Effects of the In-Situ Upgrading Project in Afghanistan: A Case Study on the Formally and Informally Developed Areas in Kabul

Authors: Maisam Rafiee, Chikashi Deguchi, Akio Odake, Minoru Matsui, Takanori Sata

Abstract:

Cities in Afghanistan have been rapidly urbanized; however, many parts of these cities have been developed with no detailed land use plan or infrastructure. In other words, they have been informally developed without any government leadership. The new government started the In-situ Upgrading Project in Kabul to upgrade roads, the water supply network system, and the surface water drainage system on the existing street layout in 2002, with the financial support of international agencies. This project is an appropriate emergency improvement for living life, but not an essential improvement of living conditions and infrastructure problems because the life expectancies of the improved facilities are as short as 10–15 years, and residents cannot obtain land tenure in the unplanned areas. The Land Readjustment System (LRS) conducted in Japan has good advantages that rearrange irregularly shaped land lots and develop the infrastructure effectively. This study investigates the effects of the In-situ Upgrading Project on private investment, land prices, and residents’ satisfaction with projects in Kart-e-Char, where properties are registered, and in Afshar-e-Silo Lot 1, where properties are unregistered. These projects are located 5 km and 7 km from the CBD area of Kabul, respectively. This study discusses whether LRS should be applied to the unplanned area based on the questionnaire and interview responses of experts experienced in the In-situ Upgrading Project who have knowledge of LRS. The analysis results reveal that, in Kart-e-Char, a lot of private investment has been made in the construction of medium-rise (five- to nine-story) buildings for commercial and residential purposes. Land values have also incrementally increased since the project, and residents are commonly satisfied with the road pavement, drainage systems, and water supplies, but dissatisfied with the poor delivery of electricity as well as the lack of public facilities (e.g., parks and sport facilities). In Afshar-e-Silo Lot 1, basic infrastructures like paved roads and surface water drainage systems have improved from the project. After the project, a few four- and five-story residential buildings were built with very low-level private investments, but significant increases in land prices were not evident. The residents are satisfied with the contribution ratio, drainage system, and small increase in land price, but there is still no drinking water supply system or tenure security; moreover, there are substandard paved roads and a lack of public facilities, such as parks, sport facilities, mosques, and schools. The results of the questionnaire and interviews with the four engineers highlight the problems that remain to be solved in the unplanned areas if LRS is applied—namely, land use differences, types and conditions of the infrastructure still to be installed by the project, and time spent for positive consensus building among the residents, given the project’s budget limitation.

Keywords: In-Situ Upgrading, Kabul, Land Readjustment, Land value, Planned areas, Private investment, Resident satisfaction, Unplanned areas.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI): doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1316782

References:

[1] UN-HABITAT, State of Afghan Cities, UN-HABITAT, 2015, Vol. 1.
[2] Draft Kabul City Master Plan, product of technical cooperation project for promotion of Kabul Metropolitan Area Development, Sub project for revise the Kabul city Master Plan, RECS International Inc, June 2011.
[3] USAID, Land Reform in Afghanistan (LARA), Final report 2014. http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PA00KJVS.pdf.
[4] World Bank. 2014. Afghanistan - Kabul Municipal Development Program Project. Washington DC; World Bank Group. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/885711468187133218/Afghanistan-Kabul-Municipal-Development-Program-Project.
[5] USAID, Land Reform in Afghanistan (LARA), Informal Settlements Upgrading handbook, March 2013. pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PA00KKHR.pdf.
[6] Peikar, Jawad, “Afghan Land Administration Projects, 2003-14: A Review”, The World Bank – Washington DC, 2016. https://www.conftool.com/landandpoverty2016/index.php/Stanfield-498-498_paper.pdf?page=downloadPaper&filename=Stanfield-498-498_paper.pdf&form_id=498&form_version=final.
[7] World Bank. 2013. Afghanistan - Kabul Urban Reconstruction project. Implementation completion and results report. Washington DC; World Bank Group. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/609331468196447153/pdf/ICR22420P083910C0disclosed030130130.pdf.
[8] USAID, 2007 Delivery of Humanitarian Shelter in Urban Areas: The Case of KASS. https://urban-links.org/delivery-humanitarian-shelter-urban-areas-case-kass/.
[9] USAID, Land Titling and Economic Restructuring in Afghanistan (LTERA), project completion report 2004-2009. https://www.usaid.gov/node/52186.
[10] UN Habitat, Preliminary Study of Land Tenure Related Issues in Urban Afghanistan with Special Reference to Kabul City (Kabul, 2003): iii.
[11] Lall, Somik V. Planning, Connecting, and Financing Cities—Now: Priorities for City Leaders. World Bank Publications, 2013.
[12] Del Mistro, Romano, and David A. Hensher. "Upgrading informal settlements in South Africa: Policy, rhetoric and what residents really value." Housing Studies 24.3 (2009): 333-354.
[13] Norihiko, Yanase. “A theory of replotting design in land readjustment: adopting land readjustment in Malaysia.” Kazuhide, Norihiko (1992).
[14] World Bank, 2008. Approaches to urban slums: a multimedia sourcebook on adaptive and proactive. Washington DC; World Bank Group. strategieshttp://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/547701468346439819/Approaches-to-urban-slums-a-multimedia-sourcebook-on-adaptive-and-proactive-strategies.
[15] Nazire, Haroon, et al. "Effects of Informal Settlement Upgrading in Kabul City, Afghanistan: A Case Study of Afshar Area." Current Urban Studies 4.04 (2016): 476.
[16] USAID, Land Reform in Afghanistan (LARA), Urban Development Guidelines Mar 2013. http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PA00KKHS.pdf.
[17] http://www.fukuoka.unhabitat.org/projects/afghanistan/index_en.html.
[18] Aga Khan Trust for Culture, Restoration projects in Afghanistan - Project brief, 2012. http://www.akdn.org/publication/aktc-restoration-projects-afghanistan-project-brief.
[19] JICA (2011). Promotion of Kabul Metropolitan Area Development: Capacity Development Project (pp. 1-103). Kabul City Current Status Report for Urban Development.
[20] Ministry of Urban Development and Housing, Afghanistan. 2016. http://mudh.gov.af/.
[21] Digital globe, google earth 2017.
[22] UN-Habitat GIS Team, State of Afghan Cities (SoAC) program, Ministry of Urban Development and Housing. 2014/2015. http://mudh.gov.af/.
[23] Urban planning implementation guidelines, Ministry of Urban Development and Housing, 2017. http://mudh.gov.af/.
[24] Tamim, ASAD Ahmad, and Chikashi DEGUCHI. 2017, "Applicability of Land Readjustment Replotting System to the Rehabilitation of the Informal Settlements in Jalalabad City, Afghanistan."
[25] Sources: Esri, HERE, Garmin, Intermap, increment P Corp., GEBCO, USGS, FAO, NPS, NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong), swisstopo, © OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community.
[26] Smolka, Martim Oscar. Implementing value capture in Latin America: Policies and tools for urban development. Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, 2013.
[27] Kabul Municipal Development Program, Afghanistan. 2017. http://km.gov.af/.
[28] Kabul Master Plan (2012-2026), Kabul Municipality, Afghanistan, July, 2012. http://km.gov.af/.
[29] Nawin Asia real estate agency, and Shir Hosain Afshari real estate agency. 2017. http://moj.gov.af/fa/page/7966/registration-of-political-party-and-civil-organization/94241.