 128-131.
[60] Behnamfard A., Salarirad M.M. and Veglio F., “Process Development for Recovery of Copper and Precious Metals from Waste Printed Circuit Boards with Emphasize on Palladium and Gold Leaching and Precipitation,” Waste Management, 33, (2013), 2354-2363 (Oxford).
[61] Oh C.J., Lee S.O., Yang H.S., Ha T.J. and Kim, M.J., “Selective Leaching of Valuable Metals from Waste Printed Circuit Boards.” Air & Waste Management Association, 53, (2003), 897–902.
[62] Ha V.H., Lee J., Jeong J., Haia H.T. and Jha M.K., “Thiosulfate Leaching of Gold from Waste Mobile Phones.” Journal of Hazardous Materials, 178 (1–3), (2010), 1115–1119.
[63] Syed S., “A Green Technology for Recovery of Gold from Non-metallic Secondary Sources,” Hydrometallurgy, 82, (2006), 48-53.
[64] Xu Q., Chen D., Chen L. and Huang, M.H., “Gold leaching from waste printed circuit board by iodine process.” Nonferrous Met., 62, (2010), 88-90.
[65] Birloaga I., De Michelis I., Ferella F., Bazatu M. And Veglio F., “Study on the Influence of Various Factors in the Hydrometallurgical Processing of Waste Printed Circuit Boards for Copper and Gold Recovery,” Waste Management, 33, (2013), 935-941. htpp://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2013.01.003.
[66] Mecucci A. and Scott K., “Leaching and Electrochemical Recovery of Copper, Lead and Tin from Scrap Printed Circuit Boards.” Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, 77, (2002), 449–457.
[67] Kinoshita T., Akita S., Kobayashi N., Nii S., Kawaizumi F. and Takahashi K., “Metal Recovery from Non-mounted Printed Wiring Boards via Hydrometallurgic Processing.” Hydrometallurgy, 69, (1–3), (2003), 73–79.
[68] Ilyas S., Anwar M.A., Niazi S.B. and Ghauri M.A., “Bioleaching of Metals from Electronic Scrap by Moderately Thermophilic Acidophilic Bacteria,” Hydrometallurgy, 88, (2007), 180–188.
[69] Brierley J. and Brierley C., “Present and Future Commercial Applications of Biohydrometallurgy,” Hydrometallurgy, 59, (2001), 233-239.
[70] Brandl H., Bosshard R. and Wegmann M., “Computer-Munching Microbes: Metal Leaching from Electronic Scrap by Bacteria and Fungi,” Hydrometallurgy, 59, (2001), 319-326.
[71] Faramarzi M.A., Stagars M., Pensini E., Krebs W. and Brandl H., “Metal Solubilization from Metal-containing Solid Materials by Cyanogenic Chromobacterium Violaceum.” Journal of Biotechnology, 113, (2004), 321-326.
[72] Karwowska E., Andrzejewska-Morzuch D., Łebkowska M., Tabernacka A., Wojtkowska M., Telepko A. and Konarzewska A., “Bioleaching of Metals from Printed Circuit Boards Supported with Purfactant-producing Bacteria.” Journal of Hazardous Materials, 264, (2014), 203-210.
[73] Xiang Y., Wu P., Zhu N., Zhang T., Liu W., Wu J. and Li, P., “Bioleaching of Copper from Waste Printed Circuit Boards by Bacterial Consortium Enriched from Acid Mine Drainage.” Journal of Hazardous Materials, 184, (2010), 812-818.
[74] Silvas F.P.C., Correa M.M.J., Caldes M.P.K., Moraes V.T., Espinosa D.C.R. and Tenorio J.A.S., “Printed Circuit Board Recycling; Physical Processing and Copper Extraction by Selective Leaching,” Waste Management, 2015 (accepted).
[75] Terazono A., Murakami S., Abe N., Inanc B., Moriguchi Y., Sakai S.I., Kojima M., Yoshida A., Li J., Yang J., Wong M.H., Jain A., Kim I.-S., Peralta G.L., Lin C.-C., Mungcharoen T. and Williams E., “Current Status and Research on E-waste Issues in Asia.” Journal of Material Cycles Waste Management, 8, (2006), 1-12.